[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
As the centuries progress, will he still be as vilified as he
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 242
Thread images: 52
File: Adolf.jpg (19 KB, 250x317) Image search: [Google]
Adolf.jpg
19 KB, 250x317
As the centuries progress, will he still be as vilified as he is today? Or will people view him as a "Napoleon" of sorts?
>>
>>1361960
Napoleon was extremely succesful and great so I don't see how that comparison holds.
>>
>>1361960
He didn't lead battles personally, and he personally ordered the deaths of millions of people.

I think, no.
>>
>>1361964
>>1361965
I meant it in the sense that he was one of the people who induced profound, irreversible changes in the world.
>>
>>1361964
He lost all his gains when he antagonized the entire world and tried conquering Russia, it fits.
>>
>>1361969
Beside anti-smoking laws and a couple highways, Hitler's got shit for a legacy beside some Neo-Nazi morons.
>>
I would say no.

Hitler is unlucky because we've saved all virtually all the important data on him. We have his speech, Mein Kampf, and the books/testimonies of all those around him.

WW2 will always be a most interesting piece in World History as we had never gotten so close to blowing everything up. Hitler is a central player.

Compare him to say Ivan The Terrible and while they hold many similar shitty tendencies the fact is lots of common people don't even know who Ivan the Terrible is. Everyone will know Hitler just from the great movies based on that period.
>>
>>1361985
Hitler was probably the most influential person of the 20th Century.
>>
>>1361986
/thread
>>
>>1361993
Arguably, but the 20th century was the shit man. So much happened
>>
>>1361986
I forgot to mention that Stalin will also be remembered in an equally monstrous fashion unless you're a Russian with Stockholm syndrome.
>>
>>1361993
No, that's definitely Lenin.
>>
>>1361960
I haven't met any youth who dislikes Hitler.
>>
>>1362059
That's because you don't go outside, Anon.
>>
>>1361986
Nah give it fifty more years and his birthday will be a national holiday in Germany and Austria.
>>
>>1362036
Russia wouldn't have been pulverized by the rest of the world if it weren't for Hitler.
>>
>>1361960
They won't view him as a Napoleon. They'll view him in the context of his times. In the same way that we contexualize ancient tyrants killing thousands and barely vilify them, so will be the case with Hitler. The wounds he inflicted will fade and be contexualize. People will say "Antisemitism was normal back then" etc.

Like whenever you bring up historical child abuse or slavery.
>>
>>1361986
>Ivan The Terrible

The "terrible" in Ivan the Terrible means something more like "awesome/fearsome" than "shitty/no good". It's "terrible" in the way that seeing god would be "terrible".
>>
>>1362091
Brah, people still think the Assyrians were evil, and they were way more normal for their time period than Hitler was in his.
>>
>>1362095
Which didn't stop him from massacring entire cities for whatever reason.
>>
>>1362091
Yeah that's probably what will happen.

When we talk about the fall of Cartage to the Romans, we speak so naturally. Oh and then the Romans went and killed every man woman and child, detroyed the city and sparkled salt on top of it. You don't see mentally-ill SJW warrior types signaling, OMG I'm crying with anger and holding myself for Cartage! Let's not forget Cartage! Never again! Etc.

Distance => indifference.
>>
>>1362073
your word against mines, most youth admire Hitler.
>>
>>1362117
Where do you live, Palestine?
>>
File: Musso.gif (2 MB, 297x229) Image search: [Google]
Musso.gif
2 MB, 297x229
>>1362107
Yep.
People underestimate the importance of spacetime proximity.

I guess you could say... it's a remote concept.
>>
>>1362126
Where do you live, Tel Aviv?
>>
>>1361960
Only french can turn their dictators into enlightened rulers, non-french dictators are merely dictators
>>
>>1362107
>Salting the earth
Isn't that a myth?
The Romans founded a new city at the same place pretty soon afterwards.
>>
File: ancient.jpg (14 KB, 236x314) Image search: [Google]
ancient.jpg
14 KB, 236x314
>>1362117
lol
asl?
>>
>>1362130
No, I live outside my basement.
>>
>>1362117
Hitler is strong and has achieved more than anyone in modern history, he is to be admired.
>>
File: apocalypse.jpg (484 KB, 1024x884) Image search: [Google]
apocalypse.jpg
484 KB, 1024x884
>>1362133
Maybe.

Point is they BTFO all Carthaginians and erased the culture.
>>
>>1362136
No, I live outside my basement.
>>
>>1362130
No, really. I'm curious.
>>
>>1362090
I spent an entire minute rereading your sentence and still have no fucking idea what you're talking about.
>>
File: follow_your_leader.jpg (107 KB, 781x1023) Image search: [Google]
follow_your_leader.jpg
107 KB, 781x1023
>>1362143
>>1362117
>>1362059
>>
>>1362152
No, really. I'm curious.
>>
>>1362095
>Murdered his own son/heir
>Destroyed cities looking to get rid of traitors
>Was fucking insane
The Terrible was an apt name.
>>
>>1362156
>no proof of Hitler's death
>follow your leader
epic
Not even a nazi, but your antifa pictures don't help your argument
>>
File: serveimage.jpg (58 KB, 800x513) Image search: [Google]
serveimage.jpg
58 KB, 800x513
Reminder that Hitler is not only NOT controversial, but it's actually admired in Asia and in the Middle East.

