[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Tell me about the Polish-Soviet war, /his/. How did the Poles do it?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 73
Thread images: 7
File: polish cavalry skirmish.jpg (119 KB, 800x551) Image search: [Google]
polish cavalry skirmish.jpg
119 KB, 800x551
Tell me about the Polish-Soviet war, /his/.

How did the Poles do it?
>>
>>1075001
The same way poles win all wars
We're men and we're willing to die for our country
>>
>>1075001
Breaking the Soviet codes. That played a huge part in winning the war.

And the Poles were fighting for their nationhood after centuries of foreign domination, they were totally united and hellbent on thwarting the Soviets.
>>
>>1075189
>poles win all wars
Daily reminder, the war was primarily about control of Ukraine and Belorus which Russia won
>>
>>1075001
It was a cavalry victory before tanks were in heavy use by either the soviets or the poles. Like all calvary victories, soviets got outflanked. Part of that was code-breaking like the person above mentioned, but another big part was knowing the local terrain and the soviets being very far from their supply lines (also, for at least part of it, the Russians were hoping to break even deeper into Europe and so when they were frustrated from bringing communism to Paris, they sort of decided to consolidate within modern soviet borders).
>>
>>1075189
worked out in WW2
>>
>>1075001
The Poles at the time had a distinct advantage in cryptography, cavalry quality, and obviously the defensive advantage.

Also God.
>>
File: Friedrich_Zweite_Alt.jpg (616 KB, 1048x1321) Image search: [Google]
Friedrich_Zweite_Alt.jpg
616 KB, 1048x1321
>>1075656
pic related, you

2 milion army vs 900k of Poles attacked from every fucking front.
germans kill the captives
burn vilagges
kill women and children
genocide elites

hur dur da polez lost XDDDD
>>
File: Polish-Russian relations.png (4 MB, 2318x2995) Image search: [Google]
Polish-Russian relations.png
4 MB, 2318x2995
>>1075001
For the first time in 200 years, we weren't outnumbered and outniggered by germans, russians and other scum.

That's how we did it.
>>
>>1075189
>>1077436

Hello /int/.
>>
>>1075656
Ended up with Poles on a German territory pushing from both sides.
>>
File: 1430600854685.jpg (2 MB, 4739x1074) Image search: [Google]
1430600854685.jpg
2 MB, 4739x1074
>>1077436
great post, pic saved
also pic related further proof that we won most of wars or battles while being outnumbered
>>1075219
>that damage control
it was about spreading communism to the western Europe, commies were pretty big in Germany or France already, imagine if they had some brotherly help from red army.
>>
>>1075001
It's a badass war. Shame people chose to ignore it. And we got some great allies. De Gaulle fought in it and the director of King Kong as well as General de Wiart (only British ally in Polish history) who got busy shooting kossaks from a machine gun while riding on a train.
>>
>>1077491
>Weygand travelled to Warsaw expecting to assume command of the Polish army, yet those expectations were quickly dashed. He had no good reply for Józef Piłsudski, who on 24 July during their first meeting asked "How many divisions do you bring?" Weygand had none to offer
great allies indeed XD
>>
>>1077521
Foch had Polish ancestry and he provided some support. I think.
Better than Brits. Lloyd George openly hated Poles and he was ready to doom the whole Europe to bolshevism to fuck them up.
>>
>>1075001
It's honestly underrated, just like most of the Eastern and Polish/Czech history.

Norman Davies wrote the book, "Red star, white eagle" It's about that event, I recommend it.

But then again who has time for Poland when all the board awes about Prussia and genocidal Nazi machine?
>>
>>1077533
>Lloyd George
He was a big admirer of the Communism.
He indeed wanted to make a pact and sell the whole Eastern Europe already in 1920.
>>
>Poland

The only thing i know about this country is The Witcher game series
>>
>>1080159
don't read about anything else it's piece of shit that didn't contribute anything to humanity ever. They can only steal from Germans - first it was their rightful lands, now - cars.
>>
>>1080182
American go to bed.
>>
>>1075001
As much as I despise Polish overblown ego (that's coming from a "Pole" in Siberia), they did save Europe from communism. Trotsky-stile communism, with literal enslavement of peoples to literally Jewish overlords.
Hungarians tried hard to unite with Soviet forces in Poland and them help Jews in Germany.
If Germany, Soviet Russia and all of Eastern Europe between melded into apocalyptic USSR bent on world conquest, Eurasia would already be Greater Israel.

So Poles did good, even when everything east of Warsaw was already lost and everyone foreign already packed their bags to Poznan expecting Soviets to brutalize the place shortly.
Poles broke Soviet Russia attempt to get to Soviet Hungary, this broke Trotsky dream of world conquest lead by Jew overlords over Russian-German armies and practically doomed communism, if many decades later.

