[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
The New Essentials
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 37
File: New Essentials.png (1001 KB, 1420x1000) Image search: [Google]
New Essentials.png
1001 KB, 1420x1000
/Mu/ is dying.

We have exhausted our meme supply. The old /mu/core is pretentious, obsolete, and depressing. In order to revive this board, we must refocus on the music whose influence has shaped our modern world. In order to accomplish this, I have taken the liberty of compiling a list of albums which, I believe, best represents music's transition from the late-60's into the modern day without the bloat of prior lists.

It's not enough that an album is good, it must either directly foreshadow an important direction in the music industry, or perfectly encapsulate the style of the day. No list is perfect, but in order for this board to grow, we must move our discourse beyond Radiohead, Neutral Milk Hotel, and Death Grips.
>>
Shit chart m8
>>
>>65565174
No. Are you retarded?
>>
>>65565174
>the stone roses
no
>>
>>65565174
Like these are new essentials
>>
File: image.jpg (4 KB, 92x125) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
4 KB, 92x125
>>65565363
>not liking the stone roses
>perfers current /mu/core
>>
>>65565363
They greatly influenced 90s rock
>>
>>65565174
/mu/ core isnt some arbitrary list we all agreed was great its just the albums that got spammed the most in like 2013
thats why american football is up there despite being shit
but i mean spam rhose enough and everyone will agree theyre great /mu/ is just a hive mind of trend following hipsters
>>
File: autism-intensifies.jpg (43 KB, 514x536) Image search: [Google]
autism-intensifies.jpg
43 KB, 514x536
>>65565174
>>
File: gris-gris-4ea6863136ed9.jpg (314 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
gris-gris-4ea6863136ed9.jpg
314 KB, 1000x1000
>>65565174
>>
No new /mu/-core chart is complete without the firsts shoegaze album
>>
>>65565438
>/mu/ core isnt some arbitrary list we all agreed was great its just the albums that got spammed the most in like 2013

I'm aware of that, it's just that this board is so rooted in past orthodox that we can't evolve.

>american football is up there despite being shit

It's a good album, but an 8.5 at most.

So you like the list?
>>
>>65565406
>>65565420
britbongs detected
>>
>>65565526
What is this?
>>
>>65565541
Who cares fucking /mu/ core? Changing /mu/ core is vain.
>>
soul mining is the best album ever
>>
>>65565555
nice dubs.
>>
>>65565174
good idea, bad chart
i took the liberty of expanding upon yours a little
>>
>>65565420
who cares
>>
>>65565591
this is actually really great
it sounds like a voodoo ceremony out in the swamps near new orleans
>>
>>65565660
Even worse than kpop
>>
>>65565601
Because the current /mu/core is a false idol which stifles discussion. It's like our Torah and we are the pharisees.
>>
>>65565420
>>65565406
don't put the Stone Roses, put R.E.M. or something
at least R.E.M. has more than one good album
>>
>>65565717
get off this board, your taste is beyond saving
>>
>>65565717
I thought that was kpop
>>
>>65565555
I would call you an idiot but those digits are amazing
>>
>>65565730
Doesn't matter if they only made one good album. The Stone Roses may not be the greatest artists, but their first album is the pivotal transition between 80s and 90s rock.
>>
>>65565730
which rem album would you put though

murmur is the obvious choice but the next two are equally worthy
i'd probably pick fables because it's underrated, even if i prefer murmur
>>
/mu/core isn't stuff chosen because it's good, it's the most talked about albums. I do think the /mu/core chart is outdated but I also think /mu/core as a concept is cancerous and just leads to everyone on the board listening to and praising the same shit. Making a new chart won't help that, it'll just cause it to happen with the new albums. What really should happen is that people should stop thinking /mu/core is stuff that they have to listen to as this just causes what I said before, people just stick to them as the "best" albums despite that not being what /mu/core is.
>>
>>65565725
So do you want to make The Stone Roses a new idol? lol
Making /mu/core and /mu/core is just vain. Don't be serious about them.
>>
>>65565725
The current /mu/core aren't discussed a lot because they are /mu/core, they are /mu/core because they are discussed a lot.
>>
>>65565841
Mu core is helpful to newcomers as a way of saying "familiarise yourself with these, they are talked about a lot"
>>
>>65565693
you are right, this is good
thank you
>>
File: new chart.png (317 KB, 1000x343) Image search: [Google]
new chart.png
317 KB, 1000x343
>>65565660
Behold your new god
>>
>>65565925
Most of the OP's albums aren't talked about a lot and even the original ones aren't too much anymore. People like OP are just misunderstanding what /mu/core is and think it's what people consider the "best" albums and think making a new chart will help with anything.
>>
>>65566009
Eww. Cringe.
>>
>>65566037
can you name one song on the current /mu/core chart that is better than any of these
>>
>>65565925
I think its useful also, but it needs to be updated. Not as an objective list of best or most influential albums like OP is trying to do because thats subjective and impossible. But just the most talked about albums in 2016. But not more than maybe 20, beyond that it's just personal taste.

