[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
>he's a hikki NEET >who was run over by a deadly Japanese
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 34
File: image.jpg (132 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
132 KB, 1280x720
>he's a hikki NEET
>who was run over by a deadly Japanese truck
>and reincarnated in a by-the-numbers fantasy world
>that inexplicably runs on gamey RPG logic
>he has a cheat skill that no one else has
>and girls from every fantasy race with easily identifiable color schemes crawl over each other trying to suck his dick
>repeat ad infinitum
>Japan eats it all up anyways
>>
Did you finish the first episode?
>>
>>140607294
I can't tell which series you are talking about. There are probably more than half a dozen series that fit the description.

>Shukufuku
>RE:Monster
>Zero Kara
>Gensou to Hai

They are all from this year or the past year too.
>>
>>140607386
>I can't tell which series you are talking about
That's the point.
It's all the same shit.
>>
>>140607294

You're gonna miss that shit when it's gone
>>
But it's a parody anon! If they're being silly than they can put all of this stupid shit in and it doesn't matter because they don't really mean it!
>>
>>140607454
But Konosuba didn't really do any of the stuff that OP mentioned.
>>
>>140607433
But if we didn't have a dozen cookie-cutter and thoroughly awful stories with the same damn premise, Konosuba wouldn't have been as enjoyable.
>>
Is this KonoSuba we're talking about? or is it mmorpg anime in general?

Because half of it fits with KonoSuba and half of it doesn't.

Or am I being baited?
>>
>>140607294
>no more Haruhi!
>no more Lucky Star!
>no more ZnT!
>no more Shana!

You get what you deserve, /a/. You've been shit talking about the golden age of 2004-2009 for too long, and this is the answer animators are giving you.

Fuck you.
>>
>>140607669
I would murder half of you to get 2006-2011 back again.

No offense.
>>
>>140607555
Well, Kazuma is a hikkiNEET got reincarnated into fantasy Australia which runs on vague RPG mechanics. So there's that.

Also is Japan eating this stuff up? Konosuba sold decently well in a slow season, but Re Zero looks like it isn't getting as warm of a reception.
>>
>>140607757
If Japan wasn't eating it up why would we be getting an isekai show every season?
>>
>>140607669
Only Haruhi and ZnT had any value
>>
>>140607669
I can't believe we've fallen so low as to actually look back on tsundeRie shows as preferable to the current drivel we're getting.
>>
>>140607820
>znt
>haruhi
nostalgiafags get the fuck off
>>
>>140607669
The irony is that ZnT is your prototypical isekai fantasy before isekai fantasy actually became a thing. And it was actually good.
>>
>>140607820
>ZnT
>better than Shana
>>
>generic fantasy
>fantasy with someone transferred from the current world
>fantasy with someone reborn from the current world
>fantasy with someone reborn from the current world, with rpg mechanics

i dont think they can add any more crap to this stupid trend
>>
File: Chaika Grapes.gif (1 MB, 345x588) Image search: [Google]
Chaika Grapes.gif
1 MB, 345x588
Why can't we get pure fantasy adventure any more? What's the point of putting RPG mechanics into everything?
>>
>>140607669
>>140607820
2000's was a time of bountiful seasons.
No matter what you liked, there was always an anime to satisfy you.
GAR fags, moe fags, DEEPfags, and even harem fags always had a decent anime to suck on season after season.

What we have now is a shadow of the golden age. Everything is a twisted mockery, and I can find no joy in new anime anymore. Even harem anime feels off compared to 2000s. Can any harem anime of 2010's hold a candle to Love Hina?

I blame Strike Witches/OreImo/Bakemono.
The above are individually good anime, but I feel like the industry has changed because of those titles.
>>
File: original.jpg (60 KB, 450x557) Image search: [Google]
original.jpg
60 KB, 450x557
>>140607294
>Japan buys discs
Your argument is invalidated by the amount of money these shows make in Japan. If you want to actually make a difference instead of echoing into the chamber that is /a/, support the industry with your autism/NEET/wageslave bux. Otherwise, relax it's just entertainment bruh.
>>
>>140607968
It's more familiar to the audience
>>
>>140607968
Because the neets purchasing your product need something to latch onto.
>>
Are the shittier ones being filtered out? Because the newest reincarnated-in-fantasy-land stories (Overlord, Konosuba, Re:Zero) all go in different directions and are pretty entertaining.
>>
>>140607294
The plot points weren't the main reason why it was popular, but the combination of it along with interactions between the characters. Your points don't make it inherently bad, perhaps for you and a few others maybe.
>>
>>140607944
And then you have Danmachi which is somehow a fantasy with RPG mechanics that doesn't have someone reborn from the current world.
>>
>>140607820
>>140607867
>>140607923
>ZnT
>Shana
I like Haruhi, and I didn't enjoy Lucky Star but I can respect that others did enjoy it, but copypasta tsundeRie shows have always been bottom tier and I have never had respect for you people
>>
>>140608033
>Are the shittier ones being filtered out
The fact that these kinds of stories already go through two filters where only the most popular web novels get picked up and published and only the most popular published ones get anime adaptions should speak volumes about the quality of your average isekai novel.
>>
>>140607867
>>140607923
I feel like the problem is character development and differentiation.

Sure, Shana and Louise were both tsundere loli voiced by the same VA, but they were two very different characters.

