Sleep is objectively the best Post-Rock song
>>61155634
thats not Ursa Minor Ursa Major
Okay. I am just happy that other people like post-rock :D
>>61155634
>objectively the best
>objectively
you should be able to prove it's objectivity then
>>61155634
Oh no! You seem to have posted the wrong song! I know you meant to say Djed by Tortoise.
That's not after the flood
>objectively
>talking about music
but here have a song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=du4JbfK5okA
I know this doesn't have so much to do with the OP, but you all like post-rock, so...
Would anyone be able to listen to this for me, and let me know what you think of it?
I'm not advertising. It's not for sale yet, I just want to know what you think of it.
https://soundcloud.com/between-old-and-october/between-old-and-october
>>61155725
>16 minutes
who the hell listens to songs that long... i could listen to 6 songs in that time
>>61155725
>mogwai
Lol we're talking about GOOD post rock.
>>61155634
>Sleep is objectively the only post-rock song I know
is this what you meant?
>>61155750
adhd kids get out
>>61155750
Why are you even in a post rock thread then.
>>61155755
Sorry i posted a GREAT song
>>61155823
Newfags pls
>>61155755
>mogwai are bad
Who let the contrarians in?
>>61155755
then why did OP post gybe?
>>61155634
probably the worst on lysf
That's not Djed
I think Washer is better.
>>61155859
do you know what a contrarian is because i don't think you do
sleep is the cheesiest song gybe has ever done t.b.h
>>61155694
This
>>61156079
Your "Mogwai is bad" meme has never been funny. Never will. Nobody scrolls down the catalog, sees your post and laughs. They fucking ignore it. Why? Because you're a pathetic little 9gag crossposting memester with nothing better to do besides force shitty memes on an anonymous imageboard. Get a life. Go outside. Stop making fucking posts about your shit taste in music. We're sick of this. I'M sick of this.
But you know what? No. I won't stop there. Have you ever sat down and thought, "I could be productive?" Have you? If you haven't then here's a newsflash. In that time it took to create this thread you could have called that one girl that looks at you longingly and request a date. But no, you make a "Mogwai is a shitty post rock band" post. Ever stop to think about what you could be doing if you didn't waste your life away in your parents' basement posting memes?
You could be an astronaut. You could be the CEO of a profitable company. You could be rich. Or, instead, you chose to post memes.
That said, Not every Mogwai album is great. Fuck off, meme poser
That's not Helpless Child
>>61155750
4/10 bait
Could work if this wasn't a post-rock thread
>>61156556
>getting this mad
helpless child, the sound, the seer, the apostate, and bring the sun all would like a word with you
>>61155634
Agreed.
>>61156931
>being a newfag
>>61155688
not even their best song. tortoise's best track is TNT
nonetheless after the flood is the apex of the post-rock genre
>>61157004
you sound like the bigger faggot
>>61157051
no u
>>61155661
I think it is objectively the best
>>61155634
I agree.
>>61155634
Static is better,but okay
>>61157226
>I think
>>61158198
Godspeedand *shels are better than Eva Luna and Cul de Sac at least
>>61158235
incorrect
>>61158243
I'm not though, Eva Luna's good, but both of those bands are better. Godspeed better than a large portion of the list.
>>61158198
ebin :^)
This thread is fucking cancer
>>61155634
not even godspeed's best song
>>61158198
bottom row still good, tho
>>61155634
>implying its not Vienna Arcweld/Fucked Gamelan/Rigid Tracking tracking by Set fire to flames
I don't like 20 minute songs. I always lose track of them halfway through then when the climax comes I have no idea how to take it.
![1342436849103[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/nuxonoU.png "1342436849103[1].png")
>>61155634
>listening to this with normalizer dsp for the first time
yeah, lets just make this a post-rock thread. Anyone heard this? This album is great and I think it's on par with alot of the really great post-rock releases of the 90's
>>61155634
It's pretty great
>>61157135
>>61157051
i liek u guyz xd
literally youtube audience.
>>61158198
i like both xd
>>61159541
what makes it post-rock? not arguing, but 1st wave post-rock is the vaguest and i've never heard of this album
>>61155750
>>61159933
Think about how Spiderland was post-rock and it's about similar in that sense. Like, it's alternative rock, but the guy is doing spoken word and the guitars seem to revolve around his voice and what he's saying
>>61159541
they are more instrumental rock than post rock.
>>61159989
spoken word doesnt make a song post rock. these guys are not post rock. sorry yo.
>>61160030
What makes a song post-rock then? Define post-rock.
>>61160030
Nah man, it's not just the spoken word, I'm saying they use the instruments as a reflection of the guys voice
>>61160053
using rock instruments, can also include classical instruments, in a classical fashion. thats why a lot of post rock bands use a lot of dynamics and crescendos.
>>61160081
still don't make it post rock
>>61158075
>thinking you're this clever
it's a goof, dummy
>>61160053
using rock instruments to make a sound not typical of rock music
>>61160152
nope. it can resemble some rock aspects in the writing, but the composition of the music is more classical.
>>61158198
bait. the bottom row is more post rock than the top row obviously, except for slint.
>>61160175
Quit saying shit like you know anything. It's embarrassing.
>>61160307
wanna counter my points? let's have a discussion about this then.
>The Rainbow
>Eden
>Inheritance
>I Beleive in You
>After the Flood
>New Grass
>Ascencion Day
>>61160126
By that definition, that would make something like ITCOTKC post-rock
>>61160328
Nah, I'd rather let you embarrass yourself some more.
>>61155979
False, that'd be Static.
>>61156107
False, that'd be We Drift Like Worried Fire
>>61159025
>Intentionally ruining dynamics.
Ok, bud. Whatever you want.
>>61155749
>https://soundcloud.com/between-old-and-october/between-old-and-october
Pretty neat. Bit FX heavy
>>61158198
never considered agaetis byrjun to be post rock