Mein Kampf is a best seller in Arab nations.

These regions have huge populations and as they increase in relevance in world politics, the Western consensus is likely to shift to a less emotional and more balanced view.

In short, the rest of the world is a not an echo chamber.
>>
>>1361960
The Assyrians and the Aztecs are still pretty vilified. On the other hand, we forgave the japs. Dunno.
>>
>>1362154
I think he meant how Stalin was afraid Hitler would side with the Western powers and attack the USSR and try to partition the country between Germany and the western powers
>>
>>1362185
Hitler is half satan and half meme. Even in the west people treat him flippantly.
>>
>>1362186
We forgive the Japs because we turned them into a completely different country.

The Japan that caused all of the problems is deader than dinosaurs.
>>
File: serveimage.jpg (15 KB, 350x210) Image search: [Google]
serveimage.jpg
15 KB, 350x210
The Western political and academic elites are invested in the narrative that Hitler was evil, but the rest of the world doesn't give a shit.
>>
File: Hitler_Ice-Cream.png (559 KB, 613x418) Image search: [Google]
Hitler_Ice-Cream.png
559 KB, 613x418
>>
File: hitlerclothes-582542.jpg (37 KB, 590x350) Image search: [Google]
hitlerclothes-582542.jpg
37 KB, 590x350
http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/582542/Adolf-Hitler-Ice-cream-cone-which-has-face-of-evil-dictator-goes-on-sale
>>
>>1362220
I might move to India to have the political freedom of national socialism.
>>
>>1362228
Have fun drowning in shit.
>>
>>1362167
That's fine, but the appellation wasn't given to him because people thought he was awful & piss-poor. It was given to him because he was fearsome.
>>
>>1362143
>has achieved more than anyone in modern history
in what way? All he accomplished was killing millions of people and getting his country bombed to the ground before offing himself.
>>
>>1362240
Go educate yourself shit poster.
>>
>>1362240
And that's still more than you'll ever achieve.
>>
>>1362194
Ah, that makes more sense.
In what way was that even possible, though? Hitler did a fine job of pissing everyone off even before he attacked Poland.
>>
File: hitler youth china.jpg (56 KB, 800x594) Image search: [Google]
hitler youth china.jpg
56 KB, 800x594
>>1362278
>>
>>1362288
>china
>west
>>
>>1362301
China is a larger population than the people Hitler wasn't liked by, the reactionary governments of France and England.
>>
If Hitler hadn't mass murdered Jews he would probably go down fairly indifferently with a lot of admirable aspects.
If he had never started WW2 he probably would've ended being hailed among the great Germans like Fredrick II
>>
>>1362305
Yes, but they're also a shithole, and thus irrelevant to the lives of most of the people who have good enough English skills to use 4chan.
>>
File: main_1200.jpg (68 KB, 1200x801) Image search: [Google]
main_1200.jpg
68 KB, 1200x801
The world is a big, big place.

http://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2013/07/a-mongolian-neo-nazi-environmentalist-walks-into-a-lingerie-store-in-ulan-bator/100547/
>>
File: main_1200 (1).jpg (53 KB, 1200x799) Image search: [Google]
main_1200 (1).jpg
53 KB, 1200x799
>>1362320
>>
File: main_1200 (2).jpg (81 KB, 1200x787) Image search: [Google]
main_1200 (2).jpg
81 KB, 1200x787
>>1362323
>>
File: main_1200 (3).jpg (76 KB, 1200x799) Image search: [Google]
main_1200 (3).jpg
76 KB, 1200x799
>>1362327
>>
File: baron_swastika.jpg (88 KB, 511x599) Image search: [Google]
baron_swastika.jpg
88 KB, 511x599
>>1362323
Nice aesthetics, I love the Mongols.
>>
>>1362327
I have seen a Mongolian Nazi yurt. I think that's it. I have seen all of the things. I'm ready to die now.
>>
>>1362330
Based Baron von Ungern-Sternberg. I was just thinking about him and Ossendowky's book.

The Mongols are an admirable people.

>>1362338
Kek.
>>
That is how he is considered in places Holocaustiany has not taken off.
>>
>>1362338
The Mongolian Fascist Horde comes soon.
>>
File: True Mongolia.png (53 KB, 2000x1000) Image search: [Google]
True Mongolia.png
53 KB, 2000x1000
>>
File: serveimage.jpg (17 KB, 442x305) Image search: [Google]
serveimage.jpg
17 KB, 442x305
>>1362359
Nazi Tibetan Buddhism when?
>>
>>1362371
Now.
>>
>>1362240
>rising up from the son of a clerk to the most powerful man in the world
>>
>>1362203
This is a joke right?
Japs are still xenophobic and nationalist as they were, they just don't give a shit so you can't guilt them into apologizing for their past crimes
>>
>>1362305
>implying Hitler's government wasn't reactionary
Also, the original point of this trail of thought was the potential of Hitler allying with the West, so I don't know why the hell you're bringing up China.
>>
>>1362476
>national socialism is reactionary
national socialism is revolutionary.
>>
>>1361964
>>1361960
Before Hitler, Napoleon was the ubiquitous supervillain who everyone used to scare monger. They went "that person is just as bad as Napoleon!"