NMH, Loveless, Spiderland, Kid A have to be there of course.

Think of it as, what albums would you absolutely expect every single member of /mu/ to have listened to. What albums are 100% necessary to have heard in order to participate in board culture.
>>
>>65566027
I understand that /mu/core isn't supposed to be the "best" albums, but it's treated like that because of continuous reinforcement and punishment by users of this website. Also, at a certain time, /mu/core was the defacto "best" because it was what all the discussion was about.

I'm trying to move this board's discourse towards more unpretentious, important, but often overlooked albums.
>>
>>65566056
Swans - Helpless Child
>>
>>65566159
>Think of it as, what albums would you absolutely expect every single member of /mu/ to have listened to. What albums are 100% necessary to have heard in order to participate in board culture.
none of them 2bh, that's the good thing
>>
>>65566056
I can't. Because you think Morning Musume is best. Your autism level is above all.
>>
>/mu/ is dying
i wish
>>
>>65566194
this isn't even on YouTube
>>65566208
i'm sorry but if you don't think Morning Musume is good you should quit music and find a new hobby
>>
>>65566167
>I'm trying to move this board's discourse towards more unpretentious, important, but often overlooked albums.
Pretentious is a stupid complaint and baseless really. What anyone that tries to do this is going to do is just post some albums that they like and think should be talked about more. You can't force shit like this and trying to do so will just do more harm than good. Everyone is just going to ignore any chart you make because it's just another "I'm trying to fix /mu/!" arbitrary list of albums like has been done a bunch of times before. Stop trying to force discussion in a certain direction outside of making threads.
>>
File: image.jpg (105 KB, 640x960) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
105 KB, 640x960
>>65566225
>this isn't even on YouTube
>>
>>65566225
>this isn't even on Youtube
Nigger what the fuck.
>>
>>65566225
if you havent heard soundtracks for the blind, holy shit youre in for a treat. listen to helpless child
>>
>>65566256
Okay. If you were going to change /mu/core, what would you do?
>>
>>65566288
and report back pls
>>
>>65566225
Go back to your assigned containment thread
>>
File: help.png (168 KB, 863x585) Image search: [Google]
help.png
168 KB, 863x585
>>65566258
>>65566283
weird
the way i see it there's just a live version that can't match up to the recorded album and also someone's corrupted file
>>65566324
Morning Musume aren't Korean, K-pop is all generic house and hip-hop with the same structure in every song
>>
>>65566297
I wouldn't because I don't like the concept and also don't agree with trying to force discussion about certain albums.
>>
>>65566167
Who cares /mu/core? Only newfags cares them seriously. There are a lot of good discussions without /mu/core in this boards.
And just making "The New Essentials" is means nothing. They have to be more spicy and attractive.
>>
>>65566358
the live version is superb, listen to that

the live album swans are dead is better than sftb some days for me
>>
>>65565814
reckoning or fables
>>
>>65566225
Find a new hobby? lol what? What hobby? Just watching morning musme video and jerking hard? Is that your hobby?
>>
>>65565174
desu soul mining is a banger of an album
>>
>>65566388
wait nah its just a shitty iphone video

heres the yt link to the stuio version

https://youtu.be/89mE8-MuQ0U
>>
>>65566225
>didn't listen SFTB once
>think j-pop is god-tier
Go away and don't comeback here
>>
>>65565174
You mean the old essentials?
>>
>>65566506
>has never listened to the instrumental version of Pyoko Pyoko Ultra on repeat until attaining spiritual enlightenment
>thinks this tuneless old man warbling too low for his vocal range over a royalty-free piece of low-budget documentary background music a is groundbreaking work
>>
>>65566539
Yes!
>>
>>65566358
>Morning Musume aren't Korean
So what? That make them good music? If you don't have containment thread, go make your own. Fucking weaboo.
>>
File: dog.jpg (32 KB, 450x338) Image search: [Google]
dog.jpg
32 KB, 450x338
>new list = new memes
>OP is trying to make a new meme and isn't even trip fagging
>>
>>65566609
why don't you make one for me if you care so much, it seems like it's more your problem than mine
>>
File: 1465517685546.png (88 KB, 572x433) Image search: [Google]
1465517685546.png
88 KB, 572x433
>>65565174
/mu/core are albums discussed frequently on /mu/.

