What game has the best knight combat?
Please no meme Souls
Dark Souls
Demon souls
Demon Souls
>>339789707
Dark SoulsIII
>>339789707
real answer: Mount and Blade
chivalry
Dark Souls 2
>>339789707
Blade of Darkness
Dark Souls 2
Examina. Without a doubt. Everything else here is just standard damage-armour models. Exanima factors in mail, chain, plates, slashes, trauma etc.
>>339789707
Dark Souls 1/DeS
Mountain Blade
Chivalry
>>339789707
For Honor when it comes out
>>339790128
>>339790381
>mount and blade
Stop
>>339789707
Dark Messiah.
>>339790380
Has it gotten any updates or anything? I fucking hate that early access shit because I never know when any games actually get finished.
I didn't get far in but I had fun when ipirated it
>>339790442
Looks like console shit
those brightly colored faggy knights make it worse
>dark souls isn't even real knights or knight combat
>mostly about fighting demons and shit
>dodge rolling is a common practice in it
>magic spells exist
>somehow voted best knight combat
whew, /v/
>>339790779
>tfw no realistic knight game with dark souls level of customization
>>339790779
you can't use magic if you don't put points into intelligence and faith
you can also choose a knight or warrior or whatever class
you can simply just use good shields and step away instead of rolling
>>339790734
Yeah, there's a pretty fucking great arena system now. Just about as difficult as the main story mode. Includes pugilism and "frays" (6 person free for all)
>>339790760
Fuck off turk roach, mudslims cannot be knights
>>339791348
this is what the game you posted looks like
>>339791086
>step away from giant demon AOE effects and smashes
>thinking anything about this game would pass for realistic knight combat when its whole premise is unrealistic
who are you trying to meme on right now?
certainly not me
what are some games where I can hunt bears?
>>339790475
better than dork rolls
>Warband.
>>339790475
Helllll nein, nigger.
Mountain blade.
>>339790475
Why not?
>>339790326
>darksouls 2.
hexer scum post
>>339790760
Bitch please.
Have you even seen medieval manuscripts?
Real armor was flashy, colorful, and highly decorated.
It was the fucking victorians who perpetrated the "knight in shining armor" myth and stripped the paint off of some sets to feel justified.
As for the game itself, I'll wait, need to see some actual gameplay first.
>>339793280
Alternatively, here's what most likely inspired the Drakeblood Armor of Dark Souls.
http://youtu.be/sqorZzsRiQY
>knight game
>swords have any effect on knight armor at all
>>339791630Victorious Boxers 2 :^)
>>339794120
>knight game
>everyone picks vanilla straight sword
>maces and other blunt weapons have increased effectiveness
>>339793509
No one ever wore something like that into battle. No one!
Used to think Chivalry, but I got tired of the high sens twirling and the stupid ass crouch, turn around, overhead swing shit. Probably could've learned how to to deal with that, but I just want to fight semi knight like, not whirling and jumping like a goddamn idiot..
>>339794782
You're right, That is King Henry's parade armor.
Pic related is King Edward the Black Prince, minus the mink shawl, he wore it many times into battle.
>>339795086
And forgive the quality, don't have a good one on hand, but here is an example of painted armor.
The Middle Ages were colorful, and I hate it how video games try to make everything look like shit-stained brown.
>>339795086
>King Edward the Black Prince
he was never king dip
>>339795481
It's not just video games either, it's media in general. It's a damn shame too; everyone just has this idea that the medieval era was all brown and misery when it wasn't.
Dark Souls 2
>>339791968
He's right though.
Dark Souls 2's limited stamina regen and high stamina cost for actions actually meek you feel like you're wearing armor and have to time your roll perfectly instead of just spamming them like in DS3.
Arkham Knight
Dark Souls 2
>>339793280
God damn it, first person i see who actualy know this shit.
>>339794120
aye siwmae!
kingdome come: deliverence ???
Knigga Reporting
Is this an armor thread breaching through?
also check out the sword combat in Mordhau
vid related
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p-B4AwgArwA
think WotR but less clunky and more arcadey
though
>>339798264
the combat in this is actually shitty when it comes to more than a 1v1 fight.