It really makes you think. Logically, once another warmongering dictator shows up, he'll replace Hitler's current status.
>>
>>1362495
>hurrr durr it's just the cycles of time bruh
Napoleon didn't attempt a complete extermination of an entire race of people, with some other minorities mixed in for good measure. Hitler did.
Not to mention Hitler was as repulsive as a personality as he was a politician.
He's become the archetypal villain for good reason.
>>
The west will view him more objectively once another villainous warmonger type comes along and genocide of a familiar community happens on a scale bigger than the holocaust (Rwanda, Bosnia, Darfur, etc. are too distant culturally to the west to have the impact the holocaust did)
>>
>>1362519
Genocide is only a crime post ww2, Europeans exterminated uncountable amounts of peoples in Europe.
>>
>>1362525
Same thing in MesoAmerica, Asia, Australia, middle east, Caucasus etc..
>>
>>1362519
Objectively, he caused a whole lot of war and misery for the cause of German nationalism.
>>
The reason napoleon was viewed as villain was because he overthrew the royalist's in power in nearly all of Europe, and instated a civil law which was incredibly modern at the time, and ist still used in countries around the world, and also conquered europe from Madrid to Moscow.
Hitler wasn't even close to being as good a general as napoleon was, and the reason he tried to conquer europe were to expand the living room for his race.
You can hardly compare an opportunistic racist to a dictator overthrowing the kings of Europe.
There was a reason the people in Warsaw cheered when napoleon conquered it.
>>
True but the holocaust influenced international policy like no other ethnic cleansing ever did
>>
>>1362518
Haha so much feelings.

Meanwhile outside the (((echo chamber)))

http://www.vice.com/read/hitler-is-a-rock-star-in-south-asia
>>
>>1362530
Objectively, Napoleon caused a whole lot of war and misery for the cause of French Imperialism
>>
>>1362531
No one called Hitler the bolshevik term Racist.
>>
>>1362518
That's nonsense Tons of leaders committed genocide (see Turkey) and they're not viewed as Hitlers. We have leaders from the same time period who committed even worse atrocities (see Stalin) who we don't view as Hitler. If we go further back in time we can probably find even worse ones.

What we view as supervillain is entirely contextual and what is most politically convenient at the time. The reason Hitler is a personification of evil and Stalin is not is due to one simple reason: Hitler lost the war.
>>
>>1362525
The Jews exterminated the Canaanites etc..
>>
>>1362548
Do you see any Canaanites?
Do you see any Jews?
Enough said.
>>
>>1362534
Ooo wow, a bunch of poverty stricken asians that were outside of Hitler's sphere of influence like him.
>>
>>1361960
Often the historians who write the history the soonest after an event often paint the picture that is followed for the longest.


Napoleon was considered the bad guy but even in his time I wouldn't say he was considered any more evil than any of the other monarchs in Europe at the time.

Rightly or wrongly Hitler was considered more evil than other autocrats of his time immediately after the war, and that is the view that will probably be held indefinitely.
>>
>>1362554
>Rightly or wrongly Hitler was considered more evil than other autocrats of his time immediately after the war, and that is the view that will probably be held indefinitely.
This is false, Hitler was not an evil figure in his time, people were all adopting Fascism.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfpjLsMgAsw
>>
He will be remembered as the ultimate jealousy of future 20th and 21st century political movements. All modern politics is just toned down Fascism that wishes for total control.
>>
>>1362234
>>1362167
It's the same thing with
terrible/terrific and
awful(full of awe)/awesome

english language is weird
>>
>>1362537
>7 wars with the Coalition
>started 2

>>1362543
> and Stalin is not
Are you high? Stalin is always grouped in with people like Hitler or Mao.
>>
>>1362543
>What we view as supervillain is entirely contextual and what is most politically convenient at the time.
This. Like I said before, the current political and academic elites, and even media and enternainment industry, are invested into the narrative that Hitler was the most evil man that ever lived and WW2 was "the good war". But an objective, non biased analysis shows that Hitler was not worse than Stalin and Mao, and in fact no more "evil" than, say, Charlemagne or Mehmed II. The reason Indians, Asians don't view him as evil at all is because they're not invested in the (((narrative))).
>>
File: 1452520436450.png (423 KB, 588x450) Image search: [Google]
1452520436450.png
423 KB, 588x450
>>1362156
>Edgy "fuck the system" stencil
>Stencil has isolated white areas that would defeat it actually being used as a stencil
My inner autist is raging.
>>
>>1362563
>Are you high? Stalin is always grouped in with people like Hitler or Mao.
Stop being facetious, you know that's not true. Talk to the average person and they'll say Hitler was far worse than both of them combined. That's the narrative that popular culture paints.
>>
File: RACE AND NATION!!!.jpg (52 KB, 561x362) Image search: [Google]
RACE AND NATION!!!.jpg
52 KB, 561x362
>>1362557
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJQST9JiY-k
Race and nation is a beautiful thing and the ultimate morality.
>>
>>1362569
Hating Hitler also is part of Antifa and SJW's very identity. They know they "have to" hate him, even before they know the least thing about politics, history and WW2. It just comes with the package.
>>
>>1362579
All that fascism (as well as all utopian ideologies) does is fill the void left by God, replacing God with race. It's pretty shit and fails to innovate to be quite honest family
>>
File: donnefasciste.jpg (61 KB, 650x280) Image search: [Google]
donnefasciste.jpg
61 KB, 650x280
>>1362592
Fascism enforces God.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=StaPF5qqFDk
>>
File: 1459867532041.jpg (143 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
1459867532041.jpg
143 KB, 1000x1000
>>1362557
Which is why the time period is called the age of Fascism, reactionary barbarians invaded the beginning of the new era.
>>
>>1362577
>you know that's not true
Anytime I've brought up Stalin to the average person, they know him as the brutal purging dictator of Russia. Personally, I find him more interesting than Hitler, and yet won't pretend for a second he wasn't as monstrous.

