ITT: We rate FPS games based on how realistic or arcade they are.
0 for full arcade, 10 for full realism.
I'll start.
>Half Life
7
>>344566625
>Cod of Duty
4
>7
>HL1
This is bait.
Counterstrike - 9
>>344566625
>arcade is 0
>full realism is 10
Kill yourself.
>>344567097
Its a scale, not an actual rating.
1 - Overwatch
2 - Team Fortress
3 - FEAR
4 - Advanced Warfare
5 - Modern Warfare
6 - Half Life
7 - Counter Strike GO
8 - SWAT 4
9 - Red Orchestra
10 - Arma 2
TF2
>4
The gameplay is somewhat complex, but it still uses made up rules for everything
Dying Light
3
Operation Flashpoint - 9
Duke Nukem Forever
7
>>344566625
>Crysis 1
"lmao nanosuit" can be used to explain everything so 10
>>344569658
>No bullet penetration
>No bullet arc
9.
DOOM, Overwatch - 1
>>344566625
How in the flying fuck do you figure Half life is a 7?
Try like a 4 or 5.
>>344570282
Most weapons are credible, monsters go down in a realistic amount of shots, your armor doesn't absorb ALL the damage, etc.
>>344567216
in what universe is csgo realistic.
1-Overwatch
2-DOOM
3-Halo
4-Half Life
5-COD
6-STALKER
7-Battlefield 3/4
8-America's Army
9-Squad
10- ARMA
CS GO - 9
>>344571270
The CSGO universe.
Rainbow Six (up until Raven Shield) - 9
>>344570637
>monsters
this immediately makes it a 5 at most
>>344566625
5
>>344570637
>Most weapons are credible
You get laser weapons, the ghostbusters gun, and throw alien critters at people. The MP5, SPAS-12 also aren't exactly accurate either, pump action that's also a double barrel for alt fire, ect.
>monsters go down in a realistic amount of shots
>Monsters
>Realistic
lol.
>your armor doesn't absorb ALL the damage
Neither does Iron Man's, but that doesn't mean his suit is realistic either.
It's not the most unrealistic thing on the market, but there's no way it's that high all things considered.
>>344571307
not even arma is full realistic, arma is like 8 on realism with those terrible physics it has
Space Station 13 - ???
>>344571769
I assume its a relative scale.
Is 6.5 correct for BF3?
Insurgency - 8
>>344571769
Maybe shift ARMA down to 9 and put VBS 3 in 10 slot although you need a government approved license or whatever to get it.
But as far as realism goes ARMA is about the best you can do. Nothing else even tries to get that close like Squad or RO2.
>>344572049
no
it is a 3 at best
>>344571307
I think Stalker should be higher, like 7, maybe 8.
Regarding gunplay that game is incredible, specially on Hard.
>>344572224
shooter games will never be 10/10 realistic, maybe a racing game can easily get there, but a shooter? no way
dirt rally is the closest to perfect realism
>>344572505
A racing game will not get any closer than an FPS to being the sort of 10/10 realism that you somehow think a racing game can do.
Arma and Swat are the only realistic series I can think of.
Counter Strike would be a fair bit./
Most of the others just claim realism as way to justify cover based shooting to compensate for a controller and/or get their idea of realism from Rambo.
Doom is probably the other end of the spectrum. If you are gonna ride the crazy train to batshit town, you may as well blow the whistle too.
>>344566625
cs: go - 10
This is the most realistic, true to life simulation game ever conceived of.
>>344572268
Please, don't fall into the 'STALKER has good gunplay' meme. STALKER's gunplay isn't that good, and STALKER overall has other unrealistic things that say Battlefield doesn't have by having no monsters, mutants, no instantly fixing radiation poisoning with meds, wishgranter, exoskeletons, ect.
STALKER is less realistic than Battlefield in everything but maybe damage model and medical system since you technically do need to bandage, where you just regenerate in BF.
>>344566625
what is the dark souls of fps?
>>344566892
>pinpoint accuracy
>guns make the exact same firing pattern, every time
>no riot shields
>no mines or booby traps
>no civilians in danger
>no scoping
2/10
>>344572942
STALKER
Its vastly unfair and heavy on atmosphere and it makes you keep coming back for the abuse because ultimately it is fun.
>>344572942
Quake 3.
>>344571706
>>344571759
>Monsters
You two realize that realistic doesn't mean a simulation of real life.
>adjective: having or showing a sensible and practical idea of what can be achieved or expected.
Overwatch
SC
for Super Casual
>>344572263
liar
>>344573062
Hitscan
No hinderance to movement when shot
No bleeding out/losing conciousness
Grenades do nothing
Knife instantly kills where bullets can't.
>>344567216
Where would you place Insurgency?
>>344573562
7, gunplay is realistic but the overall game isn't, in no place on earth does war play like that
>>344573718
What about a relative scale? Its probably placed with Arma?
>>344573362
>expecting monsters to appear in real life
>>344571307
Swap halo and half life
>>344573464
haha epic dude XD
>>344573718
How is Insurgency and csgo the same?
>>344573829
>Being retarded
>>344573918
i'm not the same guy, csgo is hardly a 7
>>344566625
DOOM - 8
>inb4 deons
You know what I'm talking about
>>344573924
I'm applying the definition you provided.
>>344574034
>DOOM - 8
>>344574070
>Showing practical idea of what can be achieved or expected = 100% adhering to real life
Once again
>Being retarded
>>344573362
Are you expecting monsters sometime soon?
