Hahaha.
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /v/ - Video Games
You are currently reading a thread in /v/ - Video Games
Hahaha.
>>340152514
How did this happen?
>>340152514
>>340152571
STARTING A PETITION RIGHT NOW
REMOVE THIS SCORE
IT'S A 10/10
>>340152571
>IGN of all places is more grounded than NDfags
What went wrong?
>>340152514
How is the third act a negative?
It's the first two that are atrocious and nothing like Uncharted.
lmao
>>340152571
They are not wrong though.
9 is still a great score.
Is this game shit or are they mad that it isn't a perfect 10?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXaXz-0fWkI
This video pretty much sums up what /v/ is doing with this game or should i say false flag :^)
i love this game and i love the franchise but i don't think it should be a 10/10
>>340152514
>movie
>slick gameplay
wat
>>340152717
>review
>spoilers the end in the review
whoa edgy
>>340152742
Any sonyexclusive review that isn't 10/10 is PCFRIENDS trolling and needs to be cens... I mean removed from the internet.
>>340152514
What's funny?
>>340152730
9 is mediocre dude 9.5 and 10 are good scores.
>>340152571
Yeah whos fault is that IGN?
>>340152514
DELETE THIS ITS PERFECT NINTENDO PAID IGN TO GIVE IT A LOWER SCORE
>>340152908
9 is a flop according to /v/ because it's a PS4 exclusive. Likewise, 9.1 - 10 is paid.
>>340152809
>people actually wanted that reviewer fired
lmao what the fuck it's not like he's the guy who reviews God Hand on IGN
>>340152908
It's a movie being high rated on a videogames publication.
>>340152861
>>340152571
all the inflated review scores are partly their fault. video game critique is the worst of any medium.
>>340152871
you can spoil dogshit story
>>340152908
>>340152908
I actually highlighted the dislike bar Gramps.
>>340152514
>9/10, too much game
Never change, IGN
>>340152963
>he doesn't use a 0.05 increment system
Serves you right, shills.
>>340152707
It drags on for a long ass time. The first two acts did new things, the third act was just same old Uncharted.
Still, a solid 9/10 and really the perfect way to end the series.
>>340153085
Oh.probably just children griefing for the lulz
Should be a 6/10 for lack of imagination.
>It's another boring derivative western normiecore shooter
BRAVO.
>>340153098
>Sony dudes are this stupid
Length = Quality.
>>340152514
Why is multiplayer considered a "pro"?
>comments are full of saying this deserved more because some COD game did
do these faggots realize different people reviewed them?
>>340152514
DELETE THIS BEFORE THE PKEKS SEE IT
DELETE THIS NOW!!!
IM CALLING OBAMA SO THAT THE SCORE WILL BE RAISED
DELETE THIS
>>340153326
Because it's good
>>340152514
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/comic-riffs/wp/2016/05/12/uncharted-4-a-thiefs-end-review-this-four-part-series-should-have-ended-after-part-one/
https://www.change.org/p/washington-post-remove-the-washington-post-review-from-uncharted-4-s-metascore
i can't even blame this one on uncharted fans. theres another stupid petition to remove IGN's review of doom. why are gamers such fucking crybabies?
>>340152864
only correct opinion
>>340153371
Ironic shitposting is still shitposting
>>340153326
>>340153326
Maybe because it's explained in the actually review and not a 2 word summary?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cXyQg_5uoc
I don't really understand anymore
>>340153326
because its the current year and games are either single or multiplayer now
>>340153445
Okay so they're literally underage.
Good to know.
>>340153437
It's sonyggers that are "clinging to it" if anything, look at that dislike bar, how can you be so triggered over a review?
>>340153279
>the first two acts did new things
They did nothing that TLoU didn't do. That's one of my biggest complaints actually. There is just too many TLoU influences in it which is not fitting at all.
>the third act was just same old Uncharted
And that's all I wanted. Adventure. Not this drama bs with no gameplay.
>a solid 9/10 and really the perfect way to end the series.
More like a 7. Overall the game barely felt like Uncharted.
>9/10 is a bad score
I mean come on, 8.8 was bad enough.
Granted, that was much funnier in context, but still.
>>340153419
>why are gamers such fucking crybabies?
Shut the fuck up and stop acting like you've never created a petition being on /v/. This is where these things are fucking started, normalshit.
>>340153335
>/v/ defending Cowadooty 10/10's
SUMMERRRRRR
>>340152514
Anyone needs any more reasons why score based rating is pure cancer ?
>>340153773
>Shut the fuck up and stop acting like you've never created a petition being on /v/.
