>wants to write good anime
>don't
>>141235755
I think she at least tries to write something good, instead of the usual LN slog. Although you might not get a character driven masterpiece, there's at least something interesting.
>>141235755
It's "doesn't".
>>141235755
>wants to make a shitposting thread
>makes a dubs thread instead
>>141235755
>Hanasaku Iroha
>not good
Get out
>>141235755
>memeyoiga and kiznaiver flopping hard
The shilling is over, time to join butcher in the neglected corner.
>>141235755
When did she ever pretend she wanted to write something good? All she does is shit out bad melodrama and horrible dialog. I think her fans are actually retarded.
>>141235755
>Iron Blooded Orphans
>Not good
Shit taste / 10
>>141239011
IBO is one of the worst Gundam series of all time.
>>141235755
>M3
>not good
Sounds about right
>get married
>cuck husband for material
>>141239049
shit eater pls
Better female working in the industry coming through
Is Okada-hate the newest bandwagon meme of this season?
>name mentioned here and there, little bit of discussion
>suddenly spring
>okada tied to trigger
>tied to biggest crossposter show of the season
>name pops up every thread of respective shows
>never any discussion, just "okada this", "okada that", baseless blaming
Newfags trying to fit in, nothing more.
>>141239188
>hating G-Reco
It's like you've never seen a Tomino show before.
>>141239011
It has my favorite Gundam designs but that's probably because I don't like normal looking Gundams so it's still a terrible Gundam series.
>>141239301
People are finally waking up to how much of a hack she is. Urobushit is next.
>>141239324
I did and that's why it's awful. Tomino is an absolute hack.
>>141239188
>Get told IBO is shit
>"B-B-But G-reco!"
Never change, retards.
>>141239301
>Okada hate
>New
She's always been hated and never had any talent. You only coming to /a/ for trigger's latest shitshow doesn't change that.
>>141239349
It doesn't matter though, because any bad she does is overshadowed by the utter tripe spewed out every season that's not affiliated with her. Makes her look pretty good and interesting if you ask me.
>>141239426
But G-reco is way shittier, so it's worth mentioning
Plus it had twice the budget compared to IBO
>>141239426
>She's always been hated
I never said it was new, I said the meme was. Meaning posters seemingly namedropping "Okada" with no context or relevance to the given discussion. That's definitely new this season. Just search the archives if you haven't seen it for yourself and want proof.
>>141239573
G-reco had lots of flaws, but IBO was literally garbage. You're retarded if you liked anything other than the mech designs.
>>141239614
>I never said it was new, I said the meme was.
>When I don't like it it's a meme
Kill yourself.
I've liked nearly everything she's worked on that I've seen. Plus the direction the story goes is more up to the director in anime, if Shirobako is anything to go by.
I feel like people are extra critical on her just because she's a recognizable name. They expect her to be bad because memes and then work their hardest to confirm it while they watch.
>>141239614
fyi this meme originated from /m/
because Toshio OKADA shat on G-reco
And turned out IBO is a much better gundam show
>>141239614
Just because you're only noticing it now doesn't make it a meme.
>>141236250
>You will not post any of the following outside of /b/: Trolls, flames, racism, off-topic replies, uncalled for catchphrases, macro image replies, indecipherable text (example: "lol u tk him 2da bar|?"), anthropomorphic ("furry") or grotesque ("guro") images, post number GETs ("dubs"), or loli/shota pornography.
>>141239349
People already know Urobuchi is a hack.
>>141239664
>garbage show get 2nd season
>gunplas sells more
>1/100s and High Resolution gunpla
kekek
keep believing that, /m/emer shitheadReco is so shit that I refuse to buy any future SRW games with Recturd in it
>>141239720
>I've liked nearly everything she's worked on that I've seen.
That's because you're an idiot who thinks the worst kind of melodrama is acceptable story telling. Are you by any chance a 13 year old girl?
>>141239722
>And turned out IBO is a much better gundam show
IBO is one of the worst Gundam shows that exist.
>>141239904
>The Gundams looking good means it's a good show
>I'll just ignore that the ratings are shit and all of the nips on 2ch trash it non-stop
But please, go ahead and pretend it's a good show because they'd planned a season 2 before.
>>141239912
No, I just think she's done plenty of good work. How much of her stuff have you seen? Enough to completely and entirely condemn her abilities?
>>141239754
>indecipherable text (example: "lol u tk him 2da bar|?")
Is it really indecipherable if you can read it?