But please continue to feel entitled to tell me what I actually know, you pretentious fuckwad.
>>
>>1362598
Not the Christian God of Europe
http://www.ibtimes.com/heinrich-himmler-nazi-hindu-214444
>>
>>1362557
>Cannot into context.

I said Immediately after the war. Not during or before.
>>
>>1362613
propaganda, not a single pagan or anything non Christian was introduced into religious life.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EukxQIrJzXY
>>
>>1361960

If it hadn't have been for the Holocaust meme he'd probably just be another historical leader by this point.
>>
>>1362567
>is because they're not invested in the (((narrative)))
Which stems from the fact that nothing Hitler did affected them. They don't have relatives that were victims of his war or holocaust.
>>
>>1362644
The only thing Hitler did was declare war on Poland for Danzig, everything else was actions of other people.
>>
>>1362495
>They went "that person is just as bad as Napoleon!"
Who did? The English? In Portugal we actually complained about the English that were supposed to be protecting us from that guy.
>>
>>1362543
Except naploeon didnt write a vile book full of nonesense and misguided hate.
And stalin is hated its just that stalin didnt let his country get conquered and destroyed and thus still ejoyed some home support.
There was noing to support for the germans. Hitler as a disaster for german and his economic plans were a one way ticket ot war.
He aws an utter disaster.
>>
File: 1461333200671.png (148 KB, 2500x1645) Image search: [Google]
1461333200671.png
148 KB, 2500x1645
>>1362656
Yes, poor little Adolf was forced to invade France and Russia at gunpoint.
>>
>>1362603
>useless nazi cricle jerk

Great use of resources.
>>
>>1362669
France declared war on Germany and invaded Germany.
>>
>>1362722
http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/britain-and-france-declare-war-on-germany
>>
>>1362722
>>1362741
So? He knew invading Poland would make that happen. He planned to invade France either way.
>>
>>1362754
>he knew what others would do
>he's a prophet
Hitler wanted Danzig a German city to be German, central european border dispute.
>>
File: 1352413552676.jpg (14 KB, 300x300) Image search: [Google]
1352413552676.jpg
14 KB, 300x300
How will Hitler be remembered when the Holocaust is finally acknowledged as a massive hoax?
>>
>>1362758
I think being a European politician made him aware of the alliance between Poland, France, and Britain. It wasn't some secret.
>>
>>1362231
just stay away from the railway tracks and you will be fine. Its like saying every tourist in america gets a lead injection.
>>
File: 1464486365157.jpg (80 KB, 775x720) Image search: [Google]
1464486365157.jpg
80 KB, 775x720
Dude killing millions of people to fuel your narcissism is way worse than doing it for racism and anti-communism. Napoleon didn't even have an ideology like most dictators, you can see in Dostoevsky's works how he is viewed as void of nihilism
>>
>>1362763
As the only friend of the European peoples, others friends is capitalist profit.
>>
>>1362404

No, he's fundamentally correct. Japanese society is a totally different beast. Regardless of whether they are possessed of the same attitudes they possessed before WW2, their society is structured in a wildly different manner, to wit it isn't ordered by military/palace cabal but by representative/republican institutions and rule of law. German society hasn't changed anywhere near so fundamentally. Representative democracy brought about Hitler's single-party state and representative democracy persists in Germany today. The manifestation of power has changed, but the basis of the power hasn't.

>>1362212

This is also basically true. The power elite are invested in the narrative that Hitler was the Great Satan because it allows them to other bad government. That is to say, by pointing to Hitler and identifying him with the notion of political evil, they can hide themselves from the public's judgment. Essentially when they state that Hitler was evil, what they are saying is "I may be part of a soulless corrupt state machinery that exists to enrich me and my cronies, but at least I'm not putting you in a gas chamber, so suck it up".
>>
>>1362771
>Dude killing millions of people to fuel your narcissism
He spent most of his career fighting off invasions from the rest of Europe. The Monarchies wanted him and the revolution dead.
>>
Why did he hate Jews so much?
>>
>>1362809

they stabbed him in the rear
>>
File: jewish-feminism.jpg (320 KB, 1600x2812) Image search: [Google]
jewish-feminism.jpg
320 KB, 1600x2812
>>1362809

you tell me schlomo
>>
>>1362519
This.

I think the main reason people hate Hitler so much, is that they somehow think that he's unique in history, as the only person to quickly transform a perfectly civilised country into a purpose-driven sacred slaughter state.

Well, he's the only one so far, but obviously the next one will come along any decade now. It will probably be the US to be honest, or a country that forms from part of the US.

