[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Anatomy/lines/colouring/shading/etc . Rip it apart. I know that
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /ic/ - Artwork/Critique

Thread replies: 79
Thread images: 16
File: stpchar2016-04-14-003.png (974 KB, 1080x1920) Image search: [Google]
stpchar2016-04-14-003.png
974 KB, 1080x1920
Anatomy/lines/colouring/shading/etc.

Rip it apart. I know that I am fucking terrible at anatomy but at least it's better than some of my previous stuff. Plus I don't do full-body often.
>>
Study anatomy anon.
>>
you missed it but i got u man:

>>2510967
>>
>>2512237
got a blog where you post some other art?
>>
>>2512255
I'm not that much of a beginner I don't think.
>>2512260
I have a tumblr and a dA account. Both aren't posted to often, but the dA account goes back 8 years.
>>
>>2512303
Yes, you are most definitely a beginner.
>>
>>2512303
You are 100% a beginner.
Don't even >Muh Style.
learn the fundamentals, man.
>>
File: bkittybot-2014-4.png (313 KB, 600x800) Image search: [Google]
bkittybot-2014-4.png
313 KB, 600x800
>>2512318
>>2512324
Alright.
>>
This shit is beginner tier. And as soon
as you stop deluding yourself that it's anything but shit the sooner you can git gud.
>>
>>2512352
im sure he's got the point anon
>>
>>2512327
sorry mate, but thats pants.

the anatomy is shoddy, the colouring is basically gradient shading with some highlights, and worst of all the lighting makes absolutely no sense.
>>
>>2512361
nah this nigga is in denial
>>
>>2512237
Anatomy, proportion, volume and perspective all have problems.

You need to sit down, grab some art books and bookmark Quickposes.com pronto.
>>
There's a difference between having never drawn before, and having drawn a lot but still lacking in areas/stagnating.

I have three years of "experience" drawing shitty landscapes but only started learning how to do things properly a week or two ago.

There's no shame in it. Having a bit of familiarity with the medium will also help you learn and progress faster, but you need to be open to admitting/seeing your faults.
>>
>>2512327
Are you hoping that some kind of polished turd will disprove their accusations?

Listen man, your grasp on form and lighting is atrocious and all your drawings look as warped as an eldritch abomination. Go actually learn or the basics or go away.
>>
File: stpchar2016-04-14-004.jpg (2 MB, 1080x1920) Image search: [Google]
stpchar2016-04-14-004.jpg
2 MB, 1080x1920
>>2512237
And I just realized that I posted the wrong version. Still bad I guess.
>>
>>2512950
What's so bad about admitting that you're bad. anon?
It's fucking shit, have some dignity.
>>
>Rip it apart
>gets told its shit
>b-b-but
>>
File: 1444732635224.png (99 KB, 247x248) Image search: [Google]
1444732635224.png
99 KB, 247x248
>>2512950
>he keeps posting shit art in an attempt to try to change minds

what on earth really

just cut your losses and let the thread die, christ on a bike
>>
LOL this thread is fucking funny
>>
File: 1459820261104.png (1 MB, 762x1080) Image search: [Google]
1459820261104.png
1 MB, 762x1080
>>2513650
Why don't you give me some constructive criticism ?
>>
>>2513899
It was given, cunt.
>>2512241
>>2512324
>>2512362
>>2512366
>>
File: Goddess_Madoka.png (389 KB, 593x779) Image search: [Google]
Goddess_Madoka.png
389 KB, 593x779
>>2513902
Just so you guys know, I do these on an iPad so take that into consideration
>>
>>2513905
So now your blaming your tools?
Is it the ipad's fault you don't know how faces work? Is the ipad's fault your drawing lines randomly without understanding why they're there? Is it the ipad's fault you don't know how colors and light work?
I could go on forever so just stop already. YOUR ART IS SHIT AND YOU HAVE NO SKILLS!
Now fuck off to the beginner thread and start working, if you don't want to then get out. This is a place for people who want to git gud, not a hugbox.
>>
Everyone in this thread is saying this for your own sake.

http://azuretan.deviantart.com/gallery/?catpath=/
You are most definitely a beginner and still have a lot to learn. All of this is shit, there I said it. I was shit too, but I learned, so I'm a little less shit.

