Plebian "best band ever" bracket has come to a conclusion.
>>64189937
>velvets out in the first round
>knocked out by fucking weezer of all bands
i'm not mad, i'm just disappointed.
>>64189937
The fact that so many books still name the Beatles as "the greatest or most significant or most influential" rock band ever only tells you how far rock music still is from becoming a serious art. Jazz critics have long recognized that the greatest jazz musicians of all times are Duke Ellington and John Coltrane, who were not the most famous or richest or best sellers of their times, let alone of all times. Classical critics rank the highly controversial Beethoven over classical musicians who were highly popular in courts around Europe. Rock critics are still blinded by commercial success. The Beatles sold more than anyone else (not true, by the way), therefore they must have been the greatest. Jazz critics grow up listening to a lot of jazz music of the past, classical critics grow up listening to a lot of classical music of the past. Rock critics are often totally ignorant of the rock music of the past, they barely know the best sellers. No wonder they will think that the Beatles did anything worthy of being saved.
>>64190014
>Velvets
>rush beats the doors
>Bob Marley beats coldplay
>greenday beats black sabbath
>bowie is the only reasonable artist who made it to the final 4
>bowie vs beach boys first round
>no fugazi
This is disgusting.
Listen, I can deal with all the good bands knocked out early, but the fact that Green Day got as far as they did is too much.
>green day vs the beatles
hahahahahah
>yfw bowie only made it that far because he died this year so now the kids know his name
>>64190149
>Bob Marley beats Coldplay
How are you mad about that
>rush beating pink guy
>the neighborhood beating John Cena
I'm not mad I'm just disappointed
>>64190149
lmao what a retard
>Weezer beats The Velvet underground
Holy shit.
The best bands are Ween and Steely dan
You know it in your heart to be true
>>64190244
Because viva la vida and a sudden rush of blood to the head are the pinnacle of pop rock.
>>64190262
Nailed it xdddd
>The Strokes beat U2
>>64189937
>Velvet Underground vs Weezer
>Weezer wins
>Neutral Milk Hotel vs Foo Fighters
>Foo Fighters wins
>Pixies vs Arcade Fire
>Arcade Fire wins
>The Killers vs Grateful Dead
>Killers win
>Beatles vs Green Day is the final
fuck me
>>64190385
but this is right
>>64189937
>Green Day beats Black Sabbath
>RHCP beats Fleetwood Mac
>AC/DC beats Modest Mouse
>Pink Guy
>David Bowie v Beach Boys and Pink Floyd v The Beatles in the first round
>That shit bottom right seeding
That seeding is awful
Wu tang vs the beatles
Who wins?
>>64190868
the beatles
>>64190241
He deserves it but it doesn't make this any less true.
>John Cena Vs. the Neighborhoods
> The Neighborhoods wins
>>64190385
The Strokes are way better than U2 you fag
>>64189937
>The Pixies
>The
>>64191045
>>64191028
ELLO' ELLO'
>>64190014
Velvets are complete garbage
>no Radiohead
>>64191563
You gotta understand, they had to be cut to make room for Simple Plan.
this triggered me. Not because the bands aren't good, but because there seem to be no criteria whatsoever
who the fuck is fidlar
>>64191676
This band on a roof
>>64191676
>mfw I look them up
why the fuck would they be on a "best bands ever" list
>>64189937
wtf are half of these
what is the cold war kids
whats tricky
whats jucifer
whats delphino
whats pink guy
whats clutch
whats zedd
whats fidlar
whats eden project
whats silverstein
whats the neighborhood
whatever everything else is pleb shit anyways
>>64191907
>Pink Guy
Filthy Frank
>Zedd
Pop EDM
>Silverstien
OK Post-Hardcore, my sister's favorite band
>The Neighborhood
Pop-Indie
>>64191907
>whats tricky
Kill yourself
>jucifer and butthole surfers out first round
fucking end it
>>64191907
>clutch
Stoner rock band
>tricky
have you heard of trip hop?
>>64191907
>whats fidlar
0 for two on spelling for that one pleb
>>64189937
How did Beach Boys and Grateful Dead not get far at all
The only sort of good thing is that the doors beat Taylor Swift
Delphino is the local band I'm apart of. We rip-off The Strokes.
>>64190385
This is the only time where I expected them to go one way but they went with the correct option.
>>64189937
>David Bowie
>Johnny Cash
>Taylor Swift
>bands
>>64189937
Where is Slint on here is it cut off by the cropping???