Now, I feel like the characters from different stories are only differentiated only through their hair style. Even after character development they still don't seem distinct to me. They're walking archetypes.
>>
>>140607669
>instead of old shit you have new shit
>>
>>140607294
Why should anyone be surprised that neets buy up shows that are built from the group up to be self insert fantasies?
>>
>>140608248
How would those neets get so much money to buy those shows every fucking season?
>>
>>140608015
One of the last good harems was Sora no Otoshimono, and even that is pre-2010.
>>
>>140607757
>vague RPG mechanics
come on Anon, they got ADVENTURER CARDS recording their levels, experience points, what skills they've learnt and so on. It doesn't get much more explicit than that.
>>
>>140608286
>NEETbux
>both parents work full time
>allowance is whatever you want for my sweet little boy
>guy is close to 30
>buys shitty seasonal waifu anime every season
There are parents like that in this world right now.
>>
>>140607294
>>
>>140608286
Some have their parents to pay for them. Others feign illness (physical and mental) and the state pays for them. Others collect groups of friends and are charismatic enough to get said friends to pay for everything.
Sometimes its a combination of the three.
>>
File: image.jpg (312 KB, 869x1266) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
312 KB, 869x1266
>>140607294
And yet Mushoku Tensei still doesn't have a fucking anime.
>>
>>140608248
The shows are getting so generic that I don't even want to self-insert into them.
>>
>>140608369
Sometimes they have jobs but they live in some awful jappo shoebox apartment, eat nothing but ramen and tap water, and never go out, and thus they can blow lots of money on pure crap.
>>
>Protagonist gets sucked into RPG
>He's a bard
>Nerdy girl is a dancer
>Both of them adventure and fight monsters through songs and trickery
Would you watch it?
>>
>>140608395
Than you are no longer the target audience. The sales numbers alone show that tons of japanese shut ins are more than willing to buy up as many shows of this type as they can produce.
>>
>>140608413
And most importantly, they're not married.

People seriously underestimate the amount of spending money thirty year old bachelors have.
>>
>>140608286
NEET Japanese men is a meme nowadays.

Those NEETs and college-aged Japanese men who watched anime in 2004 grew up, moved out, and got a job.
However, many of them didn't manage to find a wife.

When you have a job but no family to take care of, buying 2 BDs a season isn't that difficult of a task.
>>
>>140607669
I remember maiHime and maiOtome, now those were the days.
>>
>>140608471
Living the dream.
>>
>>140608442
>>Both of them adventure and fight monsters through songs and trickery

Since when do any of these shows actually involve actual rpg adventures outside of the initial setup? It seems like 90% of them devolve into harem shows in a fantasy setting within a handful of episodes.
>>
>>140608381
Fuck you.

You know fucking well that Mushoku Tensei is guaranteed to get an 1-cour anime adaptation within next 2 years.
>>
>>140607757
Well according to nips on /int/ they loathe the genre and put the blame on the publisher
>>
>>140608298
Has someone never heard of tabletop games?
>>
>>140608442
Only if they were dragged into the RPG via some kind of phone hi-jinks.
>>
>>140608562

>tabletop games aren't role playing games

???
>>
>>140608560
Nips loathe this shit the same way Americans loathe Jersey Shore.

Everyone pays lip service to hating it but in the end there's still a fuckhuge demographic willing to watch the shit.
>>
>>140607294
>>he has a cheat skill that no one else has
He doesn't have a cheat skill. It's a basic skill everyone can have at the start or can learn.
>>
>>140608565
Will they be unable to confess?
>>
>>140608541
RPG adventures require plot, no matter how generic it may be. The current shows aren't written with plot in mind - they are written with the initial setting in mind.

It becomes a very difficult task to write plot when you don't know where it's going, which is why many LNs suffer from long hiatuses after the initial few volumes.

Alternatively, you can write a beach/valentines/onsen chapter in a day.
>>
>>140607294
Let's be honest here, don't pile up konosuba with all this other crap.
In konosuba he was a neet he goes to another world he is still a fucking neet who can barely do anything.
He didn't suddenly somehow became super powerful he was still the neet he is all the time.
The show was good, eat a dick.
>>
Average IQ of consumers of these type shows is confirmed to be below 60
>>
>>140607294
Self-insert, Captain Obvious.
>>
>>140608759
Its fits in perfectly with the rest of these shows.He is a neet who gets dumped into a rpg fantasy world and suddenly finds himself drowning in girls lusting after his neet cock.
.
>>
>>140608381
Funny you brought this up, as voiceless incantations filling the requirement for the cheat ability.

This series is self-inserting, wish fulfillment to the core. Those who've read this know what I'm talking about. Sure, it's a decent read but it could have been so much better. I'm on chapter 108
>>
tv series dont have a solid plot. They have concept of arcs which makes it possible to produce shows as long as it makes profit.
>>
>>140608601
No, the problem is people equate rpg with meaning vidya and start spouting their stupid memes and ignorance.
>>
File: 1460587520614.png (681 KB, 673x720) Image search: [Google]
1460587520614.png
681 KB, 673x720
>>140607669
All of those are shit and this wave of "stuck in an RPG" anime is an objective improvement.
>>
>>140608876

One girl "lusts" after his cock, and that is after he has spent weeks helping her and being a generally dependable person to her, her main perogative is still explosions and not orbitting the MCs dick.
>>
>>140607294
>also have japanese phone
>and immune to the japanese cold
>>
>>140608876
>girls just hanging out with him is "lusting for his cock"
You didn't really had many friends did you anon?
If this is harem for you you are going to have a pretty hard time in life...
>>
>>140608903
Why would you mark voiceless incantation as Rudy's cheat skill when he has a much more obvious one in the form of the Laplace Factor that gives him fuckhuge amounts of mana?
>>
File: Didn't find a way (short).webm (398 KB, 853x480) Image search: [Google]
Didn't find a way (short).webm
398 KB, 853x480
>>140609034
Go away
>>
>>140608951
To be fair most reincarnation fantasy shows are clearly more inspired by vidya than tabletop.

