How are the Madoka Magica psp games?
Are they as good as the tv show?
MEMORIES BROKEN
Mami thread
>>339453501
OP, if I liked Lagrange: The Flower of Rin-ne would I like Madoka? Also, Funimation and Netflix recommendations?
I'd ask /a/ but they seem like they've gone too far down the rabbit hole.
Of course not. Videogames are just poor imitation of source material.
>good precure games never ever because Toei is retarded
>>339456917
Honestly recommendation threads are generally cancer and invite newfags so I understand why /a/ rejects it. But yes, you should watch Madoka.
why is this series held in such high regards? I watched it thoroughly hoping for some nefarious deconstructions and was left sorely disappointed.
it's just your generic magical girl.
>>339456917
They don't really share anything in common besides the protagonist's name.
Still a great show, my personal favorite. It's better to go in knowing as little as possible.
>>339456917
>if I liked Lagrange: The Flower of Rin-ne
Rinne no Lagrange isn't particularly good by any measure. Madoka is definitely better.
It doesn't have much in common with Madoka. They both have a main cast of girls with roughly equally canon levels of lesbianism and a main character named Madoka.
>>339457408
But I've watched that crap since i was a kid. I remember being excited to get the Escaflowne and Cowboy Bebop dvd sets. I just don't keep up with it. /a/ is probably praising some harem moe at this very moment, which is another reason I never gothere.
>>339457474
because 2deep4u normie fags think their non-eva magical girl show is special when actually any Precure season is better than this.
>>339456721
>>339457651
It'd be pretty funny if Madoka had the otaku tourism angle. You'd have to go to Berlin, Dubai, Paris, Shanghai, Singapore...
>>339457942
I want to smell that fat ass.
>>339457552
>>339457651
Yeah, it isn't exactly great but Madoka was pretty great. And I've never understood having a waifu but if I did Lan would be mine. Shiki was, by and far, more interesting and I wish it didn't end.
https://youtu.be/4xVyBmkEZX4?t=42
>>339457474
I watched it expecting a good show and that's what I got
is there a show that /a/ praises that is bad? I've yet to be disappointed by their recommendations.
>>339458317
The OST is divine.
>>339458524
Not really. They usually know their stuff. People go there and they see all the cute girl threads being angry that /a/ isn't serving their needs instead. Contrary to /v/, /a/ won't spoonfeed you without lurking first. That shit is board cancer.
>>339457474
It's more that the show originally advertised itself as a cutesy girl show (as evidenced by the happy credits for ep.1/2), but then goes full suffering. No one expected the show to go that route initially.
I will say though that it is highly over hyped. It's good, but it's not a 10/10.
>>339457474
how could you not feel any impact when this series has conversations likemadoka: how can you do this to us? don't you feel bad about what you're doing?
qb: do you feel bad about cattle?
last time I saw morals like these were on arjuna eons ago, and nobody gives a shit about that anime, madoka is all about presentation and morality concepts, the girls reflect a parody on the mahou shoujo genre, but the ambience is straight out pulled out from the abstract concepts of self, hence why its held on high regard
you can find other series like this for example monster, steins gate or jokers game
but they don't play with one of the most popular genres of japanese media, they played their cards just right
"what if srs business series with dumb looking waifus"
>>339458678
>No one expected the show to go that route initially.
They did though. It was fucking ridiculous what people managed to predict just from that seemingly meaningless first scene of Madoka running through a hall made up of chess boards.
>>339458317
https://youtu.be/4xVyBmkEZX4?t=366
>>339456721
>>339457942
>>339458159
>>339458536
>>339458671
Objectively worst girl.
>>339458524
/a/ has fans for everything. I think they're less of a hivemind than /v/. Although one of the shows that is very highly regarded is Hyouka, and I've never understood why. It's not terrible, but I didn't really like it overall.
>>339458678
The original airing didn't have credits for the first two episodes. Also pretty much everyone expected suffering because Gen Urobuchi was attached to the project from the get-go. Back when his name meant Saya no Uta and not like, Psycho Pass.
>>339458678
the forced lesbianism killed a lot of parts for me
sayakaxkyouko was dumb as fuck
I get that they are in very similar circumstances and understand each other, but, is it necessary for them to be romantic partners? seems dumb, should just be total brocunts like mami and momoe
>>339457741
/a/ doesn't praise old anime because they done it too many times, only newer stuff gets threads and hopefully it will stop when they get really old.
>>339458953
Objectively worst post.
>>339458998
I don't remember the lesbianism. I gotta rewatach it.
