How accurate is this?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
How accurate is this?
100%
>>61474096
if you're talking about when the eras when the band was led by one of those three, then you should move everyone over to the right by one (with Waters going to Plebeian)
>>61474169
but most people like Gilmour's stuff more, which would make Barrett the contrarian option.
>>61474096
Come on, OP. We all know that Rick is the real patrician of the band.
fuck rush
>>61474169
Was talking about their contributions
But if we're going by their eras, I also think The Wall is their best album, the others have too much hippie wankery/shitty soft dadrock soloing
Also Gilmour was the leader, as far as I know
>>61474210
This
>>61474096
swich gilmour and waters and its good
>>61474096
is the accuracy of a stormtrooper
>>61474284
>Gimour
>patrician
kek
>muh soft rock soloing
>how i wish you were heeeeree
pleb af
>>61474249
>>61474192
The band was led by Gilmour for the albums after The Final Cut. Who the fuck likes those albums, or at least think that's their best period?
How accurate is this?
>>61474319
excellent musical analysis anon
>plebian
Panda Bear
>contrarian
Geologist
>patrician
Based Deak
>>61474330
not accurate. Wata is the most talented member of Boris
>>61474249
sorry, meant to type:
was never the leader*
>>61474192
>most people like Gilmour's stuff more
no, their most critically acclaimed records were made when the band was led by Waters more or less
>>61474421
Their most popular =/= best
>>61474375
Deak get off /mu/ and leak the new album already
>>61474096
very inaccurate honestly
>>61474823
>being this much of a contrarian
holy fuck
>>61474823
Great taste anon, would make friends with.
Though I wouldn't put Ummagumma in contrarian imo
>>61475317
ummagumma is great but jesus christ are you retarded
>>61475365
>he doesnt get it
lmao
Albums you should put on Contrarian are like Obscured by Clouds or More or anything released after The Wall
>>61475378
>damage control
ok
>>61475432
i like ummagumma because it allows the band to express themselves as individuals artists, and that doesnt always come across on some of their more polished work
if you dont think ummagumma is their best, its probably way too deep for you
>>61475006
have you even listened to those albums?
>>61475478
Well Syd was the strongest individual artist, which side of Ummagumma is his again I forgot? Might as well just listen to Piper at the Gates of Dawn or his solo stuff :^)
>>61475570
personally, i find david gilmour to be just as interesting as syd barrett, and like his contributions to ummagumma and saucerful of secrets more than syd barretts lyllabiues and nursery rhyme pop songs
>>61475478
when did i say i didn't like ummagumma, it's great.
saying meddle is pleb and the wall is contrarian is where your retardation shows
>>61475523
i own 6/9 of them on vinyl
>>61475604
>saying meddle is pleb and the wall is contrarian is where your retardation shows
not at all, the wall is overrated as fuck, and meddle and echoes are as pleb as they come
you're the retard
>>61475604
>i own 6/9 of them on vinyl
there's 12 albums there, and you haven't even listened to them, you're opinion is irrelevant
>>61475656
i actually love innerspeaker so much but i also pick ummagumma as my favorite floyd album REEE why did you make this image???
>>61475629
>the wall is overrated as fuck
this is exactly why it isn't contrarian it's pleb
contrarian are the ones that are less known and praised, like atom heart mother
>meddle and echoes are as pleb as they come
lol
>>61475629
Echoes at Pompeii is anything but pleb
>>61475699
>this is exactly why it isn't contrarian it's pleb
no because people tend to lump it in with pink floyds best periods the WYWH and animals era
>lol
so fuckin pleb
>its one of their most played songs, it must be patrician!
nope
>>61475664
my mistake i thought you were referring to>>61475317
lmao i've listened to all of those except division bell
>>61475738
>no because people tend to lump it in with pink floyds best periods the WYWH and animals era
how does this help your argument at all
>>its one of their most played songs, it must be patrician!
never said this actually
>>61475833
flip harrison and mccartney
>>61475833
nice try anon, but all 4 members fall under plebeian and George Martin falls under Patrician
How accurate is this?
>>61476170
>Division Bell and Meddle
>patrician
hearty kek
>>61476242
anybody who says this is a contrarian 2bh
>>61476170
>Meddle
>Division Bell
>patrician
lmao
also Ummagumma should be placed in patrician and you have shit taste if you place in the same category as Final Cut and Momentary
>>61476170
i'd switch division bell and ummagumma
other than that i'd say pretty accurate
>>61474210
This
T E M P L A T E
E
M
P
L
A
T
E
>>61476363
Just fucking download the picture and delete the albums already put in. It's not that hard
Am I correct?
>>61476381
But a template already exists and I don't care enough to go through any more effort.
>>61476826
then fuck off
>>61476459
i don't know who those people are
>>61474823
>>61475317
>hatin on dark side of the moon
just why
>>61476857
wew
>>61476920
holy shit. what are you even doing here?
