>Tool are way better, more unique and more creative than Porcupine Tree despite the fedora tag
>Dream Theater are a good band
>Elliott Smith is far better than John Darnielle
>Andrew Jackson Jihad are shit instrumentally and tryhard lyrically
>andrew jackson jihad are shit
this is not a controversial opinion
>>60177554
>Agreed
>They have their moments
>Agreed
>Agreed, but that's pretty much the point. Punk, lol.
>I'm a real girl
>this shit is shinier than that shit
>this shit isn't shit
>this shit is better than this shit
>this shit is shit
>>60177571
fuck you
>>60177594
>le superior to everything meme
>>60177602
I like ajj but most people here don't
I'd say
>andrew jackson jihad are good
is the controversial opinion
atleast these days
saw them live a few months back and it was great tbqh
ape of naples is not the best coil album
>>60177594
>Elliott Smith is shit
die in a fire
>>60177592
it's kinda funny that they censored t b h and f a m but people keep using them anyway. in a way it's an even better troll cause you have to go "why's he talking like a weeb-- oh he's memeing"
it wastes more of your time, which is really all trolling is
Fear of Music hasn't aged very well and Speaking in Tongues is the best Talking Heads album
>>60177647
>muh plinky plonky feels music
>>60177694
Half of that is right
>>60177695
>elliott smith
>plinky plonky
oh you're trolling carry on
>>60177655
I'm a real girl?
>>60177695
>No feels allowed
Fuck off, Chad.
>>Andrew Jackson Jihad are shit instrumentally and tryhard lyrically
This isn't news to anyone, and I say that as a big AJJ fan
>>60177715
>muh /mu/core
>>60177554
>>Tool are way better, more unique and more creative than Porcupine Tree
despite the fedora tag
both shit
>>Dream Theater are a good band
ok fine controversial mostly because of how fucking awful that opinion is
>>Elliott Smith is far better than John Darnielle
both shit
>>Andrew Jackson Jihad are shit instrumentally and tryhard lyrically
lmao true though theyre way better than all the bands and artists above
end yourself/10
>>60177724
boohoo make me beta
>>60177753
>AJJ
>better than Mountain Goats
top kek
On Avery Island is better than In The Aeroplane Over The Sea.
Christmas Island is the only listenable AJJ album, the rest are total gimmicky shit
>>60177757
Sorry, I don't speak jock. Maybe you'd feel more at home on /sp/.
best KC album
>>60177773
>Christmas Island
> the absolute worst AJJ album is somehow the most listenable
Please end your life.
>>60177782
>boo fucking hoo
>>60177771
>muh lyrics
>>60177803
>muh shit instrumentation and shit fake punk persona lyrics
Anything but classical and jazz is for children
>>60177795
> the absolute worst AJJ album
That would be Knife Man.
People Who Can Eat People is the best AJJ album by a LONG shot though.
>>60177773
Agreed on OAI. Both are good though.
>>60177815
better than literally only having lyrics senpam
>>60177833
People Who Can Eat People is awful. It sounds like novelty music.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74g4LeTipB4
how can anyone like this honestly
the lyrics are the only vaguely redeeming factor about this music and you can't even really consider lyrical content music in my opinion
also I hate his face
>>60177864
literally only having lyrics is better than literally having nothing
>>60177878
it couldn't be as awful as Knife Man
Townes Van Zandt was a better folk/country songwriter than Dylan was. That being said, Townes had nothing in him like the electric trilogy.
>>60177833
b-but what about can't mantain....
>>60177887
All Hail West Texas is better than your dad
>>60177900
only having lyrics is having nothing desubh
you dont judge music by its lyrics
>>60177900
do u even know what literally means
>>60177915
I haven't heard it so I can't speak for it but my dad is a pretty swell guy so I doubt it
>>60177909
Massive amounts of "meh". I liked Truckers are the Blood and Sense and Sensibility, but the rest didn't really stick.