Wait, you're telling me you've actually created petitions before?
>All those dislikes for a very good score
Now I remember why Sony fanboys are the worst fanbase around.
>>340153773
no i've never done that, quit projecting turbonerd
>>340153850
>I'm so illiterate that I don't know the difference between explaining and defending
Good to know champ
>>340153875
gaming journalism itself is cancer.
>>340153437
>PS4 exclusive got a 10/10
which one?
>>340153884
normalshits leave
>>340153950
REMINDER /V/
>>340153954
>TPP has a better score on Bone than on PS4
BTFO
>>340153850
not defending it, just saying that because some other retard gave shit a good score doesnt mean this should get a better score.
>>340153986
>He thinks petitions are a /v/ thing
You first buddy
>>340153850
>>340153850
sauce?
>>340154110
normalshits leave
>>340153850
>summerfag meme
>>340154198
Seriously?
>>340154234
I don't see a petition in there friend
>>340154198
http://exhentai.org/g/753050/0772bc0841/
>>340154262
>summer doesn't exist >>340154198
GO PLAY COWADOODY NORMALSHITS
>Bloated third act.
Add "Bloated first act" to that as well.
Only the middle act of the game is actually good.
>>340152514
I think it's the best Uncharted by a long mile.
I had no problem with the pacing either. The long trudging through Madagascar and those islands made it genuinely feel like an adventure.
My biggest gripe is they've never hinted at a brother until they forced him in. Outside of that, ND fucking knocked it out of the park.
>>340154354
i see retarded shit like that all year
>>340154364
Game is perfect. You just have ADD and don't look for treasures and don't talk to your partners.
>>340152871
you mean YOU CAN KILL YOUR SON AND NUKE BOSTON which was spoiled about a week before release?
>>340154347
>>340154275
I don't get it? can u just give me the gif hentai so i can fap
>>340154516
SUMMERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
NORMALSHITS LEAVE
>>340152717
what review is this?
>>340154572
again, i see retards like that all year.
you just act like its different when it happens during summer
>>340154347
Wait a minute i recognize that boy.... anon are you trying to trick me le goofy.jpg
>>340154572
Calm down anon.
>>340154430
Oh please, it's a bunch of exposition and character building for a story that isn't even that good.
It's well written, I'll give them that, but it's pretty much as run of the mill as it gets
>>340153298
>It's another boring derivative cliche trope-laden japanese weebcore jrpg
>>340154347
>amputee
>anal
>bondage
>cbt
>guro
>piercing
>prostitution
>rape
>sex toys
>shotacon
>snuff
>torture
>urethra insertion
>>340154749
>run of the mill as it gets
And you're the type of person to call Vertigo a generic detective thriller lol
>>340154910
>>urethra insertion
The worst
>>340154910
Oh please. Every other thing on exhentai has some kind of rape.
>>340152514
DELETE THIS NOW
IGN WERE PAID BY NINTENDO AND XBOX AND THE PC
>>340154945
unless it's nonfatal cockvore, of course
>>340154749
Let me guess. You're favorite game story is Nier?
>>340154934
The story is pretty much National Treasure 2 dude.
>>340154038
Immediately triggered. Bioshock Infinite is the only game I've ever refunded. Not because it was bad, but because it was fucking boring. There is no way in hell this game is even a 8/10
>>340155060
The only thing both of those have in common is globe-trotting and treasure-hunting.
>>340152514
their complaint about the "bloated third act" was just made up bullshit. For some reason IGN expects constant globetrotting and that every area you travel to to get an equal amount screen time in the game; otherwise it's bad pacing
>>340155215
There's nothing wrong with that statement. The Last of Us and the Uncharted's are some of the best games of all time next to Crysis 1 and Half Life 2 and Symphony of the Night
>>340152514
Why are Sonyggers so obnoxious?
>>340153954
>undershit
>93
>>340152514
>still no perfect 10/10 game like Bioshock Infinite rated by multiple experts on IGN, Gamespot etc.
Gaming is truly dying.
>>340154973
>nonfatal
really, faggot?
testicular digestion or nothing.
>>340155319
Don't hate us cause you ain't us.
We're geneally
smarter
more creative
more open-minded
more artistic
more cultured
>>340154641
its a meme u dip
>>340155235
>>340154516
>>340155520
>>340152571
They literally caused this themselves and they are doing it with this game too
Uncharted 4 is not a 9 game, it's a banal cinematic corridor shooter filled with QTEs up the ass
I liked U4. One of my favourite franchises.
A nine is a fair score though, maybe a little high. A 10/10 rating should only be reserved for amazing games that come round once every decade.