Deus Vult
Exanima
New level just came out and it's hard as heck
>>339793280
Same with the white marble statues and columns. Ancient Greeks and Romans painted everything. Paint wore off by the time renaissance artists started copying them.
>>339789707
Mount and Blade and Souls games.
>>339798403
>ill-fitting sugarloaf
>knight using a buckler
>sparring nylon
>socks
Anon please
>>339798403
>>339798331
Hello felow knightbros
>>339794120
> MMXVI
> Not knowing the Mordhau Grip
Being this fucking peasant
>>339789707
Severance
>>339798536
Mine diferent helm
>>339798519
>ill-fitting sugarloaf
it fits fine over a maille coif and cloth coif
>knight using a buckler
men at arms used bucklers all the time especially in the 100 years on the english side also, not being manly enough to fight "the one true way"
>sparring nylon
>socks
sure you can have those two, it was unboxing day when i first got it I was excited
>>339798536
>>339798831
nice kit anon you should join us in the Larp thread on /cgl/
>>339798875
>men at arms used bucklers all the time especially in the 100 years on the english side also, not being manly enough to fight "the one true way"
Neat I did not know this
Lookin' spiffy, anon
>>339798946
Well im more of a reenactor then larper but i will defiently check.
>>339798331
Hahah, A black knight.
Getit
Bwhahaah
>>339799204
yeah Skall has a video (kinda) about it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tFOJFyTl1U
lots of english bucklers used offensively even.
>>339799639
its a good mix of HEMA/SCA/Reenactors/Larpers
>>339791516
>A melee based game where friendly fire can be a big problem if you can't differentiate between teams
No shit they have colored armor and banners
>>339790326
Muh nigga of darkness
>>339799896
How much does the whole kit cost you?
Im more into early ages, not allowed to be fully armoured like that
>>339795086
>that BLACKED armor
L O L
War of the Roses was great initially but now it's shit and dead
Warband is pretty good for it
I want a knight game that emphasizes physicality and using leverage against a opponent rather than simply weapons.
Like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFiIDl_mt2c
If you're fighting someone in plate armor you should be able to tackle them to the ground and pull off the plate to kill them like or dagger them
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tr6VrmOQY1M
The games I've seen are basically mashing buttons and trying to time and measure sword distance. A sword doesn't do much against heavy armor. No bec de corbins to penetrate armor either? Also a huge lack of jousting. Even that old SNES game where you could joust for land had jousting, it got ported to GBA too.
>>339800179
out of the kits I have the 15thc plate armor is the most expensive
All in the milanese style with most being 16g steel and 18 on some of the lames, and the sallet being 14g used for rattan and live steel. With all of the arming garments and straps and stuff it was maybe over $2k burger bucks.
The maille early period crusader kit was more like $600 with all the arming wear and helmet but thats because i got butted mail since i wont be fighting in it other than light sparring.
>>339800786
Have you ever considered moving to britain and getting a lord title so you can do the whole shebang
I want to get a castle and walk around in full period clothing and tell people I'm a real Lord and shit. And learn how to do a perfect old timey british accent.
>>339800951
There are many groups that go extremely far into roleplay thats its not even fun anymore.
>>339800951
alas anon, my coffers are full but I have no friends or subjects willing to swear fealty
I would love to just roleplay all day getting drunk whipping peasants and making fair maidens drop their wimples for me.but really i have no friends
>>339801126
I don't know what you're implying anon. They do it too hard?
>>339801191
me too anon
Don't worry I'm sure I can still roleplay that rich spoiled brat who fires all his servants and secludes himself in his castle studying the classics.
>>339798536
I like that helmet
>>339801191
http://www.cnbc.com/2016/03/29/historic-83-million-italian-castle-for-sale.html
Buy this castle mate, and we can start our own kingdom, ill swear fealty to you and will be your stounch protector.
I can train your men after i finish the army soon
Only thing i ask for return is some land to live with my lady and be allowed to have my own family crest, lord
>>339801525
thats seems quite inexpensive too! we should start a kickstarter and get some others on board lol
You will be counted among my greatest and mostly (and well paid) personal guard.