Put your ego aside and study. Don't be a baby.
>>
>>2513905
You didn't chicken scratch the hair, so why chicken scratch everything else?
>>
>>2513905
What do you want to hear? That your sloppily added effects make >>2512950 a good drawing? It's just as bad as the one in your OP, and that is, because you neither understand forms, nor perspective. The anatomy is totally off, the proportions wrong and the gesture stiff. The stylisation is unappealing and bland looking. The cell shading looks bad, because a) the light source is inconsistent/ shadows wrongly cast, b) the blurred edges look like shit and c) it's totally oversaturated, leading to the last point - the colors are also poorly chosen and you clearly don't know a lot about color theory or character design. Linework's sloppy and while the accusations of chicken scratching do not apply to this picture, you clearly know nothing about line weight.

If you're looking for praise, go to DA.
>>
this whole thread is a goldmine
>>
>>2512237
Don't listen to these people, OP, your art is pretty okay and I think you have a lot of potential to become really good. This board is full of bitter people. I bet you're already better than 90% of them.
>>
File: srsly.jpg (7 KB, 244x208) Image search: [Google]
srsly.jpg
7 KB, 244x208
>>2513949
>>
File: two_catgirls.png (79 KB, 500x406) Image search: [Google]
two_catgirls.png
79 KB, 500x406
>>2513923
I don't chicken scratch often (pic related) I'm still in the process of improving though
>>
File: 174_by_GentlemansClubStock.jpg (31 KB, 476x719) Image search: [Google]
174_by_GentlemansClubStock.jpg
31 KB, 476x719
>>2513966
Anon please, just stop.
You suck, just got to the begginer thread and read the sticky, for your own sake
>pic unrelated
>>
>>2513953
you did not just fucking post that pic
>>
its ok op
learn your fundamentals
and this isnt a muh sticky advice
fundamentals is all that you will ever need. you will practice fundamentals even after you 'git gud'.
also flipping the canvas to get a mirrored version of the original always helps me see all the problems to fix proportion wise.
now draw us 1000 figure drawings and redraw your picture.
>>
>>2513966
Why aren't you replying to helpful posts?
>>
>>2514003
Because this thread is fucking bait. Everyone in this thread is retarded. Let this thread die for fucks sake.
>>
>>2514003
What should I write to them, thanks? I will consider the tips they are telling me
>>
>>2513974
you deserved it
>>
>>2512237
if it makes you feel any better I like the background.
>>
>>2513899
>>2513905
>>2513966
What the fuck.
>>
>>2514003
Because this thread is bait and the pictures posted aren't from the original poster but just some random kid's account the fisher found.
>>
File: FullSizeRender.jpg (356 KB, 1280x1248) Image search: [Google]
FullSizeRender.jpg
356 KB, 1280x1248
OP here.

I admit it. Everything that I've done that has been posted in the thread and whatever else that I've done is... really bad.

>>2514366
That "random kid's" art is actually mine. Yes, most if not all of them are pretty bad.


To make it up to you guys for me being an idiot, I did a few quick 60 second gesture sketches using quickposes as reference.

This first one though is not. (did it before.)
>>
File: FullSizeRender_1.jpg (296 KB, 1004x1280) Image search: [Google]
FullSizeRender_1.jpg
296 KB, 1004x1280
2/5
>>
>>2514400

To prove you're not a troll do a front, side, and back view gesture and write /ic/ and date it.
>>
File: FullSizeRender_2.jpg (289 KB, 1282x982) Image search: [Google]
FullSizeRender_2.jpg
289 KB, 1282x982
3/5
>>2514404
Will do.
>>
File: FullSizeRender-2.jpg (917 KB, 1856x3264) Image search: [Google]
FullSizeRender-2.jpg
917 KB, 1856x3264
>>2514404
There.
>>
File: FullSizeRender_3.jpg (265 KB, 1280x1164) Image search: [Google]
FullSizeRender_3.jpg
265 KB, 1280x1164
4/5
>>
File: FullSizeRender_4.jpg (316 KB, 1080x2029) Image search: [Google]
FullSizeRender_4.jpg
316 KB, 1080x2029
5/5
>>
>>2514428
>>2514427
>>2514425

