[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is this show just a ripoff of saekano?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 204
Thread images: 47
Is this show just a ripoff of saekano?
>>
>>135815122
Tell me about the leg and pantyhose service anon, is there any of that?
>>
>>135815122
The Mc is 1 billion times better so nah.
>>
pushwa
>>
Yes but with better MC, better premise, better story and better girls.
>>
>>135815122
No it's not. Koya goes in depth with the visual novel or Bishoujo games industry, it's Meta show to the core. Saekano on the other hand is just your typical harem romcom LN. If you want to compare, Koya is like the manga Bakuman. People seems to like Saekano because Maruto wrote it, but for me Tanaka Romeo did much better job at the same concept of making a doujin Bishoujo game.
>>
>>135815563
Believe it or not, the MC is the best girl. He is moe as fuck in the game.
>>
No because they're making an actual porn game this time
>>
>>135815122
It's actually a Pokemon ripoff because they are going to collect the 7 dragon balls and become shogi champions.
>>
>>135817166
is there a sumo arc as well?
>>
>>135815956
When will this shit meme end
>>
mc is a real human bean
>>
>>135817380
PUSHWA
>>
File: 1447221126085.jpg (74 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1447221126085.jpg
74 KB, 1280x720
She's way too cute holy shit.
>>
>>135815122
Saekano is shit so no
>>
>>135815122
>Saekano
>Good
It's just for waifu shit

This on the other hand has a good MC, which Tomoya will never be.
>>
Tanaka Romeo has never let me down so I will watch this and pray that the director does not mangle his greatness.
>>
No, this already looks so much more promising and interesting.
>>
File: 1428701336873.webm (369 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1428701336873.webm
369 KB, 1280x720
>>135817380
>>
BUNTA
>>
>>135815956
What a cute boy
>>
File: 1443237775155.jpg (120 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1443237775155.jpg
120 KB, 1280x720
Have there been any stitches done yet? I'm being retarded and can't find the last thread on archive.
>>
>>135818927

Is she voiced by KanaHana? It sounds like her.
>>
File: 1437632203419.jpg (90 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1437632203419.jpg
90 KB, 1280x720
>>135818962
She sure is
>>
>>135819040

Fuck yeah knew it. Auto best girl right there.
>>
File: 1394775846923.gif (711 KB, 480x270) Image search: [Google]
1394775846923.gif
711 KB, 480x270
>>135815122

>yellow subs
>>
Deep
>>
>>135819107
There's an ass rip you can use with the raws.
>>
>>135819142

8man was right all along
>>
>>135818962
yeah its drunk kanahana
>>
File: 1430182084120.jpg (246 KB, 1275x1718) Image search: [Google]
1430182084120.jpg
246 KB, 1275x1718
>>
File: 1449688757901.jpg (192 KB, 1214x1540) Image search: [Google]
1449688757901.jpg
192 KB, 1214x1540
>>
>>135815122
Takahiro self insert show. Probably tired writing all these edgy action so doing self insert harem vn this time.
>>
File: 1427678862043.jpg (362 KB, 1263x2138) Image search: [Google]
1427678862043.jpg
362 KB, 1263x2138
>>
File: intro.jpg (93 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
intro.jpg
93 KB, 1280x720
I hope Satomi Akesaka delivers. She has limitless potential.
>>
File: 1447893524019.webm (299 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1447893524019.webm
299 KB, 1280x720
>>135819090
Best girl has already been decided.
>>
So, is anyone actually subbing this? Hulu subs are awful.
>>
File: 1450810973182.png (346 KB, 816x785) Image search: [Google]
1450810973182.png
346 KB, 816x785
>>135819975
>subs
>2016
>>
>>135819975
>tl note
>"subs" is short for subtitles
>>
>>135818962
>>135819040
Did anyone else hear Minorin? She sounds like Yui Horie, I swear.
>>
File: proportions.png (2 MB, 1493x1004) Image search: [Google]
proportions.png
2 MB, 1493x1004
what in the fuck
>>
Saekano with a Yukino that's actually likeable as main girl?