Don't quite know what I didn't like about this game, just didn't feel as enjoyable as previous Uncharteds and TLoU. Think it was a combination of Sams character not being as likeable as Sully, Elena, Chloe or Cutter even. And the fact the pirate treasure story wasn't as interesting as the previous stories.
>>340152861
>occasionally lonely
>in the game where the characters talk the most during gameplay
>tfw you will never play Uncharted 4 for the first time ever again
why even live bros?
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1465144092450.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1464768665156.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1465143359229.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1465143558802.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1465145028771.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1465146391811.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1464479191056.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1464478954680.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1464573215851.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1464885360253.webm
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1464583366846.webm
>>340155991
jesus crist calm down man, it's just a game.
>>340152514
>not posting the video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJ2Fd7o8A90
The average Sony fan and it's pure autism.
>hates Uncharted
>yet pays full price for low budget waifu cashins
???
>>340156125
>linking to IGNorants video
Hello shill
>>340155978
>>340153028
I love how faggots take the shorthand pro's and con's of every IGN video and act like they're retarded. no YOU'RE retarded for not watching the review. Marty pointed out that the game didn't feel as polished in EVERY part of each level. Some parts are completely barren with nothing of interest when you go off the main path.
>>340155991
those npcs cant aim for shit
>>340156150
who are you talking about
>>340156161
>video name is Sonyggers
>IGN
>>340154468
Except for the fact that was always a fake spoiler.
>>340156290
Then say something like "some barren landscapes." It's supposed to be a summary that people see for the tl;dr version of the review, so when you say "occasionally lonely" it sounds like there's not much communication to the main character by other characters in the game. They should learn how to properly summarize their points.
>Muh Graphics
>Muh QTEs
>Muh easy A.I. that let's me win
>Muh brother
>Muh 10
I really miss traditional games. They were so fun unlike these game that play themselves and only look pretty. And they get 10/10 from everyone.
>>340153051
>video game critique is the worst of any medium.
This.
It's amazing how less known sites have to resort to being controversial to get anything done at all.
Just give up, people don't give a shit about sites other than IGN anyway.
>>340156301
I've talked to people on this very board who say the AI is overly-accurate and that the game is too hard on crushing (those webms are on crushing). A lot of people just dont know how the game is meant to be played
>>340156594
too bad you cant just go back in time to the good old days huh
>>340156715
What's the point of going back in time if nothing will change.
>The XB360 and PS3 generation will still happen.
>Normies will still begin playing games.
>Females, SLW, etc
There's no point when it will come to this again.
>>340156625
that's definitely not Crushing difficulty.
>>340155398
>bloated scores only count when they're on PS4 exclusives!!!one111!!one
>>340156994
it is, though. I know because I recorded most of those webms.
If you are in the middle of doing an animation that moves you (like transitioning to cover or punching someone), enemies will miss like 90% of their shots even from very close range until the animation completes, on any difficulty level
That slow motion webm is even on Crushing, and the guy barely gets hurt at all. You can tell because he only gets to shoot 3 grenades from the China Lake before it is emptied
>>340156594
What I want to know is WHY they get 10/10 from everyone. Like, you'd think that anyone who wanted to make game critiquing their hobby must really fucking love games, right? But in reality everyone I know who really loves games finds the triple A roller coaster ride games to be insipid and boring, yet reviewers seem to gobble that shit up.Good graphics? High budget voice acting? Template gameplay? Shit tier Hollywood movie script? 10/10
>>340154347
TO DEFEAT
THE HUNS
>>340152871
That explosion was in one of the trailers, unless he told you the context of it he's hardly spoiling, but for all I know he could've and I'm not seeking this out to check.
>>340155296
>uncharted
>tlou
>hl2
>best games ever
Like holy shit they barely even qualify as good games how is your taste so bad.
>>340157773
What are the best games ever in your opinion family?
>>340157856
I wouldn't know, I hate flat out saying "these games are better than every other game ever made" but that doesn't change the fact that the games you listed aren't very good.
![2ln7g3q[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/G0AlifV.jpg "2ln7g3q[1].jpg")
>>340152514
THESE MOTHERFUCKERS HOW DARE THEY I CANT BELIEVE THIS BELIEVE THIS BELIEVE THIS BELIEVE THIS BELIEVE THIS BELIEVE THISSSSOJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSJJJJJJJJEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE132222222222222444444444444444444304444444444444444433333-----------------------------------------------
>>340157773
Oh you like weebshit too? :DD
As a fan of uncharted 1 and 2 (3 was a bit shit)
The 4th one is fucking dogshit. Sure, it looks really nice but most of the game is you just walking around. I don't want to drive a jeep around a big open area, I want to shoot niggers in the head.