We will defend the land and the commoners the holy church
>>339801350
Thanks, i love this type of helmet since i can actualy see shit though it
>>339801350
i think it's a norman style
it's one of those pre heaume heavy helmets though
>>339801896
>>339798875
Where did you get that set?
I particularly like the helmet.
>>339790145
He said knight not circus contortionist.
>>339801679
Yes,my lord
This will be greater honour to protect you and your lands
Ill bring my small personal retinue and some servants to accompany and help us to start on building our kingdon.
>>339801951
Norman full face helmet, style brought from Sicily/Italy
>>339789707
Kingdom Come: Deliverance maybe?
>>339802185
yeah it's one of those enclosed helmets from the 11th/12th century
>>339789707
Defender of the crown
>>339802062
helmet made by GDFB its called Italian Sallet or European Sallet it comes with the bevor
i believe there are some that just got put up for sale on Kultofathena.com
>>339798403
>Little Dink shield
Holy fuck I'm crying.
>>339802701
do people really not know what bucklers are
Mordhau is coming along nicely. First game I've seen with any half-swording
>>339802701
i dont need a big shield to compensate for anything
anon also its called a buckler
>>339802760
i love these threads because there are always a few of us with historical knowledge and tons of clueless ppl who have never worn armor let alone gripped a real sword or shield
>>339802275
The combat in Mordhau looks just as shitty when it comes to more than 1v1
>>339802868
>First game I've seen with any half-swording
you haven't seen many games then
>>339802880
>>339802760
I know what a fucking Buckler is, its just that... Holy shit, I didn't know they could be so small.
>>339802892
this 150 times
I wish there was a first person melee game that made good use of formations or small shield walls. Like even granting bonuses for fighting in formations or something.
>>339802983
>I didn't know they could be so small.
that's average for real bucklers
>>339803065
Really?
Goes to show how Little I know about shields, and Knights in General.
WE
>>339803112
WUZ
>>339790442
my nigga. Vikings vs Samurai vs Knights.
>>339789707
Kingdom Come Deliverance
Mount and Blade
Chivalry
In that order
Jap shit need not apply.
>>339803102
yeah, they're used more aggressively than regular shields as well
they're great because they're easy as hell to carry around
>>339803152
NIGHTS
>>339798264
came here to post this
>>339793280
They have For Honor gameplay tho
>>339803205
>chivalry
semi-decent graphics can't save that awful combat system. I'd rather replay Dark Messiah.
>>339801525
For 8.3 million I could build a more castley looking castle and not have it be in a shitty country like Italy.
Its gotta be britain, norway, france, or germany.
I want germany myself. The castles from disney movies are actually based on real german castles, and I mean the German castle have the same design. The castle in their logo actually exists.
There was this faggot prince that funded the shit out of the arts and make a bunch of cool ass fucking castles there.
any anons here tried Exanima?
I want to into it but fuck man the weapons seem so heavy
>>339803396
It's a better system than what other games have though, people itt listing off Dark Souls and For Honour like they have any system worth praising at all.
CoE apparently is obsessed with making sure their combat relies on more skill than zerging
i.e, peasants want to bumrush the knight? good fucking joke
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ov-qzi6FUms
>>339790760
>brightly colored knights
you mean like they actually were, not everything was gray and brown in the medieval ages
>>339791516
>turkroach cannot into color thread
>>339803691
Where have I seen this before? Is this what "Im your father" is from?
>>339803850
No knights looked like that.
>>339790760
They were their house colors, or their Lords/Barons/Counts/Dukes/Order/Kings colors
>>339803421
Its not only the castle, you get shit tons lf land around it, with fields forests and other stuff
And why hate italy?
I would prefer England myself but italy sounds cool too
>>339791516
>not maining Danju
It's like you fucking WANT to lose or something
>>339803880
I believe its a tongue in cheek nod to Princess Bride, But CoE itself for now looks a bit like KC:Deliverance
>>339791903
What kind of fucking hipster one has to be to claim that M&B has a better combat system than dark souls ?