At that point, people will just generally be frightened of what humans are, not Hitler in particular.
>>
>>1362809
At a personal level, his mothered died and he suspected the doctor who tended to her to be a Jew. Otherwise he read a few anti semitic pamphlets in Austria and lived with political losers who blamed all of Germany's woes on the Jews.
>>
>>1362809
>why do they hate me so?
educate yourself.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pDtgWUtdUM
>>
>>1362820

nah they'll keep on blaming white european males for everything that's wrong with the world
>>
>>1362820
If you learn anything from being on 4chan, it's that thinking like a fascist is an intoxicating feeling. It's basically the most pleasurable and meaningful state for a human, and can only be tempered by boring "facts" or "ethics".

/pol/ isn't miserable. They may have shitty lives that are falling apart, but they're clever, happy people. That's why it's growing.
>>
>>1362834
waiting desperately for the day of the rope isn't happy.
>>
>>1362763

>the holocaust didnt happen but it should have.

And they laugh at jews who talk about a rise of anti semitism.
>>
>>1362804
He crowned himself emperor, no need to worship some one for being really good at killing
>>
>>1362845
It really is, though. I've been in that mindset, and pulled myself out. There's nothing more fun than being around amusing friends with a common purpose, a common enemy, and reports of a constant stream of victories.

I would tell myself it was "ironic", but there is no such thing as irony. Irony is just how we pretend not to like the things we do.
>>
>>1362846

antisemitism was on the decline until they established a jewish state
>>
>>1362853

those Brexit threads last week were solid fucking gold
>>
>>1362845
"Day of the rope" is such a funny expression.
Why do i find it funny? I am jewish.
>>
>>1362854
You mena right after the halacaust? Oo
>>
>>1362809
He used many political enemies for slave labor. Its like saying stalin hated ukrainians because he killed so many of them
>>
>>1362853
yeah. A dose of cold hard facts really slaps you in the face. I used to frequent a similar website once, like /pol/ but for my country, and it felt nice to think that our time in the sun was just about the corner.
>>
File: 1434364377911s.jpg (3 KB, 125x93) Image search: [Google]
1434364377911s.jpg
3 KB, 125x93
>>1362857
probably because you will sell hemp and make a profit off it. :^)
btw you got a full pic of this? I saved the thumbnai.
>>
>>1362809
Those poor Jews! Dey dindu nothing wrong!
>>
>>1362201
This. Even back in the day Adolf was still-meme as fuck with things like The Great Dictator. If anything Hitler won't be seen as a man of "power" like Napoleon, but as a man of "excess"--the face of an ideology that became so extreme it ended up untable, even if some of its bases made sense.
>>
>>1361960
Napoleon wanted to spread the Revolution, and he managed just that. His troops planted the seeds of revolutionary ideas wherever they went and soon the whole of Europe was democratic.

Hitler, on the other hand, managed to make it so everything closely or loosely related to his ideas has been fiercely rejected and probably will be for a while.
>>
>>1362870
What made senses about it though?
He literally declared himself part of a greater race and then proved they werent.

Like trudeau said if you kill them you lose. The Nazi's killed the jews and the jews won.
>>
File: 1819M.png (19 KB, 304x224) Image search: [Google]
1819M.png
19 KB, 304x224
>>1362870
*untenable
>>
>>1362874
Though if centralized religious authority gains power in the future napoleon will probably be seen as an atheistic tyrrant.
>>
File: state sanctioned hitler youth.jpg (103 KB, 704x498) Image search: [Google]
state sanctioned hitler youth.jpg
103 KB, 704x498
>>1362874
managed to make it so everything closely or loosely related to his ideas has been fiercely rejected and probably will be for a while.

Yeah he managed to do that when bolshevik jews in soviet union decided to exterminate the german race and all european races, while the capitalist jews follow this today.

Ask a Jew if you believe in the rights of European peoples to their own homeland, he will say no, if you asked first about Jews and their homeland he will say yes.
>>
>>1362874
You have to be over 18 to post on this board.

Literally everything you said is 8th grade tier history and politics.
>>
>>1362878
>he killed the Jews
Why do Jews still live when Germany had an army of 4 million and the Jews were defenseless in camps?
>>
>>1362853
I think that the left has made a massive mistake by trusting that people are telling the truth on polls, etc. or that they even acknowledge their own true beliefs.

I think everyone has a politically correct mask, but underneath they remember every single time they noticed that something in their lives didn't match the narrative.

So you'll get people who have been telling people how politically correct they are, mysteriously not getting involved when the fascists come to power.

They're literally just waiting for permission to unite their two lives.
>>
>>1362518
Napoleon was cast as a villain before because he represented the french revolution which was a total bloodbath. Hitler's basically the same for industrial society as Napoleon was for the enlightenment.
>>
>>1362885
What are you butthurt about?
>>
>>1362884
what are you babbling about?
>>
>>1362874

Napoleon crowned himself Emperor and effective ended Democracy in France while he was ruling.