>>340155319
>that chink in the bottom right that starts crying
i wish i could get this emotional over a game reveal desu
>>340158223
Yeah, my mom says I have ADD too.
>>340158212
Kek holy shit nice try at putting words in my mouth but no, I actually prefer western games for the most part, just not shitty ones.
>>340158394
>Kek holy shit
stopped reading there.
>>340158223
ur retarded
>>340152514
IGN
Disregard and move along
>>340158497
why?
>>340158465
You're really bad at this, aren't you?
Don't worry by the time summer is over I'm sure you'll know how to shitpost just as well as those of us who are here year round.
>>340158563
use the encounter select (or better yet the MP) if you want to shoot niggers in the head. You dont have to play the non-combat sections more than once ever if they annoy you that much
>>340155069
No, you're just incapable of having fun.
>>340157474
It's called progress, faggot.
Colin Moriarty's favorite games of all time are Mega Man 3, FF Tactics, Wild Arms, Symphony of the Night, and The Last of Us.
He still loves Uncharted an puts 4 up there with one of the greatest video game stories.
They're just great fucking games, hipster weeb.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVHjIaST6XM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=II2VHj9cWOU
>>340158813
Wait wasn't he the faggot that started the whole entitlement bullshit?
>>340155398
>It's okay for uncharted to get 93 but not undertale
>>340157474
>Shit tier Hollywood movie script
What does that even mean?
I feel like a lot of /v/ that shits on movies here has no clue what a good script is and how great Hollywood is. The greatest films of all time were major studio productions, not indie arthouse bullshit.
>>340158813
Question, why the fuck should I care what this faggot thinks about games? Especially when his list of favorite games of all time are probably the safest fucking games you could possibly say. I mean shit I love Megaman and would agree that 3 is probably one of the best (although 2 is still a hugely close contender) but I wouldn't call a megaman game on of the best games ever.
>>340159013
He's smarter than you'll ever be in your life.
And weren't Giant Bomb the faggots that gave Bioshock Infinite a 10/10 or Uncharted a 5/5?
http://www.giantbomb.com/reviews/uncharted-4-a-thiefs-end-review/1900-744/
>>340159178
>how great hollywood is
>>340159243
>safe
Alright, then you ARE a hipster.
Let me guess. You're also the type of person that calls Overwatch Reddit: the Game?
>>340159284
stay mad
>>340155670
That's Uncharted 1 you're describing. Uncharted 2, 3, 4 are pretty good.
Fuck NDfags who want UC4 to be a 10 though. It's not a perfect game.
>>340155461
So you're basically the macfags of gaming.Nice
>>340159402
>greatest AMERICAN films of all time
lol
>>340159426
>Fuck NDfags who want UC4 to be a 10 though. It's not a perfect game.
It is though.
>>340159341
If by "hipster" you mean someone who actually plays games aside from ones that are already hugely popular that literally everybody has played then yeah. Not saying any of the games he listed are bad (although TLOU is intensely mediocre and him putting it on his list basically invalidates any claims to taste he might have) but there are better fucking games that exist, with plenty of them being relatively popular or AAA.
>>340155319
EBIN THEY REMADE A GAME WE CAN EASILY PLAY RIGHT NOW xDDD
IT'S NOT LIKE ALMOST EVERY REMAKE IS TRASH xDDD
When will they learn?
Anons, how did this happen?
https://twitter.com/myuRanRan/status/739754837395410945
>>340159284
He has a point though, along with the shit, basically all the good movies come from the same studios. "Hollywood" could be talking about Transformers 4, your favourite movie (I had a few ideas, but I knew no matter what I put it would be greentexted followed by ">good", so pick what you want) or even The Citizen Cane of filmsNational Treasure.
>>340159457
And what does that mean?
Uncharted 3 only seemed worse and worse as time went on after release. You kept noticing more and more flaws.
U4 is not like that at all. The longer I play this game, the more I notice and appreciate all the little nuances and details that make it so good
>>340152514
wow, game is literally blunder of the millenium
>>340156125
I like it.
>>340152514
people are right in disliking it
its a 8 at best
>>340159609
I dunno but I've been waiting since amamami 3 came out. Seismic da best.
>>340159681
that Americans make the best films
>>340159178
i agree that it's annoying that people assume they sound like patricians by bashing hollywood but you know as well as I do exactly what he meant. You're just doing the same thing by trying to sound patrician by shitting on an established narrative.
