Who would win in a fight?
>>82462486
Peter always defeats himself.
Me.
Me
>>82462486
Me on the left
door
>Yfw Marvel could make a Spider-Men movie and bring them all together
>>82462486
Didn't Toby get way more buff?
Maybe he's too weak from his vegan bullshit.
Toby seems stronger but Andrew seems faster
Memes.
>>82462784
this
>>82462580
>>82462609
>>82462635
Literally?
>>82462486
>John Romita, Sr. Vs JMS
>>82462657
/thread
Really interesting, we see Raimi doing things that take a lot of power, so I think he's the strongest, but Andrew seems faster more spidey way of fighting and from I can get, he has this huge tolerance to pain( he got so wrecked against Electro) but still managed to keep going. Which makes this fight prett hard
Now Andrew and Holland you know they seen pretty even at the strenght but Joe Russo is such a spideyfag that in an interview he said that Spidey is weaker than the Hulk but by a minimal margin, so who knows what the potencial of Holland but Andrew, like I said before, he has this huge stamina and tolerance so if they fight it might be like a Cap vs Batman scenario when at the end Cap wins because stamina
Peter Maguire seemed to endure fights that were waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more brutal than what Peter Garfield had to go through. Also, his displays of strength were incredible, and didn't seem to lack much speed, although Garfield was maybe a bit faster.
I'd go with Maguire all the way.
Tobey because Garfield is a pussy AND Tobey doesn't have to worry about webshooters.
>>82462486
Wasn't it revealed in the Sony hacks that they wanted to make a Spider-man vs The Amazing Spider-man movie?
>>82462486
Tobey because Garfield is a huge pussy
>>82465319
I hope not. There's no way they would have been able to pull that without it being retarded
>yes, I know what Spiderverse is
Also, there's no way it's going to happen with the current state of things.
The only way I see either of those two reprising their Spiderman role is making Tobey Maguire old Peter Parker in a Spidergirl movie. He'd need some aging, sure, but:
>just
>let
>that
>idea
>sink
>in
>>82462486
>>82465224
Except when he somehow manages to run out of web even when he has organic webshooters, right?
The one with the hottest Aunt May
>>82465319
>>82465362
I wouldn't be opposed to a Phase 5 "Spider-Men" film that involves Maguire, Garfield and Holland teaming up. Holland's Peter is still completely green and unsure about what the future holds and is constantly awe-struck by his older selves and showing off to them, Garfield is in the full swing of things as Spider-Man but depressed after the events of ASM2, and Maguire is a wizened punished Parker who's had some serious shit happen to him in-between Spider-man 3 and Spider-Men. Holland's arc is about realizing the full impact of what being Spider-Man could mean for his life and accepting that, Garfield's is about fearing the future and moving on from the past (he gets over Gwen's death at the end of the movie and returns to his world to see if he can find his world's Mary Jane) and Maguire's arc is about refinding the spark that made him love being Spider-Man and going back to fix his life that fell apart.
They all get sucked into Holland's MCU verse for the length of the storyline, no idea who the best villain for them would be. Maguire's Peter keeps hinting at the other two about a lot of 616 Spider-Man storylines, implying versions of those events have played out for him such as the Clone Saga and Superior Spider-Man.
The ultimate point of the film is to pass the torch on to Holland, and give a full sense of closure to the Maguire and Garfield worlds and foreshadow some of the comic storylines and arcs that Holland's films will be adapting.
Keep the tone light, and lay down the fan service, and it'd be spectacular.
>>82465224
>implying his glands wouldn'r dry out at some point
you can't sweat forever, you can't cry forever, your nose can't run forever, organic webbing can fail just like the mechanical one
stop this meme that organic is better
I'm voting Andrew bc he's more handsomeyes homo
>>82466094
>you can't cry forever
i can tell you firsthand that you can, anon ;_;
Toby is the fucking worst.
Gwen > MJ, too.
>>82465538
Funny how MaY gets younger for each generation.
Then again, Ben must've had a good 30 years on his little brother originally.
