Rate every single every Animal Collective album and EP you've heard.
>>65823495
I've only heard four.
Feels = Sung Tongs > Strawberry Jam > MPP
Listened to Sung Tongs for the first time a few days ago. Visiting Friends is the fucking jam of a lifetime.
Okay.
>>65823495
only heard 2.
STGSTV 10/10 imho
MPP 8/10
>>65823535
interesting chart....
Spirit - 10
Campfire - 9
HCTI - 8
Young Prayer - 10
Sung Tongs - 6.5
Prospect - 10
Feels - 10
Strawberry - 10
Person Pitch - 9
MPP - 10
FBK - 10
Down There - 11
Tomboy - 8
Centipede - 10
Slasher - 7.5
PBVSGR - 10
Painting With - 8
Sleep Cycle - 7.5
>>65823669
I've been posting this chart for at least two years, updating it for each release.
It's not bait. But I guess you are.
>>65823691
>Sung Tongs 6.5
>almost every other album gets a 10
explain yourself
>>65823495
I might miss some, but here goes.
>out of 10
>STGSTV = 9.5
>DM = 8.5
>CS = 8.7
>HCTI = 8.2
>Hollinndagain = 8.3 but I need to listen to it again
>ST = 8.7
>Feels = 9.3
>Strawberry Jam = 8.0
>Water Curses = 8.1
>MPP = 8.5
>Fall Be Kind = 8.2
>ODDSAC = 8.7
>CHZ = 7.5
>Painting With = 7.0
Fall Be Kind is honestly a 10/10 EP
>Spirit 10/10
>Danse 5/10
>Campfire Songs 9/10
>HCTI 7/10
>Hollinndagain 5/10
>Sung Tongs 10/10
>Prospect Hummer 9/10
>Feels 10/10
>SJ 7/10
>Water Curses 9/10
>People 10/10
>MPP 9/10
>Fall be Kind 9/10
>CHz 7/10
>PW 8/10
>ODDSAC 6/10
>Everyone giving MPP this low scores
>>65823535
you might have just scared me away from going through their whole discog, so much output!
never was a fan of mpp or feels, im bout to rec myself based on your chart to dip my toes into anco, since i cant form my own opinions
MPP 10/10, only one I've heard
Spirit - 8
Danse Manatee - 6
Hollindagainn - 7.5, first two or three songs are incredible
Campfire Songs - 6.5 but I think I need to listen to it again.
Here Comes the Indian - 8.5
Sung Tongs - 8.5
Prospect Hummer EP - 7
Feels - 8
People EP - 6.5, Fickle Cycle and Must Be Treeman from the Grass single are better than anything on it.
Strawberry Jam - 7.5, has some really great songs but has some pretty weak moments as well
Water Curses - 7.5, Steet Flash is one of their very best.
Merriweather Post Pavillion - 8.5
Fall Be Kind - 8
ODDSAC - 7.5 or 8
Centipede HZ - 6.5, though I could see giving it higher. I love some of the songs but they come hand in hand with some of the band's absolute worst and I rarely want to listen to even the songs I like.
New Psycho Actives Vol. 1 - 8
Painting With - 7
Don't want to compare their live albums to their studio recordings, but live at 9:30 is a definite improvement over Centipede HZ and the 15 minute long Pulleys is killer. The Painting With live albums are really good too, the songs benefit from the live drumming, added energy and the transitions, but I feel like there's something lost in the texture and aesthetic of the album.
Person Pitch - 9
Tomboy - 6.5 or 7
PBVSGR - 6 or 6.5, Mr. Noah, Boys Latin, Tropic of Cancer and maybe Come To Your Senses rate among his best for me but half the album feels like throwaway songs.
Pullhair Rubeye (Unreversed) - 8
Down There - 8
Slasher Flicks - 7.5, I think his songwriting here is much better than on Centipede Hz, and as good as on MPP, but there's some duds and the style can get tiring. Still, it does the Centipede Hz rock band style much better than Centipede Hz.
merriweather post pavilion - 9.3
sj - 8.7
sorry, i'm just getting into them don't shoot me
>>65823810
>PW 8/10
>ODDSAC 6/10
gross desu
>>65823535
Shit are you me ?
>>65823535
Nice, nothing I really disagree with. You're missing Live at 9:30 though
Albums
>Sung Tongs
8/10
>Feels
8/10
>Strawberry Jam
9/10
>MPP
9/10
>Centipede Hz
10/10
>Painting With
7/10
EPs
>Prospect Hummer
7/10
>Water Curses
6/10
>Fall Be Kind
7/10
Solo
>Person Pitch
8/10
>Down There
8/10
>ETSH
8/10
>PBVSGR
9/10
i think thats all i've heard. i'm a big fan but i have weird taste so you probably think my ears are broken. still gotta listen to their early stuff.