Not your shitty taste you fucking faggot.
>>
>>65565174
>/mu/ is dying, so /mu/ shall become rym

great stuff
>>
>>65566567
>the instrumental version of Pyoko Pyoko Ultra
Morning Musume composed instrumetal part? lol
>>
File: 4524981_std.jpg (8 KB, 231x233) Image search: [Google]
4524981_std.jpg
8 KB, 231x233
>>65565406
The Stone Roses blow
>>
>>65565174
>the bloat of prior lists

There's too much to pick from, you can't even fit it all in

The thing about your new essentials besides loveless/vu&n/maybe forever changes is they aren't even disliked or anything, they're all number 49 best albums in a top 50 tier albums

Top 50 is really fucking good

This is just proof there will be new memes
There will be memes for ages to come
>>
>>65566388
it feels like the musical equivalent of some Hollywood film in that it's very predictably structured with a "grandiose" kind of feeling to it (not really a bad thing, because if there wasn't demand for this kind of entertainment nobody would make it)
the vocal section was poor because the vocalist doesn't have the range for the song, but the intro that sounds kind of like a neutered Mille Plateaux act and the crescendo part were pretty okay
of course the downfall of making music that's so "cinematic" in scope is that it often feels incomplete without accompanying context or visuals
6/10
>>
>>65566929
did you hear the live version? like i said it's a shitty recording. i posted the link for the real one
>>
>>65566973
you posted an NBA game trailer
>>
>>65566999
oh my god, fuck the youtube app. i pressed share while the ad was playing
>>
>>65566999
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2NOc1Gnu18I
>>
File: help.png (203 KB, 641x321) Image search: [Google]
help.png
203 KB, 641x321
>>65567043
ah, fuck
>>
>>65565174
>but in order for this board to grow
Instead why don't you just leave?
>>
>>65567070
get the youtube unblocker extension
>>
>>65567070
lol what a country
>>
File: nu mu core.png (796 KB, 1420x800) Image search: [Google]
nu mu core.png
796 KB, 1420x800
From a completely objective standpoint, these are the only albums I could think of that are frequently posted around here, are usually well-received, and aren't posted just as a meme.

If there's a new mu-core, IMO, it's something like this.

Feel free to add/change whatever you feel makes sense!
>>
>>65565420
Says the blazer
>>
>>65567227
and before you guys lose your shit for TPAB, it's a very similar situation of that of MBDTF
>>
>>65567161
oh, it's on Vimeo
>>
>>65565174
> best represents music's transition from the late-60's into the modern day without the bloat of prior lists
Pet Sounds better represents its era (and is a more ambitious and necessary listen) than Forever Changes, as much as I like both.

I like the Feelies, but what are they supposed to represent here? If you want post-punk or new wave, Remain in Light and Unknown Pleasures are the more immediately necessary listens- one of which is on mucore already.

>The The
why
>>
>>65567227
Thank you, this is more like it.

I would remove Twin Fantasy tbqh and add Spirit of Eden or Laughing Stock

Perhaps a Swans album also, maybe SFTB.
>>
>>65567227
sweet trip is a nice record, but it's in no way well discussed here, and there's not much to it that makes it essential.

Turn on the Bright Lights is half a good record. The second half is so dull.

Tago Mago and TPAB are the only ones on there that I would ever argue are mu core.
>>
>>65565174
what are your thoughts on this
>>65567227
>>
>>65565526
This
>>
>>65567306
Not talking about the quality of the records though. I made that chart, and I only listened to Tago Mago. I checked the archive for some reference. These records popped up a lot (of course, not a s much as current mucore, but that's prob because they're already established as so). The discussions about these records were generally positive, so, opinions aside, they're kinda liked around here.