>>340159752
it's objectively a 9 at worst
>>340159547
The stealth is decent but the gunfights are too easy. It's the best Uncharted game but not a genre-defining 10/10 game. I enjoy the MGSV influence though.
>>340159768
Oh so all of a sudden you trust "film journalists" but not "game journalists"?
>>340157474
>Template gameplay?
huh? Name one other game that plays like the webms in >>340155991
In terms of combat mechanics, not even nu Tomb Raider is all that similar
>>340155991
>Self-insert man shooting the gun bangs pew pew slow motion is kewl
Sorry, I fell asleep.
>>340159943
The sheer fact that Naughty Dog answered the narrative dissonance criticism by making the combat encounters "cause-and-effect" and completely bypassable until self defense is warranted makes it a 10/10. They didn't have to do that. They couldn't just bombarded action for no reason, but they did. They made a genuine sequel that built on the past entries. And thanks to the episodic nature of prior games and the retconning in 4, the way those games panned out and whether Drake killed a bunch of people first before being provoked is entirely up in the air. There are no strict allusions, so they might as well have not happened EXACTLY as played inthe games.
Then, there's the gameplay and how they've nailed the adventure feel by levels being open-ended and playing the metagame of finding the bonus treasures more fun than ever with your partners realistically talking and reacting with you and the optional dialogue moments. That moment where you're exploring Libertalia and you pull up to a random chair with Sam and ASK him questions about how they're lives could've ended up differently touched me because I was asking him those questions, I was with Sam this whole time and I grew to love him. It was magical.
is the only reason people are flipping their shit over any non-10/10 scores because its PS4 exclusive? like nintendo faggots do the same with any zelda game or mario game not getting 10s?
>>340159682
This is true, 3 was pretty great first playthrough bevause the story was still a mystery and I was excited what Talbot's supernatural revelation would be (fucking hell ND) and the set peices were amazing. It ended when I thought I still had 20% of the game left and was a unsatifying ending, but I was pretty happy with it.
But on replaying (I've done it 6 times for some weird reason, despite really disliking the game) more and more flaws become apparent. It's ND's worst game (post Ps1, bevause technically they made games before that) and 6/10 is being generous.
4 I've only played twice, but it stands up much better. Story makes sense, the goal of the game (Libatalia) is given over a quarter of the game to be fully fleshed out (as opposed to 1 chapter before blowing it up) and I noticed a bunch of stuff on my second playthrough that impressed me, like alternate climbing routes or cool contextual dialouge from enemies. Unlike 3 where I noticed flaws after flaws, such as the secret entrance that collapses in the Chatau wouldn't have led anywhere if it hadn't collapsed, there was no secret there, Drakes falls, gets out the other side and finds the hidden stuff on the other side of level.
2 will remain the untouched champ of this genre of game, I could replay it endlessly and it's truly magnificent example of how to pace a game, something 1, 3 and 4 all fucked up (4 is good movie pacing, not game, other two just have pacing issues from any perspective)
>>340160502
It's because they're underage and they think people should respect their fee-fees above all else because we live in a fucked up pussified world.
Lol ps4 faggots have no life.
It's not like they will remember this game in 10 years.
He's kinda right though.
>game introduces a whole bunch of different problems and conflicts
>lel fuck that, all of them solved, lets get to the ending
For the supposed last game featuring Drake, the climax was boring as shit.
>>340160501
Nigga you're pathetic. Read a book
>>340159943
>gunfights are too easy.
turn up the difficulty. Even if you are really good at moving around the map without getting hit, the game can be quite challenging on crushing. Especially on the later encounters.
>>340160547
I disagree completely. 3 is far superior and more memorable than 2 to me because I liked the development they gave to Drake and his relationship with Sully. I liked how everybody came together and it was an ensemble hanging out with Chloe, Elena, and Charlie. I liked the early foreshadowed complications being put on Drake and Elena's relationship, I loved the melee feel i 3, I loved the grenade tossback, I loved the setpieces, and I stand to this fucking day that this scene was the one of the single most heart-poundingly epic things in all of games. This moment where after the plane crash, after the soul-searching in the desert, you rush to save Sully from Marlowe's convoy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-mFJH6wOsw
>>340160502
it's because IGN didn't elaborate on their complaint. They basically said they thought it was boring that the last third of the game all took place on the same island. People get pissed because games like Super Mario Galaxy have scores of 97 and IGN's gotta be bringing Uncharted down
I was 18 when normies invaded my "nerdy" and "childish" hobby. They turned it into what gaming is today.
In a few years a next generation under them will takeover. Developer will cater to that generation just like they did when my generation was consider too old for gaming.