Most actual tabletop inspired fantasy doesn't indulge in the cringeworthy RPG logic.
>>
File: 1379902945747.jpg (315 KB, 1250x1036) Image search: [Google]
1379902945747.jpg
315 KB, 1250x1036
>>140607294
>he has a cheat skill that no one else has
>and girls from every fantasy race with easily identifiable color schemes crawl over each other trying to suck his dick

Looks like someone can't read at the same time there are pretty moving pictures. 1. It's a basic skill and 2. No they aren't.
>>
>>140607944
generic fantasy with WRASSLIN
>>
>>140609129
>infinite revives
>not a cheat skill
>>
>>140607968
Re:Zero is pure fantasy, though. No RPG mechanics involved.
>>
I like how OP wrote a completely generalized statement and people are still responding to it as if they know which anime he was addressing.
>>
File: image.png (509 KB, 1332x3858) Image search: [Google]
image.png
509 KB, 1332x3858
>>140609107
Which is a shame, because I'd love to see an Orc girl and a Drow be party members.
>>
>>140608759
>who can barely do anything
>literally the leader that manages to get a band of retards to function
>>
>>140609253
That's just casualization
>>
Do people still remember a time period when fantasy/action anime had MORE male characters than female ones?
>>
>>140609280
Not being a retard don't mean the he got some weird superpowers.
Also yeah, Kazuma was one of the few MC's in similar setting that didn't act like a complete retard and there were no "BAKA MC" moments. I guess thats why i like it.
>>
>>140609309
You mean like Kamigami ni Asobi?
>>
File: 1443867354433.png (247 KB, 500x612) Image search: [Google]
1443867354433.png
247 KB, 500x612
>>140609309
>SAO
>>
>>140609035

Yea right friend give you breast massage in the bathroom alone willfully as long as long as he want. You need by a clear mirror desu
>>
>>140608903
I wouldn't say voiceless incantations are all that broken, since anyone can learn them if trained from an early age. Also, genuinely good fighters can still beat the shit out him without issue as long as he doesn't have his magic armor and the one time he gets in a fight with an actually experienced mage he gets utterly shat on.
>>
>>140609043
Because voiceless incantations is a unique cheat ABILITY that's exclusive to a very select few (which a lot more people get as the series goes on). Rudeus having almost infinite mana may not be an ability, but is a factor to him being grossly overpowered (aka wish fulfillment). It doesn't end there either:

1. Voiceless incantations
2. God ranked amounts of mana
3. demon eyes
4. king-class attack power despite being 16-17
5. Ran Ma magic, which he learned by seeing it ONCE, can stop any magic, also cast with voiceless incantation

Plus there's more wish fulfillment things like his harem lusting after his dick. I'm sure Rudeus will only get more and more overpowered as the series goes on.
>>
>>140609328
He's got literal God-tier luck.
>>
>>140607294
>who was run over by a deadly Japanese truck
Did you even watch the show?
>>
>>140609368
> to buy
>>
>>140607794
Because modern anime doesn't reflect the tastes of the whole Japanese population?
>>
>>140608560
>nips on /int/ are a good indicator of the general audience
Icameheretolaughatyou.png
>>
>>140609373
You say that, but Sylphy also has access to every cheat skill you just listed, and she ends up being the weakest harem member overall.

Meanwhile Eris, who had nothing going for her other than sword autism, ends up the most powerful member of the party, stronger than Rudy even.
>>
>>140609309
You can't get away with that these days without being called a fujo show or if the men are heterosexual enough Toonami bait.
>>
>>140609309
Grimgar had more males than females.
>>
>>140609453
Feels like Grimgar was forgotten quickly.
>>
>>140609478
Lackluster ending and beating the Manato horse so hard it died twice
>>
>>140609368
But darkness was a huge perv, would probably do the same to anyone else, if that happened with aqua of megumin i'd agree but she was literary the biggest pervert i've seen in a while.

>>140609376
He is so lucky that he was taken by the guards after a bomb he took responsibility for exploded in the middle of a city. Sure mate.
>>
>>140609541
>He is so lucky that he was taken by the guards after a bomb he took responsibility for exploded in the middle of a city. Sure mate.
That was actually a stroke of good luck.
>>
>>140607386
But Zero Kara only has the first trope. The MC was never run over, nor it is a by-the-numbers world with RPG logic, his skill isn't really something worthy of being called "cheat" (suffering induced) and the girls don't give a fuck about his dick (and he doesn't give a fuck about their pussies either).
>>
>>140609371
>the MC lost once!
>s-see guys, he's not overpowered...!
I've noticed that Mushoku Tensei tries to "balance out" Rudeus by giving him some bad points like "his physical abilities are average" or "he can't use voiceless healing incantations no matter how hard he tries". I'm sure he does lose, just to try and make it seem like he's not overpowered.

Does he lose? I'm sure he does. But this doesn't change the fact that it's self-inserting wish fulfillment.

>>140609422
Fair enough; just because someone has voiceless incantations doesn't mean they're overpowered. Sylphiette is probably meant to be a healer anyway. But even she is subject to clichés like "I like him because he helped me one time". Like I said, the series has been a good read so far. I just think it could have better in some parts.
>>
File: 1376589254515.jpg (51 KB, 488x410) Image search: [Google]
1376589254515.jpg
51 KB, 488x410
>>140609253
Fuck mang, you either baiting or just stupid. Dunno what else to tell ya except good night.
>>
>>140609253
That's just a high class healer skill. Not a skill exclusive to the MC
>>
>>140609541
If she is pervert why she still virgin while has pretty face and why choose to be a knight not straight whore and wht he fid not use revealing clothes and seduce every man instead act like a shy and androgineous woman in front don't be stupid. Whatever i'm done this is stupid the level of damage control and masturbatory bad logic has reached a stupid level.
>>
>>140609478
Grimgar was 5 minutes of Manato flashbacks, 5 minutes of tavern talks, 5 minutes of song advertisement, and 5 minutes of actual plot on average for each episode. 3 minutes of legs being an addon.

