has any Open world game ever surpassed the quality of RDR ?
>inb4 Witchter 3
name another one
Nope, and it probably never will
>>342766404
Most of them actually. RDR wasn't anything special outside of a western theme.
Witcher 3: Blood and Wine
>>342766404
Witcher 3
>>342767243
Nah you're retarded.
>>342766404
Skyrim
>>342766404
morrowind and oblivion
>>342766404
GTA V
>>342766404
RDR was boring as fuck though.
>>342766404
>the quality of RDR
You mean an empty fucking bunch of dirt, a couple shacks, some trees and a bunch of cougars?
Yeah, pretty much every game surpassed that shit.
Probably not.
RDR successfully condensed every western movie/tv trope into itself.
Its probably the reason their holding off making a sequel. I mean where do they go from here? other than improved graphics/gameplay
>>342766404
Maybe GTAV. Maybe.
>>342766404
>>342767451
so yeah....mad max
>>342767418
>>342767451
Little dick white bois detected
>>342767418
>>342767451
Fucking end yourself
gothic 2. set the benchmark for open world until tw3 came out.
>>342766404
Skyrim.
I even hate skyrim and love RDR, but the map is shit
>>342767068
>>342767418
>>342767451
Anally annihilated PCucks detected
>>342767572
>>342767653
>>342768123
rdr is the pinnacle of the empty open world meme
the only reason it isn't universally shit on like any other shitty open world game is because it was saved by a great story, cast, and western theme
the world was only filled with sites for missions you got at a town, no exploration or anything interesting to find
t. loved the game
>>342768123
I'm a sonygger for life and rdr did nothing for me.
>>342768347
Only little dick white bois can't comprehend how excellent the map was
>>342766404
the game was fun but it suffers so much from "babbies first openworld game nostalgia"'
most openworld games are better
>>342768634
>most openworld games are better
name 5
>>342766404
Rdr really wasn't that great. I don't see why people like Rockstar so much. I'd say Phantom pain blows it out of the water for me.
Before you call me a pcuck Bloodborne is the best game of the last few years. RDR just was mediocre as fuck.
My only gripe with the world map was the rapid transition of certain zones.
>In Hennigans Stead, a dusty prairie flatland like Oklahoma or some shit.
>walk 20 feet and you're in Thieves Landing, a swampy wetland like New Orleans.
Anyways, if RDR2 addsa fishing mechanic, I will never leave
>>342768997
>RDR just was mediocre as fuck.
the gameplay /Gunplay was solid, the story was solid and the graphics too maybe its the shitty mission design from GTA4 ?
Plenty of them have.
A recent example would be Dying Light.
>>342769138
Yeah I dunno. I haven't enjoyed a rockstar game since maybe SA.
>>342768347
>the open world was a character of its self
>a back drop to the story of your character
Oh wow you're a fucking retard who can't actually play games.
Open world doesn't mean shit.
Just like mafia 1 and 2, the open world was a back drop for the events to transpire in.