Might be good.
>>
>>135821167
he's a big guy
>>
>Maruto made a self insert show starring himself
>Romeo decided to do it too

The absolute madman
>>
>>135821167
>1493x1004
Yeah anon, what the fuck?
>>
>>135821167
Look again. That's his elbow, not his shoulder.
>>
I thought that girl was KYH for a second.
>>
>>135816129
And better writer.
>>
Decent subs when?
>>
>>135822840
Accel World.
>>
>>135823036
Shit son. Isn't that the precursor to SAO?
>>
>>135822840
1984:Harem edition
>>
>>135819040
picked up
>>
>>135815122
No, they're both rip-offs of NHK. People wanting to make eroge is not a fucking new idea.
>>
>>135822840
Fuck off mobile user.
>>
I've never played a Romeo game since I don't feel like my japanese is ready yet, but I can kinda see the hype after this episode. It felt really refreshing and actually fun, for some reason. How does he do it?

Too bad the subs are shit, though.
>>
File: received_10206526521934389.jpg (35 KB, 448x424) Image search: [Google]
received_10206526521934389.jpg
35 KB, 448x424
>>135823262
>>
>The VN will be all ages

Disappointing
>>
>>135815122
Does it have someone like best girl Megumi, the saving grace of the show?
>>
>>135823369
>JoJo image
Of course.
>>
>>135823402
Fuck.
>>
>>135819335
My seasonal waifu.
>>
So does bro get a girl or not?
>>
>>135824032
_no
>>
File: jun.jpg (19 KB, 210x240) Image search: [Google]
jun.jpg
19 KB, 210x240
>>135819416
>takahiro
You what?
>>
I'm a bit worried about the budget. I mean, the fucking OP has gootage repetition. That can't be a good sign.
>>
File: 83.png (51 KB, 189x244) Image search: [Google]
83.png
51 KB, 189x244
>>135823402
>expecting all those VAs to do eroge roles
>expecting HanaKana to do an eroge role

I'm laughin'
>>
>>135824987
>you will never hear hanakana moaning
why live
>>
This was better than expected. Having the main girl be a cool beauty is always a good thing, but the other girls seem good too.
Even if they're just the typical genki childhood friend and the typical fujo.
>>
>>135815122
I never had a problem telling characters apart, but I thonestly wouldn't be able to tell the difference between her and Accel World's heroine.
>>
>>135825523
You will always have her screaming. It's too bad she's not in the League of Legends Japanese dub, almost all the noises each character makes when they get hit is essentially moaning
>>
File: 1451944462337.jpg (24 KB, 329x297) Image search: [Google]
1451944462337.jpg
24 KB, 329x297
>>135815122
>Saekano invent Eroge making anime
Shitkanofags everyone
>>
>>135825524
>Having the main girl be a cool beauty
She seemed like having a serious case of autism for me.
>>
>>135825524
The character arcthype is generic, but likeable. Kuroda is Yukino + Yozora done right.
>>
File: 1451820588132.jpg (106 KB, 1280x738) Image search: [Google]
1451820588132.jpg
106 KB, 1280x738
>>135825677
I just thought she was kind of chuuni. She talks like one.
>>
MC picks Genki girl right?

