[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Legend of the Galactic Heroes
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 82
Thread images: 23
What are your opinions on this?
>>
File: sas.png (223 KB, 500x375) Image search: [Google]
sas.png
223 KB, 500x375
>>143743901
memes
>>
>>143743901
2D battles in 3D space.
>>
>>143743901
Takes like 30 episodes to even get somewhat interesting. Is shonen tier slow with story progression.

I don't understand why retards praise it so much.
>>
It's good.
>>
>>143743901
Starts out great and starts to drag on.
>>
>>143743901
remake when
>>
Overrated Star Trek clone.
>>
Manages to make politics boring.
>>
File: snapshot-00008.png (462 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
snapshot-00008.png
462 KB, 640x480
>>143743901
Free Worlds could have used more development for it's main characters. The Terra conspiracy was was dumb. The villains were stupid. And 80's anime looks like shit. 10/10
>>
File: 1459354052045.jpg (42 KB, 1024x576) Image search: [Google]
1459354052045.jpg
42 KB, 1024x576
HIKARI NO HASHI WO KOETE
>>
>>143743901
Overrated shit.

>>143744041
Babby's first 'serious' i.e. non moeshit or generic shonen show, clearly. Babbies tend to be extremely defensive of those.

>>143745065
Really? After the Berserk travesy you still want a remake of anything?
>>
Too entry level.
>>
>>143748083
The Berserk anime isn't a remake.
>>
File: 13350414_m.png (52 KB, 288x320) Image search: [Google]
13350414_m.png
52 KB, 288x320
>>143746288
Yang a cute.
>>
>>143748083

Fujisaki Ryu animated Eiyuu Densetsu when?
>>
I love it. It's not really deep or anything but the characters are some of my favourite in all of anime.
>>
>>143743901
Democracy is the best.

DIE KAISER REINHARD
>>
File: Bitten.jpg (9 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
Bitten.jpg
9 KB, 225x225
Bitten
>>
File: follow_l.gif (4 KB, 243x319) Image search: [Google]
follow_l.gif
4 KB, 243x319
>>143748243

NAZI PUNKS FUCK OFF!
>>
File: mai waifu.jpg (336 KB, 1254x1771) Image search: [Google]
mai waifu.jpg
336 KB, 1254x1771
What are 11/10 fuccbois for?
>>
>>143748609
Johan Liebert vs Reinhard
who's the most handsome male char
>>
>>143743901
It's good but overrated.
>>
>>143748664
I'd say Reinhard, Johann is somewhat too cold, but he gets bonus points for trapping, so it's a pretty tough choice actually.
>>
>>143744014
But the one in the OP is pretty 3D though.
>>
>120 episodes
>two side stories each spanning 24 episodes
>some more shit to watch

wew
>>
>>143743901
It's garbage. Even 3DPD trash like the walking dead is better.
>>
File: 0HYA0mW.jpg (1 MB, 3840x2160) Image search: [Google]
0HYA0mW.jpg
1 MB, 3840x2160
>>143748809
That's basically as 3D as having two rows of guns stacked on top of another.

A real 3D battle would not have a concept of "topside" or "bottomside".
>>
It has a lot of seriously retarded things, most importantly when characters are supposed to look smart the author makes their adversaries suddenly develop retardation instead, HALF-CIRCLES etc, but the characters (not all of them though) and overall story make up for the cheese.
Great series, but definitely not GOAT as some were led to believe.
>>
>>143749069
Nice pic, is it from/illustration for something or just the artist's imagining of a cool space battle?
>>
>>143743901
Its such a shame that japan doesnt produce good space operas anymore
>>
>>143749069
It would also be a clusterfuck every single time. 3D dogfights are fine, but fleet movements in 3D would basically always be those scenes where both armies mixed.
>>
>>143749458
How was that Titania one? I remember I started watching it but dropped, I don't even remember why.
>>
File: 2016y04m30d_145345898.jpg (145 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
2016y04m30d_145345898.jpg
145 KB, 800x600
Please play this piece .
This is a great masterpiece .
>>
>>143748083
Fuck off cuppy
>>
>>143743901
Great show but you're more likely to get actual discussion on /m/ instead of /a/
>>
File: wegLoGH.png (213 KB, 1053x416) Image search: [Google]
wegLoGH.png
213 KB, 1053x416
>>143743901
>>
>>143748183
I don't think it is trying to be deep, it's more or less condensing a lot facts about human nature and politics.
>>
>>143749557
I don't remember it being completely terrible, I think the ending wasn't conclusive too.
>>
>>143749541
Personally I think manned space fleet battles are a dumb like hell, outdated concept. Why all the expense of life-supporting a fuckton of organic creatures in space, when there are things like cloud technilogies, autonomous driving, drones, etc, and this is still before we even left our planet properly. I'd imagine an anvanced space-faring civilization will have honed those things to perfection and will just have AI-fleets which are operated by a bunch of commanders from the comfort of a CIC on their home planet. Shows how most sci-fi writers in fact have no fantasy (or no grasp of current technological trends... Btw, I read an interview with LoGH writer, and he said he still writes in a notebook with a pencil instead of typing and is all but unfamiliar with computers. You want to unironically watch a space opera by that kind of guy? Really?).
>>
>>143749567
But I don't know moonspeak.
>>
It's my favorite show, it's heavily flawed, but still great.
Ignore most shit you hear about it online, it's become sort of a "babbys first mature anime" thing which has made it a topic of controversy among shitposters.
>>
>>143749877
Remake and translation because the went bankrupt on top of the old work is hopeless .