>>60177923
>what is a capella
>>60177949
a capella is music sung using only voices
it doesn't just have lyrics, it has vocal harmonies and melodies
how do you not understand the difference
Coldplay is way better than U2
>>60177554
>>Andrew Jackson Jihad are shit instrumentally and tryhard lyrically
who could possible disagree with this?
>>60177976
Nah bro. They're definitely the shittier of the two shits.
>Incubus is a good band
Well, that's not really controversial. Just rare.
>>60177982
13 year olds who have their minds fucking blown by someone singing about edgy stuff over cutesy folk instrumentation
Jason Lescalleet is way overrated.
>radiohead is boring
>kanye west is one of the shittest artists but his attitude is funny
Radiohead is the blandest band I can think of, I'd rather listen to Creed or Grand Funk and God knows they're dull as shit, yet not as much as Radiohead
>>60178007
They're okay as far as like radio rock goes I guess. Bassist is good.
Genetically, pedophiles have more in common with CRABS than they do with you and me. Now that is scientific fact. There's no real evidence for it, but it is scientific fact.
>>60177554
I thought both PT and Tool are fedora
PT are still more diverse and interesting though
>>60177554
> Death Grips are actually good.
>>60178018
How is he overrated? He isn't particularly well known, and most of his work has received mixed reception. There's a world outside of mu. Are you sure you don't just dislike his music?
Doolittle is overrated and it doesn't have shit on Surfer Rosa and Trompe Le Monde. Also, Trompe Le Monde is their best album.
Mbv > Isn't Anything
That Ceres and Calipso in Time is boring and awfully produced
Murmuure is just ok
>>60178116
NONCE sense
>chance the rapper is trash
>ICP has released great material.
>Nu-Metal is not an inherently bad genre.
>Bring Me The Horizon is great
>Earl Sweatshirt keeps getting better with each release
>Left Brain is the worst member of Odd Future
>>60178105
Agreed, even though Science is my favourite of their's which isn't very accessible. Yeah their bassist has a really nice tone
>Death Grips s really good
>Tyler The Creator is great (except for Cherry Bomb)
>Metal is one of the best subgenres
>there are no bad (major) genres
>jazz and classical are great genres with some of the finest music but they are not ''intellectual'' music, if you think so then it's clear you only care about image and don't actually know the origin and target audience of the music
>>60178259
>BMTH are great
This. They only get hate because of the fanbase and some really bad lyrics
>>60177554
>Tool are way better, more unique and more creative than Porcupine Tree despite the fedora tag
How is that a controversial opinion here? I thought /mu/ hates both Tool and Porcupine Tree.
>Dream Theater are a good band
Maybe they were once but their recent albums are utter trash.
>Elliott Smith is far better than John Darnielle
Again, how is that a controversial opinion? Elliott Smith is basically /mu/core.
>Andrew Jackson Jihad are shit instrumentally and tryhard lyrically
Totally agreed. Fuck that band.
>>60178331
i love that album friendo
>>60177554
Riverside and Oceansize are better than both Porcupine Tree and Tool
>>60177554
>likes tool
>likes dream theater
>wants me to respect his musical opinion
Nice try hombre
>>60177786
I disagree thought this is a respectable opinion
>>60178116
If you show a picture of a child to a pedophile they will and reach and grab it, thinking the picture is a real child.
Don't try cake kids.
>>60178259
>Nu-Metal is not an inherently bad genre.
Yes
>Bring Me The Horizon is great
No
>>60178331
>>Metal is one of the best subgenres
>>there are no bad (major) genres
Ya
FKA Twigs is the most innovative pop musician out there right now with actual sales and mainstream recognition.
Kendrick Lamar is the perfect rapper.
Weezer's new songs are still shit and trying to win back the Blue/Pink album fan boys.