No way is this dead fish winning shit.
>>
>>135826173
Genki childhood friend never wins. If MC picks someone is going to be the long haired beauty.
>>
File: 1442882446646.jpg (116 KB, 1306x1224) Image search: [Google]
1442882446646.jpg
116 KB, 1306x1224
>>135826173
I'll give you a hint anon.
The best girl never wins.
>>
File: 1423876942994.jpg (121 KB, 599x880) Image search: [Google]
1423876942994.jpg
121 KB, 599x880
>>135826241
>>135826213
>>
>>135826173
Genki will love MC while MC best friend loves Genki. Unrequited love all round. You should know this by now.
>>
File: 1743272.jpg (38 KB, 225x347) Image search: [Google]
1743272.jpg
38 KB, 225x347
>>135826213
>Genki childhood friend never wins
Oh really?
>>
>>135824668
https://vndb.org/v14303
>>
File: 1432701456384.webm (663 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1432701456384.webm
663 KB, 1280x720
Yuuka a cute!
>>
File: DEEP.png (916 KB, 1279x1068) Image search: [Google]
DEEP.png
916 KB, 1279x1068
>>135819142
>>
>>135826414
>no sexual content
>>
>>135826660
Because Akame ga Kill and Yuuki Yuuna changed Takahiro like Tosh.
>>
Dolphins are fucking terrifying.
>>
Swear to fucking god if my Oscar-sama clone doesn't appear I will murder Takahiro
>>
>>135826917
No, the Japanese are just afraid of dolphins.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGepBtBCuTY
>>
This reminded me a lot of early 2000s romance shows like Amagami and such, and I liked how everything looked a bit rundown. Animation was a bit rough in places, but seems enjoyable.
>>
>>135827678
Or jesus, Amagami was only 2010, why the fuck does that feel so long ago.
>>
>>135827755
Because 6 years is a long time? That's 2 years longer than High School.
>>
>>135815122
Is that Yukinon? Yahello!
>>
>>135827879
True true, anon.
>>
>>135815122
No it's better
>>
>>135816236
I thought the game was due to be released in March
>>
File: 1401872420428.jpg (60 KB, 550x366) Image search: [Google]
1401872420428.jpg
60 KB, 550x366
>>135827879
>Amagami was only 2010
>>
>>135828144
time moves forward and nothing changes
>>
>>135815122

Kuroyukihime, is that you?
>>
File: 1452188852394.jpg (341 KB, 1920x2608) Image search: [Google]
1452188852394.jpg
341 KB, 1920x2608
>>
File: 1452189276353.jpg (159 KB, 1920x1215) Image search: [Google]
1452189276353.jpg
159 KB, 1920x1215
>>
>>135815122
What's with that dirty piss sub? What did HS ripped from this time? Is Senketsu decent as an alternative?
>>
>tfw fansubbing is dead
>>
>>135829524
Ripped from Hulu. Senketsu is the same.
>>
>>135829633
>Hulu
Well shit. At least I can change the color and font so let's go with senketsu and a raw then. Thanks mate.
>>
>>135815122

Yeah, I'll make a game with you. An endurance game in your bed. Why don't we skip the production part and start testing it straight away?
>>
>watching the anime when the superior VN is coming out
>doubting Romeo in any way

If you'd read the VN trial and some interviews, you'd see that it's almost nothing like Saekano. I'll even tell you the details.

Saekano is a show about girls with a doujinshi creation at its background. The focus in put on the girls, their relationships with Tomoya and past things that happened between them. When it depicts doujinshi creation, it's all idealistic and self-congratulatory.

Shoukomeza is about VN creation first and foremost. The latter parts (which the anime won't cover) will have plenty of drama surrounded with VN creation, which you can see in the "coming soon" segment at the end of the trial. The trial itself is all about Sayuki gathering people to make the game with.

If you want to say Romeo ripped-off Saekano, at least use Otaku Masshigura, that's like a Saekano rip-off with cosplay instead of doujinshi. Romeo wrote in it 2006 (lot of foresight on his part).
>>
I don't like the MC, it gives me Hayama vibes.
Also this shitty hulu rips are the worst, everything looks fucking blurry and those yellow subs gave me eyecancer
>>
>written by Romeo Tanaka
I never checked who did this one. I'm totally in for this.
>>
>the chances of this getting S2 is almost zero

Damn. It's so good but we're going to get cucked by the ending.
>>
>>135830398
You don't need a S2 when it's a VN.
>>
>>135830398
Play the game™
>>
>>135830448
Yeah you do.
>>
>>135830483
You don't even need a S1 when it's a VN.
>>
>>135830520
Yeah you do.
>>
>>135827879
>2010 was six (6) years ago
Holy fuck, it feels so weird.