Is the challenge to language learning in this opportunity ...
>>
>>143750044
besides the last part and cult of earth what are the other flaws
>>
>>143750137
I'm lazy like Yang, so I'll just direct you to this anon>>143749333 who explained it pretty well.
>>
>>143749820
If you want remote controlled fleets then you need a zero latency system and something that can't be jammed or hijacked. autonomous fighting forces are another thing that may have the same problems in addition to ethics and the rogue AI story.
>>
>>143749820
You can't do remote piloting in space because speed of light issues. Having most ships be unmanned drones is a good idea, but you would need a manned command ship.
>>
My favorite show. I know it has flaws but I think said flaws were necessary for this kind of story. For example manned space battles are infinitely more interesting than the more practical and likely drone battles. Fully exploring the 3D plane for space battle would change the whole point of the battles of showing historical tactics in a new environment and instead place emphasis on action (showing what's possible in 3D) instead of tactics (showing what has worked in the past). And LoGH certainly cares more about having the tone of a history book than being an action thriller. Because of this it's certainly not for everyone, but those who can get behind it really enjoy it as I did.

Also if tactics were entirely new based on 3D warfare, Yang's edge of winning using historical methods most others forgot about would be moot, which would also harm the series' historical tone.
>>
>>143749567
This work is formidable to be proposed to the boss than the enemy .
You can also enjoy the battle to be caught up in the strategy of the incompetent boss .
The career overlapped the meritorious , it will be able to contribute to the strategy .
And you will be able to fight a barely decent enemy .
You can taste the hardships of Yang Wen-li .
Naturally or cause a coup , you can also belong to the hostile forces in exile .

Sorry in clumsy English .
>>
File: detail634521719564547500.jpg (18 KB, 290x220) Image search: [Google]
detail634521719564547500.jpg
18 KB, 290x220
Apoligy for poor Alliance

when were You when Miracle Young Legend dies

I was sat at Palace drinking Tea Fluid when Sieg ring

'Young is die'

'no'

and You????????????????
>>
>>143750601
>>143750454
Well, some authors work around latency issues by inventing some deus-ex-machina wunder-technology (see Hyperion series). Can't see why you can't do this when you do things like healing capsules and unexplained FTL.
>>
>>143749820

You do realize that automated system and radio communications have all been hacked and jammed to all hell and back. Each fleet is located light-minutes from each other, meaning that their laser beams take several minutes to reach enemy ships, and even if they hit, they will not see any feedback for several more minutes Communication is done by shuttle craft or Morse code over laser light relay systems.

Warfare has reached such an advanced state that all technology is made irrelevant because of the technologies themselves. The only outside factor is human judgment.
>>
>>143749406
No it's from Eve Online. Battles that massive don't happen too often anymore.
>>
>>143752700

FTL does not need to be explained. It is already understood in reality that there are certain possible outcomes. Also, magical healing capsules are not magical, but rather a thing that might be possible in the near future due to advances in medical technology. Also, making pseudo-science hand-wave explanations go against the spirit of the story, as well as the established environment.
>>
File: 1030237.jpg (97 KB, 600x600) Image search: [Google]
1030237.jpg
97 KB, 600x600
>>143743901
I love it. I'm actually watching and at episode 70 I know what happens but I don't think I'm prepared for it. I also don't want to finish it because the void will be too big. SIEG KAISER REINHARD
>>
>>143749069

