[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why can't there be good medieval fantasy rpg series
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 48
File: shit.png (2 MB, 900x1350) Image search: [Google]
shit.png
2 MB, 900x1350
Retarded, all those characters in this first fucking chapter. Just why? Why? It's like they had little to no knowledge of how their fucking world works. Shit. I assume they don't even know each other, that faggot swordie just picked up some random youseemuseful-people in the guild and "Hey, let's hunt some shit." wtf. They didn't even know how each member fights, how in the world can they even compliment each other in real combat. This is some vidya thier shit, I'm getting tired of it.

Pls tell me how this series fares in later events, man.
>>
File: 1451660382885.jpg (189 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
1451660382885.jpg
189 KB, 1024x768
>>142098563
Only here for the GOBLIN SLAYER.
>>
>>142099140
>>142098563
I know OP's saying its shit but...is it at least readable without cussing every page? Or just complete shit?
>>
>>142100245
Don't know, it certainly wasn't that shit. but not as good either.

It got potential though. I'm only following because helmet.
>>
>>142100360
But the characters they're not....stupid? Are they? Annoyingly stupid I mean
>>
>>142100472
I only read the first chapter, which is about the fodders and main girl. So who knows?
>>
>>142100554
Can't find it, link please?
>>
>>142100711
I read it on /a/. Check the archive.
>>
>>142100733
So basically dark souls fag vs. Goblins cool, though main girl kinda sucks and by sucks I mean boring
>>
File: lady_of_pharis_vol01_pg_032[1].jpg (129 KB, 728x1076) Image search: [Google]
lady_of_pharis_vol01_pg_032[1].jpg
129 KB, 728x1076
I woundn't expect anything that includes mmo mechanics like quest boards and hard classes to have any semblance of good story. When it's done for comedy it works, but otherwise it's just lazy or tries to appeal to general mmo audience.

Dunno if there's anything recent, but there's enough decent fantasy manga if you dig a bit.
>>
Do japs even play DnD?
>>
>>142102675
They play phantasy star online and ff whatever.
>>
>>142102675
/tg/ here, they do. See Record of Lodoss War for an anime inspired by a DnD campaign.
>>
>>142102675
They play Wizardry.
>>
>>142098563
>It's like they had little to no knowledge of how their fucking world works.
Very realistic then.
>>
>>142102675
Yes, although you can trace every cliche they use to wizardry and dragon quest.
>>
>>142098563
The worst thing is about that series is that they picked the blandest girl as MC
>>
>>142098563
It's gonna end up like any other generic fantasy rpg harem series but /a/ is gonna love it because
>he doesn't take off the helmet
>he doesn't speak
>mysterious
resulting in a lot of baneposting in the future and some people who actually thing it's good even though it's the same old thing with a slight quirk. I mean blonde bimbo is probably gonna be retarded.

In the end I'll probably end up following it anyways as I always do, I just hope I one day get out of this hell.
>>
File: 1461909988069.jpg (30 KB, 380x448) Image search: [Google]
1461909988069.jpg
30 KB, 380x448
>>142102928
>he doesn't take off the helmet
>he doesn't speak
>mysterious
He speaks, he take off his helmet.
And I'm not happy about that.

But this is the closest things to what I want, so may as well followed it.
>>
>>142102928
spoilers got posted in that thread
he takes off the helmet
it turns into lighthearted shit right after
a cute elf, a dragon shaman, and some random kung fu elder joins the party
/a/ only cares because everyone dies in the first chapter and the part where the guy says his name is unintentionally hilarious
>>
I just need a real adventure style.
Opening chapters is world and character building, lets get to know the group.
From then on they take on specific quests, doesnt really matter what kind.
Have them prepare/go shopping for supplies.
Let the group explore a well crafted dungeon.
Let the rogue type search for stuff and jolt everything down on a map.
After the dungeon give us a full 2 page image of said crafted map.
>>
I guess tower of druaga and its second series could be recommended...
>>
>>142103158
Have them hang out at the inn, share stories with others. Give us the ingredients on how to make mead (fucking water honey and yeast but people will get excited to read about it)
Introduce the a bigger plot point from referencing to older hints given out in the story thus far.
Have them fight a lich.
Present real danger by killing some of the crew.
Have some shananigans the that some /tg/ stories have produced (sir bearrington for example as questgiver)
>>
>Fighter got cocky and said that fighting Goblins need no planning
>Cleric is a fucking liability that slowed the mage down and got split up from the Fighter/Monk
>Mage got out numbered and stabbed
>Fighter got too cocky and this time he paid for his cockiness with his life
>Monk held her own until a bigger goblin appears and turned her into rape fodder
>The dying Mage slowed useless Clerics escape and ended up being a lifeless sextoy for the goblins
>For all the trouble CLeric got an arrow to her shoulder

The cleric should end up being a rape fodder just like the Monk. She just got lucky when Goblin Slayer appeared to rekt goblins' faces in.
>>
So did the monk survive?
>>
>goblin slayer
There isn't a good future for something named "fodder mob" slayer.
It isn't really a impressive feat or anything.
>>
>>142098563
>RPG
ThereĀ“s the fucking problem. Whenever they talk about stats and levels, is automatic shit.

Also good fantasy medieval fiction is hard to write.
>>
>>142098563
>characters are retarded
>they get btfo in the first chapter

I don't see the problem anon.
>>
>>142100245
>>142100360
>>142100472
The first chapter is edge and show potential of some kind of silent knight adventure.
From there on, is a lighthearted rpg adventure, the guy talks a lot, remove his helmet to show his bishounen face, and is a harem btw. Guy is Gary Stu self insert. Harem consist of useless healslut, elf, and cowtits.