Anyway, this show seems comfy as fuck. I hope the bro wins.
>>
>>135815122
>female autism the anime

why did this shitshow even get the go ahead
>>
>>135830398
Don't worry friend, I'll make some threads about the VN once it comes out. Got it preordered already.
>>
>cute and genki tomboy who's voiced by HanaKana
>a girl with long black hair and autism
>that cheap animation quality
Not going to drop this either. Hopefully the Saekano comparisons will end at some point because holy fuck I don't want the threads for this show to become like the threads for that.
>>
>>135828120
There's a demo or something
>>
>>135818962
Hanakana can only do one range voice
>>
>>135824032
yes, a megane qt
>>
>>135815122
Yukino rip-off.
>>
File: 18143.jpg (16 KB, 256x300) Image search: [Google]
18143.jpg
16 KB, 256x300
>>135831580
You mean Aoba ripoff.
>>
>>135831814
who
>>
I liked the G string refrences
>>
>>135832133
>he didn't even play Kazoku Keikaku

It's even in English.
>>
>>135832314
Looks like shit
>>
>>135832359
>this new
>>
File: Shoujo-tachi on the G string.jpg (356 KB, 2204x718) Image search: [Google]
Shoujo-tachi on the G string.jpg
356 KB, 2204x718
>>135832218
I kinda thought his looked like one.


also though piss yellow subtitles were hell.
>>
>>135832218
It had for all looseboy games, many giga games yet no minato games, weird.
>>
why so dead
>>
>>135832671
I'm surprised they didn't mention F/SN, that's the most popular VN after Looseboy's VNs.
>>
>>135834145
You're overrating Looseboy as fuck.
>>
>>135826519
"I hate nice grills" incoming
>>
>>135815122
What the fuck is Saekano?
>>
LOL
>>
File: 58452121212.jpg (353 KB, 1249x889) Image search: [Google]
58452121212.jpg
353 KB, 1249x889
>>135834236
Right now Looseboy isn't that popular, but back then he was popular as fuck.
>>
>>135834497
His reputation went down after the Juukishi scandal and BokuSen being meh.
>>
Ain't this by that fucker that has some grade S grammar LN that no one dares to translate?
>>
>>135835564
It's by Tanaka Romeo.

He wrote Kana: Imouto, Kazoku Keikaku, Natsuyume Yawa, Cross Channel, Saihate no Ima, Junrui wa Suitai Shimashita, AURA, Ken to Mahou no Fantasy etc.

He's indeed most excellent at stringing words together, but some of his works were translated. Quality of said translations is another issue.
>>
File: 01_064.jpg (142 KB, 674x989) Image search: [Google]
01_064.jpg
142 KB, 674x989
>>135835564
Jinrui wa suitaishimashita was that one. Here is a page from the first LN if you know japanese to confirm this grade S grammar meme.
>>
>>135835991
I do know, but fuck me trying to read that gave me a headache
>>
>>135835991
That was rather easy for me.

>>135836034
Are you sure you know Japanese? I guess "know" is a broad word.
>>
comfy show of the season.
>>
>>135826519
I just had this playing in my head while listening to that

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H-POzIrRh0c

She's too chuuni4me
>>
>>135819681
>>135817720
>>135819040
>>135815956
DUDE DRESSES LIKE A LAYDEEEEEEEH
>>
>>135836103
He knows of it.
>>
Damn that was so good, the main chracters are all great.
>>
Why are they suddently using piss subs again? That Norn show had it as well. How could CR even get worse than it already was?
>>
>>135840424
It's Hulu.
>>
File: 1338839990439.jpg (161 KB, 400x450) Image search: [Google]
1338839990439.jpg
161 KB, 400x450
>>135815122
>Is this show just a ripoff of saekano?