Like it or not the organic webbing is a huge advantage
Peter is a smart guy. He'll figure out pretty quick that Garfield's shooters are mechanisms and he'll either try and make him run out, break them, web them shut or short them out somehow.
>>82466274
>Peter is a smart guy
for you
>>82466191
I will never understand why they haven't taken the multiple opportunities to retcon 616 May into one of her younger versions. They even passed up doing it with Secret Wars.
>>82466307
That's a movie synergy I wouldn't actually mind. Seeing how the Ultimate May is a much better character than the 616 May.
>>82466307
Well, in a certain way they do try to make her feel younger, making her marry, get more "hip" haircuts and shit
>>82466307
It's honestly always bugged me that Pete's aunt and uncle were so old. Why weren't they nearer his parents age, or instead of that his grandparents?
>>82462784
and Toby makes his own web. Andrew would run out before coming close to taking out Toby.
>>82465940
This is actually pretty good, holy fuck.
I'd scream like a little girl if they made it.
I wonder, would they change Punished Pete's uniform?
![500px-Amazing_Spider-Man_Vol_1_637_page_28_Peter_Parker_(Earth-TRN151)[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/w4JLxSs.jpg "500px-Amazing_Spider-Man_Vol_1_637_page_28_Peter_Parker_(Earth-TRN151)[1].jpg")
>>82465940
Tobey wearing that future outfit would be goat. I need to see this now.
How do you think Garfield feels about having such a short track record as Spidey before a new Spidey is brought in?
Tobey man couldn't even deliver pizzas on time while spiderfield has daddy issues.
I'm calling this one a tie
>>82467034
It's a one movie difference.
>>82467034
I don't think anybody blames Garfield, and he knows it
It all comes down to the screenwriters, director and SONY being very unflexible, and he critizised them in public for it
>>82462486
>Tobey's kill count: 3 villains and one best friend
>Andrew's kill count: one gf
You tell me.
>>82462657
too soon
>>82467034
I don't think he gives a shit. He got two movies under his belt and a lot of exposure.
>>82462486
Tobey's Spiderman was a powerhouse. He wins. No contest
>>82467336
seen him in any major roles lately?
he was Hollywoods boy toy at the time.
you bet your ass he gives a shit: it may have ruined his career
>>82467034
He took Ema Stone for himself, so, I doubt he has any regrets. I bet some of the scenes in Amazing Spider-man 2 weren't even scripted, it was just Ema and Andrew.
>>82467319
Electro
>>82465538
>not posting the best "aunt" may
>>82467416
Did he died? I actually forgot he was at the end of the movie. I wish I could forget he happened at all.
>>82467374
Maguire's career didn't exactly take off after Spider-man.
>>82467426
Supposedly. Do batteries "die" when they explode? That's how Peter and Gwen pictured their plan
>>82467431
>Spiderman 3's reception
my point stays. Become big in Hollywood, get cast in a bad written movie, and then crumble down
It has happened countless times
>>82467034
he's mentioned he's bummed but understands
I'd love to see him return in some capacity
>>82462486
>thinking this is even a question
Tobey beefed up for real and isn't the sissy faggot that wanted a boyfriend.
Anyone that wants the other guy is a flaming faggot.
>>82467391
Then he got fired as Spider-Man and she dumped him
Why even live.
Garfield's Spiderman is smarter
>>82466383
Elderly aunts and uncles were more common in 1962 when Spider-Man was created. It was common for families to have six or more children meaning there could be a large age gap between the oldest and youngest siblings.
>>82462486
Get rekt longneck
Toby, he stopped a train. I can't think of anything Andrew did that even comes close.