It could've been decent if the show had a focus.
>>
>>140607294
>>he has a cheat skill that no one else has
Pretty sure steal is a basic skill everyone can learn. Actually, everyone can learn everyone else's skill provided they see it and have the necessary skill points.
>>
>,why she choose non revealing
> instead of
>>
>>140609601
MC in Zero just wants his happy ending with Emilia.

That's all he ultimately wants.
>>
>>140609822
Revive only works once per person unless you have a damegami in your party that can bully Eris into breaking the rules.
>>
>>140609606
>But this doesn't change the fact that it's self-inserting wish fulfillment.
Almost every anime series has an element of wish fulfillment actually.

The entire Tsukihime and Fate series, for example, are both self-insertion wish fulfillment franchises that masquerades as "le deep masterpiece" for "adult" men.
>>
>>140609844
>If she is pervert why she still virgin
Nobody wants to fuck her because she's too fucking creepy.
>why choose to be a knight not straight whore
Because she's from a noble family and she's a masochist? Just being a whole means getting fucked for money, but she wants to be abused and at the same time protect the lands her family governs. Being a knight is a convenient compromise.
>wht he fid not use revealing clothes and seduce every man
Because she doesn't want to seduce? It's not part of her sexual fantasy.
>>
>>140609844
Darkness wants to be "forced" into abusive and sexual situations. But her "rank" prevents her from just getting debauched of her own free will. She has to actually struggle against it.
By being a frontline knight, she gets pushed into these situations virtually all the time.
Do you remember what she deems a perfect man for her?
>>
>>140609989
Good thing that was his first time in fantasy land
>>
>>140609941
>>140609844
forget to quote

People here think pretty tsundere shy in front of people
woman give you breast massage because she their friend. Yea right
>>
>>140610022
>nobody want to fuck darkness
Idiot logic.
>>
File: 1440914234215.jpg (68 KB, 373x373) Image search: [Google]
1440914234215.jpg
68 KB, 373x373
>>140607294
I like power-trip series as long as they're consistent.
The problems arise when series like these introduce an opponent that the MC can't fuck up six ways from sunday.

i.e., if Saitama met an opponent who he couldn't one-punch, and the series didn't end after the resolution to that, then I'd probably drop it then and there.
I was also on the brink of dropping Overlord during the Shalltear fight.
>>
>>140610085
But not his last.
>>
>>140610119
Sometimes I forget the level of virginity on /a/
>>
>>140610009
True, they need to give the readers/viewers something to get interested in. But in the case of Rudeus, he almost becomes a god at the age of 16.
>>
>>140609601
>hikki NEET
>suddenly transferred into a parallel world
>save point/checkpoint based skill which is practically also a cheat skill cause he couldn't die
yes it's trying to be a little bit different, but stop saying it doesn't fit in with this shitty tropes. this why re: zero fags pissed me off most of the time.
>>
>>140609272
looks like OP is just trying to complain about isekai genre in general. nothing specific yeah.
>>
File: 1448424520000.gif (935 KB, 200x154) Image search: [Google]
1448424520000.gif
935 KB, 200x154
>>140610351
But Subversion.
>>
>>140610351
He's not actually a hikki NEET. He called himself that, but only stopped going to school a few months ago because of the inferiority complex he developed towards his Onii-sama-tier father.
>>
>>140607294
I won't defend the general trend, but Jesus Christ man, KonoSuba is a joke at the expense of that bullshit.
>>
File: Anna crazy.jpg (43 KB, 400x363) Image search: [Google]
Anna crazy.jpg
43 KB, 400x363
>>140610119
>putting your dick in the mentally ill
>>
>>140610804
Fetishes aren't mental illnesses unless they cause clinically significant distress. Darkness seems fine, other than the occasional moment of distraction.
>>
>>140607294
Hence why non-otome feMC isekai series are so much better on a whole.
If the first cliche gets broken and the others then tend to follow.
Hell even otome isekai series tend to be more enjoyable on average since they tend to focus on personal drama and politics more.
>>
>>140609309
Yes, I remember Record of Lodoss Wars. That was a long time ago...
>>
Aren't there more salaryman isekai protagonists than hikkiNEET ones?
>>
>>140607294
>he's a a hikki NEET
I fucking hate this shit because none of them act like an actual hikki NEET.
90% of the time they have no problems interacting with other people and venturing outside right off the bat with little to no justification. At most they spout "muh second chance at life" or "it's like a game so my social anxiety doesn't kick in" or "I'm not like other hikki NEETs, I'm actually a normalfag who only became a NEET due to extenuating circumstances" as their reason for being a total social butterfly.
>>
>>140609266
Not RPG more like a classic game with very few savepoints.
>>
>>140608015
Eh, don't blame everyone else for making shit copies of otherwise decent series.
>>
>>140607294
>tfw no show starring a damegami reincarnating schmucks into a fantasy world and having the time of her life watching them screw up
>>
>>140610119
If I had a choice between fucking a crazy masochist and fucking anyone I want in any way I want I'll choose the latter.
Thats what the town male fucks were doing anyway
>>
>>140612146
Well if they don't interact very much they end up dying and there's no story. To Kazuma's credit- his goal is not to kill the demon king but to just be a NEET in the fantasy world too.
>>
>>140613567
>Well if they don't interact very much they end up dying and there's no story
Was there no story in Welcome to NHK?
There easily could be a story with a character who has problems interacting with people, the problem is that the LN writers are bottom of the barrel who can't write for shit
>>
>>140607294
>>he has a cheat skill that no one else has

Except he didn't in the animu. He has just regular thief skills.
>>
>>140613716
Why would neets watch a show that reflects how depressing their lives actually are.
>>
>>140607294
>he's a hikki NEET
According to Aqua, who has no idea what the terms mean.
>who was run over by a deadly Japanese truck
Did you watch the show?