TPAB, CttE and V:D:C are actually the ones I saw the most.
>>
File: nu-mu-core.png (397 KB, 467x470) Image search: [Google]
nu-mu-core.png
397 KB, 467x470
>>65567227
how about this
>>
>>65567431
Accurate. I completely forgot about Talk Talk. The other ones are already /mu/core.
>>
>>65567300
SFTB is already /mu/ core. TBK is my closest contender to new mucore from Swans.
>>
File: v2.png (552 KB, 641x497) Image search: [Google]
v2.png
552 KB, 641x497
>>65567431
actually i reconsidered right after posting this

what do you guys think of this? what should be added

>>65567463
I think the old /mu/core is outdated. we should try and make something to replace it, not just to supplement it. that means removing albums like american football that arent talked about anymore while keeping albums like kid a and sftb and (maybe) mbdtf that are still talked about all the time and a big part of board culture.
>>
>>65567505
what about adding a bjork album? homogenic? i think she's talked about a lot on here but maybe it just seems like that because of all the waifufagging
>>
>>65567431
Pretty cool.
>>
>>65567505
Oh I see. Agree. That's a good idea m8. I like that chart.
>>
>>65567536
I was hesitant about adding Art Angels for this same reason: I'm not actually sure if the album is really the main points of those discussions.
>>
File: 1463507164048.jpg (20 KB, 342x316) Image search: [Google]
1463507164048.jpg
20 KB, 342x316
"/mu/core" is a meme that needs to be destroyed. /mu/ is not unique in liking any of these bands, and except for Death Grips and some vaporwave people no real musicians actually post here. You people are all deluded idiots.
>>
>>65565174
No.
>>65567505
Yes.
>>
File: 1458182331117.jpg (61 KB, 401x606) Image search: [Google]
1458182331117.jpg
61 KB, 401x606
>>65567608
pls don't fall for this shit we're actually making some progress now
>>
>>65567628
>we're actually making some progress now
Nope.
>>
>>65567594
I think Grimes is much less respected as an artist than Bjork. She's almost Lavren tier I think.
>>
>>65567608
Yeah, it's what I said. /mu/core itself is fucing vain.
>>
>>65567404
how far back in the archives did you go? I rarely see sweet trip discussed here
>>
>>65567628
>make new meme /mu/core
>progress
Cringe
>>
>>65567505
make a full version with all the other mu core that are still discussed along with some sub-mu core. We revise the sub-mu core and /thread.
>>
>>65567258
>>65567161
anyway, hearing that in clearer definition is pretty different - the section with vocals sounds better even if that guy's range is still weak, but the big crescendo sounds worse with that cheap organ going on in perfect clarity, it sounded better with that rough, blown-out live sound
i can see why people enjoy it and that the musicianship is is of a good standard but it's not particularly appealing to me
>>
>>65567505
Needs Remain in Light. Theres no post punk on there.

Also Low needs to be on there.
>>
>>65567681
the old memecore is from like 2013. we need some new memecore
>>
>>65565174
Instead of worrying about your pathetic ego, talk about music that interests you instead of pre-approved albums.
>>
>>65567679
Around 2 weeks (page 70)
>>
>>65567706
>guy's range is weak
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDDulEQsIoI
>>
>>65567681
I'm not saying this shit isn't a all a meme. But I'm tired of the same meme.
>>
>>65567715
So... actually do you want make them meme like a death grips? wtf I realy hope there aren't my favourite album in that chart. Eww
>>
File: 641984.png (152 KB, 388x261) Image search: [Google]
641984.png
152 KB, 388x261
>>65567505
just a suggestion:
if you guys actually want to make a new, competent list - you should only include like 4 pop/rock albums and broaden the entire thing and include essentials from the generals, so like 4 /metal/ albums, 4 /classical/ albums, 4 /jazz/ albums or whatever
otherwise this will just look the same shit every time
>>
>>65567755
ok, I get what you mean. I love >>65567505 this chart also. This chart is much better than old thing.
>>
>>65567724
Oh wait, you mean in general? I don't know. I visited some random page numbers. 70 was the one where I first saw Sweet Trip. (I actually only saw it once, but I recall there was a week like last months when this album was posted daily)
>>
File: v3.png (772 KB, 631x631) Image search: [Google]
v3.png
772 KB, 631x631
>>65567707
yeah agreed. im not very into post-punk but I see remain in light posted all the time. Also I agree some bowie should be there but are you sure it shoudl be Low? dont rly like memewie tbqh but i know a lot do

>>65567705
other people make ur own charts please. this is going to be biased by my own tastes. we should make a whole bunch of draft charts in this thread and then we can see where to go from there

>>65567789
>oh no my favorite album is going to become a meme
people overstate the fear of albums becoming memes. what happened to death grips will not happen to 99% of albums, death grips are a fucking perfect storm of memery, think about it.

