For each writer, give their best and worst episode
If you have enough autism, rank ALL of a writer's episodes.
If there's a decent amount of responses I'll record the results when the thread archives.
Here's a template:
>Lauren Faust
Best:
Worst:
>Amy Keating Rogers
Best:
Worst:
>Cindy Morrow
Best:
Worst:
>Chris Savino
Best:
Worst:
>Meghan McCarthy
Best:
Worst:
>Charlotte Fullerton
Best:
Worst:
>M.A. Larson
Best:
Worst:
>Dave Polsky
Best:
Worst:
>Merriwhether Williams
Best:
Worst:
>Corey Powell
Best:
Worst:
>Josh Haber
Best:
Worst:
>Ed Valentine
Best:
Worst:
>Natasha Levinger
Best:
Worst:
>Scott Sonneborn
Best:
Worst:
>Noelle Benvenuti
Best:
Worst:
>Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco
Best:
Worst:
>Neal Dusedau
Best:
Worst:
>Nick Confalone
Best:
Worst:
>Michael P. Fox, and Wil Fox
Best:
Worst:
>Mike Vogel
Best:
Worst:
>Dave Rapp
Best:
Worst:
And for convenience I'll list out all of the writer's episodes:
>Lauren Faust
Friendship is Magic Part 1
Friendship is Magic Part 2
The Ticket Master
>Amy Keating Rogers
The Ticket Master
Applebuck Season
Bridle Gossip
Fall Weather Friends
A Dog and Pony Show
The Best Night Ever
The Cutie Pox
The Last Roundup
A Friend in Deed
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
Pinkie Pride
Filli Vanilli
Testing Testing 1, 2, 3
The Lost Treasure of Griffonstone
Canterlot Boutique
Crusaders of the Lost Mark
The Mane Attraction
>Cindy Morrow
Griffon the Brush Off
Winter Wrap Up
The Show Stoppers
Owl's Well That Ends Well
Sisterhooves Social
Family Appreciation Day
Read It and Weep
Hurricane Fluttershy
One Bad Apple
Apple Family Reunion
Tanks for the Memories.
>Chris Savino
Boast Busters
Stare Master
>Meghan McCarthy
Dragonshy
Call of the Cutie
Green Isn't Your Color
Party of One
Lesson Zero
Sweet and Elite
Hearts and Hooves Day
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Princess Twilight Sparkle - Part 1
Princess Twilight Sparkle - Part 2
Power Ponies
Three's a Crowd
Inspiration Manifestation
Twilight's Kingdom - Part 1
Twilight's Kingdom - Part 2
>Charlotte Fullerton
Look Before You Sleep
Suited For Success
A Bird in the Hoof
May the Best Pet Win!
Baby Cakes
Power Ponies
>M.A. Larson
Swarm of the Century
Sonic Rainboom
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Luna Eclipsed
Secret of My Excess
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
It's About Time
Ponyville Confidential
Magic Duel
Magical Mystery Cure
The Cutie Map Part 1
The Cutie Map Part 2
Slice of Life
Amending Fences
>>27680025
Come on, prove your taste!
>Dave Polsky
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Over a Barrel
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Keep Calm and Flutter On
Games Ponies Play
Daring Don't
Rarity Takes Manehattan
Twilight Time
For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils
Equestria Games
Appleoosa's Most Wanted
Brotherhooves Social
On Your Marks
>Merriwhether Williams
The Mysterious Mare Do Well
Hearth's Warming Eve
Putting Your Hoof Down
Dragon Quest
Wonderbolts Academy
Spike at Your Service
Bats!.
>Corey Powell
Sleepless in Ponyville
Just for Sidekicks
Rainbow Falls
Inspiration Manifestation
>Josh Haber
Castle Mane-ia
Simple Ways
Leap of Faith
Bloom & Gloom
The Cutie Re-Mark - Part 1
The Cutie Re-Mark - Part 2
The Crystalling - Part 1
The Crystalling - Part 2
On Your Marks
>Ed Valentine
Flight to the Finish
Three's a Crowd
>Natasha Levinger
Pinkie Apple Pie
It Ain't Easy Being Breezies
Make New Friends but Keep Discord
and Scare Master
>Scott Sonneborn
Somepony to Watch Over Me
Trade Ya!
The Cutie Map Part 1
The Cutie Map Part 2
Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?
>Noelle Benvenuti
Maud Pie
Made in Manehattan.
>Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco
Castle Sweet Castle
Rarity Investigates!
The Hooffields and McColts
Gauntlet of Fire
>Neal Dusedau
Princess Spike
What About Discord
>Nick Confalone
Party Pooped
Hearthbreakers
No Second Prances
The Saddle Row Review
>Michael P. Fox, and Wil Fox
The Gift of the Maud Pie
Applejack's "Day" Off
>Mike Vogel
A Hearth's Warming Tail
Spice Up Your Life
>Dave Rapp
Newbie Dash
Flutter Brutter.
>>27680025
Im sure some of those eps were written by 2 goys at the same time
>>27680049
Nah, that is a lot of work.
I will just say that the real MLP died in the S3 and that OP is a faggot
>>27680051
If people pick an episode that multiple people wrote, consider them marks of shame.
This is a ranking of the episodes and not necessarily a ranking of just the writing since there are aspects of the show that can carry an episode. A good example would be A Canterlot Wedding
>>27679993
>Lauren Faust
Best: Friendship is Magic Part 2
Worst: The Ticket Master
>Amy Keating Rogers
Best: Crusaders of the Lost Mark
Worst: A Dog and Pony Show
>Cindy Morrow
Best: Read It and Weep
Worst: Owl's Well That Ends Well
>Chris Savino
Best: Stare Master
Worst: Boast Busters
>Meghan McCarthy
Best: A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
Worst: Green Isn't Your Color
>Charlotte Fullerton
Best: May the Best Pet Win!
Worst: Baby Cakes
>M.A. Larson
Best: The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Worst: The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
>Dave Polsky
Best: Daring Don't
Worst: Feeling Pinkie Keen
>Merriwhether Williams
Best: Hearth's Warming Eve
Worst: Spike at Your Service
>Corey Powell
Best: Sleepless in Ponyville
Worst: Just for Sidekicks
>Josh Haber
Best: Simple Ways
Worst: The Crystalling - Part 1
>Ed Valentine
Best: Flight to the Finish
Worst: Three's a Crowd
>Natasha Levinger
Best: Pinkie Apple Pie
Worst: It Ain't Easy Being Breezies
>Scott Sonneborn
Best: Trade Ya!
Worst: Somepony to Watch Over Me
>Noelle Benvenuti
Best: Made in Manehattan
Worst: Maud Pie
>Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco
Best: Gauntlet of Fire
Worst: The Hooffields and McColts
>Neal Dusedau
Best: What About Discord
Worst: Princess Spike
>Nick Confalone
Best: The Saddle Row Review
Worst: No Second Prances
>Michael P. Fox, and Wil Fox
Best: The Gift of the Maud Pie
Worst: Applejack's "Day" Off
>Mike Vogel
Best: A Hearth's Warming Tail
Worst: Spice Up Your Life
>Dave Rapp
Best: none
Worst: Newbie Dash
1-4 = shades of bad
5 = mediocre/meh
6-10 = shades of good
>Lauren Faust
Best: The Ticket Master (7)
Worst: Friendship is Magic Part 2 (4)
>Amy Keating Rogers
Best: Pinkie Pride (10)
Worst: The Cutie Pox (4)
>Cindy Morrow
Best: Hurricane Fluttershy (10)
Worst: Owl's End That Ends Well (2)
>Chris Savino
Best: Stare Master (7)
Worst: Boast Busters (5)
>Meghan McCarthy
Best: Green isn't Your Color (10)
Worst: A Canterlot Wedding Part 1 (3)
>Charlotte Fullerton
Best: May the Best Pet Win (10)
Worst: Baby Cakes (3)
>M.A. Larson
Best: Magical Mystery Cure (10)
Worst: Secret of My Excess (4)
>Dave Polsky
Best: Too Many Pinkie Pies (10)
Worst: Appleoosa's Most Wanted (3)
>Merriwhether Williams
Best: Wonderbolt Academy (10)
Worst: The Mysterious Mare Do Well (1.5)
>Corey Powell
Best: Sleepless in Ponyville (10)
Worst: Just For Sidekicks (2)
>Josh Haber
Best: The Cutie Re-Mark Part 1 (9)
Worst: The Crystalling Part 2 (2.5)
>Ed Valentine
Best: Flight to the Finish (8)
Worst: Threes a Crowd (6.5)
>Natasha Levinger
Best: Pinkie Apple Pie (10)
Worst: It Ain't Easy Being Breezies (4)
>Scott Sonneborn
Best: The Cutie Map Part 2 (8.5)
Worst: Somepony to Watch Over Me (3)
>Noelle Benvenuti
Best: Maud Pie (8)
Worst: Made in Manehattan (2)
>Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco
Best:
Worst:
>Neal Dusedau
Best: What About Discord (3)
Worst: Princess Spike (1)
>Nick Confalone
Best: Hearthbreakers (10)
Worst: Party Pooped (6)
>Michael P. Fox, and Wil Fox
Best: The Gift of Maud Pie (9)
Worst: Applejack's Day Off (3)
>Mike Vogel
Best: A Hearth's Warming Tail (10)
Worst: Spice up Your Life (3)
>Dave Rapp
Best: Flutter Brutter (7)
Worst: Newbie Dash (1)
>>27680398
Oops
>Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco
Best: Rarity Investigates (7.5)
Worst: Castle Sweet Castle (6)
>>27680248
>best: Made in Manehattan
>worst: Maud Pie
Not a fan of Maud?
