Give me a song. I'll listen to it and do some critique. It can be material of yours if you want.
hey man, appreciate it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c71RCAyLS1M
>>64809470
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3rg4psdHxw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CozBD3GAP0
could you check this one out for me my man https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMbQsKJ64S0
>>64809518
Very nice start, that's a lot of sound for just a voice and an ukulele. Didn't expect the percussions mid-way. Nailed composition and lenght. (7.5/10)
>>64809586
I think this played in Namco videogame collection game on PC during the selection menu? Good sounds and progression, the voice felt a bit off. I like that style of singing but it didn't fit well... (6/10)
>>64809625
Oh well, there is a lot of effort and it sounds like a proper song. The piano blends well, but the song's third act is lame and the backing vocals were stereotypical as hell. Really generic lyrics and production... (5.5/10)
>>64809632
It's like a mediocre stamp of the first song, very little variation. (4/10)
>>64809470
thanks my dude
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0B7Z3JERdk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8GH_zacKZ0
>>64810069
I've always been on the not-so-cringy side on this. TMM is some experimental shizz. The guitarist is going all virtuoso on this but there is little coherent material throughout all of the set. At 4 minutes in they redeem themselves. It's like Ride and early Slint had a crazy nerd baby. Mad drums, bass is on point. (8/10)
Now, this is art
https://youtu.be/gN2zcLBr_VM
Ladies and gentleman, The next anthony fantano
>>64809470
just found this guy yesterday and I like it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVbupT0o0gQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-zIXTn63hg
https://youtu.be/VfEvLC1Lw8c
I dont know what hour is better, please help me
>>64810069
Bad production, he sounds like someone who just... tried. Decent movements there. Not a great song to cover... (3.5/10)
>>64810223
Cage's piece is one big meme. Modern and contemporary art itself doesn't have standards by definition, so I really can't judge anything. Just analyse. It's a meme indeed. (?/10)
>>64810299
Missing punctuation and a wrong choice of casing don't honor the dubs very well. (5.5/10)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWeDev0QWLc
>>64810376
>Missing punctuation and a wrong choice of casing don't honor the dubs very well. (5.5/10)
kek
>>64810317
I don't like the burstsy/high filtered drum change. Whack beat, sick flow and lyrics. The ending is DGripsesque. (7/10)
>>64810349
Reminds me of Halsey which isn't really a good sign... (2/10 for now, requires more time to decide)
>>64810428
Hot fucking damn, this is a literal drum banger. I hope the lyrics are good. Those fucking backing screams kill it. (9/10)
>>64809470
What are your qualifications pertaining to the criticism of music?
Hey OP, you forgot to review: >>64810150
>>64810612
I have basic knowledge of music theory, can play piano and bass decently and I listen before I say anything.
>>64810636
I have, it's the 3.5/10 one, I hit the wrong reply.
You should start a youtube channel. This sort of criticism would fit in well there.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=0541GWOYkKM
Interested in hearing your thoughts OP
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbTggEMAtHs
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0adEBYz7B0v
Tear me up OP.
>>64810850
Strawberry Jam is my favorite record from AnCo, yet I think that Reverend Green is probably its weakest song: it goes quite hard but doesn't transmit the same feels as any other song. While every piece of soundscape from SJ can fit a definite image in your head, Reverend Green struggles to do so since the signifier is as tame as the message, even if well done by my standards. The cryptic lyrics and the accessible tunes sure make a weird contrast, but it's not my shtick. I don't know if, objectively, it could be good, but it could be done a tad better. (8.5/10)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fAnkU9hqJbE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WVE90vGS9ps
>>64810869
It feels hard to rate this, it's a generic rock song with a slight quality twist. Kind of a vengeful happy feeling, lasts as long as it should, good vocals. (A point more or less from 6.5/10, giving the benefit of the doubt here)
>>64810947
Feels like the ending theme for a 2006-2009 DS video game, processed by MIDI. (6/10 if it's made to fit the mood)
>>64811124
Correction, like the really sad moment when you discover someone died in a DS RPG.
>>64810997
I like the ups and down as the song goes and get the right kind of vibe. Feels like homemade tempura. Gets good in the middle. (7.5/10)
>>64811022
Never heard this one but I know that QOTSA knows how to give a certain kind of emotion. Nice progression and drums, the vocals at the start fit perfectly. (9/10)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wilAJ3IMqOo
>>64810371
Hey OP! You forgot this!
for u https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_l8RXpYYjA
I'm so nervious by this one
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQAIdE0hP50
SPOILER: turn down the volume of your speakers
>>64809470
http://nocband.bandcamp.com/track/swallow-this-fire
jazz
>>64811355
Experimental film soundtrack? Feels useless as a standalone song. I like the tempo. (?/10)
>>64811384
I'd be down to do this but I only have one hour.
