[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
What went wrong?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 181
Thread images: 44
File: Total_Drama_Island.png (24 KB, 290x170) Image search: [Google]
Total_Drama_Island.png
24 KB, 290x170
What went wrong?
>>
>>80924322
Appealing to a wider audience.
When it was originally made with just North America in mind, it was allowed to have a more grounded tone. When it blew up in popularity right afterward and they wanted it to have global far-reaching appeal is when it took such a sharp drop.
>>
>>80924322
it didnt stop after season 2
>>
File: HQHP-HeatherDummy.png (474 KB, 846x635) Image search: [Google]
HQHP-HeatherDummy.png
474 KB, 846x635
>>80924322
Nothing, best girl won Season 3
>>
>>80924644
>won
>>
>>80924322
Depends what you mean by wrong since the newest season was actually just as good, if not better than TDI
>>
>>80924705
OP's pic is clearly referring to the TD series. Ridonculous Race is a spin-off, not a new season.
And RR is definitely not as good as TDI but I would agree it's much closer than the TD seasons that followed Island.
>>
This show is my guilty pleasure, which is wierd since I hate toilet humor.
>>
>They will never expose Gwen's panties again.
>>
I would play Banjo Kazooie on an emulator while TDI was playing on TV. A few summers back they did a TDI marathon that lasted all week.
Now whenever I see anything TD related, I think of Banjo Kazooie and vice versa.
>>
>>80924841
Nah, it was a huge breath of fresh air and did a lot of things well. Not a flawless season, but then again neither is TDI.
>>
>>80925298
For all the things done well, there were a lot of flaws that carried over from the shit seasons. Shitty romance subplots as major plot points and poor to little interaction between most teams.
And if this was in just the first season of RR, I'm expecting the following seasons to be even worse.
>>
>>80924841
I thought RR was WAY better than TDI. Hell, it actually made me LAUGH. It was interesting and entertaining.

Also top tier waifus.
>>
>Kitty was Emma's prom date

Need art of Kitty getting carried away with the slow dancing part and copping a feel.
>>
Shouldn't be reusing characters. Shouldn't have used so many one-gag characters in later seasons.
>>
File: Tumblr_nvxu1kUuQp1tbuk16o3_500.png (697 KB, 1334x750) Image search: [Google]
Tumblr_nvxu1kUuQp1tbuk16o3_500.png
697 KB, 1334x750
>>80925479
>>
They killed my OTP.
>>
>>80925370
I was enjoying it too, but I think overall what really kept me from putting it on TDI's level were the villains and romance subplots. I appreciate the Ice-Dancers were a parody of the Tonya Harding case, as Heather was a spoof of the typical queen bee/Mean Girls type, but I just hated their execution so much. And I really felt like the character interactions were lacking. Characters who weren't the writers' favorites just stuck to their own teammate and never interacted with anyone else at all.
>>
>>80925367
While Devin and Carrie was indeed godawful, I found quite a bit of entertainment from Noah/Emma. Meanwhile, I wouldn't exactly call Gwen/Trent or Geoff/Bridgette exciting storylines. Duncan/Courtney was alright, though.
>>
>>80925663
Didn't they get back together?
>>
>>80925670
I thought the villains were great, probably my favorite villains in the whole series, but I agree, some teams got screwed while others lasted way longer than they should've. The Daters shtick got old fast, yet they stuck around for most of the series. The Best Friends were boring, too, but at least they didn't win.

Surfers winning is bullshit too, as soon as they were brought back, they had no problems and made it to the end with barely any problems.