>>1080095
Prussia is Polish Germanic-boo joke that went too far.
If you think of it, Austria is Germanized Karintia ("Slovenia") while Prussia are Germanized Balts and Poles. So Germanic-boo Slavs and Balts practically created German empire out of nothing.
>>
>>1077481
>it was about spreading communism to the western Europe
Daily reminder: Pulowski had already invader Ukraine twice before the soviet invasion,he stopped claiming polish sovereignty to the dneiper after that.
>>
>>1080209
>Prussia is Germanized Poles

More like Poland stole Prussian land from the German people, you revisionist polack.
>>
>>1080313
>Poland stole Prussian land from the German people
More like Germans stole Prussian land from Baltic people.

Prussia was created by Kingdom of Poland.
>>
>>1080209
>and them help Jews in Germany.
that's interesting because "Jews in Germany" were viciously anti-bolshevik.
>>
>>1080385
m8 i don't agree with the other guy but nearly all of the commie leaders in germany were jews, it's an undeniable fact
>>
>>1075189
>>1077413
>>1077436
>>1077481
super autyzm koledzy, na chuj od razu z tym wyskakiwać
>>
>>1080399
Bo ludzie siedzący tutaj gówno wiedzą o historii, a wypisują tylko durne memy o "muh Prusy", "muh Danzig", "muh Posen". etc etc.

Czysty debilizm.
>>
>>1080425
nie zaprzeczam, po prostu nie rozumiem po co z tym zaczynać zanim ktokolwiek cokolwiek o tym powiedział
>>
>>1080396
They were jews and they were in Russia for a while, didn't liked the happy things Lenin was doing there.
>>
File: 1458579090243.jpg (79 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
1458579090243.jpg
79 KB, 800x600
Ugly language, bad cuisine, very shitty people, terrible politicians, boring countryside and shitty culture, hideous cities, shitty music and cinema, pathetic army, neo-colonial economy with almost non-existant native industry and the list goes on.

Poland is literally the shitbucket of europe
Its as big as germany with half the population and nothing impressive ever came out of it
Never won a war or start an empire
Sucks ball at sports of any kind
Implied huge jewish population but sucks shit at finance and economics
Hitler literally see the poles as subhumans and wants polish clay so he can populate the aryans from germany in it.
Any average person will only know poland as "that country that was annihilated by the germans in the WWII".
Most are surprised it still exist.
Most people cant even find poland on the map and consistently mistook poland for either hungary or austria.
Its a country that is consistently bullied by countries around it and have absolutely no power to fight back due to its absolute low morale within its army and people.
Poland is so uninteresting and dull that nobody, even the arabs or the indians(well known for their immigration to western countries) wants to live there
Poland was supposed to be extinct and the amazement of it continuing its pathetic life like a dying rat is what makes poland literally the shithole of europe.

So fucking useless and incompetent you mistook it as a 3rd world country.
>>
>>1080527
Here's your (you)
>>
>>1077436
I love this post, it even has haploshit in it.
>>
Poles are one of the worst shitposters and retards on top of that.
>>
>>1080680
>>1080527
fuck off back to /int/ you stupid shitters
>>
>>1080689
This.

/int/ and /pol/ out
>>
>>1080694
/pol/ can go, but /int/ are bros
>>
>>1075219
Way to cherry pick his statement and completely remove its context and meaning, so that for a moment you may shed a small fact to elevate yourself in this thread.
>>
>>1080527

Fuck off with your low quality shitposting.
>>
>>1075219
Vietnam war was primarily about stopping the spread of communism to Peru through Vietnam, Philippines and Pacific Isles therefore US won.
>>
>>1075656
Considering Germany lost territory to Poland, yeah it kinda did
>>
>>1081407
yeah, WW2 was totally worth it for Poland
>>
>>1080527
Jesus fucking Christ the autism it must have taken to write all that
>>
>>1077481
>all that Polish - Lithuanian victories
Doesn't that mean that there were shitload of Lithuanians and Ruthenians as well?
>>
>>1081407
>>1081433
WW2 was a disaster that could have been prevented.

Poland and Germany had good relations during Hitler's reign. France and UK wanted the war, so stupid polish politicians fell for it.
>>1081488
And?
>>
>>1081548
>France and UK wanted the war
>>>>>>>
>>
>
>

>>>>>>
>>
>>1081563
They wanted Third Reich and Soviets to bleed out on each other.
Poland was just used to push the war quicker.

Also, the main goal of Hitler was to eliminate and humiliate France, not kill Poles or Russians for lebensraum. This happened because Polish politicians made retarded decisions, since 1930 to 1936 Germany and Poland had very good relations.

