>Dark Side of the Moon isn't even progressive rock guys!
>Discovery isn't even house guys!
>Nevermind isn't even grunge guys! (bonus fag points for "grunge isn't even a genre guys!")
>ITAOTS isn't even indie folk guys!
>The Downward Spiral isn't even industrial rock guys!
>Hold Your Colour Isn't even dnb guys!
>Funeral isn't even indie rock guys! (bonus fag points for "indie rock isn't even a genre guys!")
>Spiderland isn't even post-rock guys!
>The Black Album isn't even metal guys!
>Souvlaki isn't even shoegaze guys!
friendly reminder that if you've ever been this guy, you're actually 'that' guy and should kys at the earliest opportunity
>>64074933
this was not grunge dummy
seriously though can someone explain to me why spiderland is referred to as post rock when literally nothing else i've heard in the genre sounds similar
Do people really think that Discovery isn't house?
>>64074933
You're retarded.
>>64075013
You'll find that many albums labelled as "first wave post-rock" have almost nothing in common.
I couldn't stand Spiderland when I first listened to it because I expected something like Talk Talk after I saw people calling it post-rock.
>>64075031
>actually believes that anything that has any kind of mainstream or crossover appeal instantly stops belonging to the genre it belongs to
>calls others retarded
>>64075017
All of these have been serious points of contention many times round here, yes
>>64075013
1st post-rock is a huge mixed bag and basically refers to a wave of experimental rock in the early to mid 90s
>>64074989
see >>64075031
You forgot to add people who say
>OP is not a faggot guys!
Those people are so wrong.
>>64075013
post-rock really means a deconstruction of rock music, not necessarily ambient crescendo core
>>64074933
>>The Downward Spiral isn't even industrial rock guys!
No one ever said this, people only say that it isn't industrial, which is the truth. This has nothing to do with "elitism" or any of the other buzzwords people like to spout.
>>64075075
prove that Nevermind was grunge
I'll wait
>>64075013
>nothing else i've heard in the genre sounds similar
Mogwai have some similar tracks
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3en9Mkx86k
I am that guy and all of those statements are true.
>>64075121
true but to be fair slint are a direct influence on mogwai
thanks for the answers guys
>>64075013
Listen to Breadcrumb Trail
there's that lil part after the second chorus i believe where the guitar distortion rings out and there's this incredible section with tension until a distorted guitar comes back in
Literally one of the birth moments of post rock in that song
>>64075181
>Literally one of the birth moments of post rock in that song
Three years after the album which is widely considered one of the first post-rock albums is a bit late for a "birth moment", don't you think?
I didn't think Discovery was much of a house album until I heard Bangalter's solo stuff.
It made a lot more sense in context.
give me some criticism on this - https://soundcloud.com/prospectartist/flying-high-prospect-remix
I agree but Pink Floyd really aren't progressive rock. They're momrock. There's literally no difference between Pink Floyd and REO Speedwagon or Journey except Pink Floyd have a few songs longer than 5 minutes.
>>64075608
pink floyd are objectively progressive rock
when will this contrarian bullshit end
>>64075608
>I agree
>but incidentally, I am 'that' guy
nosiree m8, not how this works
grunge isn't a genre it's a buzzword to sell records to stupid people
>no bonus points for saying post rock isn't a genre
0/10
It's true that Dark Side isn't prog rock though
>>64075095
Except that's wrong because rock artists have been doing that since the 60s and nobody calls a 60s album post rock.
>>64075013
Washer
>>64075654
Only in some specific albums. Dark Side wasn't, and neither their early stuff.
>>64076500
What is DSotM then?
>>64075075
>"1st post-rock is a huge mixed bag and basically refers to a wave of experimental rock in the early to mid 90s"
Ok can we all agree that the definition of post rock is confusing and fucking retarded
>>64077594
Psychedelic rock
Post Metal is not a genre.
>>64074933
Hold Your Colour is dnb, it's just shitty and watered down for pop appeal
>>64074933
the spiderland one is true tho
>>64077652
Just psychedelic? Its a mix between Prog and Psych, just like 50% of the prog music at the time
>>64075013
I have always seen Spiderland as the birth of math rock simply by how accurate this chart is.
Even Piper is more prog than DSOTM
>>64074933
>>Dark Side of the Moon isn't even progressive rock guys!
Pink Floyd sucks.
>>Discovery isn't even house guys!
Daft Punk sucks.
>>Nevermind isn't even grunge guys! (bonus fag points for "grunge isn't even a genre guys!")
Grunge sucks.
>>ITAOTS isn't even indie folk guys!
Nmh its okay.
>>The Downward Spiral isn't even industrial rock guys!
???
>>Hold Your Colour Isn't even dnb guys!
idk
>>Funeral isn't even indie rock guys! (bonus fag points for "indie rock isn't even a genre guys!")
David Bowie sucks.
>>Spiderland isn't even post-rock guys!
Slints sucks.
>>The Black Album isn't even metal guys!
Idk???
>>Souvlaki isn't even shoegaze guys!
Shoegaze sucks,.
>>64078131
Nobody asked your opinion fagtron.
>>64078160
HELLOO??? are you clinical stupid?? Its a public forum of music... What the fuck do i suppose to do?
>>64078231
Stop posting
>>64078131
>>>Funeral isn't even indie rock guys!
>David Bowie sucks.
lol
>>64078131
>Doesnt know shit about Hold Your Colour, The Black Album
>Pink Floyd, Daft Punk, whole grunge scene, Slint, whole shoegaze scene sucks
>Arcade Fire - Funeral, Bowie sucks
>Nmh is ok
Autismo Maximus
>>64078231
just stop
>>64078255
>>64078285
>stop posting opinion on an opinion board
dude...
>>64075608
>There's literally no difference between Pink Floyd and REO Speedwagon or Journey
If you seriously think The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, A Saucerful of Secrets, Atom Heart Mother, Ummagumma and Meddle sound like REO Speedwagon and Journey then you're either deaf or retarded.
>>64078370
Stop being a newfag. This isnt reddit
>>64078508
>le ironic hate to someones opiniones
Calm down with your passive agressive post, faggot.
>The Downward Spiral isn't even industrial rock guys!
more like industrial butt-rock, haha.
>>64078370
You're annoying fuck off
>>64075608
Animals is 100% progressive rock
>>64078554
>ironic hate
There was no hate in my post
>calm down
Im pretty calm, dont project
>Passive agressivenes
Are you getting insecure, newfag?