Congrats. Now go to the beginner thread and do us all a favor and delete this thread.
>>
>>2514425

Well to be quite honest you're in the top 15% bracket of /ic/, so that means you're in the same league as this guy >>2514291 and if you practice you can get to the top 20% bracket.
>>
>>2514460
I guess I have a long road ahead of me then.
>>
>>2514460
practise to get into a shitter bracket?
>>
>>2514500

The power of regression.
>>
>>2514500
>>2514503
Obviously I'm confused.
>>
>>2514460
im glad the people who hate me are so illiterate.
>>
>>2514522

By the way post your art. Here is mine: http://nameleems.deviantart.com

yeah you wish you had my skills
>>
>>2514522
>le haterzzzs maek me famous
>implying youre good enough to even care about

That fragile ego though wew lad
>>
>>2514529
>sketchdump

Ay yo more like crapdump, am I right fellas?
>>
>>2514533
Ayyy
>>
>>2514529
Hahahahahahahahahhaha
Oh wow
>>
LEAVE NOSEBRO ALONE!

He a good boy! He didn't do nuffin!
>>
>>2514549
why did you take your name off nose
>>
>>2514529
wasnt me but ya that is me. Call back when youre willing to show me your bad stuff.
>>
>>2514583

How is that not you? It has your art on there?
>>
>>2514584
that wasnt me commenting, but it is mine.
>>
dont bother with this place, its absolutely useless

the beginner threads have people that are absolutely shit that needs atleast 10 more years of practice to get anywhere and people that just learned to pick up a pencil, and anywhere else they will tell you to go to the beginner threads unless you are better than 90% of /ic/

i dont know why having random anonomous people on the internet with no credibility what so ever shit on your art sounded like a good thing to do
>>
>>2514684
You're absolutely right.
>>
>>2514588
Hey by they way putting self aware text in your faggy trip doesnt make it le sylishly ironic just tryhard
>>
>>2514795
k
>>
>>2514807
>look mom i did the thing he doesnt like i sure showed him

Congrats youre a child, you win
>>
>>2514832

There is a limit to how much you can bully someone in a day. Save your combantz for tomorrow.
>>
>>2514835
Its not hard to bully someone when they pretend to be completely retarded every day
>>
File: h35i13jh5.jpg (75 KB, 554x528) Image search: [Google]
h35i13jh5.jpg
75 KB, 554x528
>>2512327
>theres something clearly wrong with the pic
>it's anime

>act like a dickhead when called out
>>
>>2514400
Why would you do quick gestures?

Just learn how to draw in the first place.
>>
>>2514400
so many lines in this, all of them useless
do you even understand what are you doing?
>>
>>2514922
Because others have told me to do so?
>>2514927
Making some kind of attempt at getting a very basic body form (or skeleton) down.
>>
>>2515230
Eh, I would say these are gesture-ish?

Your problem anon is that you're really not doing gestures in these. A gesture is when you're quickly trying to capture the form; I feel like you're just trying to draw the body and adding in boobs, butt, kneecaps and the like.
Unfortunately you may not like it, but what the others say is true (minus the dickhead/troll comments). There is no shortcut to learning anatomy. If I were to guess, it seems like you are learning to draw from manga. It's a legit way to go, but it doesn't teach you the fundamentals. You need to read up on anatomy but most importantly you need to draw from life. Learn how the body works and bends and what goes where. Don't learn anatomy from manga, learn to draw a person and apply that to your manga.
>>
>>2514460
>if you practice really hard, one day you can be a shittier artist
>>
>>2514529
You and OP should hang out.

I absolutely love your decomposition of shitty, poorly proportioned drawings into shitty, poorly proportioned wireframes and elements.

You've managed to make every sketch look like you started with a shitty final product and then used that to back into the rough sketches. Like everything was done in reverse
Thread replies: 79
Thread images: 16

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.