Just how many titans are there in that image? I remember when one titan was a special thing. That is too many.
>>
Wonder how the remake will turn out, and what they'll cover.
>>
File: 1461794060217.jpg (94 KB, 700x520) Image search: [Google]
1461794060217.jpg
94 KB, 700x520
Why did Reinhard grow such long hair?
>>
>>143753228
>a thing that might be possible in the near future due to advances in medical technology
O rly
Call me when said medical technology is advanced enough to get rid of even ridiculous things like fucking HPV or chlamydia, not to mention heavy shit like AIDS, crohn's disease or cancer, nice and for good, before we discuss capsules which cure gunshot wounds and fuckin everything in 5 minutes. We sure ain't in the 18th century anymore, and thank God for that, but medical science has still even barely moved out of its infancy, and in some areas is still barely a science.
>>
File: 1466625664377.jpg (124 KB, 800x560) Image search: [Google]
1466625664377.jpg
124 KB, 800x560
>>143753275
Fuck off nazi punk.
>>
>>143753977
He wished to be a little grill.
>>
>>143752547
Yong is kill
>>
>>143748609

Surprise Alliance loving, long and hard. Preferably while they are dressed in a maid costume.
>>
>>143753281
Titans are like Dreads. I loved it when CCP thought it would take years and tons of resources to build just ONE Titan and the alliances started popping out one or tow per month.
>>
>>143743901
remind me of Homeworld and how i autistmally managed to capture more than 50 laser frigates in one mission
>>
>>143749720
>>
Enjoy it while you can before the remake turns it into the reddit-anime that you have to dislike.
>>
>>143755960
It's a readaptation, not a remake
>>
File: 1465791406368.jpg (104 KB, 986x553) Image search: [Google]
1465791406368.jpg
104 KB, 986x553
>>
So how're the books compared to the anime, now that the first volume is translated in English?
>>
>>143749820
>You want to unironically watch a space opera by that kind of guy?

I think most watch space operas less from a technological angle and more from a opera angle. I mean Star Wars has blatant fantasy elements in its fiction.
>>
File: 1398402861309.jpg (41 KB, 960x720) Image search: [Google]
1398402861309.jpg
41 KB, 960x720
Daily reminder that Fleet Admiral Paul von Oberstein did absolutely nothing wrong.
>>
It's one of the best series there is. It has a huge cast that actively participate in the plot, big enough that in most cases it would've been a clusterfuck of "who is this guy again?", but most are incredibly likeable and memorable characters. I would go so far as to say it has the best cast in any anime. This is the single most crucial aspect, and because of it it achieves its goal of making you sympathize with both sides of the conflict.
I also love the writing, which almost entirely avoids the pitfalls of most anime involving non-japanese characters and culture. Most often characters are non-japanese in name and description only, but their way of speaking, mannerisms and other subtle tells are still very japanese, or more specifically, they are anime japanese. The writing is mature without being tryhard or pretentious. It feels like it was written by a capable person with respect for the audience and complete faith in their target demographic.
>>
>>143756017
It's very close to the first arc of the anime. For example the battle of Armistar, where the Alliance overextends its invasion, is nearly word for word the same. The anime stuck quite close to the books in tone and content.
Having said that, there are a few small details different, like Dusty not existing in the books and a few extra history lessons.
If you liked the anime you'll like the books.
>>
>>143749069
that's retarded. space is vast. you want to use the distance as defense. it makes it impossible to hit you with directed energy weapons while you can still use homing weapons.
>>
>>143753281
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloodbath_of_B-R5RB
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ab36h4aDUUI
>>
File: 1421579284794.jpg (184 KB, 1587x1194) Image search: [Google]
1421579284794.jpg
184 KB, 1587x1194
>>143756554
You would be correct.
>>
File: 1443968639325.jpg (57 KB, 960x720) Image search: [Google]
1443968639325.jpg
57 KB, 960x720
>>143757760
>>
File: CSc14nNVAAAfhUV.jpg (38 KB, 600x450) Image search: [Google]
CSc14nNVAAAfhUV.jpg
38 KB, 600x450
Best pilotfu.
>>
File: 1406410325365.jpg (231 KB, 640x1920) Image search: [Google]
1406410325365.jpg
231 KB, 640x1920
>>143758281
>>
I collected this series in VHS back in the 90s. Back then the subs ended around the battle for Iselhorn. Hungry for the rest for years until someone finally subbed the rest -- just to find the series goes way downhill and had a shot ending.
>>
Yang was a cunt that prioritized his pride and naive ideal than the lives of his man and country.
Thread replies: 82
Thread images: 23

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.