>>65567832
this is a fair point but I think it should be more like 12-16 pop/rock and 2-3 from each general. /metal/ is the biggest one, /classical/ and /jazz/ arent too big, /shugazi/ has been kind of dead sadly, /bleep/ hates the rest of /mu/

anyway feedback please. also please make ur own charts dont expect me to do it all, im gonna go to sleep soon anyway.
>>
>>65567832
Particular Genre Essentials arleady exist
>>
File: index.jpg (14 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
index.jpg
14 KB, 225x225
NICO - Desertshore
THROBBING GRISTLE - The Second Annual Report
BRIAN ENO - Music for Airports
DEATH IN JUNE - The Guilty Have no Pride
>>
>>65567890
Even though I love Spiderland, it's been quite a while since a saw a discussion of it. It may just be me. Where are you making these charts?
>>
>>65565174
so these are the new universal essentials as dictated by one person, correct?
>>
>>65567748
he's not actually singing here so it's not comparable, but because he's really struggling to hit the low notes on tracks like Helpless Child then it's better to change the key of the composition rather than force him to bring down the overall quality of the performance
>>
>>65567930
>BRIAN ENO - Music for Airports
this is a good shout

>>65567932
http://topsters2.herokuapp.com/
idk I think I've seen it a fair bit int the last few weeks. also it was voted #1 when someone made a poll thing where you could vote albums up and down, a few weeks ago.

and it's very memetic with the whole I MISS YOU and all that

>>65567948
yeah this is why I keep saying for other people to make draft charts also
>>
File: 1465586781710.png (943 KB, 1420x1000) Image search: [Google]
1465586781710.png
943 KB, 1420x1000
>>65565174
worst thread of the month
>>
File: mucore.png (318 KB, 689x463) Image search: [Google]
mucore.png
318 KB, 689x463
You guys have completely missed the point of /mu/core. It's not about amount discussed or your shitty taste or how good only you think an album is. This is /mu/core and it should never be changed.
>>
>>65565555
>>65555555
>>
>>65568008
Hospice and meme grips need to go. OKC is unnecessary as Kid A is discussed far, far more. ITCOTCK isn't discussed very much at all anymore. LYSF is a good shout

ITAOTS is beyond /mu/ core
>>
>>65568008
What's the "point", then?
>>
File: 936.jpg (33 KB, 625x626) Image search: [Google]
936.jpg
33 KB, 625x626
>>65565174
>>
>>65568041
>Hospice and meme grips need to go
fucking this
>>
>>65567890
needs morning musume
>>
>>65567960
Pleb
>>
>>65568008
This.
There is no new /mu/core.
>>
>>65568127
i'm not the one out here shilling generic soundtrack music with a vocalist who can't sing
>>
>>65567227
Slint Spiderland
>>
>>65568041
>>65568083
Why? No one has ever provided a valid answer as to why Hospice needs to go. Sorry you started browsing /mu/ late but it's a part of the foundation of this board.
>taking off meme grips
Opinion discarded. However superior you think your taste is, DG is a part of the board whether you like it or not.
Again, it's not about the amount discussed or your shitty taste. You cannot and will never change /mu/core.
>>
>>65568144
>has hospice
>no swans
>no talk talk
>no tago mago
>no pet sounds
>no spiderland

those are all undisputed /mu/core now
>>
>>65567890
objectively correct chart for /mu/
>>
>>65568174
>not about the amount discussed or your shitty taste.

What is it about then?

And yeah tbqh I wasn't really convinced when I dismissed death grips, I'm having second thoughts now. I mean it's true, they are discussed a lot. Bottomless Pit was one of the biggest releases of the year (in terms of impact on /mu/) after AMSP and TLOP
>>
>>65568174
So you think /mu/ core is the essential culture from this board. I get your point, the whole point of this thread isn't to destroy the meme culture of this board but to, Idk, enhance it?

Adding the new albums for the sake of organization, to keep the albums that are rising in popularity in a "notable" place as well.

Besides, don't take any of this too seriously. This is literally just a big meme.
>>
>>65568161
>generic soundtrack music
Pleb
>>
>>65568236
>Idk, enhance it?
update it

>This is literally just a big meme
fucking this. it's just, why do we still have the same /meme/core as in 2013? it's 2016 people, come on!
>>
>>65568241
that is exactly what Helpless Child sounds like
they aim to do too much and end up achieving very little
>>
>>65567832
Something like this?
>>
>>65568273
lol listen to the whole album
>>
>>65568285
No. That's fucking sucks. WTF??? BTBAM? lol
>>
>>65568290
i've already expended more than 40 minutes on Swans just for you
they're not that great
>>
>>65568285
I don't think the generals should have as much of a say as main /mu/. They are pretty small after all. And you might as well throw in /bleep/ if you're doing that.

