[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
COMIC THREAD
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /ic/ - Artwork/Critique

Thread replies: 65
Thread images: 33
File: 14-2.jpg (814 KB, 940x1504) Image search: [Google]
14-2.jpg
814 KB, 940x1504
Post anything comic related, preferably your own work.

Critique is always welcome.
>>
File: 15-1.jpg (1 MB, 940x1511) Image search: [Google]
15-1.jpg
1 MB, 940x1511
>>2497148
>>
File: 15-2.jpg (1 MB, 940x1489) Image search: [Google]
15-2.jpg
1 MB, 940x1489
>>2497149
>>
File: 138318937756.gif (71 KB, 170x170) Image search: [Google]
138318937756.gif
71 KB, 170x170
Oh my, this looks really good. Nicely done, OP. Nicely done...
>>
File: 1442468932219.jpg (33 KB, 625x476) Image search: [Google]
1442468932219.jpg
33 KB, 625x476
Holy fuck nigger I need more. I love this shit! I remember the first couple of pages. I forgot what board I went on and became a poltard. Found you again and I'm still in love with this shit.
>tldr look at thumbnail
>>
>>2497177
>>2497192

Thank you!

I've been posting them here, I'm trying to do a page a week.

>https://tapastic.com/series/CROWFACE
>>
File: pulp.jpg (245 KB, 1920x810) Image search: [Google]
pulp.jpg
245 KB, 1920x810
>>2497222
Literally registered just so i could give you one more sub. Your stuff is seriously great.

I'll be watching you, motherfucker. Don't you dare stop drawing.
>>
File: page_2_resize.jpg (1 MB, 1000x1414) Image search: [Google]
page_2_resize.jpg
1 MB, 1000x1414
Class assignment from last autumn. I'd like to say I've improved significantly since then.[spoiler] I have not.[/spoiler]

Colored recently to submit it to a school I've applied to. Tear me apart anon.
>>
>>2497273
dear anon,

it's weird but kinda interesting.
would be better if you were able to draw better. Hoewever, your art isn't too bad
>>
File: 5V0gW0K.png (399 KB, 800x1237) Image search: [Google]
5V0gW0K.png
399 KB, 800x1237
did these 10 pages for LAS

was a bit rushed because had to do 10 pages in 20 days
>>
File: cGLHUSy.png (414 KB, 800x1237) Image search: [Google]
cGLHUSy.png
414 KB, 800x1237
>>
File: QVwycxu.png (471 KB, 800x1237) Image search: [Google]
QVwycxu.png
471 KB, 800x1237
>>
File: w6lBton.png (611 KB, 800x1120) Image search: [Google]
w6lBton.png
611 KB, 800x1120
>>
File: 4yciW3D.png (556 KB, 800x1120) Image search: [Google]
4yciW3D.png
556 KB, 800x1120
>>
File: bVeteiz.png (699 KB, 800x1120) Image search: [Google]
bVeteiz.png
699 KB, 800x1120
>>
File: xDl0K4N.png (533 KB, 800x1120) Image search: [Google]
xDl0K4N.png
533 KB, 800x1120
>>
File: mmjbW77.png (469 KB, 800x1120) Image search: [Google]
mmjbW77.png
469 KB, 800x1120
>>
File: 5t7bnrG.png (399 KB, 800x1237) Image search: [Google]
5t7bnrG.png
399 KB, 800x1237
>>
File: wMTEFzO.png (467 KB, 800x1237) Image search: [Google]
wMTEFzO.png
467 KB, 800x1237
>>
File: Hunger & Hunters at Comicfury.jpg (120 KB, 700x990) Image search: [Google]
Hunger & Hunters at Comicfury.jpg
120 KB, 700x990
>>2497148
>>
>>2497472
Using the square boxes for anything but the digital text messages doesn't read well. It clashes too much with your cartooning style. There's also inherent associations with various shapes, and boxes tend to read stiffer and less organic which is why we've adopted speech bubbles for spoken words in the first place. An alternative if you are pressed for time is to leave the text free, then connect it with a curve to the speaker, though it's still not as appealing as bubbles.

On this particular page there's also some confusion regards to who is speaking. It becomes obvious what dialogue belongs to whom from context, but any momentary doubt as to who's speaking here breaks up the pacing unnecessarily.
>>
>>2497486
Thank you anon. You've made my day.
>>
File: CH3 PT1 FULL.png (2 MB, 940x6118) Image search: [Google]
CH3 PT1 FULL.png
2 MB, 940x6118
Recently began the third chapter of my webcomic
>>
>>2497476
>>2497475
>>2497474
>>2497472
>>2497471
>>2497469
>>2497466
>>2497465
>>2497463
ignoring the fact that youll probably turn this into homo propaganda, It's quite nice.
>>
File: Gooby car suspicious hd.png (37 KB, 1128x943) Image search: [Google]
Gooby car suspicious hd.png
37 KB, 1128x943
>>2497503
>>
File: 1459192644009.jpg (10 KB, 300x225) Image search: [Google]
1459192644009.jpg
10 KB, 300x225
>>2497222 same as >>2497252
>>
>>2497500

very good tips

thanks for your time and critic
>>
As simple as the art style of OP's comic is, I really like it. Sort of reminds me of this http://samaldencomics.tumblr.com/post/32842625940/farmers-dilemma-2012 . I'm really warming up to simple ink comics. I'm thinking about doing my own, with mostly simple, quick panels and a few detailed splash pages. OP, what size paper do you work on?
>>
>>2497486

keep on keepin' on

Draw figures from life for practice if you can, that pose is pretty awkward.