>>64189937
>Green day>black sabbath
>pink guy
>>64191907
>whats tricky
>whats pink guy
>calling other people pleb
The others are pretty pleb though
>>64191209
wrong
>RHCP beats Rush
>Green Day beats Black Sabbath
Fuck this gay earth
I don't even like u2 that much but how the fuck do the strokes beat those guys! Meanwhile Beatles sweep cause of seniority. I gotta say I would never pick Bowie over Marley- 420 and everything but as far as music it is no contest, Bowie sounds like a virgin freak compared to Marleys concrete subjects. Also >no credence fuck this gay earth
>>64190149
>rush beats the doors
Rush are better than the Doors you dope.
Lastly what the fuck is with all the beast bands placed so close? Rolling Stones knocked out by queen for no fucking reason. The stones still have tracks that could be released yesterday
Fuckin lastly all this confusion between band and artists- and they nominate edm abortion like zedd and not rob swire. Am I fucking mad
>>64189937
>21 pilots
>imagine dragons
>foo fighters
>childish gambino
mfw
>>64190332
Pop rock is an inherently shit genre, so the moderately good Reggae sings that Marley wrote easily beat it out
>>64190523
I highly doubt there is any seeding. Pretty much everyone who doesn't organise tournaments or regular take part in then didn't even understand the concept in my experience.
>>64191606
Yeah and John Cena and Filthy Frank
>Fidlar
>Zedd
>Pink Guy
>Tricky
>Jucifer
>Silverstein
who
>>64190149
>bob marley beats coldplay
That's a good thing
/mu/ should do this
This really is The Most White and Normie Thing I've seen in a while.
Damn dirty apes.
>>64190149
You know Bob Marley has more albums than Legend right?
>>64194066
There was round not shown where Slint was voted off first round, along with The Clash, The Unicorns, and The Dismemberment Plan.
>>64194066
Oh also Arcade Fire and Johnny Cash got free byes.
every single band on there sucks. idk why you guys care either way.
>>64189937
>foo fighters better than neutral milk hotel
>ac/dc better than modest mouse
>green day in the top 2
beatles are literally better than every other band ever meme still going strong I see
>Left
Black Sabbath beats Cold War Kids
The Strokes beat U2
Smashing Pumpkins beat Beasite Boys
Tricky beats Green Day
Grateful Dead beat The Killers
Butthole Surfers beat Soundgarden
Led Zeppelin beat Jucifer
Fleetwood Mac beat Red Hot Chili Peppers
Gorillaz beat Delphino
Modest Mouse beat Imagine Dragons
AC/DC beat 21 pilots
Velvet Underground beat Weezer
The Doors beat Taylor Swift
Cake beat System of a Down
Rush beat Pink Guy
Black Sabbath beat Johnny Cash
Smashing Pumpkins beat The Strokes
Tricky beat Grateful Dead
Led Zeppelin beat the Butthole Surfers
Gorillaz beat Fleetwood Mac
Modest Mouse beat AC/DC
The Doors beat Velvet Undergrond
Rush beat Cake
Black Sabbath beat Smashing Pumpkins
Tricky beat Led Zeppelin
Modest Mouse beat Gorillaz
The Doors beat Rush
Black Sabbath beat Tricky
Modest Mouse beat The Doors
Modest Mouse beat Black Sabbath
>Right
Pixies beat Fall Out Boy
Wu-Tang Clan beat Clutch
Pink Floyd beat The Beatles
Nirvana beat Queen
Rolling Stones beat Zedd
NMH beat Foo Fighters
Fidlar beat Rise Against
Alt-J beat La Dispute
Eden Project beat Childish Gambino
Sublime beat Cage the Elephant
The Beach Boys beat David Bowie
Coldplay beat Three Days Grace
Silverstein beat Simple Plan
Bob Marley beat Blink 182
The Neighbourhood beat John Cena
Pixies beat Arcade Fire
Pink Floyd beat Wu-Tang Clan
Nirvana beat The Rolling Stones
NMH beat Fidlar
Alt-J beat Eden Project
The Beach Boys beat Sublime
Coldplay beat Silverstein
Bob Marley beat The Neighbourhood
Pink Floyd beat Pixies
Nirvana beat NMH
The Beach Boys beat Alt-J
Bob Marley beat Coldplay
Pink Floyd beat Nirvana
The Beach Boys beat Coldplay
Pink Floyd beat The Beach Boys
>Pink Floyd beat Modest Mouse
>the Beatles win, of course
I'm sure the people who made this knew in the pit of their hearts that this would be the conclusion, what was the point?