>>339803691
this looks awful
>>339804116
well some of the darksouls shit is pretty awful, those sword swings are terrible
>>339804116
In terms of realistic historical European martial arts Dark Souls doesn't even come fucking close to being better than M&B.
I wonder what kind of fucking weeb faggot one has to be to claim otherwise. Kill yourself.
>>339804116
souls combat is shit
Probably kingdom come
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0sK7Xqfvpc
also the dev is based as fuck
>>339804020
I don't like the government there I read shit about it. Plus the climate is pretty shit and the culture is steeped in fucking olive oil or some shit.
I don't know what the fuck I'm talking about.
Fuck italy anyways.
And fuck the forests. I want a forest around my castle but I want a peasant town at least so I can have some industry and serfs, but if the castle isn't imposing and shit then whats the fucking point? why not just have a mansion at that point?
>>339804139
Cause its someone elses engine and they are just making assets and some dumb animations.
Its really hard to do something even as complex as MnB, and look how little the gameplay has changed for that game over the years. Its basically just assets and a few menu screens they added, even fucking mods add more.
>>339804354
>thinking the goverment can do shit
just outfit the castle with modern weapons and shit, you've got a motherfucking castle
>>339801525
Pretty sure Spain, Italy, and Portugal are selling entire villages and keeps for less
Think i saw an entire town of maybe 15 buildings and 60+ acres of land on sale for 15 million or so
>>339804139
No shit, it's on the backburner of an already pre-alpha alpha design stage. But you wanted realistic, so they made combat have extreme penalties for being reckless. Tried to backstab a knight in full plate while you are in studded leather and a rondel? Guess what, his blow to your head, if it doesn't instantly disable you, now makes your footwork staggered, your attacks a tenth of the initial force, and you're bleeding
>>339804354
>and look how little the gameplay has changed for that game over the years
M&B hasn't had a complete sort of sequel though, warband was just "M&B but better"
there were lots of mechanics added in warband from M&B like kicking and chambering that aren't in original M&B
there was also a parry system but they ended up removing it
>>339804354
I meant it has fields and forests, there are lots of place for labd cultivation and shit. But anyways i would love to see your suggestion for our castle then, i really enjoy the early Norman castles
>>339804202
>>339804186
>>339804209
https://youtu.be/NaNjkrKZlQ0?t=410
Pure fun, this is so deep damn :^)
I really suspect none of you actually played that game, you guys seriously have to consider ending yourselves.
>>339804483
>dark souls
>press RB and RT at times
>maybe parry
>so deep lolz
see I can do it too
>>339804483
>I really suspect none of you actually played that game
dumb shitposter
>>339803945
it's a beta
>>339804274
>its an rpg so you just need to level up to get faster
god damn you nigger holy shit you make the whole game skill based and timing based and make thousands of animations just so you can negate it all with your rpg bullshit holy fuck
And if it doesn't have much impact on the skill anyways, whats the point of even including it?
shit nigger
and why the :Deliverance? Kingdom Come just sounds fucking cool for a knight game, why do you need to make it longer?
>>339804116
what kind of a fucking retard do you have to be to think that knights fought like in dark souls
>>339804274
Stop shilling your game slav
>>339804686
isnt the experience called experience because you have to work to get it, you start as a peasant so of course you need to train to get better, but yeah it could be better without the skill system
>>339804561
Even when you caricaturate like a retard, it is literally more than what M&B offers you on a 1vs1 knight combat.
Don't misunderstand me, I love M&B maybe more than DS but holy shit do your post stink neckbeard rage, you guys have to understand that this game isn't perfect
>>339804565
Than you're thousands of time more retarded than I thought
>>339804791
>OP asks which games have good knight combat
>recommend game
>SHIIILLL
>>339804809
>it is literally more than what M&B offers you on a 1vs1 knight combat.
roll & backstab: the franchise
>>339804756
Ok listen, knights didn't fight like in fucking M&B or Dark souls, stop telling that to yourselves and stop telling us that, it make you look like completely retarded.
