[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Daily reminder that Madoka was a perfect show before it was ruined
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 228
Thread images: 77
File: 1438337932936.jpg (3 MB, 2932x4020) Image search: [Google]
1438337932936.jpg
3 MB, 2932x4020
Daily reminder that Madoka was a perfect show before it was ruined by Rebellion Story
>>
>>143093375
Rebellion was nice.
>>
>>143093375
>madoka was a perfect show
bait or bait?
>>
>>143094713
It's nice when viewed in a vacuum
>>
>>143093375
Yeah. I personally liked how the show ended. And then Rebellion came along. And now people are desperately waiting for a sequel of it.
>>
>>143093375
Rebellion was perfect thematically. It just ended in a way without catharsis, the next project should deliver that.
>>
File: mm111102001.png (468 KB, 853x480) Image search: [Google]
mm111102001.png
468 KB, 853x480
>>143093375
Why did you think "it was ruined by Rebellion Story"?
>>
rebellion was better than shitdoka
at least I could understand characters motivations and the retards were punished for being retards instead of becoming fucking gods

madoka is a 4/10 rebellion is a 8/10
>>
Rebellion is kino.
>>
>>143094713
This.

>>143095093
And this.

Rebellion is the absolute kino of anime.
>>
>>143095093
whats this kino meme
>>
File: heresy.jpg (118 KB, 500x661) Image search: [Google]
heresy.jpg
118 KB, 500x661
>>143093375
Daily reminder that everyone that hates Rebellion are fags that only like happy endings and would rather have the story be going against what it has set-up the entire show just to have happy yuri times.
>>
File: 1458282958472.jpg (528 KB, 1200x1500) Image search: [Google]
1458282958472.jpg
528 KB, 1200x1500
>>143093375
The opposite really. It was improved by Rebellion.
>>
File: 1437237619344.png (123 KB, 318x190) Image search: [Google]
1437237619344.png
123 KB, 318x190
>>143095187
>implying Rebellion didn't have a happy ending
>>
>>143095187
but it was a happy ending
the fucking retarded sayaka got what she deserved
>>
>>143095249
A "happy" ending. Everything was set up for Homura's eventual demise and the world she created crumbling.

I suppose this is the happiest ending we'll get because the next project is going to shit all over that.
>>
>>143095337
I wish they didn't do a fourth movie, even more so that it'll be focused on fucking Mami of all the girls.
>>
>>143095369
>let's kill a character for cheap shock value
>no jk we're going to resurrect her a gorillion time she's ok
the pandering is this series is fucking insane
>>
>>143095369
I doubt it.

Mami will just get a side role where she'll battle Homura and possibly die since she's supposed to be based on Guan Yu.
>>
>>143094891
What? Overall sounds and voice acting were okay.
>>
>>143095488
She'll refuse to kill Homura in the same way Guan Yu refused to deal a crippling blow to Cao Cao. Homura and Madoka will die for sure. Sayaka will probably die.
>>
>>143095407
Mami wasn't killed for shock value. The purpose of her death is to show that being a magical girl isn't just some game where all the battles against the big bad are won through the power of love/friendship/family/comrades/whatever. Her death serves as a big wake up call and lays the foundation to the true tragedy of what it means to be a magical girl. With Sayaka we go more in depth on how crushing it is to be one.

Pandering? Time travel is the major plot point . Of course characters will come back if someone travels back in time to a time where they were all alive.
>>
File: 1439226864075.jpg (929 KB, 848x1200) Image search: [Google]
1439226864075.jpg
929 KB, 848x1200
>>143095407
>>143095488
Mami is a mess. Mami Tomoe is the weakest person on this series so and by far. Mami is a waste and everybody knows it. She is so weak... it's laughable. Mami is a mess. Mami is a waste. Mami is a MESS. Mami is a big fat mistake.

Excuse me, Anons. Mami is a BIG FAT MESS.

Excuse me, she killed Kyoko and tried to kill all her friends after realizing the truth, nasty girl, she is a nasty girl. Mami is a nasty girl.

I would tell you, I don't often agree with Madokafags and I don't often agree with Homurafags but I get along with everybody and I say this every NIGHT, every DAY, every AFTERNOON and it's so TRUE: Mami is a mess. Mami is a waste. Mami is a big fat mess.