So is the usual LN trash with a bait starting chapter.
>>
>>142103747
sounds disgusting.
good thing I didn't expect anything to start with.
>>
>>142102928
>He talks
>He speaks
>He is not mysterious
>Edge gone
>Not just goblins
>Happy party adventures
Did you miss the LN art dump?
>>
>>142103635
It is if the writer was clever to utilize a system of real goblin army, smart goblins, mage goblins and so on. But the author go and stretch the definition, so he will kill anything that is ugly and falls under orc, troll and so on.
>>
>>142103747
I-i just wanted a dark souls like manga
Baw
>>
>>142103917
I just wanted something good, not another generic shit.
>>
>>142104169
No, you wanted generic shit that pandered to you, you don't actually care about the quality of the work.
>>
>>142098563
Nanatsu no Taizai? The mangaka actually uses real weapons, symbols and names from European folklore/history (and not just King Arthur either).
>>
>>142104169
People eat rezero though.
/a/ is weird sometimes.
>>
File: Gnashra_Shroomchewa.png (100 KB, 222x190) Image search: [Google]
Gnashra_Shroomchewa.png
100 KB, 222x190
>>142099140
more liek rape goblin, m8
>>
File: 1444854940195.png (525 KB, 1040x1040) Image search: [Google]
1444854940195.png
525 KB, 1040x1040
>>142098563
So let me get this straight.
The novelty of this generic fantasy with RPG mechanics is that MC actually wears armor along with a full helmet?
Goddamn. I mean, I also wish for the day where MC actually doesn't have to leave his head unprotected and show his face for no other reason than being MC, but subjecting yourself to LN trash for it is too much.
When will there be a fantasy anime with a mute self insert protag that never removes his helmet and goes on adventures that parodies the fuck out of Jrpgs?
>MC is a mystery that never shows his face, some say he was born with that fullhelmet. He's uncomfortably quiet all the time, is unfazed by anything and only barely emotes when needed too. This is his shtick. He's a weirdo with the murderhobo life style fit for the setting.
>Cast is a mixed gender, and one token beast race, almost self aware bunch.
>They are the only ones that realize the frivolity of going into a cave and murdering all the goblins inside just for a new sword to replace the now worn down old one, they pick apart the shallow philosophies thrown about by the big bads, or complain about the stupidity of every little adventure they have snowballing and ending with them fighting God, or a God-like being in some intangible reality.
>All while MC just does his silent bob routine and just keeps taking on more and more ridiculous side quests for crap he'll never use so he can hoard it in his overflowing bag of holding.
Something like YÅ«sha Yoshihiko
>>
File: That_meddling_vampire.png (409 KB, 367x768) Image search: [Google]
That_meddling_vampire.png
409 KB, 367x768
>>142098563
Japan can't into good warhammer tier fantasy setting and all they could do is to introduce rape and pillage.
>>
>>142099140
DOMO, GOBLIN-SAN.

GOBLIN SLAYER DESU.

YEAAAAAAAAAAAAART
>>
>>142098563
The first part was the best part, so if you disliked it, you will hate it now.
>>
>>142104273
/a/ no matter how much to deny it, got the same shit taste as fat nip otakus and casual teens. SAOfaggots moved on to Reddit:Zero, in words of the fans, "Is like a more mature SAO for more mature people".
>>
>In the end we truly were the GOBLIN SLAYERtm
>>
>>142098563
So why should I read this and not Grimgar?
>>
>>142104548
oh and they get most of their knowledge from their shitty jrpg like dragon quest and final fantasy
>>
>>142104533
Sounds like shitty YT paraody video to be honest. I want a Dark Souls anime without your shitty slapstick humour.
>>
File: Bitch won't let me eat in peace.jpg (436 KB, 1045x1088) Image search: [Google]
Bitch won't let me eat in peace.jpg
436 KB, 1045x1088
>>142104654
No one in grimgar wear Full face concealing helmets.
That detail is important.
>>
>>142104533
>What is Konosuba
If you just want a guy with a helmet and no talking, you are just a faggot that want a specific pandering to you.
>>
>>142098563
Will this healer become badass eventually? Like learn some offensive spells in addition to healing or are there stupid class limitations? Maybe I'll continue. If she's just going to hide behind Dark Souls Kun all the time then I'll probably pass.
>>
>>142104710
So then...Grimgar x Dark Souls? hmmmmm...
Do you see this series going places anon? I've looked at the image folder for the volumes and the only character that interest me is the blind chick.
>>
>>142104568
I RAPED THAT MONK GIRL
RAMMED MY COCK THROUGH HER HYMEN
TOTALLY WORTH IT


SAYONARA!
>>
File: 12.jpg (180 KB, 626x960) Image search: [Google]
12.jpg
180 KB, 626x960
>>142104674
There's comics of it.
Pic related is good, the newest one is shit.
>>
>>142104533
>Some say he was born with his helmet
>Others that he can throw his sword and kill a boblin but not hurt the girl behind it
>All we know is, he's called GOBLIN SLAYER
>>
>>142104533
Most LNs are the epitome of generic but I'm surprised there hasn't been a LN that parodies all of it. Have a LN where not just the MC is in full armor. Make the chicks have full armor too. And Helmets. We can still add full armor fan service, if /a/ gets cranky about it.
>>
>>142104948
there's nothing sexier than some good armor.
>>
>>142104718
As opposed to a generic guy wearing sweatshirt?
>>
I'm pretty sure that if we unite or something we can craft a better story than this one
>>
File: sigmar.jpg (35 KB, 300x528) Image search: [Google]
sigmar.jpg
35 KB, 300x528
daily reminder you must always pray to sigmar for orc and goblin killing
>>
>>142104948
There is stuff with women in proper plate and helmets, /a/ just doesn't care for it.
>>
>>142104948
There is already a LN with girl wearing helmet 24/7
http://grimdarkztranslations.com/kuro-no-hiera-glaphicos-toc/
>>
>>142105001
How about we start now?

