What's Animal Collective's best album?
Strawberry Jam
probably tylo be living on it
As an album
>>65021137
whichever one's the shortest.
>>65021171
I agree, as an album it's the most consistent
>>65021137
that's third place
best is definitely sung tongs
>>65021137
right now? sung tongs
in 20 years? painting with
>>65021137
STGSTV > SJ > MPP = Sung Tongs > Feels = PW >>>> CHz >> HCTI > Danse = Campfire
MPP, also its the most accessible so its a win-win
Feels
If you say STGSTV you're jusy being a contrarian for the sake of it
Its a good album but being obscure =/= being the best
Why is Hollinndagain and Campfire Songs so slept on?
>>65021742
Campfire isnt slept on at all
And holland is just a live album
Spirit or MPP
>>65021703
STGSTV isnt obscure and sj is better than feels
>>65021137
feels = sung tongs = mpp > stgstv > cs > sj > hcti > pw = chz >>>>>>>> danse
Feels = Campfire Songs > Sung Tongs > Fall Be Kind > MPP > HCtI >Spirit = SJ > Painting With > Centipede >>>>>>>>>> Danse
imo
Feels = Sung Tongs = MPP = Strawberry Jam > STGSTV = Campfire Songs >> Here Comes The Indian >> Painting With = CHz > Danse
Fall Be Kind > Prospect Hummer > Water Curses >>>>>> People
by far
Despite what the special snowflakes on /mu/ will tell you, their best is one of their big 4 albums. Sung Tongs, Feels, Strawberry Jam, Merriweather Post Pavillion. One of the most solid runs in any discography.
STGSTV > SJ = ST = MPP > HCTI > Feels > Danse = CS > CHz > PW
In my opinion
>>65021703
STGSTV isn't anything weird, it's genuinely great music with excellent drums and vocals
>anco
>good
https://youtu.be/KiSwGbv4QUg
>>65022176
they look kind of ridiculous playing that song but it sounds great. i wish i was there
you posted it
>>65021778
>>65022111
both of these Tbh
>>65022213
>anco fans
>>65021758
hollidnandagiggidy is from two different sessions and all the songs are exclusive to the album
also it's one of my favorite so fuck off
>>65021742
hollinndagain is slept on cause it's a live album. It's good though
CS isn't slept on, it's just their worst album
>>65021172
So Painting With?
>>65021137
Yes, STGSTV is their only listenable album.
STGSTV>>>>Feels>Sung Tongs>SJ>MPP>HCTI>Hollindagain>PW>CHz>Campfire Songs>Danse Manatee
All of them <3
SJ = STGSTV > The rest
>>65021703
spirit has most of their most ambitious song writing tho
>>65023372
kek its probably one of their least listenable but I will agree it is their best
>>65021137
You answered that question yourself. Here's my personal rating.
STGSTV>SJ=ST>Feels>MPP>PW
Haven't listened to their other albums.
STGSTV, MPP an CHZ are the only enjoyable Animal Collective albums for me, but then again im the apex patrician when it comes to music.
Alvin Row is the best rock song ever made
Spirit > HCTI > Feels > ST > MPP > Hollindagain > Campfire Songs > Jam > Danse > Painting With > CHz
This is objectively correct, with the only exception being that someone may prefer HCTI to Spirit.
>>65025204
>Apex patrician
>CHz
"no"
>>65021137
STGSTV>Feels>SJ>MPP>HCTI>Sung Tongs>Campfire Songs>Centipede Hz>Painting With>Danse Manatee
>>65025461
Switch HTCi and MPP and it's good
>>65025461
>>65025505
>SJ that high
but why
>>65025617
also
>danse last
this meme needs to stop