Don't even let me get started on fucking Sayaka.
Homura > Madoka = Kyoko > Mami > dogshit > Sayaka
>>
Madokami is down
>>
>>143095559
So you think they will all die except Kyouko? That's pretty sad.
>>
>>143095337
>Everything was set up for Homura's eventual demise and the world she created crumbling

All the girls have to die at some point and her world isn't any more shit than Madoka's "Buddhist monk demons rape humans and megucas" universe.
>>
>>143095644
They've all died already except Homura.
>>
>>143095689
Homura died too though. Thanks to the power of love she overcame even death.
>>
File: 00.jpg (103 KB, 600x424) Image search: [Google]
00.jpg
103 KB, 600x424
>>
>>143093375
Actually Rebellion is better than the show.
>>
>>143095755
It's not the same. She reset time one last time. She's the only one who hasn't accepted death yet.
>>
>>143095862
She'll never accept death because she's an obsessed psychopath. She'll burn in hell, abandoned by Madoka, and never cease suffering for the shit she did.
>>
>>143093375
>Obvious bait thread set up by HomuHater
>>
>>143095954
Literally everyone hates Homura.
>>
>>143095828
What the FUCK is this shit???
>>
>>143095981
I don't hate her.
>>
File: 1459287140262.gif (980 KB, 1415x1079) Image search: [Google]
1459287140262.gif
980 KB, 1415x1079
>>143095981
It's about time to stop hating yourself, Homura.
>>
>>143095981
Homura's the only meguca who sells.
>>
>TV show ends with a heartwenching bittersweet ending with Madoka sacrificing her existence to end everyone's suffering.
>Nope, fuck that shit. Instead Homura happily retcons everything pretty much ruining the whole "self-sacrifice message".
>>
>>143095828

do people really find the ume designs sexually attractive?
>>
>>143096098
>TV show ends with an unrealistically solution to complex psychological issues
>Movie shows what happens to a girl who has lived through far too many timelines when her obsession up and vanishes
>>
>>143095921
>suffering for the shit she did.
what did Homura even do that was that bad?

The cycle is still in place, just now the Incubators take the suffering in place of Madoka
>>
Reminder that the movie is only hated by people who need happy Hollywood endings.
>>
>>143095060
Damn, I think this is actually a perfect explanation of my thoughts on Rebellion. I really liked everything about it, but somehow that ending made me feel unsatisfied and empty.
>>
>>143096166
Magic was part of the concept of the series
>>
>>143095187
>Everything set up in the show
Urobuchi was ready to end it on the Madoka takes Homura to heaven note. Even though that's not the road they went down, don't pretend that wasn't the first option.

It was a happy ending for the character it focused on because the character it focused on never gave a fuck about her own well being.
>>
>>143095573
doesn't seem so bad since you can't be resurrected any time
>>
>>143096226
>that ending made me feel unsatisfied and empty.
because it's sequal bait
>>
>>143096196
It's a pretty unfulfilling ending that leaves you wanting more. Rebellion isn't bad, but it ends just as things start getting serious.
>>
File: 1450809637489.jpg (10 KB, 193x245) Image search: [Google]
1450809637489.jpg
10 KB, 193x245
>>143095981
>>
>>143093375
Reminder that the judgement is still out on rebellion and it's sequel(s) will determine how it is looked at when Madoka is finished.
>>
Rebellion is the worst post series movie since Nadeisco's.

If not for E7 AO it'd be the worst post series anything.
>>
>>143096342

even before astral ocean pocket full of rainbows is a resounding "what the fuck is even the point of this"
>>
>>143096098
All she really did was prevent them from becoming witches. The world was still shit and filled with suffering. And if Homura was any indicator, she only increased Homura's suffering and made all of her pain and struggling pointless. Madoka literally just made a wish in the final episode that freed her from becoming a witch.

>>143096166
She wasn't answering a psychological problem though. She just wanted witches to go away. Agreed on the final part though.
>>
File: bye-bye.png (285 KB, 555x739) Image search: [Google]
bye-bye.png
285 KB, 555x739
>>143095981
Does everyone include Homura herself?
>>
>>143096316
Thread/
>>
>>143096431
Homura only cares about herself. She hates everyone else because she blames them for her own shortcomings like Madoka never loving her. She is a deranged, obsessed, abusive monster wjo deserves to die, and Madoka will kill her happily for ruining her wish and raping her.
>>
File: me.png (150 KB, 388x280) Image search: [Google]
me.png
150 KB, 388x280
>>143096431
only the jews can hate our true godess
>>
>>143096571
FUCKING EVERYONE HATES HER.