>and reincarnated in a by-the-numbers fantasy world
>that inexplicably runs on gamey RPG logic
Succubus dream shops are new to me.

>he has a cheat skill that no one else has
Basic skill.

>and girls from every fantasy race with easily identifiable color schemes crawl over each other trying to suck his dick
Only Darkness does this and she does this to anything with a dick.
>>
>>140613797
100% chance to get pantsu is cheating.
>>
>>140613827
>>140613716
Then don't make the character a hikki NEET in his backstory if his character completely fails to reflect it?

Make him a part-time worker who indulges in otaku hobbies if you want someone pathetic and relateable but still has a semblance of social skills?
>>
>>140613832
>he didn't spec in panty snatching
pleb
>>
File: 1455828909670.jpg (287 KB, 801x801) Image search: [Google]
1455828909670.jpg
287 KB, 801x801
No one got this started? Step up your game fampais.
>>140607294
> Truck
>>
>>140613831
>Only Darkness does this and she does this to anything with a dick.

More to anything that is remotely abusive or reminiscent of a hentai plot. Doesn't seem to require a dick given her reaction to getting hit by cabbage.
>>
>>140613827
It doesn't have to be depressing, it at least has to be a bit more realistic than "look the MC is a NEET just like you, except he doesn't act like the one at all". Why not make him a character with social disorders that slowly overcomes them through struggles and such? It would be both wish-fulfillment and relatable
>>
File: 1459467937263.jpg (257 KB, 1270x1222) Image search: [Google]
1459467937263.jpg
257 KB, 1270x1222
>>140609266
you're half right. fighting is free-form, no yell-out-the-name techniques or anything.
I think thing that people are picking up on for the RPG sense, and rightfully so, is that the MC is brought in from another world. There was no plot device/event that explained how he got there, but it's still not a pure fantasy setting like chaika, which starts in universe and stays there.
>>
>>140610351
>yes it's trying to be a little bit different

After a while it gets obvious, they're all trying to be a little bit "different", changing one or two bits.

For instance, Log Horizon has the MC be a background manipulator instead of the Big Hero.

Re:Zero has him start out as a suffering butt-monkey instead of the Big Hero.

Konosuba has self-conscious lampooning of the genre.

So on and so-forth. There's always got to be something different, you can almost hear the author's sales pitch to the magazine editor, "It's just like X, except imagine if Y happened!"
>>
>>140607669
Zankyou no Terror is a new show though
>>
File: 1456977798013.jpg (324 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1456977798013.jpg
324 KB, 1280x720
>>140614151
> Social Disorders
Literally everyone in the group has those.
>>
>>140610351
>Subaru
>Having a cheat skill

Being able to come back to life after dying is nice, but it causes him a metric fuckton of suffering and despair. Not to mention he has to GET to these savepoints, and he doesn't know when or where they are.
>>
>>140608876
Darkness lusts for EVERYONE's cock.
Aqua has no interest in his penis and is more like an annoying drunk of a sister you can't just abandon.
Megumin lusts for his cock only after he goes through a lot of shit with her and goes full heartwarmer mode on her.
>>
>>140609989
That's not on him, that's still Aqua's skill. The fact that he chose Aqua as his cheat item gives him basically nothing but infinite debt in return for being able to revive.
>>
>>140614197
Well, obviously they have to try to be different to be different. I don't care as long as they ARE different and/or good enough
>>
>>140614151
The MC isn't a NEET, he's literally just playing eternal hooky and refusing to attend class.
The guy is still a buttmonkey, and everyone in the fucking group has social disorders of some sort
Kazuma tends to get in over his head and fuck up at a critical time
Megumin is obssessed with BOOM
Aqua has the maturity of a middle schooler, and has had that maturity for 12000 years according to some anon's calculations
Darkness is basically Anna, but a hard M.
>>
File: 1458176072930.png (425 KB, 512x720) Image search: [Google]
1458176072930.png
425 KB, 512x720
>>140614391
> revive
and boy does he ever. Kazuma racks up a death count high enough to make a revenant blush.

There may also be some aspect of Aqua being able to do a Perfect Revive. Mortal clerics have dirty souls manhandling other dirty souls and just can't compare to a true goddess.
>>
>>140614481
Kazuma even complains when Aqua calls him an hikiNEET
>>
>>140610351
this. re:zero seems like it's trying, but it's not like it's totally fresh, these points in particular are indefensible.
it's pretty good so far, coming from someone who's sick of the format.
>>
>>140613897
Aqua calls him a hikkiNEET. He's not. He got depressed after seeing his crush on the back of a delinquent upperclassman and stayed at home refusing to go to class. He was basically in a post-NTR slump at the time and went gaymin to drown the sorrow.
>>140614502
Well I mean, she IS a deity, the fucking undead follow her around looking for salvation and she can basically BTFO any undead instantly.
>>
File: 1454725263823.png (369 KB, 401x720) Image search: [Google]
1454725263823.png
369 KB, 401x720
> Not even the dead can know peace from Aqua
>>
File: diluted.gif (82 KB, 278x340) Image search: [Google]
diluted.gif
82 KB, 278x340
>>140614290
>His special power hurts him, mentally!
>He doesn't have control over it! It's not cheating if you don't chose to use it!
>>
>>140607386
>le its not shit because other people do it argument

you gonna have to try harder if you wanna defend this shitty cartoon
>>
>>140614481
>The MC isn't a NEET, he's literally just playing eternal hooky and refusing to attend class.
That's literally the definition of a NEET.
>>
>>140614197
that image size gave me autism
>>
>>140607294
>and girls from every fantasy race with easily identifiable color schemes crawl over each other trying to suck his dick

Where?

