![Trout_Mask_Replica[2].png](https://i.imgur.com/LwXyqge.png "Trout_Mask_Replica[2].png")
>DUDE SO RANDOM LMAO
this album is literally the musical equivalent of YouTube Poop
>inb4 butthurt contrarians and Scaruffi drones
Why is it that no one can come up with an intelligent argument against this album?
trick question: it's because they're all kids who hate this
>>60476477
but its fun :(
>>60476477
obviously you don't know what random means.
>>60476477
as a classical/jazz fan who has studied music seriously I can honestly say that Trout Mask Replica is the only rock album worth listening to.
>>60476477
The vocals and retarded lyrics make listening to it unbearable for me
>>60476941
lmao
>>60476941
>as a classical/jazz fan who has studied music seriously I can honestly say that Trout Mask Replica is the only rock album worth listening to.
Literally kill yourself
>>60476477
>this album is bad only post ITT if you agree
sounds like this will be a fascinating discussion
>>60478311
>expecting anything from a re-worded "Prove Me Wrong" thread
>>60476477
>there are people on /mu/ RIGHT NOW who don't enjoy YouTube Poop
gee, it sure is boring around here
This is one of the few albums /mu/ circlejerks over that is genuinely good. Even then a lot of people find it inaccessible because it's not your average indieshit.
>>60478410
it's not a very good album regardless of what it is or isn't
>>60478377
now THIS is a great album
>>60476477
it is actually quite complex and structured. His later albums are a little more polished, if you really want to know what it is about.
>>60478429
Listen to it a few more times.
>>60478429
c'mon m8 it's at least an 8/10
>>60478377
checked
>>60478429
yeah it is
>>60476477
Yfw your cold vibes can't stop this here boogie
Just because something is unique doesn't mean it's good. It was composed by someone who knew nothing about music or how to make it and it shows.
>>60478513
Seems to me that this post was composed by someone who knew nothing about music or how to make it and it shows.
>>60478453
no, no it isn't
>>60478501
nuh uh
>>60478513
Go hear Safe as Milk if you want to hear Beefheart playing more "traditional" songs.
>>60478526
Unlike your statement, mine is actually backed by something. It's on the wikipedia page anon.
>>60478513
>someone who knew nothing about music or how to make it and it shows.
But Captain Beefheart is proficient at several instruments and is admittedly a very proficient vocalist
>tfw he never revisits the guitar tones from dropout boogie
>>60478538
woah, hoo boy, I tell ya, this guy knows what he's talking about
>>60478547
>wikipedia
huehuehuehuehue
>>60478551
The guy who composed the music parts on the album didn't know anything about making music.
>>60476477
Lol. Idiot. Nice dubs though.
>>60478568
Or wherever else it's documented.
>>60478568
kendrick lamar sucks ass too
>>60478538
dude you listen to unwound... lol
>>60478573
>>60478588
Yeah, that's why he had already written two albums prior to TMR. You're a tard.
>>60478593
F I L T E R E D
I
L
T
E
R
E
D
>>60478605
he's right about kendrick tho
The actual musical equivalent of youtube poop is vaporwave.
This isn't meant to be a claim about it's quality, but the very method of its production is the musical equivalent to ytp.
>>60478597
what about unwound
>>60478605
fine by me, i don't want people with shit taste reading my posts anyway
>>60478617
well two people on the internet said it, so I guess I have to reevaluate all my opinions about music
>>60478605
>Van Vliet used a piano—an instrument he had never played before—as his main compositional tool. Since he had no experience with the piano and no conventional musical knowledge at all
No fucking shit. It's awful, what a surprise.
>>60478626
mmmmmmm feels good
>>60478636
have fun being a pleb, one day you'll realize you're wrong
>>60478626
>sour grapes
the maturity I've come to expect from tripfags
>>60478631
are you implying you would do just that if the majority said it
what a pointless post, kendrick fans are so dumb it's surreal
>>60478651
you're reading this and are tempted to reply but that would take a shot at your pride
>>60478636
I feel bad for you if Trout Mask Replica is your threshold for something being inaccessible.
>>60478660
>>sour grapes
that doesn't mean what you think it means. the stupidity i've come to expect from anons?
>>60478651
If I recorded my nephew slamming touching keys on a piano as fast as he could and trancsribed it into different guitar bass and horn sections, then gave it a good pitchfork review, you'd call me a pleb for not liking it. God you guys are insufferable.
>>60478664
It's not inaccessible, it's bad.
>>60478661
mmmm mmmm mmmmm yum in my tum
>>60478677
>yeah well I don't want PLEBS reading my posts anyway!
>not sour grapes
are you retarded?
>>60478686
epic
>>60478700
but you evidently are a pleb if you like kendrick lamar, so
>>60478680
Wow, you know even less about composition than Beefheart! Nice!
