>Venus in Furs is the only good song tbqhwy
>>61458782
>>61458782
>not Femme Fatale
>>61458782
Kid A
>>61458782
>>61458782
>:^)
>>61458782
no
>>61458815
yes
>>61458963
not shit but meh
I say Daydream nation
>>61458782
absolutely not
>>61458815
overrated yes, but still good
>>61458963
perhaps a little
ITAOTS, though one of my favourites, is blown out of proportion
Shit album and shit artist.
>>61458782
top pleb
>>61459527
literally how. most properly rated record of all time
everything metallica did before this felt way more raw and true
>>61458782
>>61458815
>>61459126
>>61459515
>>61459527
these are actually pretty good
>>61458782
I think you're forgetting Black Angels Death Song there mate
Otherwise yeah Venus in Furs is probably the best.
>You need to consider the context/ era of the album.
>>61459572
i think this album is a meme
i can't believe people enjoy Oasis that much
>>61459682
Yeah, I know it is. it's even worse how seriously people take it in northern england.
>>61459707
i'm from north england, i never liked manchester
>>61459731
>>61459707
im also from northern england
normies might like them, but they're shit
>>61458782
no
>>61458815
hell no
>>61459567
GET OUT
>>61459731
>>61459752
The fucking huge buzz of pre-teen normies trying to shove their "good" music taste in your face by referencing The Stone Roses, Oasis, Kasabian and Aaachtec Munkehs at every fucking turn is a plague I have to face daily and I want it to die
>>61458782
>>61459100
Retarded weeaboo
>>61459572
What a shit album, it actually irritates me they they could produce a track as perfect as Live Forever and then a track as shit as Wonderwall.
>>61460630
are you a woman by any chance?
>>61459515
Bowie is GOAT but who honestly enjoys the B-side on this album? It's just... shit.
>>61458963
>>61459515
most correct answers itt
>>61460630
it doesn't even get any praise at all lol
cardiacs
>>61460868
>not liking Queen Bitch
>not liking The Bewlay Brothers
>>61460891
>Spiderland
>doesn't get any praise
u new?
>>61461247
>a bunch of autists post it on a mongolian website
>this is somehow actual mainstream praise
no but you clearly are trying way too hard
Here's some food for thought: I know a guy irl that posts on /mu/ and he prefers Coldplay over radiohead and thinks this album is not very good.
>>61461293
what album?
>>61461307
TVU&N
>>61461281
Is this bait?
>#50-something on RYM with over 10,000 ratings
>often called upon as an important inspiration on Math-Rock, Post-Hardcore and Post-Rock
>massive underground acclaim
>reviewed basically everywhere
u dun goofed
>>61461281
I want the police to be notified
>>61461357
>RYM
>not just a bunch of people like /mu/
>massive underground acclaim
so is everything else from that era...?? where are you getting with this
>often
often not**
>basically everywhere
basically nowhere**
>>61461400
It's been a feature album on Rolling Stone, NME, Pitchfork and even the fucking Guardian newspaper. Not to say I read these publications but many people do. Go to any record store and ask them if they know Spiderland, they'll be insulted that you asked. My dad's a 56 year old northern rural Englishman and even he knows it.
This is either bait or you're literally retarded.
also
>asserting that RYM is /mu/
>>61461400
>he actually thinks Spiderland is some obscure album nobody else has heard about and only /mu/ likes!
do you think we discovered Loveless as well?
>>61458782
Venus In Furs is great but what about Heroin, Sunday Morning...
Fuck that it's all gold
>>61461487
>My dad's a 56 year old northern rural Englishman and even he knows it.
i'm happy to hear you talk about these things with your dad but what does this have to do with anything?
>Go to any record store and ask them if they know Spiderland, they'll be insulted that you asked.
i had to buy my copy online because everywhere i went (and i'm talking about EVERYWHERE, both big cd stores, small but traditional stores, indie hipster stores, etc) no one knew what it was nor had it on catalog. but hey this is just anecdotal so who cares
also i never asserted that rym is /mu/, but it is just a bunch of people so of course fans of the album are going to talk about it there
also rolling stone and nme never had it as a feature album, nme only had it in a corner page and rolling stone fuck if i know maybe online they talked about it
>>61461504
no but it's not getting praise all over the place like loveless and tvu&n
>>61460630
wrong
>>61461573
Rolling Stone reviewed it and there was outrage because they gave it a 2.5
NME has a full page feature on the fact it's being reissued
Guardian hailed it as the album that changed rock music and did an entire story on it
Pitchfork gave the reissue a 10
It's been well talked about since the conception of /mu/ and fucking long before it.