Literally never in konosuba
>>
>>140614760
No it fucking isn't. NEET means not in Education, Employed, or in Training
Kazuma is IN education, he just doesn't attend. You're basically saying that someone who's been hospitalized and is therefore not in class is a NEET.
>>
>>140607294
Did you actually watched Konosuba or read the LN? He died from the shock of thinking that he got ran over, he don't have a cheat skill, he actually kinda suck and there are no girls that really want his dick. Aqua simply just don't care, Darkness like EVERYONE'S DICK and Megumin started to actually like him late in the series.
>>
>>140614884
Hospitalization counts as training, since the goal is to return to society.

Failing class is NEET.
>>
>>140614931
I don't remember him failing any classes mate.
>hospitalization counts as training because the goal is to return to society
No fuck off lad, next you'll tell me taking a piss counts as training too because the goal is to empty your bladder
>>
>>140614550
When I read posts complaining about isekai game mechanic plots I can only think they are reading too many WN/LNs, I barely see it in anime and its almost always done in a interesting way there.
Even most WNs at least explore it in their own way. Like death march has the MC basically being a game master bugtesting his own reality, Counter Stop has the MC being socially/culturally retarded(stuck inna cave since childhood gitting gud), Katahane no Riku outright ditches the revival part early on for one character and makes the other revival guy suffer for it, etc.
There's not many I can think of where the MC is OP as fuck in a game world with a cheat ability and he just collects haremettes indiscriminately without any type of internal logic or special way of dealing with the plot.
Like Slave Harem and the dungeon grinding. Its like a combat log.
>>
>>140614902
Btw, Konosuba is fucking Platinum.
>>
>>140614990
SAO is the posterboy, although the goal there was to leave the world instead of stay in it.
>>
>>140609272
It's just that he used a picture of Aqua and it rustled a lot of jimmies cause they think OP talking shit about Konosuba. I'm one of them.
>>
>>140614829
I dunno, demihuman representation seemed well rounded.
>Blue is a bitch, aka elf.
>Red is a little girl, aka dwarf.
>Yellow is a dog.
>>
>>140613831
>Succubus dream shops are new to me.
You are not playing the right games.

Also did you just ignore the Class System, Stat System and Level Up System?
>>
>>140614902
>he don't have a cheat skill
Bringing the goddess and having her at his mercy is his cheat skill.

Ironic that you bring the LNs into this, where it gets painfuly evident how much of cheating it was to bring Aqua as his "Item".
>>
>>140609253
Aqua's a goddes. Basically the one with cheat skill is Aqua, not Kazuma. Kazuma is really lucky after all.
>>
>>140609266
And it's shit though.
>>
>>140614793
>gave
>>
>>140615268
How is it evident? Aqua is useful by bring opportunity to him, but for the most part she only solves the problems she causes.
>>
>>140614696
Not that anon, but a cheat skill, by definition of it being a cheat, should be something that only benefits the user. At least to me, that is the definition of a cheat skill. Subaru suffers a great deal because of his ability, and it doesnt always benefit him. The nature of the ability and where it comes from even fucks him over sometimes.
>>
File: rebellion.jpg (249 KB, 1279x716) Image search: [Google]
rebellion.jpg
249 KB, 1279x716
>>140607669

>tfw every season had some amazing rollercoaster of hype and fun like Haruhi, Code Geass, Gurren Lagann, Star Driver, Tiger&Bunny, Horizon, etc
>now it's all the same Is It Bad to Fondle Tsundere's Tits in a Battle Academy Tournament Zero Season 4
>>
>>140615268
Well, he did choose Aqua because he think she would be a cheat machine.
>>
>>140615503
muh nostalgia
>>
>>140607669
>Shana
stopped reading
>>
File: aquabarf.gif (544 KB, 303x357) Image search: [Google]
aquabarf.gif
544 KB, 303x357
>>140607794
Konosuba was a deliberate PARODY of the entire isekai genre.

It still doesn't explain Japan's usual poor taste, but it was good because it made fun of all the tired tropes.

Re:Zero is only interesting at all because of the Groundhog Day trope, and because MC is Wrong Genre Savvy. And having a Best Girl doesn't hurt.
>>
Speaking of trucks, do japanese have some sort of phobia of being crushed by huge vehicles, since they're so tiny?
>>
>>140607669
>no more Shana!

Are you stupid? How can you put Shana! on the same level as Haruhi and Lucky Star!?
>>
>>140614973
> Physical therapy isn't training
wew lad
>>
>>140615645
>Re:Zero is only interesting at all because of the Groundhog Day trope
>it's only interesting because of the main focus and gimmick
>>
File: 12093812508123.gif (88 KB, 500x280) Image search: [Google]
12093812508123.gif
88 KB, 500x280
>>140614973
Hospitalization obviously doesn't make you a NEET.
Being enrolled in school, but not attending functionally means you're not "in" school. Just because I have a subscription to a magazine doesn't mean I'm reading the magazine. You can't tell me I'm receiving the information within the magazine just because I could chose to read it, which I could, since they're probably laying right there in my mailbox.
Failing class by absence is a common occurrence, which usually leads to being a NEET. If he's a shutin who's not attending class, then at least functionally, he's a NEET. A shut-in who's not doing anything with his life day-to-day. If he attended class every other day, I'd argue he wouldn't be considered a NEET, but if you've been absent for a month with no intention to return, you're a NEET that point.
If you're saying you have to completely fail the class, being completely unenrolled, before you can be considered a NEET in your book, you're interpreting the definition too literally and should probably consider suicide.
>>
>>140615874
>le therapy is training
If you want to do that, Kazuma playing games is psychological therapy after getting cucked.
>>
>>140615679