>>141239664
>>141239735
>http://desustorage.org/a/search/text/%22okada%22/
Literally a meme. It's a buzzword to add relevancy to otherwise banal shitposts. Stop trying to fit in and convince yourself otherwise, your utter newfaggotry is showing.
>>141239722
>Toshio OKADA
Are you saying people bandwagoned up on the wrong Okada to hate?
>>141240010
Her work is all melodrama, I've seen plenty of her work.
>>141240039
>your utter newfaggotry is showing.
You fucking idiot, do you have any idea how much time is missing from that archive? And you have the gall to call other people newfags?
>Are you saying people bandwagoned up on the wrong Okada to hate?
No you idiot, the nips have always had a field day shitting on Fukuda and (Mari) Okada. If you weren't such a stupid newfag obsessed with pretending he's not a newfag, you'd know this.
Someone needs to stop Okada
>>141239049
I thought every Gundam show was the worst
>>141240072
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree then. Whether melodramatic or not, I think she's got a solid portfolio.
>>141240274
Well, Reco was so shit thatTomino apologized
>>141240137
>the nips
>Not just buttmad G-recofags
Nice disinfo there
>>141240278
>Whether melodramatic or not
It absolutely is, and melodrama is garabage. Her only work with dialog that isn't melodramatic crap is Koufuku Grafiti.
>>141240343
Should've just apologized for the dialogue and writing. I don't know how he assumed any of those characters were a good idea.
>>141240379
>I didn't check 2ch once while IBO was airing to check all the threads absolutely shitting on it
I know you read some retarded troll/Okadafag's post on /m/ that claimed IBO was super popular and loved and then they called G-reco shit, but how about you actually try checking the site where nips talk about anime.
>>141240137
>No you idiot, the nips have always had a field day shitting on Fukuda and (Mari) Okada
Nowhere have I stated contrary, only that the recent influx of near-random "Okada" spewing is itself a developing buzzword, and the hate a meme. Posters clearly have no idea what they're talking about, nor do they elaborate - they just label anything they dislike as "Okada". This is apparent in Kiznaiver and Mayoiga threads, with most of the recent archive linking to said threads. I have no idea what you're trying to prove with your utter lack of reading comprehension. My advice is to get off your stupid phone and don't post.
>how much time is missing from that archive?
I was under the impression that posts going back to 2008 were migrated in. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how it looks.
>>141240039
In case you're interested
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUfoABgld2g
Okada is good when she doesn't try to force pointless love triangles. Hanasaku Iroha and Toradora were both fantastic and had minimal love triangles.
>>141240419
That's cool man. I didn't watch that show though, I saw a couple episodes and decided it wasn't my cup of tea.
>>141240525
>Toradora
well, it was written by someone else so
>>141240474
>Okada" spewing is itself a developing buzzword,
>A writer's name is a buzzword.
>They just label things they don't like as Okada
Okada is the writer, they aren't mislabeling anything as Okada. People frequently talk about her ridiculous melodrama, lack of tact with dialog, and repetitive plot lines. No amount of a fucking retard pretending that this is all somehow just a meme will change that.
>I was under the impression that posts going back to 2008 were migrated in. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how it looks.
>All the posts migrated in
Like I said, you're a fucking idiot.
>>141240559
Toradora and Sakurasou both had anime adaptations that tried to crank the melodrama up way higher than it was in the source material. Okada definitely made those stories worse.
Remember that melodrama is a buzzword, essentially a way to continue saying forced drama without getting called out for shitposting. Nobody knows the definition and so have incorrectly decided it means "drama I don't like."
>>141239349
Urobuchi legitimately makes kino though
>>141240679
>melodrama is a buzzword
Reminder that anyone that says "X is just a buzzword/meme" should be permabanned.
>>141240432
He just doesn't care anymore, being a 74 yrs senile old man and all
>>141235755
>want's to be able to speak good English
>can't
>>141239049
fuck off shit taste
Okada is profoundly and universally great, there exist not a bad anime in Okada's repertoire, her anime range from between above average or good.
Okada stories are poetically written with a sincere flare to them, she writes heartily and unapologetically, the allure in Okada anime is the psychological complexities of her characters and their own empirical pain and solace they experience as they wade through their lives trying to make atonement. I'd even extend my hand and say Okada is comparable to Dostoyevsky.
Never doubt Okada. You only feel ostracized and deattached from her anime because you aren't on her wavelength.
>>141235755
Fuck you OP. I'm getting fucking tired of this "Okada is a hack" meme. She's written plenty of good anime, and plenty of mediocre anime too. Why don't you try writing at the pace that she does? Do you think if you did that every work would be a masterpiece?