>>82467544
>having to look at youtube vids to know how batteries function
>taking off his mask every 5 mins just because
>leaving his photocamera with his name on it
>finding about his father's secret because the plot demanded him to angrily smash a calculator
>using bing
>sistematically hunting down blonde criminals on the off chance to find his uncle's killer
>smarter
he did build a cool bluetooth lock for his room, I give you that
>>82465940
That's amazing. Too bad the hacks who make these movies would never do anything this creative
>>82467712
>using bing
that part killed me in the movie
>>82467712
>using bing
>>82467712
>sistematically
>>82467907
yeah that too
>get rekt, Garfield
>Spiderfield
>having shit against Spiderguire
>>82468025
>>82467973
I forgot how based those fight scenes were. I gotta re-watch SM2.5 now.
Also, landlord daughter is best waifu in any cape film.
>>82468467
and I couldn't upload the best gif cuz filesize
the beating Doc and Spidey gave each other is boner-worty
>>82468467
also, what is that 2.5 thing?
is there a director's cut or smth?
>>82462486
Which Spider-Man? Garfield's version. He's shown to be way more agile, stronger, and creative in his fights, not to mention he actually cracks wise the way Spider-Man is supposed to.
Damnit I loved Amazing Spider-Man 2. I wanted that series to continue.
Fuck.
>>82467973
>>82468025
Maguire Spidey is really a brawler. He knows how to use his agility and strength well. He'd beat the shit out of Andrew if he got his hands on him.
Andrew relied mostly on his webs and using other objects.
>>82468586
yeah, there was a cut released with extra footage, like a slight extension to the train fight scene and all that.
>>82468665
I'm sorry, but I don't ever really see his super-strength or quick reflexes on display in the Maguire Spider-Man movies.
Whereas in Amazing, Garfield's Spider-Man is all over the place, constantly leaping around and on the move, taking full advantage of his agility.
Plus there's that scene in Amazing-2 where he saves a half-dozen people from Electro, with only one functional webshooter at the time, *and* catches a police car like it's no big thing.
Sorry, but no. Amazing Spider-Man just comes across as better than Maguire Spider Man.
Hence the title.
Add in the fact that he actually wisecracks like he's supposed to, and a far better score, and yeah. I just massively prefer Amazing and Amazing-2 to any of the Maguire movies. Spider-Man 2 was pretty good but mostly because of Mr. Doc Ock Freeze, not Spider-Man.
>>82468645
>>82468791
>>82467672
It's mush harder to stop a train then catch a car.
>>82468791
How will making wisecracks help him fight Maguire man? Considering their fighting experience, Maguire is far better at it. Which villain did Andrew defeat completely without help? None. Lizard and Electro fucking manhandled him.
>>82468893
i think he might be meme-ing you. that's way too much shill to be taken seriously.
are we going to have in our lifetime a movie like the Spiderman Shattered Dimensions with all the actors that impersonated Spidey?
it will be cool
>>82468868
Oh, yeah, forgot the train. Then again, like I said, Garfield Spider-Man caught a police car like it was nothing; the hardest part seemed to be holding it right so that it wouldn't break due to its own weight.
Still prefer the fights Garfield did.
>>82468893
Electro's essentially a god, so I don't see why Garfied not being able to beat him really matters. It's not like Maguire was able to actually defeat Sandman, after all.
>How will making wisecracks help him fight Maguire man
The audience will like him more because he's actually acting like Spider-Man. Never underestimate the power of plot armor, sempai.
>>82468645
>>82468837
>liking that fucking trainwreck
>wanting it to go on after ASM2
>actually believing Garfield is stronger or faster
>implying Garfield would win the fight
>>82464290
It's so nice knowing spiderfags are in charge of spidey now. Maybe it's the beginning of the end for our suffering
>>82469028
>liking that fucking trainwreck
Maguire fans don't get to talk about trainwrecks. Pic related.
>wanting it to go on after ASM2
Fuck yeah I want it to go on. The next movie was Sinister Six, man. I wanted my supervillain Ocean's 11.
>actually believing Garfield is stronger or faster
Stronger, maybe or maybe not; faster, definitely. Look at his fights with Lizard or Goblin as compared to any of Maguire's fights.
>>82469100
Did you watch them? Gar is not much faster if at all than Mag's fights with NuGobby and Ock.
>>82465940
Well guess I'm adding this to the list of things that I want to happen but probably won't
>>82469146
He certainly seems faster, and far more agile.