Still, I thought it was a fun, entertaining season.
>>
>>80925758
I will agree in the sense that I haven't found any of TD or RR's romance storyline's to be exciting or good even, I think with the exception of Owen/Izzy.
>>
>>80924841
Ridonculous Race was the best thing that happened to the TD universe. A refreshing breath of fresh air and going back to the 26 episode format helped a lot.
>>
>>80925817
Tyler/Lindsay was pretty great for a minor romance.
>>
File: Lindsay's_mad.jpg (42 KB, 636x480) Image search: [Google]
Lindsay's_mad.jpg
42 KB, 636x480
>Horrible art style. Characters are literally simply geometric shapes.
>Show transformed from an animated reality show to an average cartoon that takes place in a reality show format
>seasons have been shortened so characters and story arcs cannot be developed fully
>creators only focus on their favourites, taking the focus from more interesting characters
>muh waifu/ship didn't get as far as I wanted.
>>
>>80926026
>Show transformed from an animated reality show to an average cartoon that takes place in a reality show format
>seasons have been shortened so characters and story arcs cannot be developed fully
Ridonculous Race did at least fix those two. The most the show has actually felt like a reality show by far.
>>
>>80926026
>Show transformed from an animated reality show to an average cartoon that takes place in a reality show format

Fuck me, this is exactly what happened. I was struggling through Pahkitew Island and wondering what the fuck went so wrong compared to the early seasons, and it was this. It felt like just a shitty cartoon with a reality show going on in the background.
>>
File: GwenFaceRemodel.png (127 KB, 640x359) Image search: [Google]
GwenFaceRemodel.png
127 KB, 640x359
This bitch may have been the worse in Season 1, but she went through a lot of fucking character development
>>
The show was mismarketed by Cartoon Network. The first season was clearly skewing for a slightly older audience (like 12-17), but CN decided to just hackjob it for young kids.

Which leaves us with such confusing edits as two teenagers passionately making out in a bathroom and pixelated tits being okay, but the words 'stupid' and 'hot' being forbidden.
>>
File: Pain2.png (339 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
Pain2.png
339 KB, 640x480
>>80926177
Watch the first season and notice how the challenges are something like you'd find in a real reality show. Contrast this to later seasons where the challenges are over the top and ridiculous.
>>
>>80926523
That's one of the things I liked in RR. The challenges became much less over the top (but still retained a cartoon reality show spoof vibe).
>>
File: vlcsnap-2010-09-19-01h21m45s176.png (447 KB, 720x540) Image search: [Google]
vlcsnap-2010-09-19-01h21m45s176.png
447 KB, 720x540
So, who is best girl and why is it Beth?
>>
File: 1412567845538.png (205 KB, 301x957) Image search: [Google]
1412567845538.png
205 KB, 301x957
>>80926904
Sierra.
>>
>>80926904
Is RR counts, MacArthur
>>
File: aimimg_4f.png (530 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
aimimg_4f.png
530 KB, 1280x720
>>80929175
It does, and good taste.
>>
>>80926210
This. She is my favorite character because of how she got nicer. Now she is not a total bitch, but very determined.
>>
>>80924322
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ds3rfAU_5sM
>>
>>80924322
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLYPyXGRB_U
>>
>>80924322
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z60miLweF8Q
>>
>>80924322
I would really love to see Sky and the rest of the Pahkitew Island cast but mainly her as ABDLs.
>>
>>80929480
I could do without seeing a character as dull as her again
>>
>>80929348
>>80929374
>>80929401
what is this?
>>
>>80925796

The only good thing about the Surfers winning is that no fucking body expected it. We all thought the Sisters were going to he top 2.

I do like surprise endings, I also expected Cody to be top 2 in WT. And AS has the most predictable winners ever.
>>
>>80929667
In Real Life. It's similar to The Amazing Race. Like the Total Drama franchise, it was also produced in Canada. Total Drama should parody this show as a follow-up to The Ridonculous Race.
>>
Someone brought up something interesting in a past thread.
Would a future TD benefits from being aimed to more mature audiences? And be streamed in day, [as]?

In one hand, the F-bomb Lindsay dropped on Heather after she lost is still one of my favourite moments in the series. TDI also had the more 'adult' humour with all the double entendre and pixilated nakedness.
While also having the most childish one with fat/fart jokes from Owen.