Just got done watching and no, it isn't a rip off if it does everything worse. Less fan service, less story, less interesting characters, less interesting MC, less animation, less colors and worse writing.

I guess some people would say that writing and story are the same thing, but I disagree here. In Saekano, the girls were well rounded in their likes and dislikes while taking actions to further their own means without the MC being involved. That is an example of good writing, but the story is the ultimate goal that pools these characters towards their ambitions, which Saekano did better. In Saekano, each girl was an opponent to be won over by MC-kun, in Shoujo-tachi the cast feels like same minded goal pursing people, who magically found each other and everything was honkey dory.

The tension should come from conflicting views and goals which Saekano did amazingly at. In Shoujo-tachi, I can already foresee the forced DRAMA signs creeping up on the series that runs rampant in other shitty harems.
>>
>>135841265
You're retarded.
>>
>>135841339

no ur face is
>>
>>135835991
I've finished jinrui and it's really not that difficult. Of course that's just a personal opinion though.

Something that's hard would be like stuff from railsoft or muramasa.
>>
>>135841265
>complaring a first episode of anime to a series you fully read/watched
Are you retarded?
>>
>>135842107
comparing*
>>
>>135815122
>Is this show just a ripoff of saekano?

https://youtu.be/EAisB1qV6q0
53分ぐらいから 「少女たちは荒野を目指す」について

川瀬P、里見P、黒田役の千菅:

・学校の同好会でゲームを作る話。内容はざっくり言うと去年うちで作ったSHIROBAKOのゲーム版。
会社に企画通す時にゲーム版SHIROBAKOって言った。
ものづくりの面白さや楽しさ、想いを表現する。それプラス青春もの。
ものづくりに関わる人の本音を込めて作っている
・ロミオさんの元シナリオは膨大だが、脚本の綾奈(ゆにこ)が上手く整理している。1話ごとの情報量は多い
・監督(佐藤卓哉※Selector、シュタゲなど)は
 あまりマニアックなネタにばっかり走りすぎないように人間ドラマとのバランスに気を使ってくれている
・オーディションはゲームとアニメ合わせて行った。結構な人数。
>>
>>135842212
・黒田役の千菅はSHIROBAKOもやっていて、アニメ作りモノとゲーム作りモノどちらも関わった事に。
・夕夏役の花澤さんは一発で場の空気を持っていって、やっぱり凄かった。
もう既に釘宮の領域に入っている。完全に作り込んできてぴったり合わせてきた
夕夏は作品内におけるゲーム内キャラの芝居もやるので、一番大変な役かも。
・佐藤聡美さん、豊永さんも良い仕事してる。青春物は空気感も大事なので
 キャスト陣の年齢を合わせることが多いが、今作はそこも上手くハマった
・佐藤卓哉監督はSelectorで初めて組んだが本当に優秀な監督。
 群像劇における人物描写を丁寧にやってくれていて、本人も手応えを感じてる様子
・ゲームと一緒に世界観を統一して作っていったので、感覚的にはほぼオリジナル作品に近い
・1話はもう完パケ済み。アフレコは色がついていた。
・水島努は完成形をすでにイメージして作っているので、ダビングの仕事が毎回早い。
・SHIROBAKOは大人のプロ達のモノ作りの群像劇だったが、今作は若者達なりのモノ作りの群像劇になる。

Basically they want to be Shirobako of galgame industry, not Saekano.
>>
I want to bully her.
>>
>>135841265
>In Saekano, each girl was an opponent to be won over by MC-kun, in Shoujo-tachi the cast feels like same minded goal pursing people, who magically found each other and everything was honkey dory.
It's called "friends" anon, no every female should be friends with MC only because she's after his dick.

