[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
I don't think this show is cool anymore.
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 134
Thread images: 19
I don't think this show is cool anymore.
>>
i dropped it a while ago too. Zombie stories never outlast zombies becoming fodder.
>>
>>142883736
It gets even more special snowflakey? Awful. I dropped it the minute I realised it's pseudo SnK of the season.

We could have had pseudo-tokugawa period steampunk samurai fignting against monstrosities, instead we got this.
>>
>>142883736
It's been going downhill since the second episode. Worse than Aot honestly.
>>
>>142883736
It stopped being cool when we got yet another "but humans are the real evil" sort of shit.
>>
>>142883736
It was always shit. The only good episode was the SoL episode.
>>
desu i've dropped everything this season except re:zero and the only reason i'm still watching that is because novelfags have hyped arc 2 all the way to hell.
>>
i'm mad that they get steam and railway technology wrong simply because the director is lazy and doesn't care. there's no point complaining about zombies because those aren't real, but all this other shit? pop riveting a boiler? a steam leak so hot that it's not even condensing, yet it doesn't flay their skin and cook their lungs or even suffocate everyone in the carriage, and he fixes it by shoving it back into place? trains accelerating and braking with the momentum of a family sedan, speeding around radiuses that would have derailed a loco that long at a walking pace?
fucking cogfops. bunch of poofters.
>>
>>142883736

Should have listened to all the people telling you that it's going to be shit since episode one.

All the signs were there.
>>
>>142884593

Retarded shonenfags like you should be executed.
>>
>>142885120


i'm just having a rough time anon
>>
>>142883736
Once it stopped being solely about fighting zombies, it went to hell
>>
>>142883736
It went from looking better than SnK, to being even worse than it. I would drop it, but with only three episodes left I want to see the train crash with no survivors, so that I'll learn to never give Okouchi a chance again.
>>
File: 1463531406944.jpg (152 KB, 872x1280) Image search: [Google]
1463531406944.jpg
152 KB, 872x1280
Once it stopped being about Mumei's delicious-yet-strangely-inconsistent-in-proportions-body, it went to shit, and no amount of fapfics can salvage this show but at least you tried anon
>>
>>142883736
>thinking it was ever cool
>thinking steam punk in japan is cool
>thinking any zombie type story is cool
this thing was stupid from a mile away. How dense are you? i thought even a retard would see that moncycle shit was retarded
>>
>>142884593
>listening to novel fags
You never learn, do you.
>>
>>142885728
>thinking steam punk in japan is cool
It is cool, you tasteless pleb. Kabaneri being shit at making good use of its setting doesn't stop the concept being cool.
>>
steampunk sucks and so do you
>>
>>142883736
It could've been great, but the quality is all over the place. I feel like they conceived it as a 24 ep show and had to cut it down to 12.
>>
Steampunk is gay world war 1 for retarded people.
>>
>>142883736
>Grumpy sexy machinist took a sword in the chest for her lady.
>tragedy because best loyal girl dies.

It's still fukken awesome.
>>
>>142883736
I don't understand problems with magical zombies people suddenly have
>>142884517
Except it's not humans are evil but Biba and his underlings are.
>>
>>142884138
>I realised
This was clear from the start, prime retard.
>>
>>142883736
It dropped the ball really fucking hard in the last two episodes,the MC became an insufferable piece of shit and bibi is cartoonishly evil.
>>
Will the producers punish the staff for introducing Biba and making the preorders tank?
>>
>>142883736
>it's becoming popular so I hate it
Go back to your containment threads
>>>/re:shitro/
>>
>>142887460
>cartoonishly evil
Same goes for real life people like Hillary, David Cameron and Kim Jong Il. It's over the top, but those people exist in real life
>>
Power level escalation has just been fucking dumb.
>>
>>142887395
>fukken
>>>/kindergarten/
>>>/reddit/
>>>/tumblr/
>>
This show had a really great scene in about Episode 4 I think it was, where the characters had to deal with zombies slowly crawling to the front from the back of the train.

It was a really great way of creating tension, using the setting in a smart way, and confining spectacle and action to small places. Even the colony thing wasn't too contrived as it allowed you to ramp up the action to one focused more on the train as a whole instead of merely compartments within it.

From that we've moved to a retarded villain who's motives are completely unintelligible, zombie lasers and crazy escalation.

How can anyone be so unaware of what makes a show good and escalate it in the space of 3 episodes to just another generic anime. It was an excellent pulpy horror action before and now it's power level shit where characters act illogical and 100 Frodos are created for the sake of pointless shit happening.