On the other hand, RR really toned both down, but it was still funny, maybe even funnier than previous seasons.
>>
>>80929246
McArthur's my favorite but I really love her relationship with her partner as well. I wouldn't mind them coming back.
>>
>>80929851
Anything can benefit from not having to censor self, but something that markets itself as adult tends to be hindered by it.
>>
>Most of the original cast haven't competed in over 5 years
Feels bad man. I want more Tyler and Izzy.
>>
>>80924322
Amy should be killed in the same way Ralphie did to Tracee as punishment for mistreatment to Samey (a.k.a. Sammy).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYDbiodGMKk
>>
>>80926026
>Horrible art style.
Nah, the art style is good. All the designs are unique and fit the characters well.
The animation sucks, though.
>>80925869
They apparently broke up
Fuck Fresh

Anyway, I'm glad I found a TD thread before that one tripfag who complains about Tumblr ruins it.
>>
File: Why Fresh, Why.png (58 KB, 735x459) Image search: [Google]
Why Fresh, Why.png
58 KB, 735x459
>>80925869
>>
File: download.jpg (12 KB, 183x275) Image search: [Google]
download.jpg
12 KB, 183x275
I think this movie served a main influence for the series.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_9KQvRKKKU
>>
>>80930041
No Harold in over 5 years should be a crime
>>
Kitty and Emma are best contestants of all the seasons.
>>
>>80931722
I agree dude.
>>
Top 3 Girls, anything else is objectively shit
>MacArthur
>Courtney
>Kitty
>>
>>80932264
I don't think anyone would disagree about Courtney's ass being top tier, but personality wise she's low tier.
>>
Ezekiel bashing
>>
I read Total Obama Island
>>
File: Ella_in_the_Land_of_Chocolate.jpg (398 KB, 2432x1086) Image search: [Google]
Ella_in_the_Land_of_Chocolate.jpg
398 KB, 2432x1086
No one care about Ella.
>>
File: 1_by_chi_trish_d7eeyz2.png (257 KB, 678x1200) Image search: [Google]
1_by_chi_trish_d7eeyz2.png
257 KB, 678x1200
I want more lewds of dawn
>>
I made this recently, since the next season's probably coming out next year, might as well post it now. Sung in the tune of this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHNJPsCDSqo

It’s Total Drama Fever
The terror’s coming Forth
It’s Total Drama Fever
The menace from the north

It’s Total Drama Fever
Causing us lots of Strifus
It’s Total Drama Fever
With all of our Waifus

It’s Total Drama Fever
We’re trying hard to mesh
With the new season
Bought to you by Fresh

Start typing with your keyboard
And start the speculation
About new plot and characters
And their sexual orientations

Imagespam left and Imagespam right
You don’t need to try your best
Just be whipcraking thankful
We’re not talking about Johnny Test

It’s Total Drama Fever
Tumblr still holds a grudge
Their headcanons didn’t happen
About characters packing fudge

Ze season’s ended in ze old verld
Ze spoilers appeared and hopefully zey will be unheard
We were watching, watching like a bunch of freaks
But then the leaks

It’s Total Drama Fever
Let us all be brief
We’re obsessing over a cartoon
From A FUCKING LEAF

I had a favorite contestant
But he was voted off and became irrelevant
And now I’m going to have a rant

Total Drama fever has come back again
We do this every season and McGillis still wants ten
We are watching, watching
Animation that is crappy
And though we’d hate to admit it
It makes us happy

TOTAL! DRAMA! FEVER!
>>
File: 2326_66350166310_8282_n.jpg (58 KB, 431x604) Image search: [Google]
2326_66350166310_8282_n.jpg
58 KB, 431x604
>>80924322
>>
File: dodo6.png (180 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
dodo6.png
180 KB, 480x360
>>80936314

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ew6vtU2rg0o
>>
>>80932264

>no Heather
>no Leshawna
>No Jasmine

Shit list

>>80936256
It only took 60 post before you dropped in. Great.
>>
>>80936314
What is this
>>
>>80925767

Not yet (unless Izzy gets a new voice actor, they're not likely to)

>>80926384

Kids are the bigger demo and are more likely to watch
>>
>>80936753
What happened to her voice actor?
>>
>>80924322
Everything.
>>
File: trolling tumblr.png (862 KB, 1073x1897) Image search: [Google]
trolling tumblr.png
862 KB, 1073x1897
>>80936883