Setting, pure high/dark fantasy. No isekai garbage, transported, reborn or summoned. Continue.
>>
>>142104548
>warhams
>anywhere close to good
GW drone pls.
>>
>>142105001
>MC is a veteran cleric that everyone looks up to as a hero
>sick and tired of dumbass adventurers charging in and getting into trouble, over and over and OVER again
>is totally willing to let them die if they do retarded shit
>often knows how to do the party members' jobs better than they do thanks to long experience
>still goes adventuring because there's a fragment of the idealistic young girl who wanted to help others buried under the cynicism
>carries a staff, which she uses to break bones and crack heads
>overloads people with healing energy to make them explode
>considers blinding people with holy light to be a good setup to beating them to death
>can't lose to cock because she has a tame rape plant at home to satisfy her sexual desires
>>
>>142105152
Just read fucking deathgod or flame ring.
>>
>>142105001
I'm pretty sure if one person put even a little effort in it he could make a better story than this one.
>>
So any update on that /a/non-chan story someone was writing?
>>
>>142105198
I would read this, reminds of the one story of the elf who was trying to get raped by a very nice orc
>>
>>142104833
> comics panneling and narration

Eww, fuck no.
>>
>>142105417
Well your loss
>>
These grim RPGs are even more annoying than the happy go lucky ones. At least have characters die to real monsters not
>Muh goblin with the capabilities of a child killing retards.
>>
>>142105338
>Veteran cleric wants to retire and spend the rest of her days with rape plant
>guild regulations require her to train a successor
>problem: all parties she goes with know her rep and expect her to save them from everything and basically act completely retarded
>solution: go in disguise, go with people who don't know her (i.e. nubs)
>full plate armor, full helm, no talking except through sign language and headchops when people are being stupid
>is surprised when nub party actually tries to be smart and does things like set traps, makes tactical retreats
>ends up bonding a little with them, and delays her retirement

Now the problem is that I'm stuck for the personalities of the nub party.
>>
File: consider.jpg (170 KB, 919x720) Image search: [Google]
consider.jpg
170 KB, 919x720
There has never been a good grim fantasy manga. Dont bother trying those anymore,theyre just generic shit
>>
File: 1333831527375.jpg (56 KB, 600x564) Image search: [Google]
1333831527375.jpg
56 KB, 600x564
>>142105661
>>142105198
this has potential.

Try to start by defining which class are each member of the party, and start thinking if you're gonna play stereotype or against them. Since this is more of a parody, you can really make a play on expectations
>>
>>142105661
>Now the problem is that I'm stuck for the personalities of the nub party.
Make them girls and let them fall for MC
Fantasy cleric yuri
>>
>>142105479
Not him but, the talking is killing it.
>>
>>142098563
>Genre fiction
>Good

Pick one and only one.
>>
>>142098563
I expect this series is going to get an anime. The LN is ranking pretty highly and there's a lot of buzz/controversy online with nips about it.
>>
>>142105198
You almost had me. Then your retarded rape plant killed it. Just make the cleric a guy.
>>142105769
Yuri never sells as a good straight show does.
>>
>>142105911
Only to portrayed the desperation he's facing. It's not about being badass you know?
>>
>>142105923
>Another Grimgar
Please no.
>>
>>142105922
/lit/ leave and masturbate over some pretentious whack that have won a nobel prize.
>>
>>142105969
Looks like more things actually happen in this.
>>
File: s001.jpg (168 KB, 869x1232) Image search: [Google]
s001.jpg
168 KB, 869x1232
>>142103028
If you want an mc that never takes off his mask you should read this.
>>
>>142105138
I just see a little blonde girl in lingerie.
>>
>>142098563
>Fantasy RPG setting
Is this the new hype for elevens?
>>
>>142106055
I did. There's no further translation.
>>
File: Edgy teen butchering knightbros.jpg (1 MB, 1816x1296) Image search: [Google]
Edgy teen butchering knightbros.jpg
1 MB, 1816x1296
>>142098563
Can't wait for
>That edgy kid easily slaughtered soldierbros
episode.
>>
>>142105769
>>142105757
Combining these two:

Fighter: tactical genius who could and should have been a mage, but became a warrior instead to support her little bro (who is totally a spoilt brat whom she loves dearly) to go into mage school. Often the first to tell everyone to run away, if only to lure the enemy into a trap or to actually run away (they've developed a system of "run away!" cues so they know which is which. She's not strong and she knows it; prefers to keep her enemies on their backs and shoot them with crossbows or trip them up.

Thief: bad alchemist who turned to thieving to raise funds for reagents; ended up being good at it. Spams alchemical items like tanglefoot bags and alchemist's fire and stuff but magic potions are beyond her. Deadly accurate with an acid vial to the eye.

Mage: illusionist who specializes in incapacitating the enemy. Carries a gigantic executioner's axe which is useless in normal combat but which is great for executing KOed enemies. Runs out of mojo fast at her level, but that's what slings and crossbows are for.

Cleric: cute adorable ditzy kouhai. Frequent headchop victim. Completely overshadowed by MC, but reminds MC of how she used to be so she can't just walk away.

This party has basically been working together for some time and so veteran MC doesn't want to get too involved and ruin their teamwork (besides, she's the guest member; she should match them rather than the other way around)

>>142105951
The rape plant is just a stupid joke and is hardly critical to the plot. Maybe she just wants to retire knowing that her skills and experience have been passed down.
>>
>>142106055
That guy's surname is amazing.
>>142106070
She's a wizard, pay her no mind. Think Louise.
>>
>>142106224
Is it necesary that they're all women?
>>
>>142106401
No. Their gender is unimportant, but I like looking at girls.
>>
>>142106447
What's the setting, dark age euro?
>>
>>142098563
>hot fighter chick getting gangraped by goblins

Damn son
>>
File: Solaire_is_a_bro.jpg (84 KB, 500x339) Image search: [Google]
Solaire_is_a_bro.jpg
84 KB, 500x339
Dark Souls anime when?
>>
>>142106675
High fantasy. When I think dark age I think Berserk and Ubel Blatt and I can't really compete there.