Do you not see this thread? Everyone hates her. She sunk the franchise. Their plans for another plotless cashgrab fell through due to heavy fan backlash and only now are they starting to work on it with the promise that Homura is going to pay for her sins.
>>
>>143096413
I'm fine with that if only for the idea that it's saying "For fucks sake, leave E7 well enough alone."
>>
File: 1398432692700.jpg (49 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1398432692700.jpg
49 KB, 1280x720
I love Homura.
>>
File: 1463619397203.jpg (86 KB, 1024x1024) Image search: [Google]
1463619397203.jpg
86 KB, 1024x1024
>>143096640
What if Homura suddenly appears right in front of you? What are you going to do?
>>
File: 1436888463992.png (460 KB, 1121x733) Image search: [Google]
1436888463992.png
460 KB, 1121x733
I don't hate Homura. She was just doing what was necessary for Madoka to see her family again.
>>
>>143095828
Is the ice pop a metaphor for dick sucking?
>>
File: Ck6TRm6VAAA35w1.jpg (190 KB, 1200x907) Image search: [Google]
Ck6TRm6VAAA35w1.jpg
190 KB, 1200x907
Reminder that the conflict is forced to begin with and they will reconcile as equal gods who will set aside their pride and compromise. Their feelings for each other connect them through eternity.
>>
>>143096230
>Urobuchi was ready to end it on the Madoka takes Homura to heaven note
And then proceded to say that such an ending didn't satisfy him.
>>
File: comic447.png (87 KB, 650x527) Image search: [Google]
comic447.png
87 KB, 650x527
>>143096878
This, basically.
>>
>>143097096
Interesting how dicks come to your mind. You a gay?
>>
>>143097128
retcons: the anime
>>
>>143097165
>this triggered
>>
File: 28345850_p0_master1200.jpg (147 KB, 486x640) Image search: [Google]
28345850_p0_master1200.jpg
147 KB, 486x640
>>143097096
Yep.
>>
File: 1458313618947.jpg (225 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1458313618947.jpg
225 KB, 1920x1080
>>143097189
I'm sure Homura doesn't like dicks.
>>
>>143097188
It was just a simple question.
>>
>>143097135
The point being they already had the rest of the story planned. You can't say it was all set-up and meant to go that way when it wasn't even their first idea for an ending.
>>
A cute.
>>
>>143097228
She likes melon though.
>>
File: 1440051863385.jpg (109 KB, 800x643) Image search: [Google]
1440051863385.jpg
109 KB, 800x643
>>143096919
I don't hate Kyoko who is a juicy Apple. I was just doing what was necessary for you/her to remember the truth again.

>>143097165
Do you like a gay?

>>143097239
Mine is just a simple question.
>>
>>143097334
>I don't know what cuck means
>>
>>143097334
How is he a cuck?
>>
>>143095981
I might not like her. But I still want to fuck her.
>>
>>143096919
>it's okay that Homura brainwashed everyone and tortures them for her own amusement while emotionally abusing a Madoka who never loved her and can't fight back
>it's okay Homura ruined everything because I can have yuri fantasies

People like you are degenerate.
>>
>>143097488
Homura is the reason all the girls are living a much happier life though.
>>
>>143097488
>it's okay Homura ruined everything because I can have yuri fantasies
Actually Homura fixing everything is the reason my yuri fantasies are still only fantasies. She's too much of a beta and too guilty to get the pussy she deserves.
>>
File: 1461238226382.gif (1011 KB, 500x245) Image search: [Google]
1461238226382.gif
1011 KB, 500x245
>mfw nobody will ever again be able to break the wall hiding the hearts of Apple and !GMeguca and I cannot talk to them about Madoka Magica again.
>>
>>143097569
Man, I wish tripfagging was a bannable offense.
>>
>>143097602
Not even that. Just him in particular.
>>
>>143093375
Daily reminder that Madoka is shit, Urobuchi is a hack and it only took 3 movies for people to finally realize it.
>>
File: 1429063945414.jpg (91 KB, 572x850) Image search: [Google]
1429063945414.jpg
91 KB, 572x850
>>143097549
What does cat's have to do with that? Is Amy still around at all? Is Amy actually Homura?
>>
>>143097637
Why do I need to know who the fuck they are when they post something? They're not translators or someone "important".
>>
File: 1459438734068.jpg (517 KB, 768x1024) Image search: [Google]
1459438734068.jpg
517 KB, 768x1024
You take Devil Homura by surprise and run at her at full speed and full erection. Are you able to get it in and how long are you able to keep it in before you're dead?
>>
>>143097682
Filtering does wonders.
>>
File: 26958919_p0.jpg (268 KB, 626x541) Image search: [Google]
26958919_p0.jpg
268 KB, 626x541
>>143097681
>>
>>143097255
But the ending they went with was better.
>>
>>
>>143097687
I don't do it in the first place. I'd just ask why she did what she did and maybe ask her if she wants a henchman