Spider-Man VS Ock: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lt56jutf1vk
Spider-Man VS Lizard: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10fno5Qpm7w
>>82466307
Well at this point it makes sense for her to be old considering peter is in his late 20's early 30's, I imagine if they did a younger Peter story she would be retconned as younger. Which brings up the question is she younger in the spidey book?
>>82469262
Basically Maguire Spider-Man seems more like a straight-up brawler. His goal is to get in close and just punch like a boxer or something. Effective, but crude.
Whereas Garfield Spider-Man moves like, well, a spider. He hops around, uses his webs to trip you up, etc. He's got the same raw strength but on top of that is better at avoiding blows and getting the opponents to trip up over themselves.
Side note, how the Hell could Ock in those fights even go as many rounds with Spidey as he did? Once you get past the arms he's just a normal human. One punch should have knocked him out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmtxiQCl6rg
This fight makes me web allover the place
also
>implying Garfield could stop a train
>>82465131
>Also, his displays of strength were incredible
Like when he was hitting chubby scientist in the face with barely any damage?
>>82469428
Peter holds back ALOT
>>82469264
yeah, he's in HS there but it's not clear whether it's 616 or not
>>82469471
Is aunt may younger in the book? I read the first issue and it wasn't 616 (even if marvel says it is)
no,
more like when he had to hold back to not crush Doc Ock
or when Norman had to stop Peter from pounding him to death
or when he stopped a fucking out-of-control train
or when he held a who-knows-how-many-fucking-metric-tons wall and threw it away
Maguire would THRASH Garfield if they were out for blood
>>82469471
616 refers to the comic mainstream only.
>>82468645
>people actually enjoyed the Spiderman movies with that pencil necked manlet
The mood whiplashes were just atrocious in those movies
>>82469454
poor alot, will he ever break free
>>82462486
Tobey stopped a train, you fucking donkey
>>82469454
It's never stated directly that he was; and there's no reason to think that Garfield isn't holding back as well. Strength VS Strength isn't going to get us anywhere because of that, so it's better to look at the rest of their fighting qualities.
Garfied was just more agile. This is mostly due to better CGI, but in the end that still makes him more agile.
>>82469504
this nigga knows what's up
>>82469504
fucking savage!
>>82469516
There's only one mood whiplash, and given that Gwen was doomed simply by being in the films at all it's not really a mood whiplash since her death is so damned expected, especially once Goblin actually shows up.
Spider-Man vs Spider-Man? You fags will debate anything.
>>82469504
this was meant for you >>82469428
>>82469499
she looks younger that 616 may ever did, she looks pretty much like 1610 may
>>82469505
I know but we've had flashback and retcon books before so you never know
>>82469504
>>82465940
I'd totally watch this.
Problem is the Raimi suit and the TASM2 suit look too much alike at a glance, unless you cheat by giving Maguire a different suit like >>82466588, or revamping Garfield's suit again.
>>82469567
>>82469574
>>82469609
would you please stop samefagging
>>82465940
Talk about taking a sellout idea and making it viable
I'm impressed, guess you can take any shitty idea and turn it into a diamond
>>82469681
like anon had to samefag to win...
I'm >>82469567 btw
>>82465940
ir's like a revised Spidermen (Ultimate and 616 team up)
It could work
though I'd lose Mysterio as the villain. Him discovering interdimensional travelling made 0 sense
Toby Spider had way better strength feats.
>>82469793
/thread
you're my hero
>>82469262
I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, but how do you choose to compare a scene where Spidey is having doubt and losing his powers with one where Spidey is fully capable?
>>82469793
how much could that weight?
>>82469943
about 3.50 tonnes
Maguire crossed his dimension's barriers and spit in the face of the Distinguished Competence.
you can't possibly get more OP
>they totally did it on purpose, the absolute madmen
>>82467907
If he is a foreigner it makes sense to make thar typo.
Here system is sistema.