With high fantasy, go full magic, but put amusing spins on the stereotypes.
>>
>>142103123
So what you're telling me is that they wasted a tpk and gangrape just a sucker people into a mediocre light novel.
>>
>>142106811
Demons's souls would be better for an anime.
>>
>>142106811
Soul Sacrifice anime would be better.
>>
This shit is hilarious. The funny thing is this is EXACTLY how a typical /a/ faggot would behave if they were sent into another world.

"Let's go kill some goblins, they're the weakest monsters, how hard could it be?"

Picked this shit up.
>>
File: img_0002.jpg (189 KB, 774x578) Image search: [Google]
img_0002.jpg
189 KB, 774x578
>>142107172
It's not a waste if it gets people to buy the novel, which they did.
>>
I just noticed, but his helmet is literally Erdrick's helmet, but the horns are broken off. You can actually see the broken horn stumps.
>>
>>142107172
Is below average when you read further, but yes. Look it worked for faggots like this:
>>142107667
Nips know how to bait.
>>
>>142107992
I like generic haremshit anyway, so I'll keep reading it. You can tell me I have shit taste, I don't mind.
>>
>>142107530
I'm interested, tell me more.
>>
>>142108034
Nothing wrong with with having no standards, if it wasnĀ“t for shiteater like you, there would be no industry. No need to defend yourself. Is like being ashamed of cleaning the toilet, is important job that someone is making sure my toilet is clean when I use it.
>>
>>142108119
Sure, but do you know what Soul Sacrifice is?
>>
File: 1446476666319.png (92 KB, 335x322) Image search: [Google]
1446476666319.png
92 KB, 335x322
>You'll never be the Goblin King.
How does this make you feel?
>>
>>142107765
Can't argue with the results. Just wish there weren'the so many series that fake their tone. I wouldn'the mind a gritty fantasy world but I can always reread berserk.
>>
>>142106811
Bloodborne anime when?
>>
>>142108559
Will they show the impregnations and births of the various women?
>>
>>142108352
Narou and the like have so much JRPG fantasy garbage that you can look forward to this kind of stuff for decades.
>>
>>142108119
MC is a magician, the magic system is based on offering different kind of things to get out an extreme spell. Like a piece of slain golem would turn into a spell that will cover your entire body in a rock armor. But you can only cast spells as many times as amount of items you have. You use it all up you are normal human bean. But most people resort to offering up their body part to continue casting spells. Like offering your blood for shooting blood bullets, and more extreme like all of your skin to remove the skin/armor of your enemy.

The story follows the mostly silent MC with a hood, and his partner, a real ice cold queen. MC and her are traveling across the fucked up dark fantasy land to take care of deformed creatures in the order from the magician tower. Trust eventually forms, and their relationship builds up. The final order at the end is that they have to fight to the death, to get one superior magician.

So is a dark fantasy action show with comfy campfire scenes. Most monsters have tragedy stories, since the bigger ones got cursed from the holy grail for their wishes. Play the game.
>>
>>142108896
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ac9ktuLvyfw
Already an anime.
>>
How about a Monster Hunter like setting? The main character could be an avid explorer and hunter. Searching ruins and finding treasure, fighting giant monsters Shadow of Colossus style.
>>
>>142109186
Yes, but why would I watch your show instead of something else? It's still missing something
>>
>>142107172
The first chapter is always the best. You should know this by now.
>>
File: 1450370680698.jpg (175 KB, 683x797) Image search: [Google]
1450370680698.jpg
175 KB, 683x797
>>142108754
Don't know who narou is but I figured this trend was going to persist for a few more years. It's just that years of shitty manga/LN adaptations, and something about that monk, and realizing that it's just flimsy edge finally wore down the thick skin I had for this stuff. Last good LN adaptations I remember was Baccano/DRRR. Now we get Grim gar and this shit.
>>
>>142109186
That's exactly the same as an MMO setting. You should think some more about what the difference actually is in your mind.
>>
>>142109186
It exist already, full girl team, is shit.
>>
>>142098563

> "Why do you only kill goblins?"
> "BECAUSE I'M A GIANT RACIST. Why do you ask so many god damn questions?"
>>
>>142109455
No, is a tragic backstory, hate boner.
>>
>>142109541

What, are you serious? I was joking. Why is he killing goblins, anyway? (Besides the fact that they're revolting creatures.)
>>
>>142105001
So who draws?
>>
>>142109601
Not revealed yet from what I have read. But is taking a backseat for some light hearted adventure shenanigans. If I had to put a bet down, they killed and raped his sister. Would be a great nip bait.
>>
>>142098563
I want an old school D&D anime - with lots of party turnover
>>
>>142109692
I've been trying, but can't really get anything out. I think if I had some kind of reference of what anon wanted the characters to look like it'd be easier for me
>>
>>142109358
>narou
Web novel site, a lot of them get turned into LNs and then manga and anime.
>>
>>142109601
>Why is he killing goblins, anyway?
Isn't it because he is a racist? Maybe in the end of the story, he will try to build a wall to separate humans and goblins too.
>>
Any good fantasy series with female MC that isn't Slayers?
>>
>>142110739
Depends on what you mean by fantasy, if you mean hero's journey stuff then I don't really have anything to offer you, like I know a couple but they're RPG wankfests.
>>
>>142105198
>>142105661
Could also maybe do something like a series of short stories of different characters doing their own things with them occasionally coming together for a big quest.
>Comfy adventure SoL with a dragoon and his wyvern
>Short-tempered healer who spends more time nuking than healing
>Big armor guy who never takes off his armor or helmet even when eating or bathing
>Thief who runs sanic fast and pulls everything away from the party like the old dynamis sac-pulls in FFXI
>Red mage type character who disturbs the party by killing enemies slow and painful after crippling them with his spells
Or something like that.
>>
File: 1453500155058.jpg (152 KB, 640x720) Image search: [Google]
1453500155058.jpg
152 KB, 640x720
>>142109289
Those monster were the pets/guardians of ancient king. Killing them gives you a proof of victory that will guide you to him. Killing him will give the mc the right to throne and gives he/she the ability to control the world. Damn this sounds like shit. I should definitely write something based on this
>>
>>142106055
IT'S NOW OR NEVER!
>>
wasnt there a manga with a girl and dragon humanoid sidekick
the mangaka had a thing for bags ala Berserk
>>
File: 1464397343176.jpg (49 KB, 539x960) Image search: [Google]
1464397343176.jpg
49 KB, 539x960
So uh... I got an idea.