>>143097709
Ye, I know. I just wanted to know the reason of this cancerous circlejerking.
>>
>>143097758
I don't disagree.
>>
>>143097682
Why not anonymize?
>>
>>143097788
Because sometimes I need to know who is who. Steiner is a good example.
>>
File: hk2vb0h.jpg (124 KB, 1003x580) Image search: [Google]
hk2vb0h.jpg
124 KB, 1003x580
>>
File: 1433370906766.jpg (147 KB, 850x478) Image search: [Google]
1433370906766.jpg
147 KB, 850x478
So how about that Madoka Magica? Sweet stuff there.
>>
I'd say all Rebellion does is free Homura from Kyubey's trap, but it just reminds Homura of how much of a fuck up she is. The next movie will free Homura from her suffering. How they do that, I don't know. Madoka should be the one to relieve her suffering, but we've got Mami now so who knows how much of a train wreck this will be.
>>
>>143097989
God just shut up.
>>
>>143097989
No one looks brainwashed you idiot.
>>
File: jjiPWBi.jpg (4 MB, 4608x3456) Image search: [Google]
jjiPWBi.jpg
4 MB, 4608x3456
>have crawled more than 4.5k of 2ch madoka general to get images
>they just don't stop posting food and gore pics
>>
File: 1432978622253.png (193 KB, 430x780) Image search: [Google]
1432978622253.png
193 KB, 430x780
>>143098188
At least Kyouko will be happy with the food.
>>
File: 1453909510656.jpg (261 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
1453909510656.jpg
261 KB, 800x600
>>143098086
What if they do end up in battle?
>>
File: 8f51ced200c644208f9f6d14d6843691.jpg (501 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
8f51ced200c644208f9f6d14d6843691.jpg
501 KB, 1920x1080
>>143093375
/thread
>>
File: 1440972388518.jpg (94 KB, 640x896) Image search: [Google]
1440972388518.jpg
94 KB, 640x896
>>143098242
>>143098333
Why don't you talk to Lawnchair-tan about PMMM?
>>
>>143098333
They most likely will. Kyouko and Sayaka ended up in battle. Mami and Nagisa ended up in battle. It's the only way for the ship to become canon.
>>
>>143098379
Shut up Lawnchair.
>>
>>143098086
>pic
Really makes me want to buy Animedia mag.
>>
Nope.
Also sequel might never happen. People are talking about it, but it is still unconfirmed.
>>
>>143098559
Why would that matter?
>>
>>143098591
I just want to know why you don't talk to him. Because you cannot beat him in an argument?
>>
>>143098671
You are getting really aggravating Lawnchair.
>>
File: salty.jpg (24 KB, 511x288) Image search: [Google]
salty.jpg
24 KB, 511x288
>>143098242
>tfw no adult Kyouko who would make a great beermate
>>
>>143097952
It's the other way around, Homura will receive more suffering for the sake of catharsis, they painted her as the villain so once she's defeated, people will immediately feel pity for her and the balance will be restored.
>>
>>143098753
Can you say that in English?
>>
File: 1454292610892.jpg (59 KB, 500x574) Image search: [Google]
1454292610892.jpg
59 KB, 500x574
>>143098711
>>143098671
can you two kevin-kuns wanna be relax and enjoy the story who cares who was right or left fact is we get new movie in 2016 so let's not grab our pitchforkes until they manage to make mami the new saint mary mother of meduka fegets
>>
>>143098753
>Homura will receive more suffering for the sake of catharsis
How much more can she really get? Episode 10 onward is nothing but Homura suffering.
>hey painted her as the villain so once she's defeated
Does anyone really view her as a villain?
>people will immediately feel pity for her and the balance will be restored.
She's always been pitiful.
>>
>>143098908
All of Japan hates her and wants her to pay for what she did to Madoka.
>>
>>143098908
Antagonist is a more suitable word to describe Homura's current role in the story.
She would need to be defeated for order to be restored.
>>
>>143097989
I hate Madohomu but I might start to like it just for the sake of pissing off this guy.
>>
>>143098941
I hate Madoka and all she did to Homura. Madoka is an abusive girlfriend who manipulated a shy, insecure girl into becoming the devil for the sake of her ego. When she kills Homura, she can stand around and gloat about killing the monster and saving the world even though she created the devil. The fourth movie will be about the other girls realizing Madoka is an evil bitch who murdered her bestfriend for the sake of getting other magical girls to like her. Junko and Tomohisa should have aborted Madoshit for the evil she's caused the world and for the quadrillion magical girls she's killed and even the entire universe she destroyed. Madoka is evil and she must be stopped.
>>
File: 1437709417666.jpg (1 MB, 2459x3500) Image search: [Google]
1437709417666.jpg
1 MB, 2459x3500
Is Mami a pedo?
>>
File: images (1).jpg (17 KB, 470x313) Image search: [Google]
images (1).jpg
17 KB, 470x313
So we can at least all agree that Homura's contract wish is finally fulfilled through Rebellion right?