Poles even had their own parts in Gdańsk(Danzig).
>>
>>1080837
fuck off /int/
>>
>>1081700
>Poles even had their own parts in Gdańsk(Danzig).
wow, Poles had their own parts in a Polish city, truly the germans are the most generous and friendly of people
>>
>>1075001
Read "Red Star, White Eagle".

We owe the Poles a debt of gratitude for stopping the Bolshevik hordes before they reached the rest of Europe.
>>
>>1080837
/int/ pls go

>my country can beat up your country
>muh haploshit
>muh HDI
>muh women

Literally nothing but shitposting
>>
>>1081715
>Polish city,
85% of citizens there were fucking German, you spastic assburger.
>>
>>1081719
/int/ is /pol/lite but with 10x better bants and shitposting
>>
>>1081723
We don't want bantz and shitposting on /his/
>>
>>1081722
so in 10 years you'll be praising turkey for letting germans have their own parts in berlin?
>>
>>1081728
>goes to 4chan
>I don't want bantz and shitposting

You might be in the wrong place son
>>
>>1081739
you already have 2 boards for your country shitposting, stick to them
>>
>>1081752
t.Alberto Barbossa
>>
>>1081752
This.

>>1081761
You can do this shit all day on /int/, /pol/ and /sp/. Stop trying to destroy another board.
>>
>>1081784
Don't forget /k/. We do that there too.
>>
File: Western Slavic Lands.png (337 KB, 723x599) Image search: [Google]
Western Slavic Lands.png
337 KB, 723x599
>>1080313
>More like Poland stole Prussian land from the German people
>>
File: typical kraut.jpg (13 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
typical kraut.jpg
13 KB, 480x360
>>1081700
>Also, the main goal of Hitler was to eliminate and humiliate France, not kill Poles or Russians for lebensraum.
>>
>>1081902
After 4 years of Polish-German cooperations, polish politicians that had internal struggle for power, forced their stupid internal politics out and Beck refused to work with Hitler.

That sygnalized Germany that Poles wanted war. I'm not all about genocide of the Polish elites, kidnapping of children and razing cities. But they made a stupid fucking decision. France and UK would never help them out, in fact, they bombed Poland with fucking brochures.
>>1081735
What the hell are you talking about?

Gdansk (Danzig) was German in that time. Historical bullshit doesn't matter if you have majority in that town.
>>
Until Stalin and Tukhachevsky fucked up on the vistula the soviets seemed as though they were going to win the war.
For a moment the poles had two eyes in what had been a losing fight between a blind man and a one eyed man, as a result of their interception of soviet communications prior to the attack. From there, it was only natural for the precariously organized red army to simply fall apart.
>>
>>1081935
yep, that's why they forced Poles out of their homes to replace them with ethnic Germans, burned Polish books, banned teaching in Polish and attempted to kill off all Polish intellectuals in order to destroy Polish culture completely
>>
>>1082047
That's what you get when you make stupid decisions that are out of your fucking reach.

Do you really think Poles stood any chance against German army and German economy? No, resistance was huge, I give you that, but in the long term, Poland would be obliterated anyway.

It wasn't about Danzig, it was about stupid decisions.
>>
>>1082062
Ps. Especially considering that Poland didn't even had fully mobilised forces and did it in the time of getting invaded (LOL)

But then of course, the great Polish mindset of EMPIRE. "IF WE CAN'T HAVE ALL, WE WON'T HAVE ANYTHING" - another kek.
Polish offered corridor to Eastern Prussia in 1920. Germany refused.

1920-1938 German and Polish relations are far more complex than we're taught. It wasn't all about killing each other and genocide. It was a big partnership untill stupid decisions came to play.

Did you know that Lithuania was a military protectorate of Poland?

Did you know that Slovakia could be Polish-German condominium if Beck didn't pussy out because he listened to western """""allies""" ?
>>
>>1082094
Another stupid decisions and mistakes which costed Poland something more than just stolen provinces, was Army not getting any sensible fucking commands from the gov.

"JUST MARCH FAGGOTS" "Who cares that you will die outnumbered and outgunned" Who the fuck rules over his country like that and then you wonder why despite huge inteligence, great working ethics, long history almost ancient like and honour - Poland manages to stay a shithole.

Because you put stupid fucking people in charge. That's like sheep leading lions.

Anyway, that's all from me.

t. German Polishboo
>>
>>1082062
>>1082094
>>1082105
I approve of this message

t. second generation Polish migrant in Norway
>>
>>1075001
It was important for Europe despite the memsters.
>>
>>1080527
Nice copy makaron, here's your (ty)
>>
>>1082105
Nice input, dude
>>
>be Poland
>work with perfidious albion&co
>get fucked

>be Poland
>work with Hitler
>get fucked

such is life for the Christ of nations
Thread replies: 73
Thread images: 7

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.