Ah yes

Getting crushed by large vehicles are a Japanese thing

No one in America is afraid of that

Im gonna get hit by a truck today, i love it, i live for getting hit by large vehicles
>>
>writing isekai
>female MC
>everyone is competent but have terrible personalities
>demon king get's taken down halfway through by someone else
>>
>>140615912
Kazuma isn't a therapist. He can't treat himself.
>>
>>140615973
>female MC

cue nerd rage
>>
File: 05.jpg (48 KB, 236x181) Image search: [Google]
05.jpg
48 KB, 236x181
Why is Darkness so impopular? 99% of the Konosuba images I see is of Megumeme or Aqua.
>>
>>140616405
Because Megumin is a cute loli and Aqua is Aqua. But I agree, Darkness is underrated, I love Darkness. Her masochist fetish is just too funny when done right.
>>
File: m saber.jpg (7 KB, 300x168) Image search: [Google]
m saber.jpg
7 KB, 300x168
>>140616405
Because M-Saber did it first.
>>
>>140616274
female MC are always more fun to write and easier to relate to
>>
File: Dandy1.jpg (34 KB, 614x337) Image search: [Google]
Dandy1.jpg
34 KB, 614x337
>>140615465
It always benefits him by nature of him not being dead, and having increased information. It's undoubtedly a unique to protagonist cheat-skill, since other than bad memories, there doesn't seem to be any limit to how many times he could die trying. With enough attempts from square one, he could learn every aspect about a given situation, and use that information to turn the situation completely on it's head. There's a physical limitation to what he can do with the information he obtains, but the only way he ever truly fails is by giving up.
It's interesting and relatively balanced for preserving dramatic-tension, but undoubtedly still a cheat. Currently, the only way to permanently lose anything is to hit one of these supposed save-points before he learns about someone he wants to save, finding he's unable to go back and fix everything via an hero.
in the end his power eventually works out as if he had clairvoyance, and so far it's implementation hasn't been boring/frustrating.
I like "save-point" powers, it's by far the most interesting MC cheat power. but it's gamey, and risks causing the story to be mega-boring like any other "only I can do this" power that makes you essentially immortal.
>>
>>140614200
You are a new fag too.
>>
>>140607294
>she's a moeblob in a series with a couple other generic stock female characters
>they just talk and do autistic things to try to be cute
>repeat ad infinitum to the point where there's 4-5 of them in this season alone
>Japan eats it all up anyways
>>
>>140615973
Sounds pretty bad to be honest. I'm glad that you're not writing these. The only part that wouldn't be terrible is female mc.
>>
>>140617736
What are you talking about? Be more clear.
>>
>>140617961
CGDCT/yuribait
>>
>>140608295
It's good sure.

But it had serious tonal mismatch issues. The pesudo-gravity of the overarching meta narrative just doesn't go well with the ecchi-harem esque tone which is presumably the biggest selling point of the series. I realize the importance of having some "down time" to balance out the episode, but the chaos arc went total overboard mental.
>>
>>140618179
I think it was better in the manga when the MC got killed every other chapter and the cock of thunder
>>
>>140607294
He didnt get ran over. He died from the shock of thinking he'll be ran over
>>
>>140608903
> as voiceless incantations filling the requirement for the cheat ability.
>no near endless mana supply
>not having been training in magic since he could walk thanks to having a full matured mind since he was born
>>
>he has a cheat skill that no one else has

But he doesn't.
>>
>>140617798
I'm writing it, but only for my own sake, ya it's kinda terrible. It's comedy though, until I usually go full edgelord and then scrap everything I wrote
>>
>>140616274
I'm basically only reading stuff with female main characters at this point.
>>
>>140621078
>self-inserting as a girl
What are you, gay?
>>
>>140621209
Having higher mental capacities and imagination than a retarded teenager like you doesnt make someone gay
>>
>>140621209
>not wanting to be the cute girl
>on /a/
>>
File: Sigh.jpg (290 KB, 1048x1059) Image search: [Google]
Sigh.jpg
290 KB, 1048x1059
>>140621209
You are in the wrong place.
>>
File: moot-1450226843508.jpg (190 KB, 768x1052) Image search: [Google]
moot-1450226843508.jpg
190 KB, 768x1052
>>140621346
>tfw newfags don't know about being the little girl

;_;
>>
>>140621078
>>140617226

I like female MCs better than males too, but Japan and 99% of /a/nons don't.
>>
>>140621460
>emoticons
Wait when did :^) become not ok?
>>
>>140621700
spoiler that shit

(╬ ಠ益ಠ)
>>
>>140621700
;_;
>>
>>140621700
I remember a year ago or more people still posted ">>>/v/" when someone used ":^)"
>>
>>140622110
;-;
>>
>>140621700
That image is at least 3 years old IIRC. I've honestly lost track.
>>
>>140621613
>but Japan and 99% of /a/nons don't.
Yes of course, it's not like they don't regularly gobble up CGDCT shows by the boatload.
>>
File: 1373801723876.jpg (75 KB, 259x259) Image search: [Google]
1373801723876.jpg
75 KB, 259x259
>>140607669
I am so fucking glad it's over. The moe shits are gone!