How fucking fuck do you fuck fuck get out
>>
>>1362891
Somebody didn't praise his nazifu so he went on an antisemitic tirade.
/pol/ posters are simple folks.
>>
>>1362885
see, not this >>1362894 is 8th grade incomprehension
>>
>>1362878
That you immediately think "gassed jews" when any room for thinking possitibely about Nazism, that any information regarding how it came about and how it makes sense in its historical context, proves my point: that our views on the matter are being extreme to what we consider is extreme.
>>
File: together we will win.jpg (78 KB, 320x500) Image search: [Google]
together we will win.jpg
78 KB, 320x500
>>1362895
And you are reddit poster or do you think yourself as the standard, and if so who gave you that right?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofgLFvFDjKg
>>
>>1362894
Well, he made it clear that the old nobilities were no longer relevant. Andd he made it so it was about nations, not dynasties. Like France trying to take over Spain in the 1700s was a dynastic thing, but the Napoleonic campaigns were an attempt to elevate the French people to the status of masterrace.
>>
>>1362886
>stalin wanted to kill ukrainians and germans
>no one knows of their death or cares
>Hitler just wanted this non European race out of Europe and did everything to do so, evil.
>>
The will see him as Der Führer, the GOAT, the one who changed the world to a better place. People will call their Kids Adolf en masse. German-Aryan Europe will be the new world and the New Era of Neo-Nationalsozialistentum will lead the World.
>>
>>1362894
>>1362894

'french democracy' was a mistake
>>
>>1362912

>he thinks "European races" exist

Oh wait, you're one of those people who reject out of Africa, aren't you?
>>
File: race and nation!!.jpg (39 KB, 700x333) Image search: [Google]
race and nation!!.jpg
39 KB, 700x333
>>1362905
The Axis population in 1938 was 258.9 million, yes you the random intellectual are true while 258 million people are completely incorrect and (((evil))).
>>
>>1362903
Firs ot all it was a joke you moron.
Second of all the nazi genocide was unique in the sense that it was premediatated and was delivered with the full force of the industrial machine and by a country that was the pinnacle of european culture and technology.
>>
>>1362918
And Africa couldn't join the Axis because they were a colony to the benevolent democratic capitalism.
>>
>>1362918
>you [...] are true
German or Arab?
>>
>>1362922
Oh vey six trillion were killed a day!
>>
>>1362913
shame hoi 4 doesn't allow for all that.
>>
>>1362926
Isnt it a bit retarded being a nationalist on an internet wesbite that is essentialyl global? Just being here talking with everyone is already helping break down national borders and creating a global culture.
>>
>>1362848
no he didnt
>>
File: image.jpg (94 KB, 1039x585) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
94 KB, 1039x585
>>1362935
>being a nationalist means being a cave man
>calls others retard
>>
>>1362922
>Second of all the nazi genocide was unique in the sense that it was premediatated and was delivered with the full force of the industrial machine and by a country that was the pinnacle of european culture and technology.
I'm not disagreeing.
>>
File: hitler franco.jpg (74 KB, 630x354) Image search: [Google]
hitler franco.jpg
74 KB, 630x354
>>1362935
>Isnt it a bit retarded being a nationalist on an internet wesbite that is essentially global?
Nationalists are all comrades.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Division

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfpjLsMgAsw

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_involvement_in_the_Spanish_Civil_War
http://spartacus-educational.com/SPitaly.htm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GcO3xrKgS1c
>>
File: 1466934467597.jpg (232 KB, 615x923) Image search: [Google]
1466934467597.jpg
232 KB, 615x923
In the future Nationalist revolution, Hitler will be remembered for the Hero that he truly was.
>>
File: kamerad.jpg (65 KB, 550x799) Image search: [Google]
kamerad.jpg
65 KB, 550x799
>>1362948
The war on a nationalist is the war against us all.
>>
>>1362944
In some sense the new media of the day contributed to the beastifying of the german and soviet people.
Today, the Genocide of ISIS and the rise of islamic spordaic violence is in some ways similair since it uses new media to make people kill others.
>>
>>1362935
>>1362185
>>1362212
>>1362220
>>1362223
>>1362288
>>1362320
>>1362359
>>1362905
Oh vey!

Goyim literally translates as "nations".
>>
>>1362885
>Literally everything you said is 8th grade tier history and politics.
/pol/ can't muster that tho
>>
File: image.jpg (29 KB, 300x400) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
29 KB, 300x400
>>1362959
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syrian_Social_Nationalist_Party
Oh to the very vey!
>>
>>1361986
WW2 won't be the end of World Wars, goyim
>>
File: image.jpg (24 KB, 309x250) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
24 KB, 309x250
>>1362967
Goyim unite!
>>
File: image.jpg (47 KB, 458x321) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
47 KB, 458x321
>>1362977
Goy power!
>>
File: image.jpg (54 KB, 316x466) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
54 KB, 316x466
>>1362981
Next time without Italy though...!
>>
File: 1455836588038.gif (2 MB, 196x300) Image search: [Google]
1455836588038.gif
2 MB, 196x300
>>1362918
Dude you're so cool and enlightened for adding parentheses around words. Come over and fuck my sister.
>>
File: look.jpg (170 KB, 700x499) Image search: [Google]
look.jpg
170 KB, 700x499
>>1362981
why do I have to listen to Jews?
Go be superior in your desert and stop speaking Aryan languages, thief.
>>
>>1362990
Huh, wat?
>>
File: ha.png (55 KB, 213x404) Image search: [Google]
ha.png
55 KB, 213x404
>>1363016
Stop speaking a European language and solely speak Hebrew, no more Goys will bother you then mordechai.
>>
>>1362309

t. I don't know shit about history

Hitler was literally nothing special besides a great orator. His policies would have bankrupted the country if he hadn't gone to war with the debtors, and his economy was entirely RELIANT on wartime production. If he hadn't started the war, he would have accomplished nothing.
>>
File: image.jpg (22 KB, 470x313) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
22 KB, 470x313
>>1363025
You're not the brightest tool in the shed, are you?
>>
>>1362917
And you're one of those people who think that "we stopped evolving" because... something. But you're not one of those creationist hicks, though! You believe in science, and spiritually comforting science most of all!
>>
File: britain have a better idea.png (337 KB, 720x400) Image search: [Google]
britain have a better idea.png
337 KB, 720x400
>>1362834

