Ed is too strong.

They're both hell fiends, but Ed is defeatable. If Doomguy were to remove the pebble from Ed's shoe, his offensive abilities would be effectively neutered.
I feel that the two of them both follow some form of cartoon law about obscene power and invulnerability, so it's a stalemate until the pebble is removed. Ed leans more on the Rule of Funny while Doomguy is just fucking invincible.
It's a draw, if anything. The real loser is anyone within a 5 mile radius of the event.

>>340314935
But doomguy isnt invincible

The episode in question can be seen here famalams.
https://youtu.be/ybbp_s0FVxU

Ed ate a fucking slide just because he was pissed off.

>>340314935
doomguy is nowhere near invincible.
if he were you wouldn't be able to die in the doom games.

>>340316849
You can die on DOOM games? What the fuck

Ed gets shot by police for an episode of manic pepersonalization. Doom guy accidentally kills 500,000 police officers due to his schizophrenia.

TFW doom guy was too late to save his canonically broist bestie who could a saved the world with him

>>340317314
Too soon rip Ed

After watching that episode again I would say Doomguy is sufficiently fucked.