>I, I want to redo my first encounter with Kaname-san. Not being someone who is protected by her, but being someone who protects her
>>
>>143099394
Yes. All the wishes have been granted. Now we can enter the final chapter of the story.
>>
File: images.png (15 KB, 235x251) Image search: [Google]
images.png
15 KB, 235x251
>>143099394
Wrong pic.
>>
>>143099394
Wasn't that obvious? She finally became strong enough to protect her.

>>143099426
Which is?
>>
>>143099156
It's an abusive obsession that Madoka wants no part of. Literal degeneracy. Homura is a terrible monster unworthy of love which is why nobody loves her.

>>143099160
Delusional.

>>143099394
Homura wanted to make Madoka her property and force her to love her, which is evil, so yes her evil wish was accomplished through murder and mind control, but Madoka will happily murder her.
>>
>>143099426
My wish hasn't been granted.
I want to be a cute little girl.
>>
>>143099606
You can be if you have enough money
>>
>Madoka kills Homura
>Homura leaves behind a grief seed
>Madoka takes it with her as a reminder of the friend she loved and the one magical girl she could never save
Don't make it happen SHAFT.
>>
File: 670338a0.jpg (117 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
670338a0.jpg
117 KB, 800x600
>>143099160
Anon, hate cannot be overcame by another hate.

>inb4 we no speak polish
>>
>>143099944
>inb4 we no speak polish

"Everything bad that happened in the series and Rebellion was because of evil Russians"
"Remember Katyn"
>>
>>143100181
>Rebellion has motifs from nutcracker
>Concept movie has motifs from swan lake
>evil russian tchaikovsky
oh shit
>>
>>143100339
Madoka never loved Homura and Homura is shit at dancing.
>>
File: Sans titre.jpg (413 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Sans titre.jpg
413 KB, 1920x1080
>>143100339

>>143100477
No she isn't.
>>
File: 1466147628700.gif (279 KB, 500x287) Image search: [Google]
1466147628700.gif
279 KB, 500x287
I thought the movie was good
>>
>>143100645
All 3 of them were good.
>>
>>143100339
>Nut Cracker
>Sleeping Beauty
>Swan Lake
>>
>>143096230
Kinda glad they didn't go this route. Homura should try to move beyond her obsession a little before that.
>>
File: 10.jpg (254 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
10.jpg
254 KB, 1280x720
>>143100504
>Homu didn't send Madoka to Russia
>Madoka will never get high-leveled Russian ballet class
>>
>>143100828
>I'm glaf they didn't go that route
>Homura should try to move beyond her obsession a little before that.
Did we see the same ending? It's not like she's going to develop a hobby or make other friends at this point.
>>
File: ribbon 2 stronk.jpg (121 KB, 873x664) Image search: [Google]
ribbon 2 stronk.jpg
121 KB, 873x664
>>143095585
t. assblasted pumpkinshitter
>>
>>143101215
This. Literally nobody likes Homura. Everything she did was terrible and with cruel intentions. She's a pathetic waste of life and her grisly death will be Madoka's fondest memory.
>>
>>143101215
>using the t. meme the wrong way

Fucking dummy Mamifags. Don't you have a friend to kill?
>>
>>143093375
Daily reminder that this is your dose of salt
>>
File: 1427820898739.png (472 KB, 450x450) Image search: [Google]
1427820898739.png
472 KB, 450x450
>>143101283
>Mami
>having a friend
>>
File: 1430423372901.png (6 KB, 369x311) Image search: [Google]
1430423372901.png
6 KB, 369x311
>>143098941
>>
File: 0fc6eb3d7aff10a9a0632c265788e785.jpg (198 KB, 1240x1754) Image search: [Google]
0fc6eb3d7aff10a9a0632c265788e785.jpg
198 KB, 1240x1754
>>143101283
>Homura is back, check out her horse
>>
Is the viewer supposed to see Homura as a hero?

