Why is this redesign so terrible?
would rather fug new ciel
>>15151498
Two reasons.
1. Even though her hair is more feminine, somehow she looks even more like a dude.
2. Shitty blazer. Blazers ruin the very concept of school uniforms.
Why is she even wearing a sweater under a blazer if she already has her shirt open. Is her shirt open because she's too hot?
it isn't
It's pretty cute.
>>15151498
Because you've got eye rot.
I think it's fine on it's own but it fails to keep the same feel as the old one.
>>15151498
Well, new Ciel has a more feminine jaw. She doesn't look like Shiki with side-bangs. But everything else is pretty bad.
The blazer looks idiotic, her figure has been "streamlined" into oblivion, and she has hair like Sayaka from Meguka despite that by the time this is released that show will be a distant footnote in history.
>>15151498
Because of this >>15151590
Every human character is turned into moe cute dolls.
>>15151498
Typemoon is working hard to eliminate even the last drop of personality from their characters. Gotta have to sluttify and make them as generic as possible.
Who in the flying fuck like Ciel?
She's fun to use in Melty (like all the characters) and that's about it.
>>15151498
New Ciel is better you bitch.
>>15152939
FUCK Ciel in melty.
>>15152939
Whats that img from
>>15151498
It's practically the same thing except for the weird hair corners though.
>>15153113
>>15151498
Maybe superficially feels more pleasant to the eye, bur its flavorless crap aimed at zero-taste millenials. Melty Ciel is the demonstration that with the right artstyle any design can look good
Typemoon can go fuck off. nasu sold his ass and its all we need to know.
I don't even think we should talk about it on /jp/ anymore since the main realeases have become anime and videogames.
I really, really loved Tsukihime but its time to let go. dream's over
>>15153121
Unforgivable shit.jpg
>>15153131
You're a retard for sperging over something like this.
Do you only care about the art or something? Nasu has developed as a writer so much since Tsukihime that it would be silly to disregard what could be a great remake for aesthetic reasons.
>>15153121
I hope people aren't upset just for the fact that the little hair flaps got taken out of the top of her head.
>>15151498
The 00s-10s anime style makes it really hard to actually put emotion into characters.
Her previous design allowed for more individuality, but today's Ciel could just be another Saber if you changed her hair to blonde.
Nowadays' anime style implies that either you bloat your character design with a billion little details (like hairclips, bracelets, flashy clothes, etc), or you end up with a forgettable blob unrecognizable when put in a group of other characters.
>>15151498
It is called 'IMPROVMENTS'
>>15151629
Both are cute dude
>>15151573
Seriously?
>>15153170
Pretentious
>>15153269
If you really think that the talk about past anime designs having more feeling to them is just pretentious, you must be blind.
>>15153245
He can't be serious. Nobody would not like blazers.
>>15151505
first post best post
Game needs to come out already so I can complain about the lore changes, complaining about the art is getting dry.
But seriously I want to see how Arc looks like when she gets serious in the remake.
>>15151498
Hair looks oily and wet
Old hair has form and that classic "up then down" bangs of the 00's
>>15153169
I don't even care about the air intakes, the main thing is they replaced her distictive look with a generic miniskirt like every signle other girl.
>>15153299
I honestly don't see the miniskirt as being that different than the obaa-san skirt she wore before. At least the boots are still there.
But either way, visual design walks hand in hand with character writing. A good writer knows that visual designers have some wiggle room in redesigns because the character's traits will show in the writing, regardless of what said character is wearing.
Yes, she looks somewhat generic now. Would it be better if they kept her untouched? Maybe, maybe not, but until the remake comes out, maybe consider that a visual design change might not be a bad thing.
>>15153245
>>15153276
Fucking new generations, used to bullshit uniforms. Sweater, sailor collar, or vest, that's all that's needed. Buruma, not spats, okay?
>>15153169
Anime characters are recognizable only thanks to their hair, eyes, and clothing.
They changed both the hair and the clothing.
It's not so much a fixation on the hair flaps as much as it is that it's almost not arcueid anymore.
>>15153009
Usakame.
>>15153656
The changes are not so significant that you can't recognize her anymore, especially if you already know who she is.
>>15153431
>not spats,
this is a problem
Were the old designs that good?
>>15153739
They were charmingly different in a way that was complimented by the poor drawings. I'm frankly surprised Akiha wasn't given a miniskirt this time around.
>>15153169
GTFO typemoon "artists"
>>15153284
>I want to see how Arc looks like when she gets serious in the remake.
Her clothes explode so only a few drops of cloth covering the bare minimum are left on her. She will then perform limbo while wiggling like she has a spasm attack.
I always find old Ciel unattractive.
I prefer the new design
It's because people are more used to the old design, not to say that the old one wasn't good or that it's all just a matter of nostalgia, however.
Melty came in, perfected those designs to a point where it honestly feels unecessary to redo them, but maybe it's more of a matter of Takeuchi simply not being comfortable with his old style anymore, somewhat like Araki changing his style from early part 4 to fuckboy central in late part 4, which then took a while to get perfected and accepted again. From time to time when Araki decides to include all main characters in a celebration image, it's extremely hard to tell them apart and they do look weird, because you're used to the older style.