Question: What will be the next trend, do you think we'll go back to the older style games or will we continue do this road where games now play themselves and are more movies than actual games?
>>340161228
Whatver gets those normiebucks.
It's never going back to how it was.
>>340161228
The latter. Sorry anon.
>>340161154
Don't forget they dickride fucking COD.
I mean fuck they gave Halo 5 the same score as Uncharted 4. A FUCKING 9
>>340159948
Film has its own problems (big ones too), but it has always had a bit of prestiege to it, there's multiple layers of film critism and lots of scholarly work done in film theory and stuff that goes alongside the regular "it's good" reviews in tabloid newspapers and recently Internet. Films are also seen as important, and efforts are made to preserve and honour them. Archives and preservation projects are seen as important and done for passion, not money. Great directors are well known and celebrated by nearly everyone in the industry.
Unfortunately games has no greater level of critism and analysis, IGN and similar is as high as it goes, it's all there is. The scholars and actual analysislists have been replaced with YouTube personality's. Some good stuff exists, but there's' no books written, no real recognition or unified respect. The low-tier critiquers are the most known and most respected.
And games arnt treated with much respect, modern gaming is increasingly hard to preserve, patches, DLC, DRM, always online, it's a shelf-life, combined with no one is really doing it except for emulation purposes which is not 100% legal.
Plus, no one knows famous game creators. Every film journalist knows Hitchcock, Kubric, and other famous directors and what they did, and many know at least some less mainstream stuff like Goddard or whatever. They likely studied them, did lame group projects at uni about a particular genre or auteur.
Tell me, how much does the average IGN writer know about influential game devs and what they contributed to the medium?
So how is this game near perfect that it deserves even a 9?
What it did that every other story based shooter didn't do?
The story can't be that great because even shit tier hollywood movies manages to be better and more interesting than the plot in 95% games.
>>340161303
>>340161307
But like.. what will be the THING that ruins games for this generation?
My Gen = Traditional - > Normie Generation -> Casualized Gaming - > Current Generation
Current generation = Current Traditional -> ????
What will ???? be? Because with each generation something is changed.
>>340161563
Normie game journalism.
It's the last entry of a popular franchise, so it must be good. It doesn't matter how derivative or unimaginative it is.
Also these hacks love "cinematic" gameplay because they suck at video games.
>>340152571
We should make a petition, it's a fucking 10/10 game fuck fuck fuck fuck.....
>>340159402
I've never watched Raging Bull, is it good?
>>340161497
TL;DR
>>340152571
What does Uncharted attract the most buttfrustrated little children?
This is an exact repeat of the tantrum GAF threw when some reviewer gave Uncharted 3 an 8/10
>>340158594
dirty weebs leave now /jp/ is that way
>>340161945
It's about Robert De Niro beating his wife for 2 hours
>>340161945
It's overrated. It's pretty much just Jake Lamotta being a violent asshole in the black-and-white look of the time
What gameplay?
>>340161497
And that's where you're wrong. Video game journalists do have prestige. There are plenty of scholarly works done for creators and portfolios in the industry. Look at Colin Moriarty's write-up of Naughty Dog. Look at some of Jeremy Parish's work.
What's the difference between the pretentiousness /v/ claims of video game journalists and film theory? The fact that you had to take film theory in school or something?
http://www.davidbordwell.net/blog/
vs
http://americanart.si.edu/exhibitions/archive/2012/games/
Also, directors aren't something that's known too often in games because of how the industry works. Games are far more expensive to make and the auteur theory isn't as prevalent.
>>340162291
this gameplay: >>340155991
webms have sound
>>340154516
Does anyone actually know why they do this? it seems really weird to me
>>340162345
>Video game journalists do have prestige
>>340159402
second to only taxi driver, as far as scorsese films go.
Post yfw you have played all the Uncharted games and can verify from first hand experience that it is a painfully mediocre series
>>340162473
And film journalists have better "prestige"?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xEzc-eqSWCU
Ben Mankiewickz basically said he didn't understand it, but felt it was smart, so he gave it a high score.
9/10 is still a great score, calm the fuck down.
>>340161725
No one can predict the future. I'd guess more lazy dumbed down shit though, borderline Idiocracy type things. Where the movie erred was in assuming stupid people would revel in their stupidity, whereas in reality they think they are smart and hide their lack of talent and originality behind pretentious and ironic veils.
>>340162345
You don't know what scholarly means
>>340161046
I thoroughly disagree with you
Pro's
> Development with Sully's backstory was pretty cool, but nothing mind-blowing, it didn't change our perception of the characters, just solidified it (probably a good thing).