I'm not surprised none of these stores had it. But every record shop I've ever been to knows Steve Albini, As they should.
>>61458782
nah
>>61458815
nah
>>61459126
what the fuck is this
>>61459515
agreed x1000
>>61459567
nobody cares about megadeth
>>61459572
yea
>>61460676
shoot yourself
>>61461659
>Shoot yourself
Fucking hick
>>61461656
i never heard of these things but then again no one really cares about rolling stone anymore
still, even with big underground acclaim, i can't agree it's a big well known and with massive acclaim album. it's more on the lines of something like husker du and fugazi than nirvana and radiohead imo
>>61461750
Then it may be time for you to read the thread title.
>>61458782
>>61458815
>>61458963
Kill yourselves.
>>61461784
>overrated
literally how when i just said what i said
are you trying to make me mad? that's kinda cute actually
>>61461234
>a mediocre VU ripoff, his worst glam rock song
>"strim strum i play folk now guys"
>>61459515
Kill yourself.
>>61460868
>implying Queen Bitch isn't the best song on the album
>>61461804
>it doesn't even get any praise at all lol
which is quite clearly objectively wrong considering it's a /mu/core album, and that the thread title said nothing about widespread acclaim, it says
>overrated
You don't "get it" do you?
>>61458782
true
>>61458815
false
>>61460630
false
>>61461659
false
>>61461859
>considering it's a /mu/core album
omg i can't stop laughing
if the point of this thread is only what /mu/ thinks, this is the saddest thread in the catalog lmao
and even in that regard it's not overrated since for every thread that's speaking positively of it there's another one saying it's shit or just making memes out of it lol
>>61461940
Holy fuck are you still baiting.
Like literally stop replying anytime now.
>Overrated
It just means overrated. Doesn't matter whether it's got widespread critical acclaim or if it's on /mu/, the point is the person who posted Spiderland thought it was overrated.
And the reason most people make memes out of it and talk about it so much is???
(BECAUSE IT'S POPULAR)
>>61458782
no, it's too influential to just call shit whether you like it or not
>>61458815
overrated as fuck but still a good album
>>61458963
not shit but mediocre
>>61459515
not at all
>>61459572
first shit album posted
>>61460630
nope
>>61461659
incorrect
>>61461940
jesus just stop... you lost like 5 replies ago but still trying damage control like a kiddo
>>61462082
>seriously saying "you lost the conversation"
that's great, this board is for 18+ only though amigo
>>61462045
>the point is the person who posted Spiderland thought it was overrated
that's great. and i think he's wrong.
also popular =/= overrated
pretty much just basic english my man
>>61462062
I agree
>>61462136
deary me.
>popular=/=overrated
ok now this is bait or genuine autism, remember if you defend this statement prepare to be laughed out of this thread
>>61462184
something can be talked about a lot (you know, the definition of popular) without it being positive discussion, you know this right
>>61462209
How does that make it inherently overrated.
>>61462250
what are you talking about lol
i just said popular is not the same as overrated
>>61462293
You just said it was, alternatively
>use greentext it's right there
>>61458782
Yes
>>61458815
Overrated but still great
>>61459567
>muh metallica/megadeth war
>muh raw
>muh true
go back to wherever you come from
>>61459572
Overrated but not TOTAL shit
>>61460630
No
>>61460676
Overrated but still great
>>61461659
Overrated but not shit
>>61462062
Overrated but not shit
>>61462351
i just said it wasn't
'=/=' means 'not equal to'
>>61462366
then what is your argument here
not even baiting
>>61462451
slint isn't overrated, just popular
>>61462504
*just popular on certain places
>>61462504
earlier you were saying slint weren't popular.
I'm quitting this thread because you're flip-flopping, damage controlling, and all the other things that showcase the fact that you're obviously underage
>>61462136
lost the argument you fucking shit
>>61462551
>earlier you were saying slint weren't popular
literally where lol
also i said on certain places like /mu/ and rym (the internet is great for this)
>this thread
>>61462589
what argument? slint just doesn't have neither a massive fanbase nor a big claim, it's just a fact
>>61462602
>claim
meant acclaim, sorry
>>61462602
99 on metacritic faggot
>>61462765
>(the internet is great for this)
>ITT: let's shit on good music because it doesn't allign to my particular taste so its objectively bad.
