![dataplex[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/QfDwDqN.jpg "dataplex[1].jpg")
This girl in my composition workshop said during class that 'glitch has no musical qualities and therefore should be considered sound art instead of music'. Teach got visibly rustled but he isn't an argumentative kind of guy and just proceeded with class.
Do you agree with her?
As long as it has a texture that seems planned or intentional, I wouldn't call it noise, at least not in the sense that she meant.
sound art is music
yes
why fags get so buttblasted when, after deliberately trying to destroy music, they get told they didn't make music?
"sound art' is pretty sweet term, I don't see you wouldnt use it
>what are you listening to ?
>Oh, just some sound art
>>61083414
/thread
>>61083383
No, but it's her opinion and she isn't wrong or right :)
this is an argument that leads nowhere, what did she mean by glitch? op pic has musical qualities
>>61083439
faggot
Post good glitch in this ITT thread
>>61083533
As I withdraw money from my automatic ATM teller machine.
>>61083533
god i love that record, its more minimal techno than glitch tho
Disclaimer: we weren't discussing Ikeda. The class was on formal experimentation and we were talking specifically about "pure" glitch, the kind you find in the circuit bending and electroacoustic tradition.
>>61083439
>>61083383
I don't even believe you can even have a classroom with 3 people who even know what glitch is, nice made up story anon
>>61083784
not everyone is in high school chico man
>>61083533
>>61084189
gr8 album
>>61083533
http://www.discogs.com/Keiichiro-Shibuya-Yuji-Takahashi-Untitled/release/241068
>>61083784
youve never taken a college level music class have you...
>>61084524
I have, they all listen to dadrock like rush and kiss.....
>>61083414
/thread
If we're talking about noise or field recordings, it would be hard to come to an agreement because there is no universally accepted definition of music.
To say that glitch isn't music pushing it though. Most glitch I've heard has rhythms, melodies, and though the sounds used may have been generated by chance, when the artists use them it's because they sound adequate in context — they often have interesting timbres too.
Maybe she's heard noise and thought it was glitch, or hasn't listened to glitch closely enough, I don't know. But you'd need to have a really, really narrow definition of music for it to exclude glitch altogether.
>>61084801
you're either from some buttfuck nowhere town where pop culture is dead or you're lying
>>61083383
just like cough in the back quietly next time:
"ahughstockhausenhem"
>>61083682
nevertheless "sound art" is still music.
>>61087350
>whatever my hoodie is dope.
whats this from anywayz?