She did fuck up the Incubators
>>
File: 1393796801096.png (201 KB, 550x782) Image search: [Google]
1393796801096.png
201 KB, 550x782
>>143101310
>mami's friend
>>
>>143101487
The guy who drew these deserves a fucking medal. Hot Fuzz is the shit.
>>
>>143101504
She gave everyone their lives and loved ones back. It's up to you to decide whether her methods make her a villain or hero.
>>
>>143101535
Yeah, I love that movie
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-lcqIuVaR8
>>
File: image.jpg (96 KB, 1191x670) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
96 KB, 1191x670
>>143096571
I'm a Jew, and I don't hate her. I'm just disappointed in her, that's all.
>>
File: 1461379999203.jpg (133 KB, 441x600) Image search: [Google]
1461379999203.jpg
133 KB, 441x600
>>143101797
fuck off kike
>>
>>143093375

"perfect" nigga, that show looks like a damn 3 year old drew it. Those dudes at shaft got their daughters to draw the characters and animate the entire show.
>>
>>143101797
>disappointed in her when she gave everyone a happier life
Even Madoka's song is about how she's so lonely and sad having the role of the LoC.
>>
>>143093375
Yeah Rebellion was total jew milking shit.

I wish they would let this series end already and leave the characters alone. The TV series end was just fine. Anything after was just created due to Aniplex jew kings realizing that anything involving the the characters prints money.

Ideally they should have ended it right at the TV series and let the movies be about new characters.
>>
>>143101855
>let the movies be about new characters.
how?

madoka was central to the universe
>>
>>143101849
This. The only person worse off after Rebellion is Homura.
>>
>>143102105
>The only person worse off after Rebellion is Homura.
how? she has madoka and power now
>>
File: image.gif (746 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
image.gif
746 KB, 1000x1000
>>143101820
Fuck off /pol/.
>>
File: image.jpg (315 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
315 KB, 1920x1080
>>143102248
>she has Madoka
Nope. She rebuilt a world where Madoka can be safe and happy. Madoka probably thinks Homu is creepy as fuck and wouldn't be friends with her.
>>
>>143102248
She has power. She doesn't have Madoka. She lives with the fear Madoka will leave her again and hate her.
>>
>>143102818
Creepy as fuck yes, but I think Madoka is nice enough to be her friend. It would be more like their pre-episode 10 relationship though: awkward and uncomfortable.
>>
>>143102894
Awkward and uncomfortable for Madoka, painful for Homura.
>>
>>143103002
Exactly like the series then. The difference is Homura can end it whenever she wants. Madoka will probably be somewhere between upset and disappointed, but Madoka hating someone is absurd.
>>
>>143102818
All the points in her wish were fulfilled in the movie by her own hand.

She denied herself paradise with madoka because deep inside she is moemura a girl who is weak, shy, with low self confidence who feels she doesn't deserve happiness.
>>
>>143103922
Probably the only character who deserves happiness.
>>
File: EjJopdb.jpg (16 KB, 600x600) Image search: [Google]
EjJopdb.jpg
16 KB, 600x600
>>143093375
>>
You mean was the anime that the most wasted by its ending before rebellion. Rebellion nicely saved it from crap statut.
>>
>>143095060
Rebellion also made more sense character-wise. "Uhr I've wasted my whole live trying so save someone but I accept to let her die just because because of 2 sentences in 5 minutes". Pre-rebellion Homura was seriously ridiculous in the last episodes of the show, which is even worse because she's the closest thing to a protagonist the show has. Her characterization is pretty much "Madoka > the whole world" during the whole show and she makes a 180 out of nowhere in 5 minutes just because a girl with a Jesus complex asked her to be ok with it. It could have worked if everything wasn't done in one fucking episode at the end, but the show without rebellion really screwed with Homura's character.
>>
>>143095585
/f/ pls
>>
>>143104446
>Her characterization is pretty much "Madoka > the whole world" during the whole show
Well to be fair, stopping Madoka from contracting was saving the world.

I don't think she accepted it as much as she had no ability to stop it. She was crying and pleading with Madoka the whole time and the manga version is even more upfront about it. Rebellion gave her a chance to restart everything and she took it.
>>
File: 1444162249201.jpg (446 KB, 800x1000) Image search: [Google]
1444162249201.jpg
446 KB, 800x1000
Homura is the coolest. The epitome of a female alpha.
>>
>>143093375
I wish Rebellion just ended before the last 10 minutes.

It would have been better if Homura was just taken by the Law of the Cycles and put out of her misery.
>>
>>143105280
>ugly
>smelly
>untalented
>unloved
>borderline retarded
>failure
>literally did everything wrong

Literally the feminist stereotype in 2D. Only worse.
>>
>>143102894
The opposite would be out of character for Madoka, we're talking about the girl who loves the whole world so much that she used a wish that could grant everything to save a cat. Madoka is like a complete all-loving hero mixed with someone with a Jesus complex, so not being friend with someone just because "she's creepy" would be weird as hell.