She lives in the states now (doing voicework for Clarence)
>>
>>80936725
In Real Life. It's similar to The Amazing Race. Like the Total Drama franchise, it was also produced in Canada. Total Drama should parody this show as a follow-up to The Ridonculous Race.
>>
>>80934478
Any other fic recommendations, anon?
>>
File: By________on_Pixiv_color.jpg (238 KB, 600x900) Image search: [Google]
By________on_Pixiv_color.jpg
238 KB, 600x900
>>80936942

Which character

is itbest girl
>>
>>80938132

Clarence's Mom and his teacher
>>
File: Ella Portal.png (407 KB, 800x700) Image search: [Google]
Ella Portal.png
407 KB, 800x700
>"Quick Anon, jump through the portal and be with me forever"
>>
File: Baker_0.png (168 KB, 1000x900) Image search: [Google]
Baker_0.png
168 KB, 1000x900
>>80938431

Cool best woman
>>
>>80939381
Can you scoot over and let in a girl that isn't an overrated shit?
>>
Is the drawfag that made this still around?
>>
>>80926904
Beth has a nice derrière and after Leshawna and Anne Maria, it's the biggest on the show.
>>
File: heather2.png (151 KB, 1200x999) Image search: [Google]
heather2.png
151 KB, 1200x999
Bump
>>
>>80943181
>upside down
>>
>>80942065
Nah, we haven't seen him since the TDPI days
>>
>>80929952
Same. Sanders starts out kinda stale, but MacArthur's role in the season wouldn't really work without her, and the development past breaking her arm is great.
Best team.
>>
>>80942065
Would love to see her as an ABDL.
>>
File: 2326_66170671310_5463_n.jpg (22 KB, 604x403) Image search: [Google]
2326_66170671310_5463_n.jpg
22 KB, 604x403
>>80924322
Sabrina Jalees
>>
>>80931722
Here is a song that accurately describes Emma.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3Zrqdfhk4c
>>
>>80926210
I still find it completely unbelievable that she lasted more than 2-3 episodes in any of her return seasons(and she really shouldn't have been brought back for Action or All-Stars), after Island you'd think every other cast member would make eliminating her their top priority
>>
File: fagots.png (488 KB, 425x1253) Image search: [Google]
fagots.png
488 KB, 425x1253
>>80949084

She was the popular villain
>>
>>80949215
that works from a Doylist perspective, but not from a Watsonian one, which I feel is the superior position to take when discussing this sort of thing(especially cause Doylist explanations like the one you gave are often incredibly boring and offer no opportunities for real discussion)
>>
Is this shit good? I watched a bit here and there when it was originally released, but I barely remember anything about it

I don't know who won any season or whatever so don't spoil that, pls.

Basically, is it worth watching?
>>
>>80949354
here's how the seasons are in my opinion;

Island: overall a really good season, second best currently

TDI special between Island and Action: terrible

Action: terrible except for a couple shining bits like Harold and Lindsay

Special between Action and World Tour: never actually seen it so I'm not sure

World Tour: okay for the most part, but the bad parts of the season are incredibly hard to sit through

Revenge of The Island: overall a pretty good season, has the most satisfying finale of any TD series

All-Stars: absolute garbage in almost every way

Pahkitew Island: not bad, but clearly suffers from the reduced episode count

Ridonculous Race: has some hiccups(like a weak finale and certain contestants way overstaying their welcome), but is otherwise the overall best season of the franchise currently
>>
>>80949354
If you get through the 1st, and then 3rd season, and don't dislike it, then maybe check out Ridonculous Race (the spin-off) as well.
That's it.
>>
>>80949450
I'd say Revenge of The Island is also worth watching, and Pahkitew might be as well if he has nothing better to do
>>
>>80949489
No. Even if he didn't have anything better to do, Pahkitew is not worth watching. Nothing in it is worth watching. I say this as a mild fan who has watched all the seasons.
>>
bump
>>
>>80949438

Addition about Season 1: Episode 22 has a moment that can either piss you off a lot or make you laugh a ton.