The fact is that the combat system of dark souls is funnier than M&B, and you have to be a real autist to think otherwise
Dark Souls
>>339789707
If you really want to feel like a knight then i recommend you Mount and Blade Warband with Anno Domini mod, you have mounted fighting with lance charges, justes, defending your damsel honor, fight for your lord, etc.. Also the armors look amazing and realistic.
>>339804967
>The fact is that the combat system of dark souls is funnier than M&B
It's definitely funnier
>>339805069
It is
>>339804967
>naked man can kill a full armoured knight with a broken sword by slashing at him
>>339805153
>Single knight with a pole can kill literally dozens and dozens of warriors alone
>Hundreds with a horse
>>339791348
Muslims were knights faggot but they weren't the gay kind that would swear fealty to their lord and basically became their bitch.
>>339804967
Just because you like a game more doesn't mean its more realistic.
Fuck off.
>>339804423
>outfit the castle with modern weapons
No nigger
No
We use the latest sound capturing technology, fucking lasers and shit like they use in Detroit to fully map the whole fucking place so we can see every fucking squirrel and we live far enough so its in the boonies but not far enough that we can't have a van of paramilitary at our doors killing shit. I don't want to actually have to defend this shit myself I'm a fucking lord, I want to go play knight I go to a goddamn larp holy shit you nigger
I'm not dumb. I know castles are impractical defense wise especially today with all the kinds of grappling hooks they got. Security is about information and geography now. Get with the times, even if you want to have your fucking stone fortress
>>339804471
That shit ain't even depth. When I look at gameplay I can tell within maybe 15 to 30 seconds how most combat will play out. Compare that to a fighting game or a level based game like a shooter. You're litterally just holding and timing your clicks, thats not fun enough get working on some new ideas to make sword combat fun nigger
>>339804480
Outside a major city in a low income area that we can buy out for cheap. We build a mountain. We fucking build hills. We build underground transport facility. We build underground horticulture for weed to sell, we put the mexicans making supermeth under this and our evil german scientists to clone mutant hunchbacks to do our manual labor under that.
We import trees and wolves and have the wolves manage the game population. Look up the work of adolph murphy(national parks guy US history) or some shit, wolves help game populations grow by eating the weak and the wolves make it so we scare off vagrants and refugees. Then we make an inner tower, build another mountain and bridge the two with steel and then put on a fake stone outer shell because real stone is fucking shit to use. From there we grow the inside with spires and then we gotta terraform a river nearby because fuck you
>>339805373
you could kill dozens of peasants if you were on horseback you just had to take your time, if you kill enough they would just run away
>>339793509
What would happen if someone were to cut off those red straps? Would his armor pants drop down?
>>339803850
That sword Design triggers me. Looks fucking horrible.
>>339805373
How is that not realistic?
You realize pikes are a very effective weapon especially for people with little experience right? Pikemen have won many a battle at disadvantageous odds in history.
>>339805457
>>339805672
ALONE
L
O
N
E
and I specially wrote "warriors" because I knew you delusional faggots would try to nuance the context
Not peasants, warriors.
>>339804797
skill only nigger I don't want to turn into a fucking lord because I played the game long enough, I want to win because I got good.
>>339805427
Yeah but they aren't european so no one cares
>>339805457
You have to remember that peasants weren't exactly smart and horses were the equivalent of a fucking house in cost. That and even if you actually killed a knight, its not like you would be able to get away with that shit. They'd probably burn your village just for the knight dying on your land.
And you have to remember how dumb all these people are and how poorly they are equipped. Its not like they've seen movies where people used tactics like digging ditches to trip the horse or just realized they can just rush the knight with a few people and hold him down and steal his shit. Theres a fucking shiny armored nigger(well if he was muslim I guess) after you and he's got an actual weapon and no one has leadership skills. And theres evidence that maybe they were all high as shit too because they couldn't mill wheat correctly so theres that too.
