[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why do people get so mad about Harley being an anti-hero now?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 12
File: harley-quinn.jpg (142 KB, 620x928) Image search: [Google]
harley-quinn.jpg
142 KB, 620x928
Why do people get so mad about Harley being an anti-hero now?

She's just the female Deadpool but not as bad since she hasn't be invited to the Justice League and absolved by Superman
>>
File: 4363670-hipster.jpg (384 KB, 1024x1024) Image search: [Google]
4363670-hipster.jpg
384 KB, 1024x1024
>I hate Deadpool and Harley Quinn now that they're mainstream
>>
>>81242575
Her facial structure looks to much like me it's freaking me out
>>
>>81243239
Congrats on looking like every Amanda Conner girl every.

London?
>>
>>81242575
Because she is different then the Harley Quinn they knew before. That's it.
>>
she was a great foil for the joker, iv never really liked her on her own
>>
>>81242575
Are there any official Harley art that is fappable
>>
>>81242575
Because she hasn't done anything heroic at all.
Deadpool has done bad things but at least he's never killed a kid.

Harley blew up thousands of gameboy type devices while children were playing them.
Literally killed hundreds of kids.
That's not anti-hero.
That's a fucking monster who doesn't realize how terrible they are
>>
>>81242915
Jokes on you, I always hated Deadpool.
>>
>>81243499
Well there's one where she fucks a whole comic con full of Joker consplayers
>>
>>81242575
>she hasn't be invited to the Justice League and absolved by Superman
Not yet...
>>
>>81242575
>>81243681
Injustice 2
>>
>>81242575
They botched the transition. Comics shouldn't play out like sweaty man-dramas, and they definitely shouldn't play out like '90s, bottom-of-the-barrel sweaty man-dramas - and yet, that's what we're stuck with. Harley Quinn's movement from side character to anti-hero is as bad as anything Delirious or Russo could come up with.

If you put the grimy backstory of the Katie Vick angle and the body count (in dead babies) of every fed's pregnancy angles in a blender, you'd get a story that's about on par with Nu Harley's entire run from the start of the Nu52 until now.
>>
>>81242575
Original B:tAS Harley Quinn was, is, and will forever be far, far superior to every other Harley Quinn though. That's just an essential fact of the universe.
>>
>>81243634
>Harley blew up thousands of gameboy type devices while children were playing them.
Not canon.
>>
>>81243855
Why not? It was New 52,
>>
>>81243239
L O N D O N
>>
>>81243810
She was an anti hero years before new52, you cuck. Stop fabricating history to suit your needs.
>>
>>81243499
Timm drew a lot of porn of her.
>>
>>81243953
She wasn't their Deadpool before Nu52, and she wasn't a full-time anti-hero. She had stories where she'd play with the idea of doing the right thing before she snaps right back to her status quo. Not the same thing.

And don't call me a cuck you colossal horned cuckold.
>>
>>81243855
Source?
>>
>>81242575
If she was male, no one would put up with her Deadpool copycating. Cause she has tits people put up with her
>>
>>81242575
I don't know what the term is for Established Villain to hero. But I don't like them. I don't like Venom either. It leads to downplaying or rewriting who they were to make them a more likeable character. And it's rarely ever better.
>>
File: 1435936961124.jpg (145 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
1435936961124.jpg
145 KB, 1024x768
>>81243895
>>81243300
What is this meme?
>>
>>81242575
Deadpool doesn't sell date rape drugs and murder children.
>>
File: image.png (317 KB, 656x706) Image search: [Google]
image.png
317 KB, 656x706
>>81243300
>>81243895
Sorry, American master race here
>>
because there used to be a better Harley

