Why is this considered "bad Noise" while other noise albums are better?
>>65439445
you can't criticize what was ahead of its time
plus it was made for laffs
>noise
>better
>implying
>lou reed is lazy and creates joke album
>everyone hails it as revolutionary new genre
lel
Because the creator of the genre even said it was a joke and only created to fulfil his contract with a label. The noise-fags claim this is bad so they can keep pretending they enjoy other noise music
>>65439793
The most talented hack of all time
>>65439445
because its too fucking long and lacks the kinds of dynamics that people look for in a noise album. try this instead.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSCrR68BxYY
>>65440357
>>65439793
i like noise and other people took it serious after Reed, like the Japanoise scene
>>65439445
he released it as a joke.
Im not a fan of noise but obviously there is more effort put into more serious noise and more interesting textures going on
>>65439476
>plus it was made for laffs
This
>>65440436
You're a fag, MMM is way more dynamic than fucking Hanatarash lmao
>>65441457
in what way?
>>65439793
>>65441389
>>65439476
I think he just said this to justify himself after the fact
>>65439445
>Why is this considered "bad Noise" while other noise albums are better?
I don't know. It's the precursor to most modern noise/industrial and it's a fantastic album.
Whether or not it was intended as a serious artistic statement is irrelevant.
>>65443421
that so many
>I don't know. It's the precursor to most modern noise/industrial and it's a fantastic album.
>fantastic album
>>65439445
it's not considered bad noise. it's considered bad because it's noise
>>65443421
i can't imagine lou reed would release that album completely earnestly
he wasn't a fool, he knew exactly what he was doing
>>65439445
This is better noise.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKA3Ycy5ioI
>>65443421
>I think he just said this to justify himself after the fact
Actually its a myth, he never said that the album was a joke or that he tried to troll the label.
He loves that album, and even make a side project called metal machine trio
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWV5wGRl-Jo
>>65443478
It is, deal with it.
in the 90s the album was even transposed for orchestra, I attended the concert, Lou was there too.
Considering TVU were already making some pseudo-noise improvisations on their albums and on the Symphony of Sound live video (both around 1967), I really doubt this was made as a joke.
It's not like they were the first ones anyways, bands like The Ethix were already doing it on 1966.