I enjoy and have fun watching a slight majority of the shows she writes. I don't let a few bad shows shade my whole perception of her.
>>141240606
>you're a fucking idiot
Great job elaborating. There's posts going back to 2008, which are clearly from the old archive's dumps.
>People frequently talk about her ridiculous melodrama, lack of tact with dialog, and repetitive plot lines
No they don't, that's what I'm saying, not recently. The archives are right there, feel free to look through the recent week or so. Otherwise don't bother replying to me, I'm sick of this "discussion".
>>141240864
/a/ hating something good isnt new anon.
>>141240858
We knew IBO was going to be shit as soon as they announced Nagai was directing and Okada writing. Sure enough, it was awful.
>>141240887
>The archives are right there
No they're not, you fucking idiot. Do you really have no idea how much is missing from the archives? And even with the missing shit, there's plent of discussion of her awful writing.
>>141240858
>>141240864
This is bad bait.
>>141240860
This is funny bait.
The only good thing she has ever done is Iroha.
Among the other relatively good shows she has worked on:
0048 is more of Kawamori' shtick,
WIXOSS was fine the first season but completely dropped the ball soon after,
and Nagi no Asakura is one of the most overrated shit she's ever worked on.
I don't even know why people even know this woman's name. The only decent thing in her CV is WIXOSS and that shit is Madoka lite.
>>141241016
Toradora was good because of the source material, koufuku grafiti was good because there was literally no drama, Mayoiga is good because the director has the courtesy to murder all of her shit characters and highlight how retarded the way she makes people talk is, and even season one of WIXOSS wasn't good.
>>141241103
She's fine with adaptations since those are largely inconsequential in the long-run unless they go anime original. So I never really give a fuck if I see her name and its an adaptation.
>>141241103
>koufuku grafiti was good
lol
>>141241171
She managed to make Sakurasou a lot worst than the source material.
>>141241258
>Can't appreciate good SoL
Fuck off.
>>141241081
WIXOSS S1 ended perfectly with the anti-madoka ending but S2 was just a chore and nothing interesting happened in the main plot
>>141241016
Wrong. HanaIroha, both TTs, Infected, Gosick, Aria, DTB and Sketchbook. NNA wasn't as bad as you're making it out to be although it could have been a lot better no doubt.
>>141241306
Sakurasou was hot garbage regardless of Okada or not.
>>141241313
>WIXOSS S1 ended perfectly
Season one had a cool twist at the end with the swap, but the entire thing with that white girl running shit behind the scenes was horrible.
>>141241358
She helped make it worse.
>>141241306
Oh I can. Koufuku was just bad and boring. All that needless exposition about masturbating to food certainly didn't help.
>>141241476
It's a SHAFT show. If you expected something else you're retarded.
Okada is a good writer if you're looking for teenage wangstfest. I personally think she's a better fit for live action shit and doramas.
I hadn't heard about this woman until after I dropped Kiznaiver. Has she ever written anything good? What thrust her into the spotlight in the first place?
>>141241476
>Koufuku was just bad and boring
I'm sorry to hear about your shit taste.
>>141241569
>Has she ever written anything good?
No.
>What thrust her into the spotlight in the first place?
You know how Nasu is a horrible writer but edgy teens and manchildren like his crap? She's like that but with the idiots that like highschool romance melodrama.
Mayoiga is pretty damn good though.
>>141241081
>I don't even know why people even know this woman's name.
Have you even SEEN the amount of shows she's written for? She does something like two or three shows a yearEven if you don't like her shows, she's worked on a fair amount of things that were popular on /a/ both famously and infamously like Rozen Maiden, DtB S2, Kodomo no Jikan, a surprising amount of mecha shows like M3, Aquarion Evol, AKB0048 and recently IBO, like three different P.A.Works shows, and a bunch of LN romcoms, notably Sakurasou and pic related
I think AnoHana pushed her into the mainstream though
>>141241631
The general consensus is that Okada writers horrible characters, dialog and horrible drama. Putting all of that into a campy horror/comedy where we get to laugh at their misfortune is a brilliant move.
>>141241569
>I hadn't heard about this woman until after I dropped Kiznaiver
It's okay, we've all been new once.
>>141241514
>It's a SHAFT show.
A bad one, yeah
>>141241476
>Koufuku was just bad and boring. All that needless exposition about masturbating to food certainly didn't help
Shokugeki no Soma took that concept and actually showed how it can work properly.