How. How can anyone ruin something this, it's like it was intentional.
>>
>>142888786
The entire thing is that Biba wants to take advantage of the zombie bullshit to get revenge because he's an angry man child.
>>
>>142888786
>How. How can anyone ruin something this, it's like it was intentional.
Okuchi is a very shitty writer and should be ignored by this point
>>
>>142884467
why do people hate AoT, seriously
>>
>>142888923
Because it's shit?
>>
>>142888786
>How can anyone be so unaware of what makes a show good and escalate it in the space of 3 episodes

The show is only one cour and the final arc has five episodes in total. The scale of the action hasn't really changed since we've seen station-wide threats from the beginning .

>From that we've moved to a retarded villain who's motives are completely unintelligible

Except they're transparent as fuck. Doesn't make him right, but you need to be a moron to not get it.
>>
>>142888786
So you missed all the blatantly unsubtle scenes where the characters have been acting like stupid teenagers before this point?

I don't think you understand what "pulp" means if you're complaining about a bigger threat entirely predictably showing up at the end.
>>
>>142884467
This has more in common with Resident Evil than Attack on Titan, honestly.
>>
>>142885667
The only thing it did better than SnK was not taking whole episodes to move an entire rock.

Everything else was just about the same, which was their plan all along. Doesn't matter if you have Okouchi or someone else working on it. Nothing would change their game plan.

Train's not going to crash with no survivors either. It'll be a generic shonen adventure happy ending. Which anyone with a brain could have foretold once it was confirmed this wouldn't have more episodes.
>>
>>142888923
2D characters driven by one motive whose main selling point (according to fanboys) is that anyone can die when it's only ever redshirts introduced 1-3 chapters prior. I heard Armin died recently, but that's it.
>>
>>142887483
Only if the pre-orders don't pick up by the end of the show, which might well happen, and it'll still sell 9k even in the worst case scenario.
>>
>>142885180
It was always about fighting zombies and dealing with humans being stupid.
>>
>>142886167
And even Kabaneri did about as much as you could do with this setting in 12 episodes. You'd need more episodes to do much more.
>>
>>142887395
She didn't die. Girl is in the previews.

>>142887460
MC was already loud about his idealism shtick even before the last two eps.
>>
>>142887645
There's literally only one being capable of escalating and she's dead. Everyone else has remained at the same level.
>>
>>142889559
Ironically, even SnK is going for "PERHAPS HUMANS ARE THE REAL THREAT" after all. Just with more time to build that up.
>>
Biba and Horobi sucked.

Don't have an issue with the rest.
>>
>>142889559
that's what fanboys makes it look like if you really think that's what it's about then you don't know how to watch anime
>>
>>142889070
be a little grown up, will you? you act like a kid who can't even explain himself
>>
>>142889466
That woman specifically reminded me the most of Kerrigan in StarCraft.
>>
>>142889856
cry about snk fanboy
>>
YAMEROOOOOOOOO!

Seriously, Ikoma is so over-the-top it's just flat out entertaining.
>>
>>142888923
>Fujoshit
>Story is bad
>Characters are bad (only one or two are good)
>Full of cliche, writing is very bad
>Bad manga art
>Shounen cliche fights (in the last chapter)
How old are you anon ?
>>
>>142890672
>How old are you anon ?
You think he will be honest
Ahahahah
>>
>>142883736
It started meh, I started liking it after the characters stopped acting like massive faggots and Mumei stopped being a retarded bitch, and then it instantly went to shit when they introduced Biba. Too bad, I thought it might end up being decent.
>>
>>142883736
This show stopped being cool when the dumbfuck villagers were ready to lynch the kabaneri duo for killing the pregnant zombie when just an episode before they were indiscriminately willing to kill people just for standing near a zombie.
>>
>>142889600
People can cancel preorders you know? I sure as fuck would after seeing the last two episodes.
>>
File: 1464037414866.jpg (68 KB, 600x724) Image search: [Google]
1464037414866.jpg
68 KB, 600x724
Remember when was about fetish fuel?
Is it all over now?
>>
>>142891799
I'd understand cancelling after the last one, but again...it's not over until the fat lady sings. If I were buying this, I'd wait to see how they end it.
>>
>>142892089
I know what you mean, but release is a week away. If they want to cancel it's now or never. Now you and me both know that the ending is going to be shit because this retarded faggot they introduced is the villain now and there's nothing that can be done about it. If I were a nip I wouldn't risk buying this before the three last episodes because it's unlikely they'll fix this mess.
>>
File: 1412145299838.png (60 KB, 250x250) Image search: [Google]
1412145299838.png
60 KB, 250x250
I literally said this was going to happen after episode 1 but you all called me faggots
>>
>>142889737
well it makes sense in the SnK sense since humans created the titans or something
>>
>>142892331
Wait until they reveal the kabane are a failed experiment to make super soldiers or something.