/pol/ is hilarious
>>
Should be remembered forever as an example of the extremes of mental illness ans why we should work on getting people's fucking heads straight.
>>
>>1363043
"No boo! I created you, you can't do this to me!!!! I am YOUR MASTER! OBEY ME!"
>>
>>1361985
>>1361985
Literally kys.

Europe was literally partitioned into two halves for over half a century as part of his legacy. Even back then people knew how important Hitler was.

He was basically a projection of Odin in human form.
>>
>>1362894
>and effective ended Democracy in France

You have no idea of what you're talking about
Democracy had never existed in France, from 1792 to 1799 some commitees were ruling unilaterally before being ovethrown by another commitee
Btw, Napoleon held a referundim before crowning himself
>>
File: 1464155157119.jpg (96 KB, 589x599) Image search: [Google]
1464155157119.jpg
96 KB, 589x599
>>1363138
>He was basically a projection of Odin in human form.
So when is Odin going to reincarnate? Or has he already?
>>
>>1361960
Men in particular are infatuated with Hitler, even if they don't admit it. Napoleon, Hitler, Caesar, Charlemagne, Alexander and others will always be Great.

Even Kennedy acknowledged that eventually Hitler would rise above the propaganda of his time and be recognized for more than a villain.
>>
>>1363138
>literally partitioned into two halves for over half a century as part of his legacy
Pretty that was the Soviets.

>He was basically a projection of Odin in human form
LMAO confirmed for knowing fuck all about the man. He was one of the most insecure bitchy cunts that ever became powerful.
LMAO confirmed for
>>
>>1362666
>"vile" book full of "nonsense" and "misguided" "hate"
>>
>>1362859
He's right, in a way,

Until Israel was established Arabs didn't give a shit about Jews, but after it's just gotten progressively worse
>>
>>1363041
Nobody who believes human evolution took place believes we've stopped evolving, unless they are subscribing to the belief ideologically and without actually reading a biology textbook.

Also how is it possible not to believe in science? It's just a method for answering questions. It definitely exists.
>>
>>1362097
what exactly was it in hitler that wasn't pretty normal for the period?
>>
>>1362253
what does that have to do with anything?
>>
>>1362398
Most powerful man in the world? How did that war turn out, anyway?
>>
>>1363956
>because he lost means he wasn't the most powerful man in the world for a few years
based retard
>>
>>1363956
beaten the crap out by mob of almost-but-not-quite-as-powerful men?
>>
>>1362542
Hitlers biggest legacy is how he set back facism or indeed destroyed it being a major political stance for a very long time (note i said not FOREVER, as i precdict some future nation will adopt its princibles, like every other form of governance that we know, out of nessesity if nothing else!)
>>
>>1362117
Several of my Mexican coworkers while I was in the army would have "Fuhrer Fridays" where they would watch Hitler documentaries, as they would frequently state "that nigga was a real G, he got on stage and got everyone wantin to fight".

As a white nationalist, that was rather surreal.
>>
>>1362821
didnt he get the iron cross in WW1 from a jewish officer? Im sure his hatred for them wasnt fully realised by then but do you think that niggled in the back of his mind everytime he wore it? or shameless glory hunting?
>>
>>1362853
Im still in that midset but because im a hopeless optomist i suppose.
>>
Hitler did nothing except cause the downfall of Germany with his shitty economic policies and bad war strategies.
>>
>>1361960
Muslims will takeover the world, so sadly he will be loved.
>>
>>1363996
Memory escapes me on that, anon.

Regardless, as far as Hitler being a glory hunter, I would say it's more complex than that.

He was a strange man in that he was perfectly content, even in a weird way happy being in the misreable conditions of WW1.

An Iron Cross certainly helped his ego, especially being a Corporal at the time, but it was also part of his sense of pride in wanting to be a good soldier.

All the way up to him becoming Chancellor, glory doesn't adequately encapsulate his drive. He saw himself as a man of destiny.
>>
>>1361960

Eh. Eventually in a thousand years no one will care because worse people did worse things.
>>
>>1362495
Literally only the English did that because the English were a bunch of butthurt faggots who only fought Napoleon once in pitched battle when he was way past his prime, almost lost, and then pretended like they won the whole war.

Fuck those assholes.
>>
>>1362542
>le Trotsky invented racism meme

Kill yourself.
>>
>>1362763
As an asshole because starting an aggressive war because muh danzig is still retarded and bad.
>>
>>1362894
The closest France ever came to democracy was the violent mob rule during a brief period c.1792-93. The Directory was a joke oligarchy. Napoleon didn't quash popular rule, he just cleaned up an autocracy that had existed under various names for the past ten years.
>>
>>1363138
>Europe was literally partitioned into two halves for over half a century as part of his legacy. Even back then people knew how important Hitler was.