>>2497573

This isn't bad, but I'm not terribly partial to it and I can't put my finger on why. It might just be because it's out of context.

>>2498344

Thanks! Using just ink and water saves so much time. Each page is like 5"x8" or so, it's in a moleskine.
>>
>>2497273

I like this a lot, maybe try playing with sizing and arranging the frames differently; everything is pretty evenly distributed and it's not very dynamic as a whole.
>>
File: 0004.png (636 KB, 660x920) Image search: [Google]
0004.png
636 KB, 660x920
sup comrades

https://tapastic.com/series/Sammy in case someone cares
>>
>>2497273
I like this. Keep drawing. Got a blog?
>>
>>2497273
I've seen this same shot from a japanese horror manga i once read
>>
>>2498472
>putting AMD in your robot
>it overheats

Come on man, use common sense.
>>
>>2498375
I did almost the whole thing on physical media, so I'd have to redraw as well as recolor the entire thing for that. I'm working on another comic project for class right now, and am drawing every frame on a separate sheet so I can just digitally rearrange them all how I like.

>>2498474
Chances are I've read the same thing and subconsciously used it from memory. I'm not sure which shot you mean in particular, but it could be all of them.

>>2498473
I have a da which I've revived to keep as a timelapse for myself:
antti-chan.deviantart.com
>>
>>2498536

I just meant in the future, not rearranging and resizing all of the frames in this comic in particular. I think trying to do each frame individually and scan them in could be helpful, but in the long run it's going to be extremely tedious and not worth the time (compared to doing a few thumbnail comps and laying them out on the page. Regardless of this, if you can find a process that works for you, use it!
>>
File: page1.jpg (374 KB, 1400x1980) Image search: [Google]
page1.jpg
374 KB, 1400x1980
>>
Anyone applying for the DC Talent Workshop? Currently inking my pages atm
>>
File: page2.jpg (468 KB, 1400x1980) Image search: [Google]
page2.jpg
468 KB, 1400x1980
>>
File: Billy Fly-dol.png (1 MB, 400x1601) Image search: [Google]
Billy Fly-dol.png
1 MB, 400x1601
I did this a week ago for fun. 1/2
>>
File: Billy Fly-dol copy.png (1 MB, 400x1604) Image search: [Google]
Billy Fly-dol copy.png
1 MB, 400x1604
Billy Fly-dol 2/2
>>
>>2498876
yo I really like this, blog?
>>
>>2497148
I love you
>>
>>2499151
cool thanks
http://snozzberry22.blogspot.be/
>>
File: image.png (777 KB, 1118x710) Image search: [Google]
image.png
777 KB, 1118x710
>>2498369
If it's context you need, you can check out the rest here
https://tapastic.com/episode/138821
Be warned, the early chapters may require some safety goggles
>>
>>2498472
Nice drawing anon
>>
File: IMG_20160424_213506.jpg (853 KB, 1920x2400) Image search: [Google]
IMG_20160424_213506.jpg
853 KB, 1920x2400
I don't usually make comics but I'm thinking of starting to post some of what I have done,please let me know what you guys think
>>
>>2499332
Is he drawing a dick in the sand? If so, thats pretty funny
>>
>>2499366
he is,thanks
I guess I should make it clearer
>>
>>2499389
It's perfect the way it is. Im really digging the subtlety
>>
>>2499389
Saved it. Sick of comics like OPs but this one really hit a spot
>>
>>2499394
>>2499395
I'm glad you liked it,thanks
I'll probably post more somewhere as soon as I got a scanner
>>
File: Ch.1 Pg.1.png (951 KB, 940x1316) Image search: [Google]
Ch.1 Pg.1.png
951 KB, 940x1316
How is it?
>>
>>2501679
I found it very boring. Too much text and if you used more panels it would be much more interesting.
>>
>>2501737
Thanks, I'll keep that in mind next page.
>>
File: Page 1.jpg (252 KB, 940x604) Image search: [Google]
Page 1.jpg
252 KB, 940x604
>>2501737 How about this one? Is it at least more interesting?
>>
>>2501792
Yeah it's much better, I also like the fact that you're using different panel sizes in this one.
>>
File: Page 2.jpg (290 KB, 940x604) Image search: [Google]
Page 2.jpg
290 KB, 940x604
>>2501792
>>
>>2501833
http://www.storytellerartist.com/documents/Perspective_Made_Easy.pdf
>>
File: drawingfur_1-3_fur_anatomy.png (81 KB, 600x485) Image search: [Google]
drawingfur_1-3_fur_anatomy.png
81 KB, 600x485
>>2501679
Fur looks like shit: http://design.tutsplus.com/articles/how-to-draw-animals-quickly-render-fur--vector-17833
>>
>>2501845
This is a great read, thank you so much.
>>
>>2501849
Thanks for this, I knew my fur looked like shit but this helps a lot.

My own fault for not trying to look things like this up beforehand, honestly.
>>
File: 1455323015303.png (14 KB, 560x407) Image search: [Google]
1455323015303.png
14 KB, 560x407
>>2501833
>>2501796
Also, I'm going to have to start my comic over again anyway, considering I could do much better with perspective and fur.
>>
>Wanna name webcomic
>Name has been used before
>What do?
>>
>>2503169
Give up.
Thread replies: 65
Thread images: 33

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.