Can this show get any worse at this point?
>>
>>142890376
I think that Ikoma is a distant ancestor of Kamina. Both scream all the time and both use red capes.
>>
>>142884138
>I dropped it the minute I realised it's pseudo SnK of the season
How in the fuck did it take you 10 episodes to "realise" that?
>>
>>142892262
Half of /a/ said this show was going to suck, dumbass.

Just because of the okouchi is shit meme.
>>
File: 1409781678021.jpg (307 KB, 1104x1104) Image search: [Google]
1409781678021.jpg
307 KB, 1104x1104
>>142892494
well yeah that's 100% going to happen, any retard could see that coming.
>>
>>142888923
It's popular.
>>
fuqq yuo gaise I just watched ep9 and didn't even look away it was so awesome
>>
File: 231231414235235.jpg (8 KB, 237x288) Image search: [Google]
231231414235235.jpg
8 KB, 237x288
>>142885050
k
>>
>>142892560
Stop lying, anon.

90% of Kabaneri threads were major circlejerks at the beginning of the season: "AOT PREMIUM GUISE HURR DURR"

See where we at, now.
>>
File: 4kurusu.png (556 KB, 806x864) Image search: [Google]
4kurusu.png
556 KB, 806x864
Kabane?
>>
File: 1440509342834.jpg (74 KB, 1191x670) Image search: [Google]
1440509342834.jpg
74 KB, 1191x670
>>142892494
I´m not saying Kabane are aliens, but they are aliens.
>>
File: 15616546541.png (2 MB, 1920x1090) Image search: [Google]
15616546541.png
2 MB, 1920x1090
>>142892644
Was getting stabbed part of your plan?
>>
why is high school of the dead the only enemy horde anime that stays about the main characters fighting monsters the entire time without pulling stupid shit?
>>
>>142892175
To be honest, I don't think the end will be anything special. Not great, but I can see a lot of "meh" ways they could end it that won't cause much drama. Kill faggot boy or cripple him, yay!
>>
>>142892494
Why would that be a problem?

The Kabane did not originate within Japan.

Something had to happen for them to come to exist.

Zombies being the product of man mucking with nature isn't a rare idea.
>>
>>142892494
It's because of this attitude that I'd rather they not explain anything. You'd still bitch about the lack of info, but whatever. No answer would satisfy your edginess.
>>
>>142892494
They'd just be ripping off SnK all the way, so that wouldn't be getting worse. No difference.
>>
>>142892633
All that proves is both extremes are idiotic.

No, show was never all that great. And no, it's not all that horrible either. Just mediocre.
>>
Shogunate = Law
Biba and co. = Chaos
Ikoma = Neutral
Kabane = Demons

Things got interesting.
>>
>>142892760

Because HOTD is based on a manga that is on hiatus. Its completely unfinished. If they ever actually decide to bring it to a final conclusion, don't be surprised if they do make more of an emphasis on humanity being evil (which they didn't completely skip with that creepy guy, so they could go back to it).
>>
>>142892760
Don't you remember the sensei fucking all the schoolgirls in his group? And the EMP from a nuclear explosion frying the bus' electronics, causing him to crash into a barrier that was supposed to ward off zombies?

HotD was stupid too, but it was openly so from the beginning and celebrated its own trashiness.
>>
>>142884467
Nah, it's better than SnK on the grounds that it doesn't look like absolute cancer.
>>
>>142893332
This isn't that different, outside of the lack of fanservice comparatively speaking.
>>
>>142883736
>mfw I saw this coming from episode one

Told you so.
>>
File: shiina01.gif (3 MB, 250x255) Image search: [Google]
shiina01.gif
3 MB, 250x255
>all these BTFO Horobifags
>>
>>142889559
RIP Petra ;_;
>>
>>142889559
>2D characters
Yeah, anime/manga characters often tend to be 2D

>whose main selling point (according to fanboys) is that anyone can die
It's just the fanbois, anon: the show/manga itself has never been advertised as such, so the main selling point is clearly somewhere else.
>>
>>142885050
I can't believe someone actually cares about steampunk besides the look the actual mechanics involved. Well done.
I'm liking it. Mumei being a shit was a major plot point and Biba being a shit was the next one. The whole science magic thing has been flying out the window since episode one.
Its style over substance. As long as you don't take it seriously its a great show.
As long as you don't compare it to SnK either.
>>
>>142892539
Where did he say it took him 10 episodes? Maybe he dropped it after the first and is checking to see how bad it got.
>>
>>142893332
>Don't you remember the sensei fucking all the schoolgirls in his group? And the EMP from a nuclear explosion frying the bus' electronics, causing him to crash into a barrier that was supposed to ward off zombies?

