What is the greatest progressive rock album of all time and why is it pic related?
you already posted it, op
It's either ITCOTCK, 666, or Close To The Edge. Tales From Topographic Oceans might be the most ambitious but it certainly has enough flaws holding it back.
>>64540102
That one is not so great.
>>64540241
A lot better than OP's pick.
I'm gonna have to stop you there my friend.
>Dancing With The Moonlit Knight
>I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)
>The Battle Of Epping Forest
>Firth Of Fifth
>The Cinema Show
Easily some of the greatest songs written in history.
>>64540102
Stupid angloshitters
Don't even know pic related or MDK
>>64540432
Go to bed Vander, no one cares about your John Coltrane Operas.
>>64540507
Fuck off Kikefield, stop stealing other people's music and go back to masturbating with your bells. Your music is novelty shit and the only reason people like you is muh Tubular Bells in muh movie
>>64540432
everybody on here knows about magma you fucking tool just that they don't really give a shit for pompous overly theatrical opera jazz
>>64540564
>everybody on here knows about magma you fucking tool
Evidently OP hasn't
>>64540548
Seriously dude nobody fucking likes you lol
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway or Close to the Edge
>>64540588
Said Mike Oldfield, man responsible for ripping other people off and then passing it off as his music, which in the first place no one even likes.
>>64540548
>magma fan calling something novetly
oh lordy fucking LORD
Fuck off you gook go play LoL or something
>>64540623
How are Magma a novelty again? Someone fell for the lyrics meme?
Whatever go back to listening to british fucks masturbating on their guitars and then selling out
>>64540620
I feel bad for you
Mods are monitoring this thread! OOOOOOOO
...anyway
>No Talk Talk post
Am I not on /mu/?
close the thread op proge mon is here
>>64540654
I feel even worse for your endless samefagging.
Well while proge thinks everyone shitting on him for being an asshole is just doing it to defend Oldfield, i'll keep posting albums that are better than Foxtrot
>>64540721
>everyone
It's one Oldfield fanboy and one butthurt shitposter
Also I'll start posting more albums better than OP's pic to rerail this thread.
Is proge mon the resident tripfag of /mu/? (fa/tv/irgin here.)
>>64540653
king crimson yes and gg sold out what is your fucking point
>Whatever go back to listening to british fucks masturbating on their guitars
>>64540763
this isnt even prog
>>64540765
I'm one of the (many) tripfags which became infamous for shitposting
>>64540816
Gee, I wonder why.
>>64540432
Was this really any point of posting that remark apart from wanting to derail another thread?
>>64540811
>king crimson sold out
Haha oh boy wew
What is Discipline
What is THRAK
Exactly, Yes and Genesis turned to complete shit the moment they stopped making money. Now stop acting like your angloproge shit is the greatest stuff to ever grace the earth.
Amazing, the deluded angloprog fan doesn't know what Canterbury Scene is
>>64540836
Screw off
>>64540856
To tell OP that he's naive and his taste is shit.
I'm posting more good prog anyways so it doesn't matter
This is something a bit more modern
>>64540868
have you really not heard beat and three of perfect pair theyre your basic new-wave album
>Amazing, the deluded angloprog fan doesn't know what Canterbury Scene is
soft machine were canterbury yea but that album really is not at all
>To tell OP that he's naive and his taste is shit.
You're the most naive person I've seen ever and the fact that you think you deserve a personality on an anonymous board is pathetic
Another more modern proge
>>64540938
Yeah but they aren't selling out either
Fuck's sake, that album is made out of 4 20 minute+ songs. If anything it's their only prog album, the ones before it were psych rock and the ones after were fusion.
Oh sure, keep telling yourself that whiny faggot
>>64540868
I wish Comus was a genre.
The album is genuinely perfect.
>>64540868
>Posting the poseurcore of prog
>Good prog
lmao, shouldn't you be getting off to some child porn right now?
Even more modern proge
>>64540986
I wish their second album really came out
Imagine though, two fucking side-long songs of the genius style of First Utterance.
Man it sucks that it never materialized properly.
>>64540990
And it's this forced meme again
>>64540990
Don't worry he'll grow up
>>64541011
>genesis are crap
>nu-prog is great 10/10
ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
Here's an obvious one
A bit sporkish but whatever
>>64541030
Oh boy it's the nu-prog shitposter again
Go away, no one likes you or your buzzwords
>>64541011
> wish their second album really came out
>Imagine though, two fucking side-long songs of the genius style of First Utterance.
OH MY FUCKING GOD
You know what the worst part about that whole affair is? They broke up ONE. YEAR. before Close to the Edge and Thick as a Brick showed how you could have side long songs and still a single. OH MY FUCK I just want to go back in time and slap them and say wait one more year I will bring you money from the damn future if you stay in this band for one more year.
At least the material on Out of the Coma was decent.