Deadpool was always, outside of his generic origins, what he is today.
>>
>>81244902
Is your name Ms. The Joke?
>>
File: Deadpool v4 019-014.jpg (2 MB, 1920x2951) Image search: [Google]
Deadpool v4 019-014.jpg
2 MB, 1920x2951
Maybe like Deadpool they could give her three dimensions and depth. Oh wait they can't that would require killing Joker off.
>>
File: 1444182830796.gif (993 KB, 250x250) Image search: [Google]
1444182830796.gif
993 KB, 250x250
>>81245067
>>
>>81245296
Man, Deadpool really rebounded nice from Way
>>
>>81245296
Or at least separate her from the Joker while giving her worthwhile writers. Seriously the way that DC is handling Harley is not different that with what they did with her in the 2000 book, it just that the current writers shits the bed everytime
>>
>>81245296
>Oh wait they can't that would require killing Joker off.
Why? Seems to me that they could do right by her by just separating her from Joker for good. I would say that cutting down the indiscriminate murder of the innocent as punchlines without any followup would help, too, but apparently people are A-OK with that.
But yeah, separating her from Joker, that would be a big help.
>>
>>81245600
They have her separated from Joker now.
>>
>>81245666
But not good writers, that's the key. If you have a good concept but not the writer(s) capable of pull off that concept then you'll have a mess
>>
>>81245666
Well, that's a start. But how long do you think it'll last, Anon of perdition? I don't want to move the goalposts, because you are right, but I think they've got to keep them separated for a good while longer for it to stick.
>>
I'll just go ahead and say it....

She was only ever interesting as a foil to Joker. She is only interesting when in love with the Joker. It's what makes her fun and psychotic.

Now, I will be the first to admit, I hate status qou. I hated that they evolved Riddlers character and then took it away (I liked detective riddler....) so going backwards with Harley isn't something I want to see.

She is what she is now. I don't really want to scream or yell "bring back old Harley!" because that'll do nothing good.

Maybe just "be better than current Harley".
>>
>>81245987
>Well, that's a start. But how long do you think it'll last, Anon of perdition? I don't want to move the goalposts, because you are right, but I think they've got to keep them separated for a good while longer for it to stick.
Why can't she stay as "Joker's Ex?
Like, we don't have to pretend she never met him, we can make it so that she still loves him but doesn't want to be around him anymore. Not everyone you love is someone you can stand.
>>
>>81243671
Source
>>
>>81247359
San Diego Comic Con Special. It's full on trash, don't read it
>>
Everything that Harley need is the same that Deadpool needed when he was under Daniel Way, a good creative clean up
>>
>>81242575
Deadpool as an anti-hero works because he's had well-written runs that developed his character and generally made him interesting.
Harley as an anti-hero doesn't work right now because she's stuck in Waypool mode.
>>
just a female deadpool
>>
>>81247612
This x 100
>>
File: ss15-21.png (186 KB, 440x235) Image search: [Google]
ss15-21.png
186 KB, 440x235
I don't understand how Deadpool and Harley are similar other than "they make jokes" and "they wear red and black"

Like Deadpool is an asshole with a heart of gold, and Harley is... a crazy person who is supposed to not be as bad as the Joker in spite of the entire crux of her characterization being "Joker's girlfriend"?
>>
>>81252364
DC's been pushing her as a 4th wall breaking memespouter anti-hero recently.
(AKA the version of Deadpool everyone hates)
>>
File: maxresdefault (11).jpg (35 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
maxresdefault (11).jpg
35 KB, 1280x720
>>81247612
Comics Harley always seemed weird to me because... I mean making someone fall in love with the comics version of the Joker is a whole different kettle of fish than what animated Joker gets up to.

The worst thing that animated Joker ever did was that shit from the flashbacks in Return of the Joker. And he died for it. And Harley got on with her life.