>>60478710
>oh no, I've been caught being a retard!
>o-oh yeah? w-well y-you're a p-pleb!
E B I N
B
I
N
>>60478714
My favorite part about this meme is that none of you can actually explain why you like it or why it's good. All you do is call people plebs or say you don't know what you're talking about. It's really telling.
>>60478733
i said you're a pleb right from the start, do you have selective memory or something? your self-awareness is that of a goldfish, i recommend some meta-analysis.
>>60478740
Yeah well your argument is the equivalent of someone looking at a painting and saying "my kid could do that," so it's not worth writing something out when you could just google "why is trout mask replica good"
>>60478741
>he thinks he's an intellectual
>he accuses people of having a selective memory when he's trying to avoid the fact that he doesn't understand a simple idiom
>he actually believes the myth about goldfish memory
you're even dumber than I thought
>>60478410
Haha in what universe is Trout Mask Replica inaccessible? Seriously, I was disappointed by how normal it was when I first listened to it and realised that people had just been memeing.
>>60478784
I'm just pointing out that the way it was composed by a man who didn't have any musical knowledge or know how to play the instrument he composed it on had a predictably shitty result.
Can you tell me in your own words why you like it or do you seriously just parrot what strangers tell you?
>>60478622
If any genre is youtube poop, it's plunderphonics
>>60478815
Trout Mask Replica is literally filled with catchy and accessible melodies, I don't see where the disconnect is for you. The album is dense, but not as dense as you.
>>60478784
i do understand it and i don't recall ever claiming to be an intellectual. but there's nothing i could possibly gain from you not filtering me in the first place, and that's why i don't care if you filter me. you're the one who doesn't understand it.
>>60478847
So you're agreeing with my post then?
Vaporwave is mostly plunderphonics.
>>60478858
>n-no, y-you're the one who d-doesn't g-g-g-g-
Yeah whatever
>>60478873
did you really think this aimless strawman soundly refuted the fact that you were wrong
show some humility you tool
your unwarranted self-importance is hysterical, like i said, look into some meta-analysis before you embarrass yourself any further
>>60478873
you sound like one of those middle schoolers who starts repeating in a mocking tone everything the person they're arguing with says when they lose an argument
>>60478853
Your threshold for catchy is ridiculously low.
This is really catchy and accessible right?
http://vocaroo.com/i/s1dm2piyyShM
>>60478873
>he imagines that the other person has a stutter to make himself seem right
>>60478928
he's a typical /mu/drone; very safe to assume he's under the age of 18.
>>60478953
why did you kill your brother
>>60478853
Dude I really like how deep and patrician Trout Mask Replica is so I emulated its style
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0CeyneVBIzi
Dud
>>60478953
what you dont like about tmr xus
>>60478853
I don't get why you don't like it. I can't explain it but just google why its good I have the same opinion for real.
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0b600sJx3Jo
>>60478853
It's probably just because my music taste is so refined and you listen to music that is popular. One day you'll be a patrician and you'll agree with the people who get good and avant garde music, but for now you're a pleb.
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0VzT50kFZnF
>>60478905
>>60478928
>>60478952
>>60478953
>implying acting self-important in response to epic memeing isn't pathetic
>>60478853
Fucking kill yourself.
>>60478953
lmao i never thought i'd see a worse trip than me
>>60478941
>>60479002
>>60479034
Did you actually think this was going to be funny
>>60479158
Rude
it sounds liek farts
>>60479169
who even are you
>ironic self-deprecation
wow nobody has ever done that before
drop trip
>>60479183
Funny wasn't what I was going for.
>>60479130
Pretty unmemorable desu, 4/10
>>60479263
Oh good, I hope clever also wasn't on your agenda
>>60479287
Nope not really. Just showing you that bad guitar playing is bad guitar playing and just because you slap a pretentious review on it from a total stranger doesn't make you somehow understand what you're talking about.
>>60479307
Don't be childish on a Mexican taco forum just because you can't into an album, it's sad that you actually took the time to improvise 30 seconds of nonsense and think it's comparable to a meticulously rehearsed 80-minute experimental rock album. I actually feel bad for you.
>>60479307
Ironic considering my fucking 53-year-old dad has literally zero background in experimental music of any kind and even he liked TMR upon first listen.
>>60479366
Lmao the dude who wrote it improvised it and then it was transcribed. Just because they rehearsed what he improvised doesn't change how it was made.
>>60479459
Turns out your dad is a pretentious faggot and the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.
>>60479556
>composing = improvising
>practicing composed pieces = improvising
You literally cannot stop saying stupid shit
>>60479556
>liking one album makes you a pretentious faggot even if all you listen to is dadrock
Careful with that edge, Eugene