>>60178539
>Weezer's new songs are still shit and trying to win back the Blue/Pink album fan boys
this is pretty damn obvious tho
I agree with those 3 opinions actually, lmao. I don't love Kendrick but I guess he's really good
The thug and bling periods between the early 90s and late 00s were the dark age of hip hop, Kanye is hip hop's saviour, and trap is its rebirth as a better, more creative form.
>>60178022
wow
controversial as fuck
i've never seen those opinions in my life
i would have never thought someone would think that
wowwwwwww this guy is in another leveeeeel of controversial guys
>>60178614
saying radiohead is shit is not uncommon but it certainly is controversial, anon
>>60178539
>Weezer's new songs are still shit and trying to win back the Blue/Pink album fan boys.
lmao really?
i haven't listened to Weezer in ages but that's pretty damn sad
>>60178539
>Weezer's new songs are still shit and trying to win back the Blue/Pink album fan boys.
They're not great, but if you're telling me they're not a step up from every album after Maladroit, you're kidding yourself.
>>60178614
>kanyehead fanboys
wew
>>60177642
I think that's pretty much the general opinion of /mu/ atm.
Picture the nerdiest kid in your class, the one that breathes funny, the ugly one that is obsessed with weird shit and most people just ignore and hate because they're fucking creeps, these kind of people are Animal Collective and The Microphones fans and they should kill themselves, you weird fucks
Alice in Chains are way better than most /mu/core
>>60178879
> alice in chains
> good
Pick one faggot.
>>60178217
Most everyone in the "experimental" world praises his shit but it's seriously boring and unimaginative.
>>60178432
Why is michael giras room burning
>>60179021
>this mad
Nutshell and Would are two quality songs faggot
>>60177554
Swans is one of the worst bands I've ever heard. I could barely get through soundtracks for the blind because it was so bad.
>>60179047
I've never seen people outside of here even mention him, and i travel within the experimental circles, like the other person said, you probably just dislike his stuff.
>>60179150
your joking. critical acclaim =/= popularity. no shit he isnt mainstream but he is taken very seriously as an artist. i study sound art i wouldnt say he is overrated but he certainly is very highly rated and receives essential unversal praise when really he hasnt developed any new ideas simply exploring well treaded waters of tape manipulation and sound collage.
Transatlantic and The Flower Kings are my favorite bands
Loveless is a shitty album. My Bloody Valentine is a shitty band. Shoegaze is a shitty genre.
>>60179975
Bands like the Flower Kings and Transatlantic? The DEATH of
progressive music. These are the bands that reinforce every prejudice
people have about progressive rock: old-fashioned, pompous,
pretentious, hung-up on sci-fi concepts - that for me is rubbish. But
there's a new wave of bands that for me are being influenced just as
much by hip-hop as they are King Crimson or Godspeed You Black
Emperor and bands like us as well, I hope.
For me, Transatlantic and the Flower Kings - and I have heard these
bands, unfortunately - they're following the blueprint from 1972 so
closely; it's completely pointless and redundant. They're never going
to better the originals, anyway - why bother? Whatever's going around
should be part of their musical vocabulary.
I don't particularly dig generic music, whether it's hardcore metal
or hip-hop, even down to the prog bands you mentioned. They're
following a formula way too closely. For me,being progressive is
about taking the word at face value: it a band is going to try to be
progressive, they shouldn't be looking at the past - they should be
looking at everything that's going on around them now,
from hip-hop to trip-hop to death metal to trance. The
word 'progressive' is about the FUTURE."
>>60180060
did he actually say that because that funny
>>60177786
totally
I like the band Pavement. They're a pretty obscure alternative band check them out.
>>60180074
Yes, Google Steven Wilson and Flower Kings and go to Progarchives threads if you want Some keks
>>60180188
>steven wilson complaining about something being derivative
theres a joke here somewhere
>>60180209
The dad prog fans getting mad were even funnier
>>60179066
His mean enemy skull face hates post rock styled reunions
>>60178683
what is?
