[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Okay be honest
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 76
Thread images: 10
File: fz.jpg (16 KB, 293x234) Image search: [Google]
fz.jpg
16 KB, 293x234
What did you think of this?
>>
The entire Fate franchise belongs in the trash.
>>
It was okay
>>
>>142125682
it was the most entertaining one
>>
LiSA, Eir Aoi, Kalafina, and Luna Haruna are based theme song singers.
>>
>>142125682
The first good anime since NGE
>>
>>142125682
Overrated
>>
>>142125682

It shouldn't have stayed the night.
>>
>>142125682
Only good thing about the Fate franchise
>>
File: tumblr_nox1x29WzM1r2g7mto1_500.jpg (36 KB, 500x281) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_nox1x29WzM1r2g7mto1_500.jpg
36 KB, 500x281
>>142125682
Edge.
>>
Badly paced
>>
>>142125714
Took the words out of my mouth, fuck this hot garbage.
>>
>>142125682
Somniferkino with overrated animation
>>
>>142125682
I can't hate it since it was the first thing Fate related I watched. I read the VN just after and get hooked.
>>
>>142125815
>>142125893
Plebeians
>>
>>142126017
Tsukihime is alright because of how campy it is but Fate takes itself too seriously and people take it too seriously for how trash it is.
>>
File: image.gif (282 KB, 500x280) Image search: [Google]
image.gif
282 KB, 500x280
>>142125682
I have watched over 1500 aniem in my neetlife and this is still one of my favourites anime.
My little guilty pleasure
>>
I struggle to decide who was the best character.

The priest or Rider.
>>
It was great, but decade+ running TM fanboys won't admit it because it's both Urobutcher and not muh Nasu with sex scenes and mollusk analogies. Zero elevated the franchise to a higher standard than the VN strove to be, and that pissed the everloving fuck out of the original fanbase.

Even with ufotable putting their back into it with their F/SN remake, neutral newfags looking at them side and typically vastly prefer Zero. In other words, it's "way worse" than S/N if you openly admit to having a giant bias. Or you can at least say they're just both good.
>>
Watched it after reading the VN and that was very disapointing. Kiritsugu is garbage, the COORU team might as well not be here, Assassin never did anything besides getting killed early, Lancer was a shitty version of Cu, and Rider wasn't too bad but kept jobbing and teasing the fuck out of his noble phantasm. To summary the Zero exclusive characters are all really forgettable.

As for Saber and Gil, nothing really new. And Kotomine was way more interesting and fun in the Vn.
>>
>>142125682
Second half was weak and a bit of a letdown.
>>
>>142125682
The best writing and story to come out of that entire universe and franchise.
>>
>>142126799
Forgot Berserker, which was cool as fuck. But still, in the end his actions didn't amount to much. It's like he was just here to be an annoyance for the other servants.
>>
It was pretty great.

It usually looked good if not great, Urobuchi is a great writer. Team caster was dumb filler, but aside from that it was relatively flawless. I would have downplayed the cooky comedy aspect of team rider, and I would have taken some of the other character developments a little more slowly. Also, Rin would not have gotten a stupid fanservice episode.

But hey, you can't have everything.
>>
File: 1432591537188.gif (527 KB, 475x267) Image search: [Google]
1432591537188.gif
527 KB, 475x267
>>142126799
>VN is better than Zero

8/10
>>
>>142126799
My feelings were pretty similar. Loved the VN but F/Z just left me feeling disappointed on a whole.
>>
File: 18651.jpg (39 KB, 225x350) Image search: [Google]
18651.jpg
39 KB, 225x350
Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi, Gen Urobuchi.
>>
>>142127108
Nothing this guy has done is good. Except Saya no Uta
>>
>>142125682

First half was decent though nothing special. Second half things just went downhill followed by Kerry's stupidly large flashback then a rushed ending.

I've seen worse but overall it wasn't great.
>>
>>142125714
who even funds this shit? who even writes this shit? isn't nasu being hunted down by takashi takeushi's hired killers? is he dead yet?
>>
>>142125682
I thought the first half was pretty dry honestly. It was somewhat disappointing that given free reign over the grail war with powerful mages, Urobuchi decided to pussyfoot around with almost no meaningful conflict. If I wasn't already invested in the franchise I probably would have dropped it. Thankfully the 2nd half delivered and is great. The ending scene is one of my favorites in anime.
>>142126927
>forgetting about Paradox Spiral
>>
>>142127239
Shit taste abounds.
>>
>>142126799
A lot of your complaints sound just like stuff that happened in the VN.
>Assassin never did anything
>Lancer was shitty
>Rider wasn't too bad but kept jobbing and teasing
>>
File: 2453451124252223.webm (3 MB, 700x500) Image search: [Google]
2453451124252223.webm
3 MB, 700x500
Gil was chill enough to share his wine
berserker was a badass
love all the lancer hate on /a/
>>
>>142127568
>share his wine with berserker
When the fuck did this happen? Wasn't it with saber and rider?
>>
>>142127646
Learn to read.
>>
>>142127646