Yes you're right. Hitler was one of the most important people of the last several centuries, without a doubt.

>He was basically a projection of Odin in human form.

Get the fuck out.
>>
>>1361960
>Genghis Khan and sons decimate central Asia the most populated area in the world.
>Untold rapes and murders
>God only knows how many children staved as their fathers, uncles, and elder brothers perished fighting the hordes from the steppes and were unable to farm the land.
>Fast foward to the 21th century in a highschool
>Genghis Khan was one of histories greatest conquerors and his grandson Kublai one of the most tolerant rulers.
>Tri-gendered poly queer Gwen struggles to lift her 450 pound 4 by 4 frame out of her state provided bean bag chair.
>Kublai was a saint and the complete opposite of Hitler and I now add Mongol to identity.
>Fast forward to 31st century
>Robotstien stands up in class
>Hitler was a political genius who saved the German nation and was misled into massacring 6 gorillion Jews but that oversight is of little importance when faced with his successes.
>>
>>1364137
Ah here is my source on my claim

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Gutmann

I think my use of the word 'glory hunter' was a tad misused but im sure that yes it did bolster his view of his independant fate and beliving he was destined for greatness.

In alot of ways though that would be correct thought oddly enough, he may not be remembered fondly but he is now recorded in history as one of the most memorable characters.

I think that Adolf Hitler the soldier was a very compitent soldier however and deserving of his Iron cross. In fact it was his war time laurals that legetimised alot of his initial following, used effectivly thoughout his political assention.
>>
>>1364212
That's the thing about Hitler- his infamy is the reason he's so famous.

If he was just a mediocre chancellor like Hinderburg he'd be forgotten, but due to his acts his name will live on forever
>>
nice guys finish last. goes for history too i guess, except 'last' is 'forgotten'.
>>
File: well liberated.png (453 KB, 803x688) Image search: [Google]
well liberated.png
453 KB, 803x688
>>1362543
>Stalin

>"even worse atrocities"

wew lad
>>
>>1361960
I could see him appearing in video games and such without controversy in the future. Maybe in the world he will become less villainized but certainly not in the West. Schools will tell his tale for years and years to come.
>>
>>1362982
Kek
>>
File: 1425016868064.jpg (94 KB, 580x700) Image search: [Google]
1425016868064.jpg
94 KB, 580x700
>>1361960
lel no
napoleon did commit genocide (haiti) but this was a minor thing due to everything he did - probably the best general in the history of warfare nearly "won" europe despite never wanting to fight any european country in first place.

hitler on the other hand, was just a very resentful person filled with hatred and an average strategist who simply fueled his rise to power by exploting the simpletons' hate and fear and the natural german urges to kill, rape, be suicidal and try to destroy europe...

so in the end, hitler created nothing and destroyed everything - while napoleon was the exact opposite but was eventually destroyed by eteral anglo and their shillwars
>>
File: anti-semitic jew.jpg (19 KB, 203x300) Image search: [Google]
anti-semitic jew.jpg
19 KB, 203x300
>>1362666
>still ejoyed some home support.

fuck off, satan
stalin is a hero revered by millions in russia and all satellite countries around russia
which is pretty ironic since he probably killed most of their parents directly or indirectly

and didn't know what to think when i saw people in ukraine praising them as a hero and licking putin's ball when stalin and the ussr did genocide those fucks with famines just for a laugh

people are so fucking stupid that it's no longer funny
>>
>>1362079
>Nah give it fifty more years and his birthday will be a national holiday in Germany and Austria.
t. /pol/ack
>>
>>1364513
The humor of that pic is lost when you learn that the Nazis a scant stance on black people. Sure, they still were racist as typical of the 30's-40's, but extremely mild compared to their disdain for the jews.
>>
>>1364259
holodomor
>>
File: ultimate teabagging.jpg (64 KB, 900x437) Image search: [Google]
ultimate teabagging.jpg
64 KB, 900x437
>>1364532
the nazis focused most of their attention on the jews because there were millions of them in german soil unlike negros, gypsies, homosexuals, etc
but you certainly say he didn't hate them all because he did; the thing with jews has just a bit more personal since he had been cockblocked by jews since most of his life and marked them as the main problem why german was so shit at everything including winning wars.

just like today's neonazis where all his failures as individuals are to blame on others
>>
>>1361985
He started the single largest conflict in human history, left Europe divided for half a century, genocided millions, and put one of the last nails in the coffin of colonialism.
>>
He'll be remembered for muh science just like Genghis is remembered for protection of the Silk Road and Alexander for spread of Hellenic culture.
>>
>>1362003
Communism is still a thing so i wouldn't be so sure about that.
>>
>>1362167
The "Terrible" appellative is prior to his madness though
>>
File: photo-savitri devi.jpg (88 KB, 663x500) Image search: [Google]
photo-savitri devi.jpg
88 KB, 663x500
He will be seen as the hero he truly was
>>
File: 1460854848958.png (744 KB, 2400x800) Image search: [Google]
1460854848958.png
744 KB, 2400x800
ah
delicious ideology
Thread replies: 242
Thread images: 52

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.