Why doesnt /mu/ like AnCo anymore? they are clearly the best band of the last 15 years
Anyone that hates on Animal Collective is under 20 years old and only comes here for the memes.
I don't like Animal Collective because they make their music in a very raw, unskilled manner and I prefer music that is more thought out and intelligent.
Go ahead and call *tips fedora* on me. At least I know my taste unlike most shitposters on here.
>>60406710
lmao
>>60406710
>music that is more thought out and intelligent.
examples?
>>60406673
circle jerking haters from what i've seen
stg is a great album but i feel like whenever someone doesn't like it they shit talk the fuck out of it (same with contrarians to an extent)
>>60406749
>inb4 anon lists of entry level jazz or classical pieces
>>60406710
only really STGSTV (and maybe Centipede) is raw like u say. MPP, feels, and sung tongs i feel are much more thought out
>>60406710
what are you on most of their stuff is really detailed, the only raw stuff was on like their live sets on 2001.
>>60406770
STGSTV is far from being raw, just because it has some harsh noise? pff
>>60406749
Frank Zappa
Beach Boys
Scott Walker
etc.
>>60406770
MPP is the one exception admittedly.
>>60406710
*tips fedora*
>>60406673
>they are clearly the best band of the last 15 years
(true, by the way)
>>60406852
>Frank Zappa
kek
>>60406710
You dropped your hat, anon.
>>60406688
>>60406884
/thread
>>60406852
>Frank Zappa
>>60406852
>implying harmony and melody are the only aspects of music that can be well thought and "intelligent"
lmaoing at your life to be sincere
>>60406896
>>60406927
What's wrong with Zappa? He has a few good albums. I don't like his full discog but let's be honest.
>>60406949
Timbres can't be intelligent.
>>60406956
Nothing, but not all of his music is thought out or skilled. Some of it's very improvised, like Lumpy Gravy.
>>60406673
Wrong
>>60406956
he is shit
>DUDE I KNOW THEORY BUT IM SO TALENTLESS I CANT MAKE REAL CLASSICAL SO IM GONNA MAKE LE COMPLEX IRONIC FUSION RAWK LMAO
>>60406852
dude
a little embarrasing
>>60407016
to be fair the albums I like are WOIIFTM, Uncle Meat, and Apostrophe
but I LOVE those albums
>>60406852
hm I can see what you're trying to say. I think you've confused the spontaneity of Animal Collective's work with unplanned, improvised playing though. they have a pretty confusing upbeat quality that attempts to emulate childhood playtime; it can sound directionless at first but every section of their songs has careful attention paid to texture and progression.
>>60406977
neither tones
> G > F# XDDD theory amirite
>>60407041
You know I have other favorite artists than him right?
>>60407045
dude
don't you like AnCo?
>>60406977
Neither can harmonies, melodies, or rhythms then
>>60407059
Even those albums are fairly improvised and unskilled. I don't see your point
>>60406710
*tips fedora*
>>60407077
you don't understand music theory I guess
>>60407113
you dont understand music
>>60407089
>WOIIFTM and Apostrophe
>improvised and unskilled
lol
>>60407088
lol
get an education
>>60407086
>You know I have other favorite artists than him right?
you asked what was wrong with zappa, retard friend
listen to this improvisation
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yzfzsKENCbU
listen to the unskilled playing
you people are just making shit up now
>>60407041
>zappa
>shit and talentless
I think it's past your bedtime son
>>60407132
here's an education bitch *punches you in the face*
>>60407145
you're the one thinking that one artist you don't like speaks for my entire taste, retard friend
>>60407132
>lol
>get an education
this is what you are saying:
>your music is not academic, therefore it is less valid
am I correct?
>>60407132
explain how any sound can be intelligent pls
can a melody make a decision?
get a brain
>>60407188
no, I'm saying don't say bullshit that's only said by people without an education like >>60407088
>Neither can harmonies, melodies, or rhythms [be intelligent] then
>>60407193
explain how words can be intelligent
words in and of themselves are not but when you arrange them into sentences and chapters and novels they become intelligent
>>60407260
see >>60407155
dipshit
>>60407187
i never implied anything in those lines
i just think zappa is cringe worthy, i cant relate to him, and i think listening to music just for the sake of music (outside of classical of course) is autistic.