>>64541075
>Oh boy it's the nu-prog shitposter again Go away, no one likes you or your buzzwords
not a buzzword a lot its very much a real thing
nu-prog is shitty progressive rock that comes from an alt-rock indie or post-hardcore background how is that a buzzword
>>64541098
It's still the best prog to come out of the 2000's and the best candidate we have for Dark Side of the Moon of the 2000's.
>>64541077
Out of the Coma was a good album, although the title track had some pretty stupid vocal performances from Roger
But holy fuck HOLY FUCK THE MALGAARD SUITE
>>64541098
Yeah it's a buzzword alright
Go away, we're actually having music discussion here
>>64541135
Fuck why haven't I listened to that album yet
>inb4 IT'S NOT PROGE
>>64541240
shub niggurath isnt good and you know it isnt
OK, guys, I was joking.
Here's the actual best progressive rock album.
>>64541269
Stop shitposting and contribute
>>64540548
>not even the best Henry cow album
>>64541303
>Halloween music
Fuck off imposter.
Done posting albums, I'm bored now
>>64541329
Leg End is great but it ain't got shit on IPoL
Unrest has a meme second side
Western Culture is just mediocre as fuck.
>>64541335
Go away
>>64541380
Western Culture is their best because it's just really good chamber music
>>64541401
Western Culture sucks compared to IPoL. Easily their worst
Every song is brilliant. Even my father likes it
>>64540102
Anyone go a link for this album? The ones in the archive are dead.
>>64541453
It's on Spotify.
>>64541444
I can't get into Cardiacs. They try to hard to be "dude we're so weird and eclectic lmao" and their style becomes really predictable after about 20 minutes.
>>64541453
>soulseek
>rutracker
>>64541282
This album is fucking awful and cringey, that being said, Our New World is the best song they've written in like the last decade. Awake is their best
>>64541415
So you think that univers zero are the best thing since sliced bread... but you don't like western culture?
>>64540102
its okay
>>64540384
i dont like the progression
>>64541497
Not the best but one of
Western Culture technically isn't even a Henry Cow album, it's a Tim Hodgkinson and Lindsay Cooper collaboration with Fred Frith and Chris Cutler as session musicians.
The first Art Bears album is the real final Henry Cow album
>>64541492
>They try to hard to be "dude we're so weird and eclectic lmao" and their style becomes really predictable after about 20 minutes.
w/e you don't know shit about anything I can say that I can tell what is going to happen in the next 20 minutes when I'm into the first 30 seconds of a Magma album but is that really true fuck off
>>64541559
This is why people think Cardiacs fans are autistic. Because they are.
It was just an honest opinion and I wanted you to give me an album that would prove me wrong. Instead you go full salt mode and get butthurt that someone doesn't like your sporkshit
>>64540241
>buy on vinyl for like 5 bucks
>its just medieval-sounding flute wankery
why the fuck do people like this
>>64541616
youre the most salty and autistic person on here
>>64541665
Either recommend me a Cardiacs album to change my mind about them or take your Dead Sea shit elsewhere
>>64541637
the best type of prog is medieval shit if im being honest
>>64541680
overrated medieval shit, i prefer midnight mushrumps for some reason
give it a spin if you havent
>>64541637
Why is it that when people hear Jethro Tull all they can focus on is the flute? Everybody that I've tried talking to about them is only capable of some "lol yeah they're that classic rock band with the flute player that's pretty cool i guess" shit.
>>64541707
listen to sing to god in short bursts whatever you do dont play it one right after the other for the entirety of the two discs
You probably wont like it anyway because you don't like Queen
You're a piece of crap by the way
>>64541779
What about something a bit shorter? Sing to God is fucking huge.
And stop being so salty. You're the one that's being an uncalled for asshole here, not me
>>64541830
you started this thread off being an uncalled asshole because somebody liked genesis for christs sake
if you really want something shorter listen to Big Ship
>>64541896
Because he claimed it was the best prog album of all time which is an incredibly ignorant and ridiculous statement
I'll try that one out then
>>64541920
who cares it may be to him genesis are great
>>64541749
im not a huge fan of the flute and it's in damn near the whole album (iirc which i likely do not). it has its place of course but damn i get it, "fwoodly doodly", tell me something i don't know
>>64542007
Genesis are good but definitely nowhere near the best of all time
>>64542106
i feel the same about magma its a huge spinning wheel that never stops
>>64541415
>>64541380
>2nd side of unrest is meme
>western culture is worst
I tried to by hop in the bandwagon and dislike you but you just proved how shit your musical perception is
>ctrl+f
>hemispheres
>0 results
>>64541637
HOW ARE YOU
Foxtrot was my first genesis and that's why it's the best genesis
>>64542166
Haha he thinks he can bandwagon hop and still have a valid opinion
Kill yourself
>>64542773
>>64542806
woah lol i got blown out there how would i recover from such a burn xd have leddit gold
>>64542820
>>64540102
Supper's Ready is the GOAT Gabriel-era song but Cryme of the Century is a better album song by song
>>64542852
woah there i got destroyed how shall i damage control from such a dank meme
>No one posted this
For shame
>>64542874