>>339805672
Yeah but thats against calvary charges and shit where they surprise them and you have to remember that if they have pikes they are pretty well funded in comparison to most of the medieval world so they aren't shitty peasants like most were. Its not like you can just make a pike out of a tree anywhere or people even knew what a pike was everywhere. You had to be a noble or clergy to know shit.
>>339805914
Warriors can die to pikes too its why irregulars use them, retard. Holy fuck read a book and get off 4chan.
>>339805914
>implying they would actually try to kill you
>implying they wouldnt try to capture you and get a shit ton of ransom
>thinking that killing knights was common
>>339805929
We're talking about M&B where you recruit these people to fight for you and you are paying to equip them with whatever they have.
Which, like in real life, meant that irregular forces would typically be armed with weapons suited to their lack of skill.
Mordhau when it comes out.
>>339806112
I don't even know why you wrote that senpai
>>339806108
Yes it was common in medieval era for a knight with any weapon to fight and kill dozens of warriors ALONE
>>339806392
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Aljubarrota
It's not unheard of, you really should stop posting.
>>339791630
Far cry 3
Hunting part was fun and you can do it right in the start. I hunted down most upgrades before I started with the story.
>>339803421
>faggot prince
>Be Bavaria's biggest autist
>Spending all my royal revenues on incredible architectural projects and art
>My ministers can't restrain this
>They have me declared insane
>Finally murder me in a lake right before my magnum opus is finished
>It was never fully finished
>tfw my "insane" projects are the only reason anyone gives a shit about Bavaria today.
>>339806584
Come on, please indicate me the exact sentence that contradict me.
I'm waiting.
>>339806693
To be honest if I was seeing my king wasting all my tax dollars on artsy shit I would have knifed his shit too.
They weren't thinking about crap like tourism then because it wasn't a thing.
>>339806808
>6,500 vs 35,000
>Decisive Portuguese victory
>>339807006
At what exact point do your brain stops when you read the world "Alone" ?
>>339807332
word*
>>339798331
Are you going to attentionwhore in every single armor thread, you fucking nigger?
>>339807332
Are you capable of stringing together a sentence in proper English?
I don't know why you're going this far out of your way to argue that some JapSHIT RPG where people roll around in full suits of armor has a better representation of combat than M&B.
>Of six chief causes, that many valiant men think themselves by their practices to be skillful in their weapons, are yet many times in their fights sore hurt, and many times slain by men of small skill or none at all.
>George Silver, Paradoxes of Defence, 1599
>>339807451
yes does it make you mad?
I am also planning to buy a new transitional setand an Italian castle
I always contribute to the thread and ask questions about vidya
>>339807694
You contribute shit-all.
>>339794120
Was giving the estoc more legitimacy your master plan?
>>339807458
>has a better representation of combat than M&B.
How surprising, you're lying again, I've never said that, try to understand my point and then answer.
When you, angry neckebeards, will prove me that any knight in the fucking history actually killed several dozens of angry warriors alone, you'll prove your point.
I will rewrite that because honestly, the fact that you didn't understand so far is frightening : PROVE ME THAT ANY ALONE HUMAN BEING ACTUALLY KILLED DOZENS OF WARRIORS HOSTILE TOWARDS HIM AT THE SAME TIME
Is it clear like that.
War of the Roses. Although it's dead now
>>339790380
All the gameplay of it I've ever seen is two people awkwardly staggering about.
>>339807983
>>339807983
>two people awkwardly staggering about.
this, and the weapons seem so god awful heavy, I want to download it but I dont want to risk it being so shit
Any anons that have played it can vouch for it?
>>339807897
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_conquest_of_the_Aztec_Empire
The main source of Spanish dominance was their cavalry techniques using lances.
I mean obviously the Spanish is a drastic example, killing hundreds of people with no way for your opponent to counter a cavalry charge using a long weapon like that.
It only lends credence to my statement I've asserted for retards like you to understand its not unheard of that even a person of little to no experience could have survived to kill dozens of people.
Now shut the fuck up and suck my dick, retarded Brazilian faggot. Come back when you can write without looking like a retard.
>>339808202
They did it together, not by themselves.
>>339808202
My god, I really thought you would understand at this point, I tried.