>HotD was stupid too, but it was openly so from the beginning and celebrated its own trashiness.

There is a massive difference between cartoonishly evil pretty boy with an army Biba, and cartoonishly evil rather pathetic guy who can control teenagers by letting them do whatever they want high school teacher.

Even when the teacher does evil stuff, it is mostly out of his control. Everything Biba does is keikaku doori for absolutely no reasons. The teacher crashing the bus into the barrier was something caused by circumstances beyond his control and natural to the setting (countries going nuclear on each other when in an extreme situation).


What I´m trying to say here is that HOTD had a plot that flowed more naturally than the one in this piece of shit.

Also, it promised tits and ass, and we got it by the ton. Kabaneri is just disappointing in comparison.
>>
>>142891835
>>142885668
The fanart for this show more than justifies its existence.
>>
>>142885728
>thinking any zombie type story is cool
I still like 28 Days Later.
Haven't watched Korean Desk Car yet, but it seems popular. Probably not cool, though.
>>
>>142895285
That just sounds like a gigantic double standard on your part.

The only difference is one of them is an endgame threat while the other isn't, mostly because there is NO endgame to speak of in the HOTD source material.

That's it. If there was, he'd be an incredibly likely and very obvious candidate for a final boss.

There's nothing less "natural" about either of both cartoonishly evil characters. And Biba does have a reason. It doesn't make him any less evil or cartoonish, but it's there.

The only thing I'll give you is that HOTD did deliver more fanservice. Kabaneri never really went that far with it.
>>
>>142895285
Teacher = childish hedonism
Liberator = childish revenge
>>
>>142895463
>Haven't watched Korean Desk Car yet, but it seems popular
Not a zombie story, and I don't even know what gave you that idea. It's like saying Touhou is a zombie story because there are zombies in Gensokyo.
>>
>>142890376
If only the whole show had been just about him
>>
>>142895748
All I know about it is it has zombie in the name and that white haired, armored qt.
>>
>>142895922
It's your typical LN bullshit about a regular high school student (with a single male friend who is also a pervert) having a bunch of fantasy girls come into his life: a vampire nina, a magical girl, a necromancer and whatever else. By the second cour they already completely gave up the pretense of it having a story.
>>
>>142892494
Resident Evil did it. Wesker and Nemesis were mistakes
>>
>>142893002
>you will never see HotD jump sharks where Saeko can cute a skyscraper in half and the fat guy becomes an improbable Golgo tier sniper

Matrix boobs were only the beginning.
>>
>>142894988
>"so the main selling point is clearly somewhere else"
>doesn't even know what it is

nice post retard
>>
>>142885180
dont get why japan cant have just one fucking man vs monster story without having to shoehorn their "humans are the real monster" meme every fucking time
>>
File: Yes anon, it's titans.jpg (129 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
Yes anon, it's titans.jpg
129 KB, 1280x720
>>142898015
>implying I don't know what that is

I shouldn't need to spell it out for you to know what that is, you imbecile. Just look at the fucking merchandise, ads, fanarts, theme parks, crossovers and whatnot that were spawned by the TV series to get your answer.
>>
>>142888923
For me? Lost Syndrome. You can only raise so many questions before you need answers, and raising too many is not an excuse if they end up being unsatisfactory.
>>
>>142885668
Bring back the gaijin
>>
>>142899105
Well, it was the first season of a show that'll probably end up being 75 episodes long, so already diagnosing a case of Lost Syndrome seems like a bit premature conclusion.
Plus, the last important questions will be raised and major answers will be provided over the course of the second season.
>>
>>142885728
>thinking steam punk in japan is cool
What a pleb.
>>
what the fug were they thinking with that motorcycle battalion?
>>
>>142890725
>overestimating underage fags
Many a time i have seen them do it anon, they are that autistic.
>>
>>142890672
That's wrong, actually:
>plot is good
>characters are good
>writing is good
>art is good
>>
File: 2011-snow-bike-test-19.jpg (304 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
2011-snow-bike-test-19.jpg
304 KB, 1024x768
>>142900645
half-bike-half-snowmobile where they couldn't quite decide if it was a snowtrack or a kettenkrad, and if you actually built one the way they drew it the track width would prevent it from leaning on hard surfaces and so it wouldn't even be able to turn unless there was deep snow and even then the front wheel would dig in, so maybe they're meant for sand dunes? endless-tide-of-zombie dunes?
it's consistent with every other time this shitshow imported a cool looking machine and glossed over the boring, restrictive realities of operating it.
>>
>>142902174
If you truly believe any of these you need to die.
>>
Has this show ever shown a single person reloading a gun with bullets? What are they shooting, magical energy? And why are they saying that zombies have a steel cage around their heart when it's magical crystal?
>>
>>142890672
Damn anon, you sure told him with your flawless arguments.
>>
File: yes that's a clip-fed machinegun.jpg (966 KB, 2500x1504) Image search: [Google]
yes that's a clip-fed machinegun.jpg
966 KB, 2500x1504
>>142902262
i'd guess they fire some sort of large caliber pellet made of condensed bullshit. japan has always been the world leader in stupid gun design.
supposedly it's steam in the bottles attached to the guns, although if you filled a bottle that size with superheated steam and didn't use it within minutes you'd have roasted asscheeks and a bottle of vacuum.