It's also the episode that establishes a ton of character plots that will keep going on into season 2 and that tend to be what people hate about season 2.
>>
>>80950839
I forget which episode is that one?
>>
>>80950366
There should be a similar picture of all the contestants from the 1st to 3rd generation as ABDLs.
>>
>>80950881
Haute Camp-ture. Don't wanna say to much about the actual plot to avoid spoilers.
>>
>>80939381
As cute as you are ella, you're asking the impossible
Nobody could fit through that thing
>>
>>80950937
oh you mean Leshawna getting eliminated in the most bullcrap manner possible, they really should have used this as a chance to get rid of Heather instead by having it be a unanimous vote against her, and have the Final Two be Gwen vs Leshawna
>>
>>80950979

They wanted a boy/girl finale, Gwen got more of a spotlight and was more relatable (being white) and less antagonistic and the villain needs to go far as possible to generate drama
>>
Which character would you want as your roommate?
if you choose a female character, the two of you will not automatically be together, but she might give you a chance
>>
>>80950979


I actually laughed my ass of at the Leshawna elimination, but that may have to do with Leshawna being one of my least favorite characters. I mentioned that it would either piss you off or make you laugh for a reason.

As for the character stories that this episodes establishes that people hate about season 2, Courtney's sudden superhuman physical attributes and her lawyer plot and Geoff and Bridgette reduced to sucking face being among them

>>
>>80951055

Easily Kitty. Nice girl who is also a fierce gamer.
>>
>>80951029
still think Heather lasted too long, would have personally had her get eliminated back in the episode with Izzy and Eva returning(basically have Eva beat Leshawna, and with Eva getting invincibility the cast goes and immediately puts all their votes towards getting rid of Heather, Eva takes over the Antagonist role in the process)

>>80951055
either Beth or Lindsay

>>80951076
yeah both of those things do suck
>>
>>80925509
>>80931722
The Sister are best indeed. got any more pics?
>>
>>80929716
Why is Canada so God-tier when it comes to making t.v. aimed at teens?
>>
>>80935872

Only one guy posts Dawn

I see she gets no love here
>>
>>80949084
>Total Drama's most iconic and popular villain
>Shouldn't have been brought back for ALL STARS
>When the theme was goddamn Heroes vs Villains
Great logic there
>>
>>80954108
She's probably the most popular Gen 2 girl in the fandom, these threads just don't reflect that
>>
Rewatching Season 1 right now.

I still don't get why people like Courtney beyond "being hot". She's the most unpleasant character in the show, and not even in a funny way(heck, I actually prefer Season 2 Courtney because at least she's so over the top there that she's actually sorta funny).
>>
>>80954939
People want to see Duncney realised and to see her win a season, something that Courtney fans think is overdue.
>>
>>80950366
>8 people on court and a king and queen
That's not how that works
>>
File: DON_Rot.png (116 KB, 640x359) Image search: [Google]
DON_Rot.png
116 KB, 640x359
How would Don and Chris interact?
>>
>>80950366
What the fuck, why is surfer girl with black dude?
I thought she was dating the cowboy hat guy?
>>
>>80955892
This picture was created by DeviantArt user GalacticRedBeauty. She's a fan of many fandom pairings and at the time she was supportive of DJxBridgette and BlaineleyxGeoff.
>>
>>80955368
Chris would be jelous of Don being on his turf
>>
>>80955368
Chris' reaction to Don would probably be very negative. The Ridonculous Race would be stealing viewers and the spotlight away from TD and Chris himself.
>>
>>80955892
Retarded ships are one of the first things you'll see a lot of in the fandom
>>
>>80955086
Courtney would have made for a really good All Stars winner if they hadn't pulled the retarded "It was all an elaborate ruse" shit with her redemption arc
>>
File: Heather_boobs.jpg (32 KB, 697x513) Image search: [Google]
Heather_boobs.jpg
32 KB, 697x513
>>80926210
it's my favorite.