Comics Joker does something as bad as that/worse in pretty much every single appearance he makes nowadays, and has more or less been on that level since the 80s, so Harley falling in love with him is less "Dumb lady with boring life falls in love with charismatic crime guy" and more "This chick is a serial killer groupie"

I dunno about you, but serial killer groupies I've known are usually not very cool
>>
>>81252549
>I dunno about you, but serial killer groupies I've known are usually not very cool
Sounds like you know some weird fucking people. I don't think I've ever known a serial killer groupie.
>>
>>81252876
There's usually two types of people who are fixated on serial killers

The kind that find them interesting and know all about them but still think they're gross and disgusting, but can't deny their intellectual curiosity

Then the ones who wanna fuck them, because they're fucked in the head on some fundamental level
>>
>>81242575

She's a literal mass-murderer who hasn't shown the least bit of remorse for her many crimes. Nor has she paid for them.

But none of the terrible shit she's done matters in the slightest because the Joker was mean to her and she's all cute and bisexual and stuff. Nobody ever calls her out on her shit. I mean, in one of her books she literally strangles an innocent woman to death in front of Batman and he doesn't help or even bat a fucking eye, and never even comments on it. What the actual fuck?
>>
Didn't she literally kill a bunch of babies with bombs.
>>
>>81242575
Deadpool would kill Harley for what she's done.
>>
File: 1443077206587.jpg (481 KB, 900x1366) Image search: [Google]
1443077206587.jpg
481 KB, 900x1366
>>81245296

What's funny is that Deadpool since his inception never really came off to me as someone who's insane. I felt that maybe is was a way to conveniently explain how he is able to do the whole 4th-wall nonsense but he ultimately feels like a guy who enjoys being a goofball. He very much is capable of being a serious individual when the circumstance call for it; and a lot of the goofy, irrational things he does in the books happens because he can afford to do it.
>>
>Hurr Durr but the exploding toys

Does ever occurr to you that maybe, just maybe, that story was written by a hack?, that that moment was totally ooc of her?. No of course not
>>
File: 1458718166490.png (367 KB, 425x474) Image search: [Google]
1458718166490.png
367 KB, 425x474
>>81242575
People aren't mad about that. They're mad that Harley is the second most popular character in the entire DC universe despite being nothing but a sex symbol. If feminazis couldn't use her as a club to beat innocent comic readers with they would demand she be removed from Skwad and Justice League entirely.
>>
>>81255317
She was never meant to be a sex symbol. She was originally just a foil for the Joker so he didn't look so bad and she could play the jokes of him
Jesus, it's like you take your headcanon as fact
>>
>>81257411
Meant
>>81257256
>>
>>81242575

The concept is whatever, but the execution is more grating than charming. Deadpool's had his own share of charmless content too, of course, but Anti-Hero Harley doesn't have any charming content.

If she got a good run, who knows, maybe opinions would turn around.
>>
>>81255317
>never really came off to me as someone who's insane.
there's only two things that come to mind
the first is The Box, and his overall fucked up relationship with Blind Al in Kelly's run
the second is when, while living on Cable's flying utopia, he murdered an ex-weapons dealer because he was bored, completely forgot about it, and then while investigating the murder unthinkingly demonstrated that he was the only person who could have done it
>>
>>81257411
>character created by Bruce 'I draw the nipples every time' Timm
>not a sex symbol
>>
>>81242575
Difference is Deadpool has been an anti hero for virtually his entire existence. And is constantly reminded and haunted by the bad things he's done. His morally questionable acts are pointed out by his supporting cast (All, German pilot girl, Preston etc).
Harley has been a full on villain for most if her existence. Time after time she'll skirt the good guys then be back with the joker killing innocents. Even if she sticks with the anti hero thing this time, she has no sign off guilt for her actions in the past. Until she takes some responsibility for her part crimes and feels guilty (wah the joker made me do it doesn't really cut it) she'll just be bomb queen with better pr.
>>
>>81242915
>now
Lol
>>
>>81257606
Like you said Harley was drawm by Timm, it doesn't mean she was a sex symbol. In fact she originally she was a one time character, to appear and dissapear in Joker's Favor episode of BTAS. She was NEVER meant to be a sex symbol
>>
>>81243300
>>81243239
overly attached girlfriend?

maniac, too open eyes, are one of her hallmarks.
Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 12

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.