>>82468982
Tobeyman held up a collapsing building's side
Tobeyman fought Goblin, Doc Ock, Venom, Sandman, Goblin 2.0
>>82470016
How many hours did he blow on that?
>>82467907
get over it, burgerman
>>82470164
'bout a minute. not more
>>82470164
Good thing he discovered it by accident and not while shouting something and he thought to say that whenever he shot some web.
>>82470339
>implying it wouldn't be amazing if he said "up, up, and away web!" every time he shot web
>>82470514
well damn...
>>82470514
that's about 20 Gwens in that wagon...
>>82470728
>>82470728
kek
>>82462486
>Who would win in a fight?
Spiderman
>>82465940
>Keep the tone light, and lay down the fan service, and it'd be SPECTACULAR.
Can't tell if this was on purpose or not.
>>82468791
>Hence the title
And Iron-Man 2 was twice as good as Iron-Man 1, right guys?
>>82470514
can't quite remember...
what did he do to save them?
>>82469100
At least Maguire fans have spiderman 1 and 2
All the amazing series has to show for it's self is an eh origin story and a schizophrenic mess.
Even a piece of shit spiderman 3 commits to going off the rails so hard it enters so bad it's good territory.
>>82471151
*itself
>>82462486
Garfield because he does skateboard
>>82471135
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3S2PqhtCO1E
>>82471135
A random barge came along and spider-man just put the cart there.
>>82471198
>>82471222
well how fucking convenient
>>82471259
It's better than that crane bullshit.
>>82469739
With talent everything can be made a good story
Is tobys rent due?
>>82471290
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=di2Qy5erfik
This scene is so fucking KINO
>All those cranes conveniently aligned along an entire street
>The perfect coordination of this bunch of drunken workers in the middle of the night
>The chopper lighting Spidey and then indicating the course like it's a fucking show
>The exaggeratedly inspirational music
>The idea that without those cranes Spidey couldn't swing to the building without hurting himself
>The idea that with those cranes Spidey can authomatically swing without hurting himself
>That fucking cliche fakeout
>AND HE'S SAVED BY ANOTHER CRANE
WAS WEBB'S FATHER A CRANE OR WHAT
>>82471564
shut up, Raimi
>>82471900
you know he's right
>>82466411
Wouldn't Toby run out of webbing sooner or later? I mean I can't piss forever. A long piss may take up to a minute but then my bladder is empty and I'm spent.
>>82471514
Not until his landlord fixes that DAMN DOOR!
>>82468645
>liking executive melt down: we need more sequels the movie
Even if you ignore all the bad shit like rhino cameo or 5 minutes goblin and you still have peter parker wanting to leave aunt may alone to go live with his girlfriend.
>>82471564
>>82472183
it's a bit different, but as this anon said >>82466094 it's gonna happen eventually
>>82470514
But /co/ told me he wasn't supposed to have spider powers, he just took the name to be ironic.
>>82465940
I'm so glad you're not a writer and that this won't happen. Easiest way to fuck up a shared universe and make it too confusing for general audiences is to introduce new storylines, clones, or alternate universes. And this would feel like it was doing all three.
They already have passed the torch to Holland. We do not need to see Garfield again, or Toby again.
Those movies are dead
Bury them
consider this mercy
>>82466149
Gwen was so fucking hot
>>82465940
and its a musical
>>82462751
Underrated post
>>82465940
>/co/, where someone not only comes up with this terrible idea, but where several anons applaud it
>>82475100
>making a movie for the general audience should be #1 prioriteh
Putting aside all emotion and fanboyism and looking at this purely from a logical point of view, it's pretty much undeniable that the fight would quickly deteriorate into nude oil wrestling followed by passionate gay sex.
>>82475437
>"Someone made me happy once. It was terrible."
>>82475483
Just finished Midnighter and still got that fabulous gay-buzz going, huh?
>>82468791
>his super-strength
Catches a sky-car filled with people in SM1. Stops a train in SM2.
>quick reflexes
Dodges Goblin's razor boomerang things like the fucking matrix. Dodges the glider.