Now we actually get good serious!
>>
File: image.jpg (85 KB, 750x520) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
85 KB, 750x520
>>140607294
>she's a spider
>who was blown up by a deadly maoyuusha combination attack
>and reincarnated in a deadly underground labrynith
>that runs on gamey Evil God logic
>she has a cheat skill that lets her GO SANIC FAST
>and monsters from every species with distinct designs are crawling over each other trying to kill her
>>
>>140623376
I shouldn't want to fuck a spider.
>>
>>140622937
>it's not like they don't regularly gobble up CGDCT shows by the boatload.

Because they're essentially just fap material with no story, nothing to relate to and no reason to self-insert, which shows in the threads
>I want to stick benis in A-chan!
>B-chan is mai waifu, I claimed her first
>muh dig
>>
>>140615268
So being into debt and not having money is a cheat skill?
>>
>>140623376
>she's a social retard
>who got blown up in a mysterious explosion
>and reincarnated in a by-the-numbers fantasy world
>that inexplicably runs on gamey RPG logic
>the only one who reincarnates as a monster which are better than humans
>kills and eats monsters of every species that humans shit their pants at the sight of
>>
>>140612146
Kazuma is actually called god by fellow MMO gamer, pretty sure he has no problem in social skill
>>
>>140623827
>the only one who reincarnates as a monster which are better than humans
yes, because starting with 100 skill points versus Shun's 200k skill points was totally better.
>>
>>140623827
>the only one who reincarnates as a monster which are better than humans
Now this is bullshit. She was earlier because spiders are born faster, and she had 100 skillpoints to everyone else's 100+k. Her being stronger is due to not being sheltered and being in danger of kicking the bucket from day 1.
>>
>>140607386
You forgot the obvious: Mushoku Tensei
Probably the most overrated of them all, I don't know why /a/ loves it
>>
>>140624105
>>140623827
>>140623376
Idaten wasn't Kumoko's real cheat skill, her real cheat was getting to buy the absurdly OP Pride skill for only 100 skill points when Ruler skills usually cost tens of thousands of skill points to learn, which leapfrogged her into powerleveling.

And then D gave her Wisdom as a gift on top of that which just accelerated things even more.

She managed to collect four fucking cheat Ruler skills in a year when most characters only got at most one of them.
>>
>>140624282
Total skill point count is irrelevant because Kumoko got access to a bunch of cheat skills for next to no skill points while the other characters had to spend literally thousands times more skill points to purchase equivalent skills.
>>
>>140624574
Pride has to do with her personality and the other skills were ground from 0 up.
>>140624439
Pride being cheap as shit has to do with her personality though.
That one lecher faggot got Lust all on his own iirc.
>>
File: 1449452873878.jpg (25 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
1449452873878.jpg
25 KB, 640x480
Japan had the right idea in the '60s. If you want to make a cool escapist character, just make a cool character.

Why saddle him down with dumb otaku hobby stuff that ain't relevant, or even worse, just half-ass rehashing the Spider-Man or Captain Marvel boilerplates?
>>
>>140609107
The last thing we got of that was Chaos Dragon.
Frankly, good riddance. Pretty much every isekai show that's come out recently is vastly superior to that worthless tripe.
>>
File: disdain.jpg (32 KB, 529x486) Image search: [Google]
disdain.jpg
32 KB, 529x486
>there are people on /a/ who believe rabid tsundere garbage from the late 00s is somehow better than haremshit LN adaptations today
>>
>>140625072
But most 00's tsundere shows were harem and most current harem shows have a tsundere as the lead.
In other words, it's all the same shit.
>>
>>140624697
>Kumoko
>prideful
>>
>>140626432
It's canon though, the Ruler traits have to do with their personalities which is why Vampire-chan gets Envy so easily.
Maybe it has to do with the fact that she's not even human or something, or that D is incredibly prideful and she's a sub for D.
>>
>>140624574
The only real cheat skill is the "full heal on level up" skill the reincarnators get. She would have been crushed by the gorillas if it weren't for that.
>>
>>140607294
>hikki
If you can't even get the word right, don't bother. Or stick to your own fucking language.
>>
>>140628332
Dude, Aqua literally calls him a hikkineeto in the first episode like five times.
>>
>>140628402
>not knowing what is wrong with "hikki"

Protip: maybe the runes could tell you
>>
>>140629564
Lad I have no idea how this weird slang of hikikomori and NEET is written, but it does sound more like ひっき than just plain ひき although maybe it's just Aqua's weird drawling voice,
>>
>>140607294
He was reclusive but he drove 5 hours to get his new game.
No, it was a tractor and everybody laughed at him dying of a heart attack.
Not really, the evil overlord lets his generals sit around playing store keep
In some ways yes, in others, no
No he's the weakest.
No it's purely platonic

C'mon OP you could have at least picked a better example.

I don't even know why you chose that show as an example.
>>
>>140609478
The story was good, the directing was shit. Really, sometimes watching Grimgar felt like watching either a cheesy music video or a subpar japanese drama.
Wich is a shame, because it got a lot of things right.
>>
>>140629564
stop showing off when you are dumb and clueless.

hikki is correct short form for hikikomori, not hiki.
>>
>>140629564
>>140629691
>>140631008
Does it really matter?
>>
>>140631103
Yes, because the first guy you posted sperged out about using the wrong form.
>>
>>140625072
The ultra vicious tsunderes of the late 00s are still more tolerable than Asterisk/Hundred/Bahamut.
>>
File: 56177468_p0.jpg (429 KB, 750x1026) Image search: [Google]
56177468_p0.jpg
429 KB, 750x1026
I just want to impregnate Megumin.
>>
>>140614128
>Doesn't seem to require a dick given her reaction to getting hit by cabbage.
How could I forget this.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 34

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.