Anyway, where are you even getting that definition of realism? Just first thing off of google, and you just convieniently cut off the 2nd part of it.
2. representing familiar things in a way that is accurate or true to life.
Which, would exclude shit like monsters, demons, magic, ect. because that's not true to life.
Just because someone realistically rendered Gandalf or a troll or something giving it a sensible and/or practical idea of what a troll would look like doesn't make it realistic.
>>344566625
All GTAs would fall in the 6-5 category I guess.
>>344574215
So you're telling me that monsters found in half life aren't fantastical?
>>344575720
Monsters found in HL and HL2 are fantastical, but behave somewhat realistically. Zombies are slow and monsters that are fast are also very thin and weight little, for example.
>>344573062
>riot shields
>mines
>"scoping"
>>344575996
>Monsters found in HL and HL2 are fantastical, but behave somewhat realistically
How the hell do you figure what is realistic behavior for something that doesn't exist?
Dragons from HTTYD and the talking thinking Sean Connery dragons from Dragonheart are equally "realistic".
It's like saying the Terminator is realistic but Robocop isn't.
>>344571270
The universe where people fear death because it has consequence and you don't get to pick and choose super powers like your guns being magically stronger or anything, where you don't have giant electromagnet rifles that pick things up and throw them at aliens from another dimension, and where bunnyhopping ain't easy.
So yeah, CS:GO isn't exactly realistic, but it's moreso than Half Life and Modern Warfare.
>>344567216
Are you just doing this so you can mention Overwatch?
Alright /v/
what's literally the best FPS currently?
no nostalgia and cult bullshit
>>344577415
Gone Home
>>344577415
Timesplitters 2
CSGO - 9
>>344577648
3 was much better IMO
>>344566625
>HL Series
1
>Counter Strike
3
>overwatch
1
>Doom
3
>Red Orchestra 1
5
Arma 3 with all the tryhard mods
>7
>Project Reality
6
>Battlefield
3
>D.U.S.T.
8
>crysis
2
>STALKER
6
>Siege
4
>Insurgency
4
>>344577415
Orion; Dino Beatdown
>>344577415
I think it's siege despite all it's problems
Fite me.
>>344578114
>>344577849
cute
>>344577415
Multiplayer: BF4 or Overwatch depending on your preferences for more 'realism' or just quick light hearted fun.
Single Player: DOOM
>>344578076
>STALKER
>as realistic as PR
>more realistic than Battlefield
You STALKER fags are delusional. All that vodka and slavshit must have scorched out your brains.
>>344578174
Of course I'm kidding you butt pirate
I'll give Republic Commando a 7 in its realism scale.
>>344570637
Nigga. Quake3 is a 1 on the scale. Half life is a 3 at most.
Halo and Unreal at around 2.8
Cod 1-4 at 4-4.5.
Modern BF at around 5
CS at like 5.5
Project Reality at 7-8
Arma at 8.5.
High end flight Sims start at 9.5.
>>344579348
Do you people even go outside, is your sense of reality this warped?
>>344578540
I understand that this is bait, but kill yourself anyway.
Verdun
10
>>344566625
1 - Far Cry: Blood Dragon
1 - Blood
2 - Call of Juarez: Gunslinger
9 -- Arma 2
9 -- Jagged Alliance 2
7 -- Men of War Series
9 -- Red Orchestra
7 -- Red Orchestra 2
Battlefield 1942 -- 4
>>344579817
How is this bait? Go on, explain yourself.
>>344580536
That sounds like something someone who posted bait would say.
Where would you put black?
I give it a 4
>>344577415
Siege, Insurgency, CoD4.
>>344573184
STALKER and Dark Souls are both fair, they just don't care if you enjoy them or not.
>>344580620
Ok, so you actually have nothing. Thanks for letting us know.
>>344571307
>DOOM more realistic than Overwatch
But in Overwatch you move about as slow as you do in real life.
10 VBS
9-8 Arma series and other consumer sims
7-6 "Simcade" RO series
5 Insurgency maybe old battlefield
4 battlefield
3 Call of duty
2 Doom because of the minigun
1 Quake 3
>>344582370
Yeah, but in Overwatch you don't get turned into paste when you get hit by a rocket, there's no blood, you just ragdoll and that's it.
Plus, it depends on character, some move far faster than you could IRL.
I think DOOM is only slightly more realistic than Overwatch, not a lot. It just edges out because things bleed when they get hit, gibbed when they get hit by rockets or other really powerful weapons.
It's got pokemon syndrome, pic related.
>>344582610
I'd say Battlefield is more realistic than Insurgency because of it's inclusion of combined arms/vehicles in combat, as well as not having hitscan, but it's close.
-5
>>344579491
>Halo and Unreal at around 2.8
Halo is, way, way more grounded in reality then UT.
>>344573062
CS is caught in some weird hell between arcade shooters and modern shooters.
>shitty "realism" mechanics like spray
>spray is implemented extremely poorly and abusing it for pinpoint accuracy is considered a feature
>>344583568
Not Halo 5
Project Reality - 10
>>344571758
On Expert.
Fuck. Expert difficulty would be perfect if it wasn't for the normal infected damage.
>survivors die easily from friendly fire
>hunters literally rip you apart in seconds
>smokers choke you out easily
>tanks smash your shit like nothing
but then
>normal infected kill you in five hits from punching you
seriously, if it wasn't for that bullshit Expert would be perfect
>>344584571
>dislike spray patterns
>shit opinion