True enough, it'd be hell for Homura. Which is kind of the point of the movie if you think about it.
>>
>>143105280
She's flawed, which is what makes the character more interesting than most of the others (granted, they all have their flaws,, but theyalso have a LOT less screen time) IMO
>>
>>143105413
She's cute
Probably not smelly
Very talented
Loved by Madoka very much
Highly intelligent
Amazing girl
Saved the world many times over
>>
>>143096547
All of this aside, because a good part of this is complete bullshit, it doesn't go against the idea that she wouldd hate herself for it. Damn, it's one of the main subjects of the movie, if it wasn't clear enough already.
>>
>>143105280
She became the firm, decisive woman that gets Madoka wet by reminding her of her mother. Now Madoka just needs to remember that conversation about doing something wrong to balance out one's dumbass friends need to be right and then she'll realize Homura was never her enemy.
>>
>>143105548
>Probably not smelly
Her poop probably smells like lilac.
>>
>>143105653
It amazesme how people tend to think that wanting to sacrifice yourself constantly even if it's not needed = right. Hell, the movie doesn't even show Homura as being ""nice"" about it or liking it, and despite it she gets hit by half of the fandom because she doesn't agree with a useless sacrifice without even the benefit of doubt. Despite what you said that was made very clear by the anime many time.
>>
File: what up youtube youtube.png (269 KB, 632x626) Image search: [Google]
what up youtube youtube.png
269 KB, 632x626
>>143105280
well she obviously smokes weed so she is pretty cool
>>
>>143105772
It's a NEED to be right. Madoka believes she's only useful when she's sacrificing for others. They both suffer from cripplingly low self esteem and think their lives aren't worth anything. And that doesn't even get into Madoka only being able to make that sacrifice because of Homura.

Now of course, the downside is that only when Madoka makes her sacrifice does she actually appreciate Homura. Of course, Homura doesn't care about appreciation. She wants Madoka to be happy.
>>
>>143106130
Yes. I'm thinking about the fandom here. From an outside PoV it's easy to see that both of them can be seen as "wrong", but instead of this there's an huge split between which one is OBJECTIVELY RIGHT when in the end from an outsider PoV they're both awkward girls with obvious issues.
>>
>>143106225
Got it. I think it's because people miss key points in Madoka. I'm not completely sure why, because they're stated multiple times verbatim, but the fandom (especially Tumblr) has a hard time accepting there just aren't any clear good or bad guys in this series. The fact there are people who think Sayaka is unrionically supposed to be a hero of justice shows you how badly some of the fandom interprets the show.
>>
Who cares about character popularity?

Madoka isn't a regular heroine show
>>
>>143104446
I thought the original ending lined up perfectly. Homura already spent most of her time away and distant from Madoka, fighting on her behalf. Madoka was more like a cause Homura would never stop fighting for at that point.

That's why they had to make up some incubator intervention plot point for rebellion. Homura would simply never believably be defeated in any normal way.
>>
File: image.jpg (607 KB, 849x1200) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
607 KB, 849x1200
>>143105813
She strikes me as more of a cigarette smoker. She probably stops time so she can grab them from behind the counters.
>>
File: 41874384.jpg (52 KB, 537x593) Image search: [Google]
41874384.jpg
52 KB, 537x593
>>143110380
Hasn't she done enough?
Doesn't she deserve, at long last, to rest?
>>
>>143109862
I always imagined that Homura will refuse Madoka's salvation long before rebellion happened. She isn't a character who can possibly die.
And all these talks about killing her in a sequel is pure trash. Even if sequel happens(which I doubt) Homura will never die, will never regret about anything or will never apologize
>>
>>143110609
>Always refuse salvation
Why? It literally required seperating Madoka from the Law of Cycles, giving her amnesia, and the Incubators putting together a plot to capture god. To call it a natural conclusion ignores that the entire situation was anything but natural.
>>
File: image.jpg (392 KB, 1920x1237) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
392 KB, 1920x1237
>>143110609
>Homura will never die, will never regret about anything or will never apologize
I thought the suicide imagery and externalizing her self-hatred was pretty clear she isn't happy with what she did. She probably doesn't regret it because it was for Madoka, but she's torn apart y it for sure.
>>
File: 1444991944030.jpg (30 KB, 480x554) Image search: [Google]
1444991944030.jpg
30 KB, 480x554
>>143105413
Those are opposites of Homura.
>>
Why aren't there doujinshi of Madoka fucking Mami or a guy while insulting Homura and telling her she'll never be worthy of her love or body?
>>
>>143110955
Homura simply has typical bipolar disorder. Her suicide depressive episode quickly changes to manic episode where she thinks how awesome she is and becomes god. She would suffer, if she wasn't able to do it. But she does.
>>
>>143111828
Also I'm pretty sure that person with the same disorder (Urobuchi?) helped to write her character.
>>
rebellion a shit
>>
I'm melting. I wish Sayaka was real so she could cool me down with magic.
>>
File: 51817053_p2_master1200.jpg (73 KB, 354x354) Image search: [Google]
51817053_p2_master1200.jpg
73 KB, 354x354
>>143114374
She'd probably set you on fire on accident. She's a baka.
>>
>>143114512
She's not that much of a baka! Plus she doesn't have that power!
>>
File: 1377794781984.gif (431 KB, 500x425) Image search: [Google]
1377794781984.gif
431 KB, 500x425
>>143114598
I don't think she has cooling powers either.
>>
File: 1436075843897.jpg (148 KB, 816x1083) Image search: [Google]
1436075843897.jpg
148 KB, 816x1083
>>143114598
She might grab a hold of a lighter or something. Sayaka is a bona-fide baka.
>>
File: an apple in a pickle.jpg (152 KB, 670x517) Image search: [Google]
an apple in a pickle.jpg
152 KB, 670x517
Okatavia = Lawnchair
Kyouko = Apple
Sayaka = Kevin
>>
File: image.png (2 MB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
image.png
2 MB, 800x600
>>
File: 1464481921023.png (593 KB, 800x1200) Image search: [Google]
1464481921023.png
593 KB, 800x1200
I want to breed with Madoka, I want to fertilise Madoka's womb, I want to give her my babies.