>>141241631
>Mayoiga is pretty damn good though.
Only insofar as it's fun to chat about on 4chan. Almost no-one's going to care about Mayoiga by the start of next year.
>>141241768
No, it's a typical SHAFT show.
Okada is like the closest thing the actual production side of the industry has to an idol
>>141241631
It's okay
>>141241798
I can't stand the threads here but I'm really enjoying the show. I feel it'll be very memorable.
She may not be the best when it comes to original works but I think she's really great at adapting manga and LNs
>>141241798
>Shokugeki no Soma took that concept and actually showed how it can work properly.
>Comparing a good SoL to literal run of the mill battle shounen garbage
>>141241798
Shokugeki's different from Koufuku, but I do think it's a better food show
I don't know if IBO is better than G-Reco or not but at least I finished G-Reco.
IBO was so boring I just dropped it.
>>141241926
How far did you make it?
>>141241874
>run of the mill battle shounen garbage
Don't be retarded. Shokugeki is food porn + comedy + cooking lessons.
>>141242003
If you think those cookoffs are anything are than standard battle shouned garbage, you're deluded.
she should just make more miserable lesbians but make them more depressing and gay.
>>141242075
I'm still waiting on her to make a show that's entirely childhood friends and every single one gets NTR'd.
>>141242042
>are anything are
>you're deluded
You've got to try out some of those recipes some time, btw. They're legit.
>>141242126
Meant more. That was a typo.
>You've got to try out some of those recipes some time, btw. They're legit.
Anon I actually know how to cook and don't need to get recipes from anime and manga. The only thing that really peaked my interest was the Chaliapin steak, and even that was wildly underwhelming compared to a proper reverse seared rib-eye.
Okay I'm going to go through her entire repertoire. Keep in mind, this will have some hot opinions and I'm only counting the shows she's listed under "series composition" or "script" for the whole show
>AKB0048
Pretty good. Too bad she and Kawamori sacrificed Evol for it
>Animal Yokochou
Never seen
>AnoHana
Not bad, kind of overrated, most likely what put her in the public eye
>Aquarion Evol
[cries]
>Black Rock Shooter TV
Actually not that bad. VERY drama filled though
>Canaan
No
>Crush Gear Nitro
Never seen
>DT Eightron
Never seen
>Fate/Stay Night TV
Oh my fucking god, Okada wrote DEEN Stay Night? Jesus christ
>Fractale
I blame Yamakan for this one
>Gosick
Bland, may be because of the source though
>Hanasaku Iroha
Very underrated
>Hourou Musuko
Good adaptation.
>Kita e: Diamond Drops
She wrote this too? That explains a lot. So much drama
>Kiznaiver
Very hit and miss so far
>Kodomo no Jikan
This was really fucking good. Near perfect adaptation
>Anthem of the Heart
Never seen. Should check it out
>Koufuku Graffiti
Boring as fuck
>Kurohitsuji
Never seen. Heard it was good adaptation
>Kyou Kara Maou
How fucking long has she been writing anime?
>Lupin: Mine Fujiko
Very odd. Not a personal fan
>M3
FUCKING GOAT
>Both Zorori series
Never seen
>Mamoru-kun ni Megami no Shukufuku wo!
I remember this being notably boring and unnecessarily long
>Mayoiga
Best comedy of the season
>MSG:IBO
I dropped this in episode 7. I blame the director personally
>Nagi no Asukara
Pure distilled. Never finished it honestly
>Otogi Story Tenshi no Shippo
Never seen
>Otome Youkai Zakuro
Super underrated.
>Red Garden
Also underrated
>Rozen Maiden
If you don't already have an opinion on Rozen Maiden, you shouldn't be here
>Sakurasou
Shit
>Sasami: Mahou Shoujo Club
Fun
>Wixoss
Dropped the ball in S2 hard
>Sketchbook: Full Color's
Very comfy
>Toradora
See Rozen Maiden
>True Tears
FUCK YOU
>Vampire Knight
See Black Butler
>Zetsuen no Tempest
Pretty good actually.
Adaptations is her forte
>>141242329
Her only good adaptations are the ones where she changes as little as possible and keeps 1:1 with the source. The more she changes it, the worse they get.
Also M3 was shit, and IBO being shit was her fault as much as the director.
>>141242416
>Also M3 was shit
No it wasn't, shut up!
>>141242329
I thought Anthem of the Heart was great, you should definitely give it a chance.