hey maybe they're trying to fight the zombies with literal airshit
>>
Are stalker threads banned?

I want to know how many preorders were cancelled.
>>
>>142888923
bad writing?
cliche characters?
zero development?
terrible pacing?
bad art?
bad design?
plot stolen from a just as shitty VN?
Short of Tetsurou Araki's directing in season1, and only season1, there's not really any reason not to hate it. It's garbage.
>>
>>142906172
Wrong
>>
>>142906172
>plot stolen from a just as shitty VN?
?????
>>
>>142888923
Personally I don't hate it, but it really has cardboard cut-out characters and inexcusably awful pacing.
>>
File: causality conductor_alternative.png (400 KB, 1088x768) Image search: [Google]
causality conductor_alternative.png
400 KB, 1088x768
>>142906326
Probably talking about MuvLuv Alternative, which isn't nearly as shitty as AoT.
>>
File: Oni_Soul_Samanosuke.png (347 KB, 559x612) Image search: [Google]
Oni_Soul_Samanosuke.png
347 KB, 559x612
Unfortunately, I feel this is as close as I'll ever get to an Onimusha anime.
>>
>>142906380
People complain about aot with "muh pacing" but compared to other shounen I don't see how its any slower
>>
>>142906536
It isn't, but that's a large part of why most shounen are shit too.
>>
>>142883736
>he thought the show was cool
>>
>>142906417

God yes it is.

MuvLuv is just as shit, if not worse, because SnK was at LEAST original at the start where as MuvLuv is 'oh hey mechs vs aliens' which has been a constant anime theme since at least Gunbuster/Diebuster.

SnK went to shit when it stopped being the 'anyone can die' and jumped the gun with LOLPEOPLEARETITANSTOO shit.

I dont mind titans being super weapons.
I don't mind the political intrigue and infighting.

The single worst part of SnK was making it a thing that the humans could become titans which then negated the entire appeal of 'guys on ziplines fighting giant man eating monsters where the entire cast can die'.

But as normal, Japan cannot keep an interesting and consistent theme in a series and devolves into shit as soon as they try to make it more interesting because they have no modicum of self control.

Could have easily skipped the ERIN IS A TITANLOL shit and gone to the Recon group doing their shit and revealing that unique titans exist. Then they could have gone on to formulate strategies to deal with said unique titans.

Or just jumped straight to the political shit.
>>
>>142887505
>no mention of Donald Trumo, literally a cartoon villain
0/10
>>
File: Billy Cellphone Smile.jpg (8 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
Billy Cellphone Smile.jpg
8 KB, 480x360
>>142893951
Is that Ghetsis in OP pic, I'm from Catalog.
>>
Has anyone read fortress of the apocalypse? It had some high notes despite having a lot of HotD like trashines / edginesd. Got a little boring and eded up dropping it after some timem
>>
>>142907483
Thats the prison zombie one right? Was pretty good until mc became zombie jesus.
>>
>>142907776
Even after that there where some memorable scenes like the ride along the coast line when they see the seal-humans on the beach. It feelt very eerie and outwordish.

I cant really pinpoint where it whent bad; I just think it wasnt really good to beging with, I just reached a point when I had my fill and was ok with it. The sotory didnt had any real depth so the author was forced to pkay all his cards straight and use cheesy action scens to carry the plot forward.
>>
>>142887460
>>142889684
MC has such ideal and it's even factually proven to be realizable right off the bat, which makes him better than most of the shonen MCs.
The problem now is most likely that we don't get the same impression we got from episode 2 ever since episode 3.
Thread replies: 134
Thread images: 19

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.