>actually wisecracks like he's supposed to
Tobey does wisecrack, they just aren't very funny, which is consistent with early Spider-man comics where every joke he makes is extremely lame. Other than the one scene in ASM where he stops the carjacker, Garfield doesn't make a whole lot of good jokes in the ASM series. His jokes are generally on about the same level as Maguire's: mildly amusing but mostly just dumb. It's like the studio added that one carjacker scene in to stop fans complaining and then went right back to the same approach.
>a far better score
Implying that James Horner's generic score (which I can't even remember if I try) comes anywhere close to based Danny Elfman. Unless you're referencing the laughable collaboration between Hans Zimmer and Pharrell Williams, which included cringeworthy dubstep and rappers whispering over the track.
>implying any fight scene in ASM comes close to the creativity and excitement of the train fight in SM2
Sure there are a couple great scenes in the Webb films, but they come nowhere close to the quality of Raimi's first two.
>>82467374
He's co-lead in the new Scorsese movie.
>>82467431
Tobey was never destined to be big, he always seemed happy to be Leo's second fiddle.
>>82469100
Spiderman 3 is fun as shit. ASM2 is just plain horrendous, not even fun to watch. Hell, I actually prefer Spiderman 3's goofiness over the extremely mediocre ASM1
>>82467537
shiet
>>82465940
Fuck, most of this sounds so good.
>>82469100
Spider-Man 3 is terrible, but at least its fun. ASM2 is just head-scratchingly bad. I'm not laughing at how bad it is, I'm just confused as to what I'm watching. I still have no idea what Harry's problem was.
>"Give me your blood Spider-Man!"
>"No it might kill or deform you!"
>Later injects Spider-serum. Gets deformed and nearly dies.
>Blames Spider-man for not giving him access to the serum earlier.
.....why does he hate Spider-Man for trying to save his life and being absolutely right all along?
At least Spider-Man was actually an asshole to Eddie Brock.
>>82470728
kek
>>82470728
Tobey confirmed for being 20 times more competent than Garfield
>>82476231
you're not counting the wagon itself, anon
>>82476231
I feel like he should have tried to web zip down, grab her and swing into a wall taking the brunt of the impact. Or at least made a web net
>>82470728
>>82476089
Literally everyone looks good in spandex pants
>>82470728
>>82462486
Peter.
>>82471564
CRANE?
>>82476290
That's one of my biggest problems with that scene (and the dumb web-hand), it seems like there are a hundred different solutions he should have tried first.
>>82468982
Jesus Christ, look at Spidey's fingers! They look like something out of an alien movie!
>>82476089
>>82476357
damn, she took his spandex too
>>82471564
>>82469262
Maguire Aunt May is best May.
>>82476549
How many wedding rings did she give him? How many super villains did she attack? How much advise?
>>82476583
Yeah, which is why she is so awesome.
Man, this whole thread just makes me wanna see all Spidey movies right nowwith friends I wish I had.
>>82476777
Just make up your own like I did
>>82475920
Elfman's score was top notch, man. The SM2 intro is fucking chilling.
>>82462486
Spider-Man
>>82476089
>filename not being spider-gwen
how did you fail so hard, anon?
>>82476965
literally who cares?
>>82476804
Y-yeap
>>82471564
Not gonna lie, I am getting goosebumps seeing this.
>>82465940
I'm down to see this, but as a short story in one large what if? movie. You know, kind of like creepshow
>>82465538
then Maguire would win
>>82469262
>Put your arms up!
>All of them!
Man, these movies WERE cheesy, weren't they?
>>82465940
That's so stupid. Just enjoy the comics because that makes no sense as a movie.
Toby has Bone Saw.
>>82477633
She's the best Aunt May. Why are Spider-Man 1 & 2 the best capeshit? It seems like every Marvel since Iron Man 1 has been trying to ape it.
>>82466094
Well it depends, since Tobey is fucking strong as hell he might not even have to use as much webbing to take down Garfield
>>82475100
Tell me, do you breed?You won't because pic related