An edgelord swordsman and his group of a cleric/mage and a thief go out on a quest to hunt shit.

They plan to attack monsters, but edgelord charges in because cockiness.

Instantly gets rekt, like bones everywhere.

The other two fuccbois run and get cornered, but then a knight comes along and rekt the monsters shit.

Then kills the two fuccbois and steals their gold and stuff.

Gets the reward for the quest.
>>
>>142098563
I'm not sure what to think of Rat Killer just yet.

The idiocy of the main party was staggering, and the priest certainly contributed. But hey, at least it's not another REINCARNATION/OTHER WORLD CHEAT POWER MASTURBATION FANTASY.

And the Roach Stomper has a SHIELD, that's rare. Who knows where it's gonna go, but at least Turkey Shooter seems promising.
>>
>>142112033
What if the knight is actually a monster in disguise that decided to infiltrate the human world ?
>>
File: 1464314841885.jpg (109 KB, 596x628) Image search: [Google]
1464314841885.jpg
109 KB, 596x628
>>142112140
I love it
>>
File: goblins.gif (24 KB, 691x896) Image search: [Google]
goblins.gif
24 KB, 691x896
>>142110088
>because he's a racist
>>
File: adorable autist.jpg (13 KB, 102x185) Image search: [Google]
adorable autist.jpg
13 KB, 102x185
>>142112087
I'd take isekai nonsense over this.
>>
File: 2016-03-20_23-28-52.png (916 KB, 851x1200) Image search: [Google]
2016-03-20_23-28-52.png
916 KB, 851x1200
>>142104710
Ranta and new tank does. Then again, the novels eventually become the Haru show, so meh.
>>
File: 1463697777413.jpg (15 KB, 292x257) Image search: [Google]
1463697777413.jpg
15 KB, 292x257
>>142112223
I love how the cleric has a Jewish star
>>
>>142111011
Oh I forgot,
>Tank who responds to almost all of his problems with a good old fashioned shield bash
>>
>why can't there be good medieval fantasy RPG series
Maybe look harder than random edgy garbage that got posted just yesterday?
>>
>>142109323
This.
Just read first chapters of series and move on. Lets you enjoy a lot more stories too.
>>
>>142112716
>first episode of akame ga kill
>first episode of aldnoah zero
>first episode of valvrave

Works for anime too!
>>
>>142109692
I draw but I don't use digital and I'm poor as fuck.
>>
>>142111011
Have you thought about adding a berserker who thoughtfully and rationally reacts to every situation, and then hulks out after reasoning that he has a legitimate claim to being very angry
>>
File: 656676543245.jpg (779 KB, 1098x1600) Image search: [Google]
656676543245.jpg
779 KB, 1098x1600
>>142113795
All are welcome. Adding on, a qt armor girl that can't really be hurt but makes cute noises when she gets hit. In other words, Adele
>>
You should all just read Invisible Dragon if you want to learn how terrible shit can actually get.
>>
>>142115734
How bad is it?
>>
>>142103158
>>142103313
Grimgar?
>>
>>142098563
dungeon meshi is godly, but i understand you might want something more "epic" and less comical.
maybe Stravaganza? there's not really a party (in D&D terms) though.
>>
>>142115855
http://www.novelupdates.com/series/invisible-dragon/
My Immortal tier.
>>
>>142100245
>I know OP's saying its shit but...is it at least readable without cussing every page? Or just complete shit?
complete trash. Imagine typical otaku pandering power fantasy harem. The mc is a "kirito" clone, needlessly dark and broding, who all the chicks want to fuck for no fucking reason. and he basically runs around in n00b areas pwning trash mobs to look OP to all the bitches and hoes. Its so cringe you'll wish you hadn't read it.
>>
File: 1452626451655.jpg (636 KB, 2126x3000) Image search: [Google]
1452626451655.jpg
636 KB, 2126x3000
>>142098563
>Why can't there be good medieval fantasy rpg series
>>
>>142098563
Lodoss was based on a DnD session and it was pretty good.
>>
>>142117041
You mean utterly generic, right? Because holy shit was Lodoss generic.
>>
>>142098563
This chapter was good 8/10.

oh fuck, I need to fit in first.

GOBLIN SLAYER lol this is shit.
dropped.
>>
>>142116904
Because "Medieval Fantasy" is by definition already a regurgitation of established, overused fantasy. It's not likely to be good.
>>
>>142117242
You're trying way too damn hard lmao
>>
>>142117242
>lol

Fuck off
>>
>>142115855
>14 (2002/07/26)
>The invisible dragon accepted the challent and
went to met the angient super hyper ultra dragon but then that dragon was to strong

>ā€œfuck itā€™s a little strong thereā€™s no choice sorry but Iā€™ll have to use my super hyper action megaton ultra ultimate attack hehā€

>so the invisible dragon used his super hyper action megaton ultra ultimate attack
so that dragon foght well but got shit on
but there was one thing the angient super hyper ultra dragon didnā€™t know even as it died. it was thatā€¦ā€¦

>the invisible dragon actually have a even strong attack that was the super duper ultra mega hyper amazing action really super powerful top-class secret power hyper ultimate attackā€¦.
>>
>>142118585
Itachi vs Sasuke?
>>
>>142098563
What is considered good? The traditional? The not? What?
>>
>>142119780
So the invisible dragon went to meet his old bro.
Whoooooosh
there was super lots of wind and because of invisible dragon and his old broā€™s energy it became ultra strong wind trees were getting rippped from ground and stones were flying and anyway it was awesome

ā€œI should call you invisivisible dragon instead of old bro now hehā€

the name of invisible dragonā€™s old bro was invisivisible dragon but then siince his old bro was an enamy now he just caled his bro by name

ā€œthis small fry gettng all confidentā€

but invisivisivle dragon didnt know he didnt know dat his broā€™s pwoer got stronger by 10000000000000000 times and his bro also made a super ultimate attack
but invisivisible dragon was strong he was super duper strong

26 (2002/07/28)
Die haiya~~~!!!