>>64811432
Classical jap culturewanking, feels like an anime theme on drugs. Great presentation, the horns guys aren't that skilled but I'm down with it. (7/10 for performance, 8/10 for on-stage fuckery)
I'm having a 3 minute pause to piss and shit. Use this time to remember I'm boss.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LP5ryVs_P0
i'd like to see what you think of these guys
Please ignore the video of the alien dancing cumbia 100% real no fake
Just listen to the sample and thell me what you think of it, is very short
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OWodAv1KHaM
https://apmacroeconomics.bandcamp.com/track/does-she-have-a-cdl
THE AWESOMENESS OF NIRVANA
https://youtu.be/5gInU1kE7C0?t=55s
>>64811541
Good, but it feels "lost"... nice lyrics, well produced, it just doesn't make sense sonorically. What is the growling bassline and repeated drumming supposed to make me feel? (6.5/10)
>>64811524
The bass is just perfect. Great guitar and singing, it's like SOAD fused with Dismemberment Plan. I already told myself to get into these guys. (8/10)
>>64811597
Melody's perfect. Nice voice and oh my, those hi-hats! Curious tempo changes, I could delve into this with more listens. (8.5/10)
>>64811789
>>64811600
Crappy latino drum machine music from the '80s they would use in comedy movies whenever someone went to South America. (4.5/10)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZfI9AT6QXU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1Ispkd-SZ0
>>64811944
to be fair, in the latin music i'm surprised that you didn't put it a 1
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0FX2iaM1oOt
6.vbnfkgtl or: Fuck Me Lil Boi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkx-7fsiWgg
This music is in every corner of south america, just see the views
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gnntMvMgx4
http://vocaroo.com/i/s1uNJ4p0CSmJ
I'm pulling these from the other thread
>>64812110
That was track 1
Track 3:
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0XBdKCIpVIQ
I'm calling it now, three more songs and the vocaroos after this post and I'm done!
>>64811660
You had cheap gear and you somehow managed to make music. That's what I call effort. Your usual college wankery but, hey... (7/10)
>>64811971
1. The next Yoko Ono. (3/10)
2. Stil the next Yoko Ono, yet somehow less painful. (4/10)
>>64811998
Novelty internet comedy music. Smithy Boy docet. (1.5/10)
>>64812015
Entiendo todo, thank (?) God I'm fluent in the language. Average, nice song at least. Disliked the autotune, liked the video, nice twist. (5.5/10)
>>64812018
Nailed guitar and bass, blows up 2 minutes in. Whistle-along melody. (8/10)
http://soundcloud.com/scratchbear/deafcon
>>64812110
I like the chiptune in the background and the racial slurs add to the mood. Feels like being closed in an autistic Garry's Mod room. (4.5/10)
>>64812110
What the fuck is that supposed to be? At least there's some kind of coherent rhythm... the singer tried. (5/10).
Come on. Post three songs so that I can fuck off.
Track 4
http://www9.zippyshare.com/v/BnFuQxVc/file.html
I'll gladly take over for him.
>>64812224
>>64812015
No! No! You must put it a 0! i hate that music! i need somebody to accompany me in my suffering :'(
https://apmacroeconomics.bandcamp.com/track/bagels-are-ill-2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAXjQ7gy6Y0
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=8&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwj3k5_hwNXMAhUX4mMKHe4NDwMQtwIIPDAH&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DXe0fvUgvvQg&usg=AFQjCNE2cWdcYOrC7bklrTh1U5zBdFp66g&sig2=xHIUb6Gennie9lilO25OEQ
>>64812403
Whoops, that's supposed to be
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xe0fvUgvvQg
After he reviews those three, foam roller takin over
>>64812269
Starts off as what I would call Pitchforkcore before delving into the realm of post-digital hardcore. I'd call this vaporstep. (6.5/10)
>>64812291
Fine, bud. You can go on now.
I don't really know, it's like this kind of half-assed lounge music and video poker selection screen combination... feels "good". (4/10)
>>64812351
Everybody hates mainstream music from their country, but close an eye, it's not too bad. But I can understand the latin american struggle situation
>>64812363
The synths remind me of Metal Gear Solid 2's as if they were handed by Trent Reznor. (7/10)
>>64812352
Feels much more generic than its predecessor. Campfireish. (5.5/10).
My eyes are closing guys, planet sleep is calling me.
I'll be here again with another thread tomorrow at the same time (two hours before now) to review and listen to your music. Another Scaruffi pic's gonna be in the OP. See you!
>>64812423
Commented earlier on the fact that I love how she became serious after this and quit two years after... (1/10, it's for the effort to produce the music and direct your own video)
>>64812466
Done, you go.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8r1GhOwzDNI
maybe just from the half to the end, because is a little long
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ae5jjFAK38g
>>64812528
Hoy boy! This is some heavy stuff. It sounds like listening to Metallica under an underpass while the local homeless guy near by is hocking a lougee. I don't like Metallica. 3/10. I liked the ringing in the end though, I like the feeling of having tinnitus.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fOaTEDYJmi0
>>64812610
I gave the beginning a little bit of a listen, and it was kinda like Cage the Elephant if they got more poppy and I guess bluesgrassy? So I started at half-way and it has this airy feel to it, almost dreamy. Got a lot heavier. I love the drum work. The singer kinda bugs me. It gets pretty crazy later on though, I dig it. Overall though, I feel the singer takes away from it. 6/10.
>>64812630
It seems like solid folk jazz guitar chord progression, seems like traditional. It kinda gets repetitive. The singer gets angry at times. At a certain point, the singer just inhales through his nose and it's kinda gross. 4/10
i seen a mars volta song here but this is different
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C0F7eFxhXM
from the minute 9 to the end is the important part if you wanna skip it, but all the song is georgeous
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1nTxbRyRMnY
animal collective here!
here OP
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3dGArEa9fA
Gotta go pick up my girlfriend but keep posting and I will get back to all of these.
>>64809470
Got into Sonic Youth recently and want to see what you thought of this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l0gVLb8i0aw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZhSVwcRcMIk&index=5&list=PLH22-xSMERQpG4M9HshhXUJ9OKMNlwU8T
Fukin Animals As Leaders
headphones necesary
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hbnnFxXLuJk
the new wave
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsr-kN3QU8U
Bump from original OP going to bed. See you tomorrow.
that's deep
some merzbow related!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gan1oKzVtiU
What do you think Piero?
https://youtu.be/1uWfTUby9IE