At the end of the day, pop/rock is like 80% of the discussion on /mu/. The chart should reflect that.
>>
>>65568285
add morning musume
>>
>>65568323
I remember Colors was posted all the time a few years ago
>>
>>65568324
Exactly that is evidence that you are pleb.
>>
>>65568324
Just listen to your jpop then :^)
>>
>>65565174
you cunt i was just getting into rakim and the feelies too. now i'm a faggot, thanks a lot
>>
>>65568285
It sucks than >>65565174 this.
>>
>>65568365
i can't believe you rused me into listening to something you think is shit
>>
>>65566159
yearly /mu/-core sounds good, i can get behind that
>>
>>65568397
wtf are you talking about, he means you're a pleb for thinking swans are bad (especially if you like fucking jpop)
>>
>>65568397
Oh, thanks a lot buddy.
>>
>>65568397
You are just model of pleb. You are pleb itself.
>>
>>65568431
surely he meant for actually spending forty minutes listening to three Swans tracks
i don't think they're bad, i think they're generic and uninteresting
>>
File: 1465594995170.png (1003 KB, 1314x912) Image search: [Google]
1465594995170.png
1003 KB, 1314x912
>>
>>65568397
i listened to To Be Kind as my first album, and I while it was playing I thought I disliked it (well, not dislike, but would never play again), however when it ended I felt like I needed more Swans in my life
>>
>>65568479
Switch The Money Store (it's shit) for Bottomless Pit or TPTB
>>
>Liking swans
>unironically
evidence enough that new /mu/ posters don't have the level of taste required to change /mu/core
>>
HURRRRRRRRRRRR REDDIT ARE SUCH PLEBS FOR CIRCLEJERKING OVER THE SAME ALBUMS/ARTISTS ALL THE TIME REEEEEEEEE

Hey guise, lets make a chart and circlejerk over the same albums all time!!!!!!
>>
>>65568514
>BP>TMS
wut
>>
>>65568479
this is very very good.

trout mask replica perhaps shouldn't be there, it's a bit too... divsive

I would also remove art angels because I believe grimes is much closer to lavren than she is to bjork

I dont think it's necessary to have 2 anco albums, although both are huge here so idk

good adds with pink moon, a love supreme, since i left you, long season, and banana

not sure about music for 18 musicians, it's not talked about too much

immunity and replica are good choices also but idk if they're talked about that much or if i'm biased by how long i spend in /aeg/ and other warp-related threads

nominations, i think you could consider adding in rainbows or ok computer possibly. maybe wish you were here?
>>
File: 1464638631410.jpg (45 KB, 681x496) Image search: [Google]
1464638631410.jpg
45 KB, 681x496
>>65568567
>tms above anything
>>
>>65568529
you idiot we already have a chart for circlejerking over. we're trying to update that chart for 2016 because it's outdated
>>
>>65568479
Beautiful. I don't agree with some of those choices, not because I don't like them, but because I don;t see them frequently being posted.

IMO, remove: Music for 18 musicians and Immunity. I don't see them often.

Homogenic and Art Angels may be debatable, as they're sometimes just posted because of the waifufags.

Replace Immunity with Madvillainy and you're done and A love supreme with Have one on me and it is done.

Where did you make this (so maybe I can do it)?
>>
>>65565174
This is basically a shorter version of the essentials.
>>
File: 1464869728009.png (395 KB, 693x614) Image search: [Google]
1464869728009.png
395 KB, 693x614
>>65568660
>bp above anything
>>
>>65565174
Funkadelc (funk and soul in general) are vastly underappreciated here
>>
>>65568727
because they're shit.

>2016
>not listening to disco and house
>>
>>65568479
sweet trip velocity design comfort and have one on me should be there

>>65568680
>because of the waifufags.

bjork and grimes are not too similar imo. i think bjork is talked about enough to be /mu/core even without the waifufags.

I'm >>65567890, made with http://topsters2.herokuapp.com/

>Madvillainy

yes, of course! 100% has to be there, how did we all miss it. 100% /mu/core
>>
File: pleb.png (481 KB, 553x827) Image search: [Google]
pleb.png
481 KB, 553x827
>>65568724
>having no taste
>>
>>65568756
>100% /mu/core
no it's not. also why not kys?
>>
>>65568679
I'm well aware of that.
>>
File: 1465457975837.gif (666 KB, 300x340) Image search: [Google]
1465457975837.gif
666 KB, 300x340
>>65568802
>preferring tms than bp is not having taste
>>
File: v4.png (1 MB, 1333x858) Image search: [Google]
v4.png
1 MB, 1333x858
whachu guys think of this.