Te invisivisible dragon attacked first lik a bitch but invisible dragon
didnt get hit
that was because invisivisible dragon wasnā€™t overlordā€™s teacher so he couldnā€™t
see the invisible dragon

ā€œyou canā€™t see me hehā€

after tat invisible dragon punched bam!!!
but invisivisible dragon didnā€™t get hit because invisivisible dragon
was invisible

invisible dragon:hey where are you heh
invisivisible dragon:what about you~~~ ;-;

they couldnt see each other it was then right then invisible dragon realized something

ā€œheh fine if I cant see with my eyes iā€™ll look with my minds eye haiya~!!!ā€

invisible dragon began to see with his minds eye then he said something amazingly profond

ā€œalthough i cant see with my eyes I can see with my minds eye! I can see when I use my minds eye! hahahahahahahahā€

invisivisible dragon was hella surprised when he hear that

no way how~~~

invisible dragon saw shit with his minds eye it was super aesome

ā€œhahahahaha I can see!ā€

what happens next you can look forward to it~~~ tada!

continuu
>>
So if the point of Goblin Slayer is that he applies tactics and strategy to take down goblins. Why wasn't that the point of the first chapter? The adventurers are clearly are going off half cocked. They don't have proper equipment, no formation, no combat experience. They should have been fighting slimes in the plains until they could handle that.

But the Goblins themselves don't don't do anything really tactical outside of taking the mage out first. Aside from that they just use strength in numbers.

Would have been interesting if the goblins were organized and had a pseudo-militia thing going on and GS is a guy who has trained himself to solo those types of groups.
>>
>no more rape after ch 1

Don't listen to these idiots, the rapes do continue.
A later chapter has vet party of adventurers trying to rescue a some village girls and end up becoming goblin meat.
>>
>>142122435
>vet party of adventurers
>becoming goblin meat

Some vets.
>>
>>142122435
is there a translation of the LN floating around? I just want to find out what happened to the monk.
>>
>>142122584
Yenpress. In a few decades.
>>
>>142122413
They used rape as a fear tactic. Pretty tactical to me.
>>
File: 025.png (2 MB, 2085x1483) Image search: [Google]
025.png
2 MB, 2085x1483
>reading edgy nonsense
How about you read some fluffy nonsense instead?
>>
>>142122863
So would having an archer firing line taking out the best melee fighter. They are basically mindless creatures and if the series is trying to prop them up as something worth of dedicating your life to killing they should at least pose a threat to anyone who isn't brain dead.
>>
File: not a child goblin.png (834 KB, 900x1350) Image search: [Google]
not a child goblin.png
834 KB, 900x1350
>>142122413
>Would have been interesting if the goblins were organized and had a pseudo-militia thing going on

These are just shit tier goblins, ogres/trolls they are all classified as goblins in this series and they can grow just like a person.
They also breed like rats, you can destroy hundreds of goblin spots but they'll pop right back up with even bigger numbers.

btw there are gods and they gave the mc the title of goblin slayer cause he killed alot of goblins.
Also they like to play dice.
>>
>>142120002
Are you paraphrasing?
>>
>>142124223
Still, what a shitty title.

MAKE WAY FOR THE TURKEY SHOOTER, HE'S SHOT LOTS OF TURKEYS
>>
>>142124223
What a shame that piece of ass was wasted on monster dick.
>>
>>142124223
This was typeset? Where?
>>
>>142124223
What happened to this ogre fuck? He appears for three panels then disappears.
>>
Is this the thread where I ask for recommendations
>>
>>142110739

Seirei no Moribito, perhaps.
>>
>>142098563
You know, without the fapbait in the top right it would seem like a decent cover.
>>
>>142098563
Is no one going to post the first chapter like yesterday
>>
>>142124223
Jesus fuck, I don't even know why I got triggered by brown monk getting raped. I should've had a boner but got rage instead.
>>
File: 1453957648439.png (45 KB, 347x385) Image search: [Google]
1453957648439.png
45 KB, 347x385
>>142124223
A shame she becomes the goblins' cocksleeve for the rest of her life.

That's hot.
>>
>>142106811
I think a Bloodborne Anime would be better. Or at least a bigger breath of fresh air since I like content that at least does some new stuff. There's already a ton of medieval Anime series so I would love some stuff with a victorian aura that isn't comedy.
>>
>>142107451
Demon's souls is the most straight forward with its story and most Anime are very "Tell not Show" if that makes sense. Dark Souls is more "show but don't tell" and I hardly see any Anime that follow that method these days. Maybe some exist but "show not tell" series are rare.
>>
>>142098563
Is the rape often?
>>
>>142124223
So if they can be this big a problem why wasn't that kind of quest just outright banned for porcelain scrubs?
>>
>>142124223
Source on this typeset version? The guy yesterday only dumped raws
>>
>>142111011
Thank you.

>>142113795
The Credible Hulk, then?