>>64198238
>pink floyd beats modest mouse
>>64189937
>foo fighters > neutral milk hotel
>>64190149
And bowie only made it that far because he just passed away
>>64194945
>9gag
>>64189937
>simple plan
>>64189937
>Bob Marley over blink-182
>AC/DC over Modest Mouse
>Foo Fighters over NMH
>THE Pixies
>Bruce Springsteen doesn't even make the bracket
>The way this bracket is set up
Every good artist except for Modest Mouse is on the right side of the bracket. This was the dumbest seeding of any bracket I've ever seen lol.
Final Four
>The Killers vs. Modest Mouse
>The Beatles vs. David Bowie
Championship
>Bowie over Modest Mouse
Only valid conclusion to this bracket
Who at your fucking high school listens to TVU or Butthole Surfers? The most obscure band I've I've ever heard anyone reference that wasn't in the vein of my chemical romance is probably Megadeth.
>>64198238
TVU>Doors>Sabbath>MM desu
>>64189937
Bowie is the only one of the Top 4 who should even be there.
>Green Day, Bowie, RHCP above the Doors
disgusting
>>64198934
lmao what the fuck is wrong with you
>>64199274
he's right
>>64190427
Neutral Milk Hotel is overrated garbage
>>64199188
>RHCP is not on every fucking level better than the Doors
>>64199311
You only say this out of contrarianism.
>>64199296
The Doors, Black Sabbath and The Velvet Underground are all better than Modest Mouse. and even then Johnny Cash, Beastie Boys, Led Zeppelin Grateful Dead and Tricky are all as good as Modest Mouse. that's even worse than the faggots who think Bowie deserves the final four position anymore than the Bealtes
>>64190067
Nice copypasta bro!
>>64199188
How is Bowie not better than The Doors ya fuckin wankah?
>>64199481
Did you really need to point out it's a pasta or are you just new?
If you lurked more you'd see this pasta at least 3 times a day
>killers>grateful dead
>weezer>tvu
Costanzaface.jpeg
>>64199417
Are you autistic or can you just not read
>PF against the Beatles
Wat the fuck?
>>64189937
The Beatles should have won but the rest of that top 4 holy shit
>>64189937
Holy fuck the more I look at it the more I cringe, and my power level is pretty low.
I literally burst into tears when I saw Weezer beat TVU, jesus christ lmfao
>>64199311
I really hope you're not implying Foo Fighters is better than NMH anon...
>AC/DC beats Modest Mouse
>Green Day beats Black Sabbath
>Rush beats The Doors
>The Beatles win
I can't look at this.
>>64193553
tf u on about? fidlar's a band
>Weezer beat TVU
My sides, oh my fucking god
Why is there no Sufjan? I always thought that he's the kind of musician that would appear on a chart like this. Nothing against his music, just wondering.
>>64199679
do you honestly think The Velvet Underground, the Doors, Black Sabbath, Johnny Cash, Beastie Boys, Greatful Dead, Smashing Pumpkins, Led Zeppelin or Rush aren't as good as Modest Mouse
> all these posts asking about Fidlar
They have the one album where it says FIDLAR all over the cover
Step up neo-mu
>>64189937
>Foo Fighters beat NMH
this was retarded from the start
>>64189937
>the beatles beat pink floyd
>alt j beats la dispute
>weezer beats tvu
>green day gets THAT far before being beat
consider me triggered
>>64189937
> Black Sabbath beaten by Green Day.
>>64189937
>Beatles vs. Pink Floyd first round
was expecting that in the final 4 for the plebs
>>64189937
what the fuck is this abomination kill it with fire
>>64201225
I'm pretty happy PF got eliminated by The Beatles early on, would've hated to see them lose to Green Day or some other shit
>>64189937
>Weezer beating TVU
>Green Day making it that far
>Foo shitters beating NMH
>mbv, Sufjan and Radiohead nowhere to be seen
>>64189937
>Green Day beating Black Sabbath
Man this is some good cringe
>>64202331
>implying either are good
>>64189937
>>64191563
>>64202261
This proves that normies can’t into Radiohead
>>64189937
Where's all the 80's bands?
I want to fucking kill myself after seeing this thread
>all this Mozart underrating
and you guys consider yourselves patricians
>>64190427
pretty much this. I lost it at killers vs greatful dead
>>64198238
You legit messed up.
>beach boys beat bob marley
>>64202560
>implying Green Day are as good as Sabbath
GTFO Pleb
>>64189937
Im pretty sure these people never listened to some of these bands
>Weezer knocks outs Velvet Underground
>>64195139
reggae is also a shit genre
>>64189937
which middle school did this oh my god
also
>the Beatles topping PF
bullshit from the start
>>64204012
Is it as shit as Coldplay though?
There isn't much that is
I've not listened or even heard of most of these bands.
>>64204155
its basically the pop-folk of the Caribbeans, so yes it is as bad if not worse