>>65568813
madvillainy is talked about all the fucking time here idiot
>>
>>65567890
>merriweather post pavilion

Why that album? STGSTV is objectively better.
>>
>>65568753
>2016
>Dismissing entire genres as shit
>>
>>65568895
MPP is a massive part of board culture and is talked about every day
>>
File: 1464557105910.jpg (561 KB, 1071x1600) Image search: [Google]
1464557105910.jpg
561 KB, 1071x1600
>>65568883
>listening to TMS more than once (to find out that it's shit)
shiddily diddily
>>
>>65568893
>two AnCo
Take off that MPP. STGSTV is enough.
>>
>>65568939
I would take off STG before MPP tbqh, MPP is not as good but is talked about much much more
>>
>>65568893
>madvillainy is talked about all the fucking time here idiot
is that what makes it /mu/core? then why not put the entire kanye discograpgy up in it, lauren's band, drake and whatever the fuck else keeps getting spammed (that album with the red lines on white background)
>>
>>65568479
>art angels

Why? It's common opinion on /mu/ that Visions was a better album.
>>
/mu/core will live forever

we have tiers in the original graphic for a reason
>>
>>65568963
1 kanye album is enough. lauren is posted as fap material only. drake is routinely met with more criticism than praise. the vulfpeck album (red lines on white background) is just some guy spamming it on unrelated threads for a laugh.
>>
>>65569026
but 1 animality collection album is not enough?
>>
>>65568893
Where is Grimes? And 1 AnCo is enough.
>>
>>65569052
yeah I agree I wasn't really sure which one to take off, as mentioned here >>65568939 and >>65568958

Which one do you think should go off? I think I'll put MHTRTC in its place

>>65569079
if a couple more people say to put Grimes then I'll do it but I'm not sure how much of it is just waifufagging
>>
>>65568482
huh, is that the one with the ugly baby face
>>
>>65569099
Painting With
>>
>>65569117
yes
>>
>>65569117
yes, but i wouldn't say it's ugly

>>65568514
this is correct. not BP though, but The Powers That B should be there instead. it's litearally the best thing death grip has put out
>>
>>65569117
No. Don't listen to that. Just listen to "Morning Musume" That's better way to you. 8^)
>>
>>65565174
This is more depressing than the current /mu/core
>>
>>65568479
fuck off with art angels
>>
>>65569193
it goes without saying that i think Musume are better than Swans, but just because you like one thing doesn't mean you can't try other things
>>
>>65568893
Seems about right. When you get tired of doing these let us know to continue the work.

If people are positive on just 1 AnCo I'd recommend MPP.

Also, about grimes: there's a thread right now about it, and there seems to be no general consensus whatsoever of the album (you can check the thread now if you want, >>65559317)
>>
>>65565174
>>
>>65567227

Whoa, spot on.
>>
>>65567431
>>65567300

Car Seat Headrest is talked about more than Talk Talk, whether you like it or not.
>>
>>65566009
best chart in thread
>>
>>65568680
Topsters + Photoshop
>>
>>65569345
agree. I like Talk Talk much more, but toledo is practically a meme.
>>
>>65569244
I listened to Musume song what you recommend ed. It's qt cute and enjoyable, but I couldn't find difference with mere k-pop.
>>
>>65569345
This.
>>
File: v5.png (1 MB, 1250x791) Image search: [Google]
v5.png
1 MB, 1250x791
>>65569279
Yeah decided to go with MPP and replace STG with MHTRTC

Also sorted by release date now.

Let me know what you guys think of this one now. I think it's looking pretty good tbqh

Also don't worry about me being finished or anything, just make your own chart and we can discuss the differences more easily
>>
>people spending time to update the meme-chart
>>
>>65569529
not like i have anything else going on in my life :(
>>
>>65569502
Is there discussion about pink moon?
>>
File: 1465404027291.jpg (54 KB, 640x472) Image search: [Google]
1465404027291.jpg
54 KB, 640x472
>>65569529
Pic related
>>
>>65569502
Ys should replace Have One on Me imo.
>>
>>65569548
Hmm good point. I think this chart might be a bit too influenced by my own taste. Feel free to make your own though I gotta go
>>
>>65569502
I think Endtroducing and That Jason Aldean record should be considered. NMH, Bloody Valentine and Nick Drake are rarely discussed anymore. TMS should be replaced with Bottomless Pit.
>>
>>65569682
I think TPTB is better to put in this chart.
>>
>>65569737
>>65569682
the guy that that was doing these left. I'd do some now, but I'm at work.
>>
>>65569682
the jason aldean album is a joke, it's not actual /mu/core