I miss the musical numer of WT
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tVr5WxrJQgA
>>
>>80958979
poor Courtney. The only, of the main character, that never go in a finale.
>>
File: Emma_kitty_bahamas.png (460 KB, 850x477) Image search: [Google]
Emma_kitty_bahamas.png
460 KB, 850x477
>>80952408
they deserve the final with the cadets. damns surfers
>>
>>80959809

All you can do is hope she gets into season 2 of RR
>>
>>80960067
Is there gonna be a season 2?
>>
>/co/ has forgotten Crimson.
>>
>>80961177
Crimson's great. Hell, BOTH goths are great. One of the best teams and they barely had to do anything.
>>
>>80961131
At this current point season 2 of RR is more likely than even season 6 of TD
>>
>>80961177
Nah, still the best TD universe waifu
>>
Stop making me want to marathon this show
>>
>>80960039
BOO! I HATE THE BAHAMAS! AND THAT EPISODE!!
>>
File: Ennui_Drawing_Crimson.png (221 KB, 976x549) Image search: [Google]
Ennui_Drawing_Crimson.png
221 KB, 976x549
>>80961177
never
>>
>>80962731
You can skip All Stars at least
>>
Action>>Island>World Tour>>>>>>>>ROTI>>>>>>>>All Stars
>>
>>80959742

best WT song coming through
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSiBkNuQ8VE
>>
>>80924322
They didn't stop at season 2
>>
>>80925266
I played Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories on my PSP while watching this. Also 6teen and Chowder. Good times
>>
>>80963327
>Action
>Best
Harold, Lindsay, and the occasional Justin aside, it was dull as fuck
>>
File: 133436121334.gif (388 KB, 400x460) Image search: [Google]
133436121334.gif
388 KB, 400x460
>>80926904
Carrie is best girl. Her butt is nicer than Beth's.
>>
>>80963670
Yeah I have to agree
>>
File: vlcsnap-2015-11-18-17h20m50s9.png (407 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
vlcsnap-2015-11-18-17h20m50s9.png
407 KB, 1280x720
>>80963670
Beth and Harold got a ton of screentime, so Action is okay with me.
>>
>>80965857
But neither of them being in the finale makes it shit
>>
>>80965895
Beth was in the finale, but losing to Duncan is absolute bullshit.
>>
File: beth2.png (129 KB, 368x324) Image search: [Google]
beth2.png
129 KB, 368x324
>>80965964

Duncan had a horde of fangirls/fanboys/people who thought he was cool to vote for him, Beth was extremely outmatched
>>
>>80965964
Beth is great, and I know you love dat ass. We all do. But Lindsay and Harold deserved it more
>>
>>80966197
I would've been happy with any of them, really, they're all up there for me.
>>
File: Beth_Pantsed.jpg (122 KB, 969x722) Image search: [Google]
Beth_Pantsed.jpg
122 KB, 969x722
>tfw when Beth and Lindsay will never buy France together.
>>
>>80966297
>You will never get to feel Beth's chubby pale thighs

What's even the point of going on?
>>
>>80949438
>TDI special between Island and Action: terrible
Ha, you have shit taste
>>
Said it before and I'll say it again - Courtney's elimination in All Stars would have been fine if it was actually Mal who set it up, rather than her just being a bitch.
>>
>>80968565
No, because that would still most likely have ended in a Mal vs Zoey finale, which sucked shit. Zoey should have gone that episode with her finding the tape immediately after Al got eliminated.
>>
File: duncan3.png (314 KB, 1280x985) Image search: [Google]
duncan3.png
314 KB, 1280x985
>>80966034
Man, they really ruined him a lot after Island. Shame. He was hot.

Beth deserved that win though.
>>
File: mother.png (140 KB, 648x976) Image search: [Google]
mother.png
140 KB, 648x976
>>80969200

Duncan didn't change, Court (and to an extent Gwen) did
>>
>>80926904
It's Sanders, actually
>>
since there's been a lot of discussion about All-Stars' flaws, felt bringing up this idea from an older thread had merit;

>actually that's a good hypothetical, in a world where the All-Stars we got never happened, and instead we got a full season length version of Pahkitew Island, and then after that they decided to do an All-Stars season(one that would be a full length season), who would you pick as contestants(it'll be at least 22 contestants like Island)?