Gil didn't share his wine with Berserker, he's implying in a new sentence completely unrelated that Berserker is badass.
>>
>>142127568
Use Punctation.
Capitalize your sentences.
>>
>>142125682
It was nice to see some of the scenes from the LN animated but it was a shallow experience and skipped some of the best parts like Gil crying over Endiku when Saber was using Excalibur on Caster. The LN itself was rather good but it's not on the same level of quality as the original VN.
>>
>>142127670
My head made a "with" from nothing because you didn't put a poor "." On your phrase anon.
>>
>>142126780
>It was great, but decade+ running TM fanboys won't admit it
Rarely does any of us do that, most will agree it's at least as good or better than the VN. It's just that when secondaries spoil their appetite with Zero then start shitting on the original due to self-inflicted poor tonal shift, there's going to be a backlash.
>>
>>142127869
Don't try and shift blame to me for your idiocy.
>>
>>142128070
Ok sorry
>>
>>142127725
My bad!
Should I comment Sudoku?
>>
>>142125682
Edgy narcissistic bullshit

desu I liked Shiro's autism better at least he wasn't an edgelord.
>>
>>142127795
Heard the translation for the LN is beyond bad. Any word on ever getting a better one?
>>
File: 1462210973718.jpg (68 KB, 600x801) Image search: [Google]
1462210973718.jpg
68 KB, 600x801
>>142125682
I enjoyed it, it was fun. It had pretty lights and cute girls. I liked it for what it waseven though it's shit
>>
>>142127308
True Assassin did plenty, and even Kojiru tied into the imitation theme of UBW

Cu was great whenever he was on screen

Medusa's powers weren't teased anywhere like Iskander. If anything it was the opposite; she was seen as pretty shitty for 3/4th of the story. She only jobber in UBW.
>>
File: 107.jpg (650 KB, 1328x1481) Image search: [Google]
107.jpg
650 KB, 1328x1481
>>142129811
Medusa is great in F/SN. Her role as antagonist for the first half of FATE was great, especially her last battle with Saber atop the skyscraper.
Yeah she completely jobs in UBW but is pretty damn amazing in HF. Then add on F/HA and she's a great character.
>>
>>142129625
I wouldn't know, I didn't read the translation. It's a real shame if the translation is bad though, It's a rather decent read
>>
File: 1392596795916.jpg (1 MB, 2732x1536) Image search: [Google]
1392596795916.jpg
1 MB, 2732x1536
>>142125682
The writing didn't have plot holes out the ass. That's all I ever wanted. So few people seem to care about writing quality and I can't understand why.
>>
Pretty good, God tier for people who don't watch a lot, and still good otherwise
>>
>>142125682
It's a fun watch with lots of interesting characters.
>>
>>142125682
was good, not great but...good.

most normals will eat up this shit and praise it like the sun
>>
>>142131100
Fate Zero isn't quality writing either. At least Fate Stay Night wrote the war part properly with most masters not being retarded.
>>
It was a decent watch but the VN is better.

A large part of why it gets so much hate is because of retarded animeonly secondaries who watch this as their entry series into fate and then proceed to shit on the original series while spouting retarded memes.

Its decent but nowhere near as great as the edgelord secondaries make to seem to be. I actually like the UBW anime better.
>>
>>142131819
>the VN is better
>retarded animeonly secondaries
>memes
>I actually like the UBW anime better.

I didn't know taste could get so shit.
>>
>>142131892
read the vn and reach heavens feel you secondary
>>
I really liked the while Fate franchise (minus FH/A). I can see why others hate it, but I don't let those things get to me.

Basically I'm the only person on this board who thinks for themself :^)
>>
>>142125682
Stay Night was better, though at least young Kirei was entertaining. He still isn't as good as he was in Heavens Feel.
>>
>>142131933
I made it up to ~50% through heaven's feel before I dropped it. Holy shit it was all boring as fuck. I'm too old for crap like that
>>
>>142131983
maybe you should leave
>>
>>142131994
HF was best route IMO, but yeah it's a bit silly/edgy

At least it's not UBW with shirou acting like a jewrat.
>>
>>142125682
READ THE MANGA YOU SPEED READER REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
or something like that
>>
Episode 22-25 is really great.

22 : Irisviel's "corruption"
23 : Kotomine prepares to fight with Kiritsugu
24 : The Duel
25 : Destruction of Fuyuki city

Overall, 10/10.
>>
>>142132215
I can barely remember anything that happens besides when the guy kills his wife and daughter. I found everyone unlikable and unmemorable.
>>
>>142132289
Thats because you are an animeonly fag and haven't read fsn VN nor Zero LN or anything at all, leave.
>>
>>142132289
People oftentimes find characters similar to themselves on television, so congrats dude
>>
>>142132215
All I remeber was the QUALITY fight in the batcave for no reason.
>>
>>142125682
The adaptation made some missteps but it was mostly a good addition to Stay Night.

Doesn't work as its own story in any way though.
>>
>>142131892
Nice counter argument. A expected of a Zerofag.
Everything Zero does, the VN does better.
>>
>>142132434
I have zero intention of reading your garbage VN. I did like Tsukihime though.
>>
>>142125682
It was great but second season had problems with pacing, some important scenes and dialogues were cut/needlessly changed, it felt a bit rushed overall and I'm especially mad that ufo fucked up final fight with Berserker and ditched the part when Kiritsugu and Saber went to old canadian's house to hunt Waver down. And while characterisation of Irisviel and Kerry is fine for anime standards they were more interesting in LN were reader actually knew their inner thoughts.
>>
>>142132524
it wasn't bad though
>>
It was ok but all the characters from F/Z are forgetable and uninteresting (except for Kiritsugu and Kirei at the end). Even the story and the universe is unexploited. the atmosphere is great but somehow inferior to FSN tho.

That's just a good bonus for FSN nothing more.
>>
>>142125682
Pretty good, but it was spread too thin, leading to a lot of pointless wheel spinning. It also requires you to have an understanding of FSN to make sense thematically
Thread replies: 76
Thread images: 10

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.