NMH and MBV are still discussed quite a bit I think
>>
>>65569755
Agreed.
>>
>>65569682
I agree TMS should be replaced, but with TPTB instead, like >>65569737 and others have said
>>
>>65569969
>>65569952
>>65569755
>>65569737


K i'll do the chart in like ten mins
>>
>>65565793
No, that would be The Pixies Doolittle
>>
don't die thread, im doing the chart
>>
>>65570399
we gon make it
>>
>>65570399
haha it'd be funny if you somehow died before having finished the chart and it never gets posted xD
>>
>>65570605
haha
>>
>>65570605
lol
>>
File: New Mucore.jpg (964 KB, 2425x1680) Image search: [Google]
New Mucore.jpg
964 KB, 2425x1680
Thoughts?

I took out Spirit of Eden because I see Twin Fantasy much more discussed around here. Talk Talk is not very frequently mentioned. Toledo is.

I also changed TMS for TPTB, out of demand. TMS is not that frequently seen anymore, contrary to the latter, specially Niggas on the Moon.
>>
>>65570783
get rid of trout mask replica and put close to the edge back imo
>>
>>65570783
Since I Left You is on twice
>>
>>65570783
Endtoducing is seen often enough to be on the chart
Everything Everything - Get to Heaven , should be there as well, even though it has died down a bit, it's still a big album on /mu/
for hip-hop, Liquid Swords or 36 Chambers, those get mentioned a lot, also lil ugly mane's album
Tobacco gets a thread once every few weeks which gets a few really hyped responses, will release a new album this year too
I thought about the new Vektor album, but it's too recent, maybe
Blank Banshee literally posted on /mu/ so he should get in there too (1>0)
Clarence Clarity gets mentioned often (kinda) too
Sunbather? ;^)

that's all i could think of
>>
>>65570871
but TMR is discussed a fuck ton here. The only other one that gets as much discussion is probably Pet Sounds and ITAOTS.

I agree about Close to the Edge. Where, if not in TMR, in case I don't take it out?
>>
>>65570920
Well you have SILY on twice lol.

Also there's no need to be stuck with 5x5. Feel free to go to 6x5

>>65570911
I think Endtroducing, 36 Chambers, and Sunbather are good shouts also
>>
>>65570920
I also really think Talk Talk deserves a place. Don't get why it's suddenly a competition with Car Seat Headrest.
>>
>>65570901
lol sorry I was doing it fast so the thread dint die. I'll fix it.
>>
>>65570911
i;d like to see Blank Banshee there too desu
Get to Heaven too.
also agree with >>65570952

>>65570920
yes, put TMR there
>>
>>65570783
>6 of those albums I consider to be some of my favorite records of all time

Does this make me a pleb, /mu/?
It's hard for me to branch from those when I feel that those are already some of the best, if not the best, of the genre.
>>
>>65570952
>. Feel free to go to 6x5
yes, feel free to expand
>>
>>65570952
agree. Will add them. Sorry about SILY twice lol. I don't want to go much more than 6x5. What should be the limit? 6x5? 6x6?

>>65570971
I love talk talk much more than CSH, but there's not much discussion about them anymore. Laughing Stock gets posted ssometimes, and Eden is rarely seen. It is almost universally loved, yes, but so are manyb albums that aren't mu-core.

If many people agree though, I'll add it.
>>
Don't die thread
>>
>>65571230
shit im leaving work. Keep the thread alive or some shit. I'll post the revised version in a little while.
>>
File: new mucore 3.png (4 MB, 2733x1988) Image search: [Google]
new mucore 3.png
4 MB, 2733x1988
OK. Thoughts? /thread?
>>
>>65571381
just saw the double madvillainy. Will fix when i get home.
>>
>>65571291
If thread dies, make new thread my man.
>>
>it's a "newfag who's only been lurking for a few hours misunderstands the concept of /mu/core" episode
>>
>>65571403
double madvillainy is ok

I'd delete death grips (love them but still), and blank banshee
>>
File: v6.png (2 MB, 1410x782) Image search: [Google]
v6.png
2 MB, 1410x782
>>65571381
honestly blank banshee and ween deserve to be nowhere near this

Im the guy that was doign these a while ago, back now. added some of the ones from urs
>>
>>65571544
It looks good.
>>
>>65571455
what's the concept of /mu/core then oh wise one
>>
All of these are pleb high school shit.

Get some personality, /mu/.
>>
>>>65571820
new thread
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 37

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.