Also read the thread before posting, it's been already explained that Saekano and this have nothing in common other than that characters want to create a game.
>>
>>135815122

With a shitty boring MC instead of funny retard like tomokun.
>>
>>135842631
>funny
He's obnoxious and annoying.
>>
OH MY GOD I WILL BE ABLE TO FUCK THE DARK HAIRED GIRL HOLY SHIT BEST DAY OF MY LIFE
>>
It sucks waiting for decent subs.
>>
>>135842735
Anime isn't real kid.
>>
No, never.
>>
>>135842735
the vn rated all ages
>>
>>135842841
Wait fucking what? Minato-Soft making an all ages VN? Literally fucking dropped before it was released holy fuck what
>>
>>135842841
So no sex? Dropped.
>>
>>135842881
>>135842882

well they did it before
https://vndb.org/v16448

come one do you guys really believe kanahana will do eroge ?

well i hope she does in the future
>>
>>135843020
>implying because they did in the past it's suddenly okay
Fuck off this is the worst news I've heard all 2016
>>
>>135815122
anyone know why the HS rip is only like 150MB @720p? i'm holding off watching it in lieu of better quality rips
>>
How do yo explain "Tanaka Romeo" to someone who only watch and enjoying Jinrui wa Suitai Shimashita?
>>
>>135843598
Do you need to? Jintai is explanation enough.
>>
>>135843598
GOD
>>
>>135826471
she clips through the other character shoulder as she runs round.
>>
Is Asenshi going to sub this or not?
>>
>>135842881
>>135842882
>all that shit taste
Go on sadpanda if you all you want is to see a girl being fucked

That VN has great chracters and interactions as well as interesting premise, dropping it solely because it doesn't have sex scenes is dumb
>>
>>135844170

actually i almost drop it, but that redhead glasses is too strong to resist
>>
>>135843861
so she's tellin him to "hit it and quit it" with her?
>>
>>135819142
What the fuck does "for the sake of her bitchiness" even mean?
>>
>>135826471
>That fucking clipping

Why is this allowed?
>>
>>135819416
>Takahiro
Wait, what the fuck? I was sold this show as written by Romeo Tanaka.
>>
>>135824987
What a fucking newfag.
>>
>>135838955
The character interactions are great, plus the MC is way better than Saekano's. As expected of Romeo.
Could do without all the obnoxious references to "you know what yuri is? It's an otaku thing!".
At least the MC didn't care or know about it.

>>135835907
And Rewrite, which has an anime airing this year.
>>
>>135826173
>genki girl is in this position >>135826241 whis her legs wide open
>no sign of lust in MC look
Pffffhahahahahaha. Yeah, sure, she'll win.
>>
>>135827879
>2
Maybe in burgerland.
>>
>>135842881
>>135842882
>>135844170
>vnfags
Honestly both sides are retarded.
>>
Good subs.
>>
Real subs when?
>>
>>135845220
Never
>>
>>135816129
>>135822073
This
>>
Looks like I am not the only one that is annoyed by the yellow text. Font size also seems a tad big.
>>
File: vlcsnap-2016-01-08-13h31m02s381.png (787 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
vlcsnap-2016-01-08-13h31m02s381.png
787 KB, 1280x720
Would you watch this social phenomenon?
>>
>>135847039
Not with vlc.
>>
>>135847039
I would watch a color swapped Madoka.
>>
>>135847039
I would let my kids watch it.
>>
>>135815122
>this fucking character again

Fucking dropped.
>>
Wait wait wait, Tanaka Romeo is behind this one? I was planning on dropping it because I thought it was going to be generic shit, but I'll give it a chance for my man Romeo.
>>
File: Capture.png (90 KB, 448x334) Image search: [Google]
Capture.png
90 KB, 448x334
mfw i dont know who is romeo, and why people highly praise him.

i only want to give a shot to this anime, since i see this in minatosoft page more than 6 months

and yes i'm a minato-fags
>>
>>135848794
You couldn't be more of a newfag if you tried.
Thread replies: 204
Thread images: 47

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.