> Cutter is a 10/10 character
> Planecrash to desert to chase was pretty cool, but they have gone too far (even ND admitted this) with 5 minutes of pushing the left stick forward while listening to poetry.
> Some of the puzzles were pretty cool.
Con's
> Gunplay was fucked, aiming much less presice than 2 (fixed in Ps4 version)
> Nate and Elena are broken up (again), except this time they were engaged. This would be fine, except they went through this story last game (without engagement part) and resolved it. Lazy and uninspired.
> Nate acting out of character, he was the first the give up to protect himself and friends from danger in 1&2, but now he drags them along. Entire premise of the story is contrived as fuck.
> Last section of the story is neutered, supernatural vase destroyed before it can be opened. Doesn't even make sense why Marlowe would want drug water, they already have more powerful drugs (actual mind control vs hallucengeons)
> Talbot survives a gunshot to the chest, and vanishes into thin air, always looks like there's more going on with him. Spoiler: there isn't.
> Cutter and Chloe vanish after Syria (so your ensamble comment isn't true) never to be heard from again. Not even the ending. Made worse by not appearing in 4. Cutters final words in the series are moaning about his leg.
> melee combat is fucked, changes your movement when in melee combat so buttons do different stuff (roll becomes shove), feels awful if you didn't intend to fistfight and just want to roll away and shoot them
> at least 4 forced melee section
> Pacing is ass-backwards: slow setup, pointless nautical detour, rushed ending with no pay off
> No bonus cheats, weapon unlocks, or skins (ps4 version added all the multiplayer ones in)
*record scratch*
yup, that's me
>>340159178
Yeah, like Capeshit every month.
Big Hollywood movies are even worse than big AAA games.
>>340162905
You guys are fucking pathetic calling this a playable movie or a dumbed down game.
It's not a simulator, ok, but what makes it worse than Wonder Boy or Kung Fu Kid? I doubt any of you could even beat the game on Crushing, let alone Chapter 20.
>>340158813
That guy is just a major league Sony cock sucker. Has been for years.
>>340152861
>Occasionally lonely
Well now we know IGN reviewers are more social outcasts than ourselves.
>>340162830
it's relative to what other games are scoring. Uncharted 4 is a much better game than Halo 5 but both got 9's
>>340160501
It's basically Uncharted 2/3 mixed with MGS5. It's great but not a 10.
>>340163040
How is this not scholarly?
http://www.anatomyofgames.com/
>>340152932
9 is shit.
9.5 is good.
10 is paid reviews.
>>340163193
except capeshit films arent regarded as masterpieces by film critics.
>>340161228
They will just stop making games and just do let's play for the kiddies.
>>340160892
Not really. It's true that enemies aim much better this time if you just hide behind cover and stand still, but if you keep moving around and killing quickly it's not hard.
>>340161563
Great mechanics. Great level design. Much more emphasis on stealth. Good mix of linearity & exploration. The story and graphics are just bonus.
>>340163203
the combat is basically "push the stick and press a button to make cool action hero do awesome judo move or crazy stunt"
its childishly simple and I dont know why people praise it
>>340163193
And you're highly reductive in your statements.
The Big Short, Civil War, Sicario, The Nice Guys, Hail, Caesar, The Jungle Book
What are you talking about? All of these films have critical acclaim. Are you the type of hipster that calls The Dark Knight Rises garbage?
>>340163203
No one said it is the worst game ever. It is painfully mediocre though and offers nothing new. To me it wasn't even exciting, just follow the road to the next set of ledges and conveniently placed cover. To make a claim that beating it on Crushing is some sort of feat is laughable considering the large amount of checkpoints and completely consequence free death. Cover shooting, forward+X and QTEs. What a thrill.
>>340162621
Uncharted 1 is a 4/10 and doesn't deserve any of the praise it gets except maybe on visuals but the other games are 8-9/10
>>340163437
Yes they are. Movies as an art form has fallen so much, they are now on par with video games and comic books (they steal from it) and bellow TV shows.
>>340153051
>video game critique is the worst of any medium.
I enjoy movies as much as I enjoy games and jesus fucking christ the differences in maturity when it comes to both industries is like night and day.
When you see a movie getting, say, a solid 7 at imdb then you're guaranteed a really good experience. But when it comes to videogames, every fucking mediocre trash is a 10/10 and the flaws are never acknowledged. In fact, you can even tell the bloggers who call themselves reviewers didn't even play the damn thing. Don't even get me started on paid reviews.
>>340163798
>I only watch mature French films for mature film fans like me.