>>142115125
Which series is she from? I had the idea for a suit of living armor who serves as a tank, but the cute squeaky noises part is hilarious.
>>
>>142127260
You'd think they wouldn't offer a prize to female adventurers for half of the monsters in the world to make them lose interest in the more rape happy monsters, but I guess that'd throw the economy off since there would be no rescue quests anymore
>>
>>142111011
How come I missed this post? This has potential
>>
>>142128437
Lurk the archives
>>
>>142128851
That goes back to how poorly these MMO fantasy stories are constructed. The guild cutie mildy suggested that they not take the quest instead of just telling them outright that they weren't at the proper experience level. So while it's clear that group was full of chuuni's that needed more training it also makes the adventurer's guild look incompetent for not instituting better screening for quests. And even then the author could have just had the group go on the quest anyways to prove their worth.

>>142126237
I'm still mad and I don't know why. Shit was painful to watch and this is not my first troll rape.
>>
>>142129599
>>142126237

Odd, I'm not usually into rape and this one gave me a boner.
>>
>>142126237
>>142129599
it was painful to watch

will mage and monk survive?
>>
>>142103816
>>Happy party adventures
Retard.

>the rape does continues, a chapter later has a party of adventurers trying to rescue some villager girls and end becoming goblin meat.
>village girls are mind broken
>used as breeding stock by goblins
>Goblin Slayer slays all the goblins there
>seeing this heresy he purges their spawns.
>>
>>142129599
>The guild cutie mildy suggested that they not take the quest instead of just telling them outright that they weren't at the proper experience level
They would have had no trouble if they hadn't all gone fucking retarded. The monk fucked up the least but she's still guilty for being distracted enough to leave the mages so far behind.
>>
>>142103123
>spoilers based on someone who just saw illustrations
You are stupid anon and should feel bad for believing that shit.
>>
>>142122584
Taken to the rape cave and dead in the LN only more painful.
>>
>>142129869
The group was doomed from the start. No coordination and since the swordsman kept the monk zoned out during the initial encounter, the same would have arguably happened if they were in a tighter formation.

>>142129981
Well shit. There's no justice in this world.
>>
>>142130105
>The group was doomed from the start.
Because they let their ranged/support get ambushed, then the retarded DPS tried to tank, and the healer fucking sucked.

If they had kept their support close, they would have been able to take care of those goblins. The Monk killed like 6 by herself.
>>
>>142112140
I'm 99% sure that's the the plot in OP
>>
>>142130175
I agree but they would have died if they had grouped anyways. The goblins have poisoned daggers the healer can't cure. The mage has to worry about how many spells she can cast and since she's a scrub she probably had only a handful of casts.

Fighter/monk had no synergy and even if we assume it's because he lost his head it's clear that he was not a good fighter to begin with. They got ambushed on both sides so if they were grouped it would just have been more hectic with them having to split their focus and the giant goblin sealed the deal.

They needed chain mail to counter light scratches and stabs. They needed more range or crowd control options. (Mage could have had greek fire or some kind of incendiary)
They honestly need more people because their party isn't going full Dark Souls like Goblin Slayer. And they needed to check for crevices and stuff in order to anticipate the rear ambush.
>>
>>142105198
>she
you lost me
>>
Dai Denyuuden anime never.
>>
Lets make a dark fantasy LN without isekai or harem bullshit. Make your stories, now. Also, Shinigami wo tabeta shoujo and Kairin wo idaita shoujo and Yuusha Aruiwa Yobareta Shoujo are somewhat examples.
>>
>>142130744
I wish there were some kind of general where we could work out these kind of ideas. Some of them are really good, and could spawn really good stuff, and it's sad that if I want to draw or write for them I can only do it for the duration of an unrelated thread, or else I'd have to just dream about meeting again the same anon
>>
>>142130744
I'd also say drop any pretense of video game logic.
>>
File: hot mom giggle.png (115 KB, 268x637) Image search: [Google]
hot mom giggle.png
115 KB, 268x637
>>142104548
>good
>warhammer tier
>>
File: 1463624488894.jpg (289 KB, 964x1020) Image search: [Google]
1463624488894.jpg
289 KB, 964x1020
>>142106811
>>
>>142130744
Ok, I'll start:
Two brothers from the slums strive to create and rule a kingdom and society. Working together to overthrow the kingdom, they gather an army of anyone from any race to fight and conquer. But the two brothers had differing views and personalities. One brother is compassionate and enthusiastic to where everyone essentially loves him. One brother is stern, pragmatic but overall has a charisma that everyone basks in respect. The pragmatic brother loves his younger brother and is pretty much the only one he holds close. They both had the same goal, ambition, but a different society they wished to create. The compassionate brother wanted to create a kingdom of peace and unity where everyone can adapt and have dreams to which can be fulfilled through hard work. The other brother want to create a utopia where the law and efficiency is absolute, where order succeed and compassion have nothing to do with success. They overthrow the kingdom, but who will rule it? Their societies they wish to create will create a conflict of one's downfall. The brothers names are Romulus and Remus.
>>
>>142124223
>just checked the archives

Well, that's...
Huh...
>>
File: The beastman war.jpg (108 KB, 1174x852) Image search: [Google]
The beastman war.jpg
108 KB, 1174x852
>>142130744
When the anime is over, hopefully they do this.
>>
>>142130744
A merchant town on the frontier finds themselves under hard times. Due to wars raging between their country and another neighboring country on the opposite side of their area trade has all but dried up. Their abled bodied men have been conscripted into battle leaving the elderly, some women who chose not to aid the war effort, and the youth that weren't brash or old enough to seek glory in battle.

To make matters worse the seasons have not been kind to them and agriculture has suffered. Crops are low, property is damaged by weather and there aren't enough skilled tradesmen left to handle it. One day a wandering priest enters town and begins to console the townspeople and renew their hope for a better tomorrow. Things look good and even the local authority (a retired soldier who suffered injury decades ago that made wielding a sword all but impossible) finds himself in better spirits.

Without warning though a string of murders and killings start. First it's livestock. Then it's people. After the soldier is able to coordinate a trap and capture the criminal it becomes revealed that it's some form of lizard man. A creature completely alien to the populace since monsters are rare and more of the direwolf, giant rat/bat variety.