>>141242329
>FUCK YOU
>>141242677
DELETE THIS
>>141242605
Ok anon, whatever you say.
>>141241704
>Rozen Maiden
She didn't write the source, director/studio didn't feel like straying away from the source, her presence wasn't even there because it was too long ago too. Remember 10 years ago she was babby tier writer and couldn't single handedly trainwreck anime by herself.
>DtB S2
She wasn't even the main writer in this, and it didn't stray away from what the person who came up with concept wanted, that person wasn't Okada either.
>Kodomo no Jikan
She didn't write the source but she prevented this from going full retard on fanservice filler. I would've loved the fanservice filler but that might've either turned it into an H OVA or cause some new anti-loli laws to get passed shortly after airing.
>a surprising amount of mecha shows like M3, (IBO)
IBO is straight garbage. I haven't even seen it and I can already tell it's worse than Wing, G, 00, and Zeta. Meanwhile M3 sold like less than 600 copies and nobody took it seriously. Then again M3 was a fucking complete disaster, anime original horror mecha genre starring Aria director and Shitkada writing.
>Aquarion Evol
No comment
>AKB0048
Xenoglossia ripoff
> like three different P.A.Works shows,
Hanasaku Iroha was drama for the sake of drama
Nobody gives a shit about Nanto
Nasiasu's mere existence is a mockery of Buriki's designs, it looks nothing like Haganai or Denpa Onna. Hanazawa couldn't really carry bad Okada drama anyway. Also first episode didn't even cover anything and just montaged, then again PA Shit does that in half their shows.
>Sakurasou
She didn't write the source, and she prevented this from going full comedy. Comedy is JC Staff's best genre, she can fuck off.
> AnoHana
I still don't know how this disaster sold 44k. Did the dipshit nips like the grey haired waifu THAT much?
>>141243014
>AKB0048
>Xenoglossia ripoff
Hold up, as a fan of both of these shows I can't let that shit slide
>>141243014
>She didn't write the source
I never said she wrote the source for everything. I know full well when something's an adaptation. In fact, I'm pretty sure she's best at adaptations. She still has to do the script and, as you said with Sakurasou, even that isn't 100% to the source if a poor job is done
Also I never indicated everything she wrote was good. Just that she's written many things, much of which got discussion on /a/ when aired.
>108 replies and 39 unique posters
>this image wasn't posted
You had exactly one job, /a/.
The only good things Okada ever wrote is Sketchbook and Graffiti, and even then graffiti is a stretch. In both of those the source had zero drama and there was no drama filler.
>>141243708
This nigga gets it.
>>141243014
>IBO is straight garbage. I haven't even seen it and I can already tell it's worse than Wing, G, 00, and Zeta.
That's how you lose all credibility of what little you had.
Reiko Yoshida is far superior desu desu.
>>141235755
>Childhood friend mostly won (Anohana, NagiAsu, Anthem of the Heart, etc)
That's the only thing I love from Okada show.
>>141235755
>good writing
>anime
>>141246951
I concur. Virtua Fighter anime, Emma anime, and Romeo X Juliet rule.
>>141246951
>Reiko Yoshida
>Aokanata
>ChuuBra
>Hanayamata
>Haifuri
>Tamako Market
Half the shit she touches is putrid shit though.
>>141235755
>wants to write well anime
fixd
>>141243014
>>AKB0048
>Xenoglossia ripoff
>>141236169
>>141240790
I think it's another /sp/ meme.
People are being retarded.
Okada is fucking shit, no need to deny that.
But not every anime with her name in it, is her own.
Her adaptations works shouldn't be counted, anime scriptwriters mostly do adaptations.
She gets partial credit for original anime with many writers, she likes to work with up to 6 writers on anime, like M3 for example. This style of work is very common in the anime industry and always, always suggests that the director is at the helm, not the writer which is 99% of anime anyways.
This leaves original anime where she's the sole writer. There are 2, Anohana and Kiznaiver. Anohana was changed completely to fit the directors ideas, and Kiznaiver seems like what she wanted Anohana to be like, and is complete shit so far.
TL;DR Okada is shit and only Kiznaiver could be called an okada show. It's also shit.
![[Coalgirls]_Keit-Ai_1_(1280x720_Blu-ray_FLAC)[75012CEA].webm](https://i.imgur.com/D1ryEFE.jpg "[Coalgirls]_Keit-Ai_1_(1280x720_Blu-ray_FLAC)[75012CEA].webm")
>>141235755
But she just wrote the greatest anime romance ever told.