I want to hold onto her tight little hips as I thrust inside of her, as she wraps her legs around my back and as I do the mating press to create a big family with her.
>>
>Homura compared to Darth Vader by Urobuchi
>Swan Lake motif for new project
>Every girl in entire the franchise has ultimately been redeemed

Are there people who seriously believe Homura isn't going to be redeemed and be walked Homu gently to the Law of Cycles by Madoka?
>>
>>143105413
That's clearly Sayaka
>>
>>143102818
>Still being buthurt delusional
Your tears in every thread will be fucking delicious
>>
>>143110955
The self suicide imaginary is not regret, Its the same as she always do, to protect Madoka. She want to die in order to prevent incubator from prying into Madoka secret. So its suicide with determination, not a rant drama bitch like Sayaka.
>>
>>143111744
Because people don't have a pleb taste like you, stay buthurt forever, alone
>>
>>143118927
You can feel guilt and remorse for an action yet still accept that it was the best possible course of action. Homura hates the idea that she may one day become enemies with Madoka and that Madoka will never understand her actions, but she also believes this was the only way to protect Madoka.
>>
ai yo
>>
>>143118927
That is a good point though. The Incubators are a consistent threat and I will not be surprised when they make a come back due to the choas caused by Homura fighting the girls aligned with the Law of Cycles.
>>
File: homu kitty.jpg (224 KB, 1100x1114) Image search: [Google]
homu kitty.jpg
224 KB, 1100x1114
>>143105413
First three are absolute bullshit.
Fourth kind of true, considering Madoka is the only apparent person who is shown to like her at all. Plus her parents are nowhere in sight.
Next three are bullshit.
>>
File: homura has autism 3.jpg (234 KB, 500x700) Image search: [Google]
homura has autism 3.jpg
234 KB, 500x700
>>143109966
Gotta have something to calm those nerves. Repeating timelines is stressful shit.
>>
>>143116007
Then who's Akemi?
>>
>>143118141
>the mating press
That is legitimately the most autistic thing I've read.
>>
>>143095187
>Homura goes through cycle after cycle to save Madoka
>fails in the end because Madoka become a goddess to save the world
>decides to settle for that end, unsatisfactory as it is, because she probably couldn't get a better one with more resets
>has to live in the better world created by Madoka becoming god, without Madoka, as the only person who knows why everyone can enjoy their lives as much as they manage to
>happy ending
>>
>>143093375
Too bad you'll only ever convince like 0,5% people of that, since the other 99,5% don't understand storytelling on even the most elementary level. Even concepts like "plothole" and "out of character" are lost on these retards.
>>
File: 1420855150473.png (180 KB, 706x677) Image search: [Google]
1420855150473.png
180 KB, 706x677
>>143095981
>>
File: learntofilter.png (7 KB, 561x301) Image search: [Google]
learntofilter.png
7 KB, 561x301
>>143097602
Thread replies: 228
Thread images: 77

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.