>>65823495
>>65823691
>Down There - 11
my nigga
>
I dont listen to pleb shit
10. Painting With - 4.5
9. Campfire Songs - 5.5
8. Here Comes The Indian - 6.5
7. Sung Tongs - 7
6. Danse Manatee - 7
5. Strawberry Jam - 7.5
4. Centipede Hz - 8
3. STGSTV - 8.5
2. Feels - 9
1. Merriweather Post Pavillion - 9.5
Haven't listened to any of the EPs yet.
>>65823495
Spirit: 9
DM: 7
CS: 5
HCTI: 4
ST: 7
Feels: 10
Strawberry Jam: 9
MPP: 10
Chz: 7
PW: 7
>>65823535
What's the release after Young Prayer? That's not a Terrestrial Tones record is it?
>>65829806
get yourself some Water Curses and Fall Be Kind boy.
Spirit 10/10
Danse 6/10
Campfire 7/10
Indian 8/10
Tongs 9/10
Feels 9/10
Strawberry 9/10
Merriweather 9/10
Centipede 7/10
Painting 5/10
spirit - 9/10
dm - 5/10
hollindagain - 7/10
campfire songs - 10/10
hcti - 8/10
sung tongs - 10/10
prospect hummer - 9/10
feels - 8/10
strawberry jam - 9.5/10
mpp - 7.5/10
fbk - 7.5/10
chz - 6/10
pw - 7/10
Yeah i rated hcti higher than mpp
Yeah im being honest with myself
>>65823535
I pretty much just agree with this, aside from a few things.
Nice chart!
STGSTV - 9+
Campfire Songs - 6+
Sung Tongs - 5
Strawberry Jam - 8+
Feels - 10+
MPP- 10
CH - 5
Painting With - 5
solo projects
Panda Bear
Person Pitch - 10+
Tomboy - 9
PBMTGR - 6+
Avey
Ribeye - 7
Down There - 8+
Slasher Flicks - 6+
Deakin
Sleep Cycle - 9
STGSTV - 10
DM - 7
CS - 7
HCTI - 8+
Hollinndagain - 6+
ST - 9
Prospect Hummer - 7
Feels - 10
People - 8
SJ - 9
Water Curses - 9
MPP - 10
FBK - 9
ODDSAC - 8+
CHz - 9
PW - 9
Panda Bear - 7
Young Prayer - 7
PP - 10
Tomboy - 8
PBVSGR - 9
Down There - 10
Sleep Cycle - 9
Pullhair Rubeye - 6
>>65829775
Haha, dude!!!
Got em ;^)
>>65823495
Feels 7/10
MPP 7,5/10
Centipede Hz 5,5/10
not really a fan I guess
most of mucore stuff that I listened out of curiosity was pretty mediocre тbh
STGSTV 8.5/10
MPP 6.5/10
10/10
STGSTV 10/10
DM 7.5/10
HCTI 9/10
ST 8.5/10
Feels 9.5/10
SJ 10/10
PP 8.5/10
WC 8.5/10
MPP 10/10
FBK 10/10
DT 9/10
CHz 8/10
PW 6.5/10
SC 9/10
STGSTV- 7/10
Danse- 5/10
Hollindagin- 7/10
CS- 5/10
HCTI- 7/10
Sung Tongs- 10/10
Feels- 8/10
SJ- 9/10
MPP- 10/10
CHz- 9/10
PW- 8/10
>EPs
Hummer- 8/10
People- 6/10
Water Curses- 7/10
FBK- 9/10
>Solo
Panda Bear- 6/10
Young Prayer- 7/10
PP- 10/10
Pullhair- 7/10 when re reversed, 5/10 as is
Down There- 7/10
Tomboy- 8/10
Slasher Flicks- 7/10
PBVSGR-8/10
SC- 9/10
STGSTV 4/10
DM 3/10
HCTI 6/10
CS 7/10
ST 9/10
Feels 5/10
SJ 8/10
MPP 10/10
CH 1/10
PW 2/10
>>65829965
i am also wondering this
>>65824017
why? if an artist releases a piece of perfect music I'd dig through their entire back catalog (and I have with such artists) searching for me
Spirit - 8.5/10
DM - 4/10
HCTI - 7/10
CS - 7/10
ST - 8/10
Feels - 8/10
SJ - 9.5/10
FBK - 9/10
MPP - 6/10
PW - 5/10
STGSTV 7
Danse Manatee 6
HCTI 10
Sung Tongs 8.5
Sleep Cycle 9
I couldn't get into anything past sung tongs enough to be able to properly rate it
only gonna rate those I've extensively listened to
Hollindagain - 7
Campfire Songs - 9.5
Sung Tongs - 9
Prospect Hummer - 8.5
Feels - 10
People - 7
Strawberry Jam - 10
Water Curses - 8.5
MPP - 10
FBK - 10
Painting With - 7.5
Bootlegs:
Other Music - 10
Melkweg - 8
>>65833882
how tf have you not listened to Spirit extensively??
>>65834379
that's a good question that I don't have a good answer to
Just haven't been motivated much to go back to it, although I did like a lot of it on first listen and whenever I go back t specific songs I enjoy them
>>65829752
holy fuck this is bad