>>340163798
96% just means that 96% of critics liked or approved of the film. it does not mean that 96% of them thought it to be a masterpiece.
>>340163437
>>340163193
Raiders of the Lost Ark and Forbidden Planet are considered some of the best films of all time.
Are you crossboarder fagots from /tv/? I can tell with your verbage and reductive statements. ARTHOUSE does not mean GOOD. And "best of all time" does not only denote arthouse, you sacks of shit. You don't know anything about film.
>>340163493
it's not as difficult as some people say once you git gud, but it's not particularly easy either.
Even if you can get pretty far into the encounters every time, the fact that they almost never give you checkpoints and you usually have to restart the whole fight if you die means you cannot afford to fuck up at all
>>340163970
You can't seriously be defending modern movie criticism
And here i thought 8.8 was the most controversial score.
>>340163337
http://geronj.oxfordjournals.org/content/42/1/82.short
This is what people think is a good game.
As you can clearly see, the game lack any form of combat depth what so ever. But people love this shit for some reason.
And the same can be said for Uncharted.
>>340164050
it's far better than modern video game criticism.
anyone can be a critic nowadays. A review is worth as much as the reviewer's reputation. Are there any reputable reviewers left in the video game journalism?
>>340164114
On average, they gave this bullshit an 8/10 >>340163798
they also gave this shit in pic-related a 9/10
Film critics are hacks.
Does anyone have the one on Bioshock Infinite where they say it's not a masterpiece but a masterwhole
>>340164108
nice b8 m8
here's a [you] for [you]r troubles.
>>340163682
>>340163927
>>340163970
>>340164005
So you guys are the faggots shitting all of /tv/ with your capeshit? Fucking /v/eddit.
And sorry, I don't watch power fantasies in spandex for balding millennials.
>>340164329
>implying Fury Road didn't deserve a 9/10
sure isretardin here
>>340164014
I don't know m8, I'm at something like chapter 14 and I'm doing fine so far
I really do appreciate how the AI is smarter now though - enemies move more tactically, and don't constantly miss you when you come out of cover
It's not a perfect game though, or genre defining. It definitely is a culmination of the strenghts of the action genre, which makes it a 9.
>>340162434
To keep normalshits where they belong.
>>340164108
But it's just like my favorite capekino THE DARK KNIGHT. Amazing, just like Hollywood, can't tell the difference, 9.8/10.
>>340158734
No, Infinite is just not fucking fun. One of the only if not only game I got bored of that quickly.
>>340164473
It's a dumb overlong unoriginal action chase scene over the span of 2 hours akin to Transformers. A nonstop barrage of repugnant noise.
>>340163623
>push the stick and press a button to make cool action hero do awesome judo move or crazy stunt
You're describing how basically every action game ever made works you faggot
How else do you want your judo moves executed? Do you want it so the player must do a complicated fighting-game-style button combo to do a melee attack?
>>340164554
>capekinowhat________________________________
>>340164612
>A nonstop barrage of repugnant noise
sounds like your mom, m8
>>340162621
I've only played uncharted 2's beta and almost all of uncharted 3 but I simply had to drop it. I couldn't fucking stand playing that heap of trash anymore. It's as linear as possible, the parkour is completely automated and you're never really in a position of true danger. For example, in the beta of uncharted 2 I remember a time when you had to jump out of a metal board that was supposedly about to fall and when you do jump from it, it ends up falling in the ground not a split second after. However, if you keep hanging on it, nothing fucking happens because you aren't in any real situation of danger.
I can really understand why people with no discernible taste like this game because it's a never ending stream of sheer deception. Naughty Dog gives you the illusion that you are in control, that you have choices, that the michael bay tier explosion on your knee can actually hurt you but everything is scripted, everything is automated and you'll always be where they want you to be. This is why when people say this trash is a movie I couldn't agree more because of how utterly stiff it feels, specially when you consider the game is a fucking cakewalk that is filled to the brim with unnecessary QTEs and cutscenes.
But hey, it has cute gwaphics and that's all that matters in this day and age. Even those cocksucking marketers at neogaf show a huge case of double standards when talking about games because they always go out their way to bash QTEs in anything, SPECIALLY Tomb Raider (gee, I wonder why), even though it's much more of a game than Uncharted could ever dream of being, but hey, when it comes to naughty shit games then QTEs are Awesome™.
There is just so much hypocrisy and bias when it comes to Uncharted reviews and discussions that it baffles me. As it is, it stands as a bold monument reminding me why this industry will never be taken seriously no matter what, no matter how much money is involved.
>>340163682
No, Batman is pure Kino for that one scene, you're right.