>Hard Mode: only one or two of the following characters can be chosen(the ones not brought back you have to explain why Chris didn't or couldn't bring them back despite being obvious choices); Duncan, Gwen, Courtney, Heather, Alejandro, Owen, Izzy, Bridgette, Mike, Zoey, Lightning

>originally I was going to suggest 22 campers, but dividing that evenly between all three generations doesn't work, so I'm bumping it up to 24(which can be divided into 3 teams of 8), here's my thoughts(following my hard mode rule from so certain characters are restricted);

Team Wawnakwa Island
>Alejandro(unanimously voted off at the first opportunity by the rest of his teammates as they show some actual genre awareness for once)
>Eva
>Cody
>Harold
>Katie & Sadie(count as one contestant, might swap them out for Leshawna instead though)
>Lindsay
>Beth
>Sierra

Team Boney Island
>Anne Maria
>Cameron
>Sam
>Dakota(zoid)
>Dawn
>Scott
>Lightning
>Brick

Team Pahkitew
>Samey
>Ella
>Shawn
>Jasmine
>Sugar
>Scarlett
>Max(both him and Scarlett are brought back by demand from the network, Chris isn't happy about either of them being allowed back)
>Rodney


any thoughts or additional ideas?
>>
>>80926026
all these are true

but it was fun
>>
>>80972953

>Katie & Sadie(count as one contestant
no
>might swap them out for Leshawna instead though
yes

I think some in Wawanakwa already had too much screentime in past season they should be cut in half.

And should winners really return? imo, it would be kinda of a waste since a) they already got too much screen time
b)they obviously won't be the winners again so no point in root for them.
>>
>>80973127
>I think some in Wawanakwa already had too much screentime in past season they should be cut in half.
well I already tossed out most of the veterans with too much screen time, and really Lindsay, Harold, and Leshawna(figure I'll go with her instead of Katie & Sadie) are the only veterans here who have been in more than two seasons, if I didn't use them, then I'd have to dig up characters from the first generation who I honestly have little to no interest in using(cause really does anyone want DJ or Bridgette to be brought back?), and I wanted all the teams to have matching numbers(and didn't want to have a contestant number less than 22)

>And should winners really return? imo, it would be kinda of a waste since a) they already got too much screen time
>b)they obviously won't be the winners again so no point in root for them.
well for Team Wawanakwa, the only possible winners returning are Alejandro and Beth(I wouldn't directly confirm it, but I'd hint that Heather won WT and Beth won Action in this AU), and for Teams Boney Island and Pahkitew, well I kinda have no choice but to bring back the winners, both seasons had anemic casts compared to Generation 1, if I didn't I'd have to either break my Hard Mode rule, or bring characters that I find boring or hate into this(hell Alejandro is only part of the Gen 1 team to be the 1st episode sacrificial lamb instead of someone who I'd want to give more screentime, although after episode 1 I'd break convention and not have another elimination challenge occur till episode 4 or 5 to allow the rest of the cast some needed time to develop)
>>
>>80924322

feels like it was only meant to be a 1 season thing and felt too forced after that.
>>
I liked it but I'm still sad that Ridonculous Race was an Amazing Race parody and not a Wacky Races parody. The Skaters would've made a great Dastardly and Muttley.

Also anyone else feel like the weakest part of RR was not having Chris as the host? He's a bit overplayed but he has the perfect level of actively trying to get the contestants maimed and completely unfair punishments.
>>
>>80974218
No. I love Chris, but his over the top bullshit was getting to be too much. A host that actually acted like a regular human was a huge breath of fresh air. Don played his role well, had some good interactions with teams (Surfers, Skaters, and especially Goths), and had some good lines ("So we covered them in sad face stickers, which is hilarious).