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/alone
Please, I beg you fucking retard, just try.
>>339808372
You know that M&B has multiplayer where you can't exploit video game AI right? The entire discussion is about how Dark Souls is a shitty interpretation of medieval combat and that shit should be obvious with the retarded rolling that people do in that Japanese trash.
>>339808583
You're lying again
>>339804967
>>339805373
That's where the discussion started
>>339808581
See, >>339808583
Brazilian retard. Stay mad that your trash Japanese action game doesn't belong in a discussion about European martial arts.
>>339804480
I know this castle, anon...
Dwi'n hoffi
>>339808683
If you think rolling around in full plate is mire realistic than pikemen beating a larger force(something you won't do online in M&B alone) then you are indeed as retarded as your poor English indicates.
>>339808945
see
>>339804967
It's not even fun anymore
Deliverance promises to be that, but I've played the alpha (beta?) a while ago and to be fair it was shit. The main hook of the game, that is to say the combat, was inherently flawed and horrible. Otherwise it reminded me of two worlds somehow.
>>339808851
Ay shmay!
>>339808945
He didn't say that dark souls is a better representation of european martial arts, you complete fucking mess of a """thinking""" brain. He criticized both of them.
He did say he thought that dark souls combat is "funnier", and I assume he meant funner, but that's an opinion that has no place in the original argument.
Not counting all those AMAZING pseudo-realistic medieval simulation games in development hell?
Dark Souls
>>339809030
Getting told shouldn't be fun faggot, go play MP Mountain Blade and see if your little exploits work while you're getting your ass handed to you. I wouldn't expect a virgin weeb loser to want to play MP when they are congratulated for beating predictable AIs by other nerds who don't play anything other than dating simulators.
Mountain Blade isn't perfect, it's not even the best representation of sword fighting, but Japshit isn't even in the top 3.
>>339809173
Thank you for being born
>>339791516
OH FUCK I REMEMBER THISwas a vladekfag 2bh
>>339808202
The situation he's clearly stated is one unmounted combatant surviving against dozens plus unmounted combatants. Not going to happen.
You're both retarded but you double so, I'd say.
>>339809173
He criticized exploiting AI rather than the mechanics themselves which again isn't a discussion since both games have MP where you can test the mechanics against something that isn't an AI.
The mechanics in M&B are more based in realism, you don't roll in full armor and you don't fight with scythes or swords the size of your body in real life. M&B doesn't have any of that anime Jap nonsense.
>>339808704
Not like you know anything about european martial arts.
I'm a member of a medieval swordfighting society and Dark Souls is one of my favourite games this decade.
No one ever said it's an accurate depiction of actual medieval combat.
>>339809491
At least you admit being retarded samefag, you also don't have massive dragons to exploit in real life and your opinion matters little.
>>339809536
>6 feet chef at Wendy's making over 100.000 yearly with 12 inch cock
>>339809536
I do HEMA too and Dark Souls is shit that doesn't belong in a discussion of sword fighting. Japanese trash to the back of the line.
>>339791630
Red Dead Redemption
>>339801896
this is why everybody claming souls are good knight games is retarded
Fuck it just bought Exanima will report back later.
>>339809536
>No one ever said it's an accurate depiction of actual medieval combat.
So why bring it up in a thread about medieval fighting, dumbass?
>>339809653
Die by the Sword
>>339809798
Go play your japshit then. War band has sold more than any Dark Souls game.
>>339809836
>What game has the best knight combat?
Not "What game has the most historically accurate medieval swordfighting?"
If that was the actual thread's topic the answer would be "None".
Mount and blade, specially since there are mods for all medieval eras.
>>339809862
It's not the same shit. Not only are European swords better than Jap ones they used armor that worked because they intended to actually live through the fight. Japanese battles were fast with massive casualties sustained because the way they fought was dumb.
>>339809862
B-BUT MUH SEKRIT HIDDEN ART TECHNIQUES!