>>27680722
>Not a fan of Maud?
I'm OK with Maud, but an episode with Coco is always better.
>>27680248
>Dave Rap's best not Flutter Brutter
>Confalone's worst is no second prances
>Canterlot Wedding part 2 McCarthy's best
>Merriwether's best not Wonderbolts Academy
Mediocre/10
>>27681486
I can't like Wonderbolts Academy as much as I'd like because Lightning Dust was an interesting character and we never saw her again, that's kinda disappointing.
Canterlot Wedding part 2 was great, fuck you.
I don't give a shit about Trixie, she's the most overrated character in the show.
And I can't rate Flutter Brutter because I didn't watch it. After Newbie Dash I won't watch any Dave Rapp episode ever, I already had enough with one cancerous episode.
>You didn't even write your own best/worst episodes
Lazy-ass/10
>>27681486
The other anon's got you there. If you wanna dish it you gotta reveal your taste and get ready to take it
>>27681559
>not watching the second best episode of the season because muh newbie dash
>calling based Dave cancer
>>27681850
Well I'm on mobile at the moment, I'll put it up in 4-5 hours when I get home. I'll even check in when possible to bump this shit and save it from oblivion. And I'll post it with the same trip as this post (not for attention, but so that nobody impersonates me and posts some abhorrent list in my place.
>>27679993
>Lauren Faust
Best: Friendship is Magic
Worst: The Ticket Master
>Amy Keating Rogers
Best: Crusaders of the Lost Mark
Worst: The Cutie Pox
>Cindy Morrow
Best: Hurricane Fluttershy
Worst: The Show Stoppers
>Chris Savino
Best: Stare Master
Worst: Boast Busters
>Meghan McCarthy
Best: Three's a Crowd
Worst: Call of the Cutie
>Charlotte Fullerton
Best: May the Best Pet Win!
Worst: Baby Cakes
>M.A. Larson
Best: The Return of Harmony
Worst: The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
>Dave Polsky
Best: Keep Calm and Flutter On
Worst: Equestria Games
>Merriwhether Williams
Best: Wonderbolts Academy
Worst: Spike at Your Service
>Corey Powell
Best: Sleepless in Ponyville
Worst: Just for Sidekicks
>Josh Haber
Best: The Cutie Re-Mark
Worst: Leap of Faith
>Ed Valentine
Best: Three's a Crowd
Worst: Flight to the Finish
>Natasha Levinger
Best: Make New Friends but Keep Discord
Worst: It Ain't Easy Being Breezies
>Scott Sonneborn
Best: The Cutie Map
Worst: Somepony to Watch Over Me
>Noelle Benvenuti
Best: Made in Manehattan
Worst: Maud Pie
>Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco
Best: Rarity Investigates!
Worst: The Hooffields and McColts
>Neal Dusedau
Worst: What About Discord
>Nick Confalone
Best: The Saddle Row Review
Worst: Party Pooped
>Michael P. Fox, and Wil Fox
Best: The Gift of the Maud Pie
Worst: Applejack's "Day" Off
>Mike Vogel
Best: Flutter Brutter
Worst: Newbie Dash
>Dave Rapp
Best:
Worst:
>>27682215
Oops, made a mistake.
>Mike Vogel
Best: A Hearth's Warming Tail
Worst: Spice Up Your Life
>Dave Rapp
Best: Flutter Brutter
Worst: Newbie Dash
