Now that the dust has settled we can all agree that
W1>W3>W2
Right /v/?
>>344439174
yes.
>inb4 buttmad Xbox kids who can't deal with pure CRPG controls in 1
Witcher 1 - Neverwinter Nights mod with shittier rhythm game combat
Witcher 2 - "we want the AAA audience" action RPG
Witcher 3 - "we want the Skyrim audience" open world RPG
>>344439661
/thread
>>344439661
>Witcher 2 - "we want the Demon's Souls audience" action RPG
FTFY. Hell, devs even admitted that.
Also, TW1's combat is great, and the game in general is comfy.
>>344439661
>RPG
>Witcher
>>344440054
>role-playing game
>you play the role of a witcher
you're a dumby!
>>344439336
I think W2 was the tightest story-wise, actually. First game was basically just adaptation of short stories with some original narrative and third game was playing on player's investment up to that point, resolving some hooks from the books and emotional factor. When CDPR had full freedom with their narrative in W2 they made a great thing. problem was people just accused it of being Game of Thrones because politics. Another problem was that Gop was a massive Dark Souls fanboys and wanted that style of combat in the game.
>>344440236
>I think W2 was the tightest story-wise, actually.
I thought it was the shittiest one with worst overall design. Also terrible gameplay and UI-wise.
I'd never even heard of GoT by the time I played Witcher 1 & 2.
>>344439661
>Witcher 3 - "we want the Skyrim audience" open world RPG
Skyrim and Witcher 3 are nothing alike, though. Just because they're quasi open world, lest we forget there are loading screens for every interior in TES games, their focuses as games lie in VASTLY different departments.
>>344439661
/thread
>>344439174
Witcher 2 had the best main quest/story, everything else was better in the other two games though
>>344440236
Expected a dumb brute, players?
>>344439174
Witcher ! gameplay sucks balls