Further investigation reveals that of the people killed, families would be murdered but always one body is missing.

I want to do something with the priest experimenting on humans to create monsters but that's the best I've got. Not a writer so it feels pretty bland.
>>
>>142134393
Sounds like a fantasy mystery series. What about my idea here?>>142131969
>>
>>142134626
>>142131969
Just need to worry about logistics. How long does it take them to garner supporters? What races are present and what are their current positions in society? Will things improve for all of them or do the different models for future societies favor one group over others?

What is the current kingdom like and why does it need to be overthrown?

Also are they werewolves
?

Sounds interesting still and I'd read it.
>>
>>142134800
It takes awhile as they start out with the people from the slums, then essentially gaining support as mercenaries while being known for their great results. Basically like how it is done in Berserk. Gaining support from the lowest races and pretty much all the demi-humans through deals and bargains with the tribes.
> Races
Humans, oni or demons, demi-humans, elves. Humans do most of the persecution. Demons are well versed in magic, demi-humans are very primitive and rely on an animal form most of the times in battles, Elves are versed in magic and weaponry (mainly bows) while the humans tend to rely on magic and many of their technologies (mostly medieval cannons, swords, bows, shields). Races don't like one another and you will be persecuted the moment you are in their territory unless you gain their trust or have some connection to them. Humans tend to be the worst of them all.
> The future
There will be a divide between those who are realistic and those who dream.
> Current kingdom
rich get richer and poor get poorer. Other races get persecuted even though there is supposed to be "peace". Gives more of a reason for the brothers who come from the slums to rule a kingdom one day.
> Werewolves
That is something to look forward to.
>>
>>142130744
Alright
The beginning of Kairin wo idaita shoujo except the koolaid makes her a zombie instead while everyone else dies.
Unable to age and with no heartbeat or hunger, she merely tries to find shelter and is sometimes taken in by kind families but most soon leave after a year or two before they notice.
Shows her desperately trying to escape slave traders.
Eventually becomes a lone mercenary and due to some circumstances with a mission involving assassinating church officials, she finds out about the origin of the black soup she was forced to drink.
She then caries on with being a mercenary but vows to get revenge of the church and find out about the origins of the experiment as well as how to fix what's happened to her.
>>
>>142136260
FUKUSHU!
>>
>>142124261
No, that's the way the grade schooler wrote it.
>>
>>142098563
Is an anime coming? Danmachi was licensed really soon and it had an anime.
>>
File: Ex vol 2.jpg (300 KB, 765x1080) Image search: [Google]
Ex vol 2.jpg
300 KB, 765x1080
>>142138824
Danmachi was terrible. Goblin Slayer turned into a haremshit antics with healer being shoehorned instead of the best girl elf. Even the side story of one of the adaptations airing is better than both of these. And it was a prequel before it turned isekai.
>>
>>142138955
Danmachi was comfy as fuck.
>>
File: Sword and shield.jpg (106 KB, 962x1358) Image search: [Google]
Sword and shield.jpg
106 KB, 962x1358
>>142139075
Slice of life can only work if there is a silver lining to it, otherwise, it is bad. I'd rather watch warfare.
>>
>>142139171
>otherwise I don't like it and when I don't like something it's bad
>>
>>142139773
> Not realizing that pointless shit is much worse.
Like I said, silver lining works. You want some comfy bullshit that has no silver lining behind it? Then just read any haremshit from any series because that is what you are getting.
>>
>>142138955
>>142139075
>>142139171
>>142139773
>>142140023
Can we get back to wondering wheter there will be an anime?
>>
>>142128492
Late as hell reply since I fell asleep but she's from Horizon.
>>
>>142140023
Fuck your silver lining nonsense.
>>
>>142140532
Fuck your pointless nonsense.
>>
>>142140588
FUCK YOU
>>
>>142112223
have helmet but wears everyday jacket and stuff only in ...
>>
>>142140701
Fuck you too.
>>
>>142140705
MonHun doujins by UDON-YA kinda have that going on.
>>
>>142140785
You're welcome.
>>
>>142103158
>>142103313
>They haven'T read Dungeon Meshi
Pathetic
>>
>>142140846
No fucks given to this entire bullshit.
>>
>>142140861
But the elf is too old.
>>
File: 1251122358879.jpg (45 KB, 210x189) Image search: [Google]
1251122358879.jpg
45 KB, 210x189
>>142122608
So it's going to be overlocalized garbage where they rewrite everything so you can't tell it was ever Japanese in the first place. No fucking thanks.
>>
>>142130570
But we hardly ever see female MCs
>>
>>142141835
Fucking hate all the takedown shit they do for stuff that will take forever to come out.
>>
mage died and monk died later on?

thats gay as fuck
>>
>goblins are actually very strong and coordinated
C'mon japan be a little bit more creative
>>
>>142142123
Just because you haven't looked doesn't mean there aren't any.
>>
If you're going to include a newbie adventurer group getting torn apart, raped and necroraped in the first chapter, that's okay if your story is some dark deconstruction of typical fantasy LNs. Even more so if MC is a fully-armored murderhobo.

Then you have MC throwing his sword and dramatically revealing himself to be Goblin Slayer, before he engages in typical fantasy LN bullshit.

Literally why.
>>
Do they ever go to rescue the monk who is being pounded by goblin cock?
>>
>>142142861
No.
>>
>killing and eating your cock sleeve instead of endlessly raping her

Dropped.
>>
>>142105923
Anime confirmed in the author's note
>>
File: 1438988731808.jpg (170 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1438988731808.jpg
170 KB, 1920x1080
>>142106811
>Bloodborne anime
>>
>>142142996
>that witch hat
Worst one I have seen in a while
>>
>>142142900
What the fuck? You can't be serious, that's awful. They're still in the same cave.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 48

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.