>>60407221
damn senpai i slept thru the class where harmonies were intellgient fuck me...
>>60407276
>and i think listening to music just for the sake of music (outside of classical of course) is autistic.
the fuck do you even mean by this
>>60407221
can a novel make a decision? can novel protect itself from water?
things that arent alive cant be intelligent, silly
>>60407221
timbre is given as much consideration as harmony, melody, rhythm, an so forth in most music. it definitely contributes to developing a mood u twat
>>60407276
>i think listening to music just for the sake of music (outside of classical of course) is autistic
why would you say this. what is wrong with you
>>60407339
>timbre is given as much consideration as harmony, melody, rhythm, an so forth in most music.
It's not nearly as important.
see this is what you get when you have a bunch of anco/drone faggots who never took a theory class
>>60407360
you're just droning your professor, nerd
>>60407304
if your reason to listen to zappa instead of anco is because his music is more "well thought" and "intelligent", by these standards why are you even listening to popular music then, is all shit compared to classical, again, by those standards.
>>60407360
this is what you get when you take one theory class and become totally delusional
>>60407360
>It's not nearly as important.
4u
>>60407383
>
I prefer Zappa because I like him more.
I've found that I like music with more thought out compositions.
I'm not forcing anything, I genuinely like the music.
>>60407387
or 4
>>60407221
What I meant was, if timbre isn't "intelligent," then neither is any other element of music. Sure, there's no real timbre theory, but it can be used in intelligent and unintelligent ways.
>>60407410
Oh, so you've taken a handful of theory classes. What do you use that knowledge for, other than shitposting?
>>60407445
>What do you use that knowledge for, other than shitposting?
well I use it to study the scores I conduct from silly you
but it certainly helps to have an actual education in music for casual discourse
everybody got trolled in this thread
>>60407410
>I've found that I like music with more thought out compositions.
then why are you listening to zappa when there is so much more music with "thought compositions"?
also
>I'm not forcing anything, I genuinely like the music.
>>60406710
>I don't like Animal Collective because they make their music in a very raw, unskilled manner and I prefer music that is more thought out and intelligent.
>I prefer music that is more thought out and intelligent.
>>60406852
>Frank Zappa
xd
>>60407556
>then why are you listening to zappa when there is so much more music with "thought compositions"?
you're implying that I don't
would you have rathered me list off 3 classical composers
fuck you just can't win on /mu/ you have faggots who complain about any SINGLE artist on your chart, faggots complaining about you liking classical music, faggots complaining that you disagree with them
I fucking hate this place
>MUH THEORY
>2015
:/
>>60407592
sounds as if you don't like homosexuals friend
>>60407630
faggot for me and plenty of people doesn't actually mean gay person, it just means assholes
cmon you watched the south park episode
>>60407592
>I fucking hate this place
then why are you here?
someone who TRULY cared about well thought and intelligent compositions wouldnt waste their time listening to le ebin ironic fedora master.
you are just too far up your ass
you a mess dude, you "like" zappa, claim to hate this place but you are still here posting, just accept yourself bro
>>60407662
name a better place to discuss music with as much activity
>>60407657
lel
this fucking guy man...
i cant tell if you are just baiting or you are really this autistic
>>60407687
>coming to /mu/ to "discuss music"
KEK
why the fuck would anyone want to discuss music lmfao, is the most pointless shit ever, everyone knows is just memes
basically what happens
>person states their opinion
>standard /mu/shitposts
>standard /mu/ reply of "NAME UR FAVRIT ARTISTS" because they don't know how to argue
>criticize a single one of the three artists in an attempt to dismiss all the arguments previous
embarrassing, fucking anco fags
>>60407592
>fuck you just can't win on /mu/
music isnt a fucking sport
why do you want to "win" lmao?
>>60407837
you can't post any kind of argument without a stupid shitpost reply
>>60407857
autism, everyone
>>60407739
i,m gay
>>60407997
do you think panda bear is cute?
https://youtu.be/EukueEjfPnk
You cannot argue that there is music better than this.
It's just objective
>>60406710
>they make their music in a very raw, unskilled manner
no
>>60406852