>>339809653
>I do HEMA
>>339790584
>Dark Messiah
Still the best
>>339809971
>tfw so mad that you insult people that actually agree with you
>>339804116
Since when baby souls has a combat system? It's a generic console shit tier combat where you have a fucking autoaim, press literally one button and have a cheat evasion roll with invisibility, because apparently console babies can't point at target or evade attacks without scripts.
>>339810034
Oh well in that case then Jedi Knight because obviously the conditions of the question don't matter of whether they're depicting realistic knight combat.
>>339810189
>I play Jap shit
>>339810110
If you have no idea what you are talking about you should just keep quiet rather than spewing nonsense.
>>339810189
>not knowing how to kill or maim a man with a sharpened metal bar
>not learning about western european history
>thinking HEMA is fedoracringe
its like you want to be cucked
>>339809513
Good, it's a fun game. But does it have a place when discussing european martial arts? Not especially. It's a pretty simple system that just works really well. You attack in four directions and you defend in four directions. Spacing is a thing but in what fighting game is spacing not a thing?
Also
>people didn't use swords the size of their body in real life
Idiot.
>>339810327
>>339810382
>muh glorious euro history
>>339810382
How many times have you hot glued that shit?
Be honest
>>339809971
you cant read or you misquoted ?
>>339790442
Game was already panned by play testers as being shit
>>339798658
Doesn't Mordhau directly translate to Murder cut?
I think you're after Mordshlag which is murder stroke. Even then theres not specific grip for it as it can be used in most guards
>>339809513
The posts in this thread are embarrassing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zvCvOC2VwDc
>>339810758
meanwhile in the real world
le combat in le armor: 1 arrow = ded
>>339810758
Is that Grutte Piers sword? Looks too big for a normal twohander.
War of the Roses for the month it was aliveRIP ;_;
>>339810553
the only modern adhesive or material I used are glue and camp mat foam, denim for strapping and high density plastic in places safety proposes.
>>339810827
It is, b there are several examples for swords of man height.
You also have to take into account that the average height in the middle ages was lower.
>>339809653
Actually I have seen some really nice stuff in DS like their buckler work and even longsword in DSII. Not everything is 100% but it did make me smile when I saw my character strike from MIttle to Ochs
>>339810887
A shame I dismissed it as being a copy of mount and blade. Looks alright.
This thread is shit.
You faggots ruined a perfectly fine arms&armour thread.
Larpers and tryhards please leave.
>>339810340
The life expectancy of a Roman soldier was higher than that of an Ashigaru.
The art of organized melee warfare was perfected from the Hellenistic period to the late medieval era in Europe, in Japan they essentially used the same tactics for swords that they did with spears.
>>339810758
>This guy rolled once in a video I saw so they did it all the time just like my Japanese anime
>>339810952
>implying I was talking about actual hot glue
You don't hang around in figure threads, do you?
But that's actually kind of interesting, how much work did you put into it? I just assumed you bought the whole kit.
>>339810758
>manly tears in his formative years grips a butter knife
>>339789707
war of theroses
>>339811084
He didn't say they did it all the time.
>>339811084
This is without mentioning the fact that full plate armor wasn't even used in most medieval battles of history, since by the time it was being crafted it was outdated by firearms.
POST CASTLES
well i havent got to fight shit yet but the character creator in Exanima by default is lulz
>>339810827
>>339811019
>>339810758
Swords like this were larger models of their real sword used for decoration. Nobody fought with swords like this because that's retarded.
No William Wallace didn't fight with a sword this big either, that's dumb.
>>339804116
Souls is good but we're talking about knight combat. Horse battle, guard system and everything feels like you're a fucking knight in M&B.
>>339811081
Realism fags ruin everything
>>339791516
i fucking loved those
>>339811264
Yes, but there were indeed swords used in battle that were as large as a human body.
Reminder if you aren't on a horse you aren't a knight.
>>339791516
who else here /rascus/
>>339811354
>not being a fallen knightLiterally
>>339811084
>comparing the roman empire to a small island nation
>comparing real life to video games
Are you actively trying to sound retarded?
>>339810816
>1 arrow = ded
>what are plates shaped to deflect arrows
>what is chainmail
>what is gabison
>what is padding