Don was far from being the weakest part. Very far.
>>
>>80974655
yeah hopefully they'll tone Chris down a little when we next see him
>>
File: Finders_Creepers_(1).png (166 KB, 635x395) Image search: [Google]
Finders_Creepers_(1).png
166 KB, 635x395
>>80975606

Yeah right! with Don being Mr. Nice Guy, McLean will probably become even worse. And with more Sugar and the plot consuming Sky/Dave resolution, Next season is probably going be just as older fandom-enraging as All-Stars
>>
>>80975874
>Next season is probably going be just as older fandom-enraging as All-Stars
I know it's possibly quite silly, but I'm hoping that RR means they've learned from at least some of their mistakes(also to be frank while I can understand why you're so negative about this kind of stuff, it's also getting really old)
>>
>>80972953
I'll just use a cast I'm using for a thing with a Gen 1 vs 2 vs 3 concept

Gen 1
>Harold
>LeShawna
>DJ
>Izzy
>Cody
>Courtney
>Beth
>Trent (or Justin)

Gen 2
>Scott
>Dawn
>B
>Dakota
>Lightning
>Anne Maria
>Brick
>Staci

Gen 3
>Shawn
>Jasmine
>Dave
>Sugar
>Rodney
>Beardo
>Amy
>Sammy

Tried to avoid using characters form All Stars, but I would still need to use two boys from ROTI's cast that was in it anyway. Scott was an obvious choice because he's the favorite, and Lightning is just more entertaining than Sam. Him being in would provide some Sam/Dakota stuff obviously, but while I think most people like the ship it also isn't a very entertaining one. Courtney is brought back to continue her story with Scoot. Chris refuses to allow Ridonculous Race competitors on to the show (hence why no Owen or Geoff), so Bridgette didn't make the cut since Geoff couldn't. I don't think Chris would willingly allow Scarlett or Max to compete again and would use his legal powers to keep them off, hence why they're not there either, but they could be reoccurring villains that try to mess with the show and steal the cash. Originally had Sky instead of Sugar to finish her story with Dave, but the majority of the fandom seems to almost unanimously hate that storyline, so she was nixed for the much more entertaining character. Dave has to stay because he's the main villain.
>>
>>80976471
pretty good overall, although having both B and Beardo in the cast seems redundant, and I'll admit I'm wary of Staci being on the roster, although I'm guessing all three of those characters will get eliminated pretty early since Staci is too annoying to stay for long(unless you have some sort of plot in mind for her), and B and Beardo not talking means you can't really do much with them(especially in a fan-fic context compared to a visual medium)
>>
>>80976599
You're forgetting that Beardo CAN talk, they just didn't have him do so in his only episode with the exception of his elimination. They're two pretty drastically different characters since B is pretty much a silent child prodigy while Beardo is a shy dude that likes music and sounds. Also he can, you know, talk. Staci is indeed an early boot, but in a different planned story that focuses solely on underdeveloped characters, I actually do have a story in mind for her and won't boot her too early
>>
>>80976193

While RR continues to be toothless and appeasing to the older fandom, Total Drama will continue follow the footsteps of Teen Titans Go!
>>
>>80963788
MacArthur has the better ass AND is actually entertaining. Carrie a shit.
>>
>>80976716
Still won't get any worse than All Stars
>>
File: Total Drama Shipping Chart.jpg (374 KB, 2000x1800) Image search: [Google]
Total Drama Shipping Chart.jpg
374 KB, 2000x1800
bump
>>
>>80950366
>>
>>80925146
>again
Pics?
>>
>>80939381
Go kill yourself.
>>
>>80950911
I bet you thought you went unnoticed.
>>
>>80950911
Weird
>>
File: Gwen's_Underwaer.jpg (15 KB, 553x414) Image search: [Google]
Gwen's_Underwaer.jpg
15 KB, 553x414
>>80980371
>>
File: GwenSkirtLoss.png (351 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
GwenSkirtLoss.png
351 KB, 640x480
>>80982255
>>
File: SierraHeatherUse.png (412 KB, 614x464) Image search: [Google]
SierraHeatherUse.png
412 KB, 614x464
>>
File: LeShawnaCourtneyInsult.png (132 KB, 480x320) Image search: [Google]
LeShawnaCourtneyInsult.png
132 KB, 480x320
Thread replies: 181
Thread images: 44

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.