>>339458953
>>339459056
whoa guys, everyone knows she's a lonely gal who just wants some good companylet's not lose our heads about it, kay?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gz4v755Z8HU
This track is a personal favorite.
>>339459186
Or well, the parts that are from Madoka.
>>339459186
That's not even Madoka track.Not that anyone could tell.
>>339459165
happens in the third movie
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AmOg3-f9z0A
>>339458757
I don't wanna sound edgy but I guess there's no helping it- morality is a concept I'm completely oblivious to. it's just not logical.
maybe that's why I didn't enjoy Monster as much as I should've, either.
>>339458678
I guess that probably helped when it was first released. I watched it specifically because I heard it went to shit.
but imo it just falls short. it's not magical enough to be part of the magical girl genre nor grim enough to be a deconstruction.
>>339459282
I mean they held hands, big whoop. They're friends and shit now, and Sayaka does remember Kyouko double-suiciding.
It's a little weird because it's kind of disconnected from the series, but that's the natural result of quite literally everyone on the staff pushing Sayaka and Kyouko together, from the director to the voice actresses.
>>339459315
>I don't wanna sound edgy but I guess there's no helping it- morality is a concept I'm completely oblivious to. it's just not logical.
I don't really get this. I'm a moral nihilist but that doesn't mean I don't have an interest in viewing my subjective morals in a different light.
>>339459056
>sole reason everything happened
>out of purely selfish desires
You can fap to her all you want, doesn't change that she's a terrible person.
>>339459315
>post yfw you realize this guy is an incubator
>>339459554
She's a teenage girl. What did you expect? Of course she would have flaws.
>>339459441
yes, that's the problem I found with it, with homuXmado it feels natural (and onesided I might add) but other pairings are just nerd fuel
>>339459705
Nobody cares about shipping shit. Loosen your yuri goggles.
>>339459282
People read too much into this. Sayaka had a crush on that cripple who played Ave Maria.
![maxresdefault[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/nYqNVuA.jpg "maxresdefault[1].jpg")
Could the last video game MC you played defeat Walpurgisnacht?
SO, are we ever gonna get an explanation on walpurgis night or are we supposed to imagine that it was something alla kazumi magica?
>>339459494
morals are wholly subjective. I was just angry at Madoka and Homura for thinking their feelings mattered on a grander scheme.
Kyubey was more or less right.
>>339460059
There's an explanation in some production notes but it's nothing particularly satisfying. They mention that it's an amalgamation of witches. So nothing special, it's not Homura's witch from another timeline or anything, it just happens. It is called Walpurgis Night after all.
Thematically, that's kind of the point. It's a force of nature, the inevitability of the universe that can't be overcome by determination. So not particularly exciting, but it does make sense.
>>339460250
>determination
do you wanna have amemetime
wait, a decent madoka thread?
you don't get these over on /a/ thanks to tripfags
>>339460505
Yeah, they've really fucked it all up. Once you filter them all, the thread basically ceases to exist. Then there's that one fag continually sperging out about crack pairings to ruin the rest.
I just rewatched Rebellion, reminded me how much I loved this series.
>>339457474
Because the audience of it love the *idea* of a magical girl subversion because they don't actually watch magical girl shows.
>>339458524
>is there a show that /a/ praises that is bad?
Yes, Clannad.
>>339458956
Anime is a visual medium and the visuals for Hyouka at the time are still really impressive. Also has a lot to do with the use of imagery much like how it's used very well in Madoka.
As a disclaimer I don't really like Hyouka at all it's too slow.
>>339458953
>Mami
>worst girl
I'd love to see your reasoning
>>339457474
>generic magical girl.
It was anything but generic at the time of it's airing 5 years ago and if anything many shows since then have tried to capture a similar essence. The story is basically just a re telling of Faust but you take the whole package into account which included the score, visuals, and voice acting.
>>339458956
>/a/ has fans for everything. I think they're less of a hivemind than /v/.
I think it's harder to fuck up TV than it is to fuck up vidya, so as such it's easier to find fans of most TV and it's easier to have consensus about what's shitty vidya.
Writing wooden dialogue doesn't make a show actively unfun per say, but designing bad controls makes a video game actively unfun and frustrating.
That being said I don't really think /v/ suffers from hivemind problems. There's lots of bickering and fire about what's good.
>>339460760
This may sound bizarre coming from a fan of Madoka, but I think the visuals in Hyouka were trying too hard. Everything was so on the nose, it just felt like showing off. Like all the stuff with Chitanda and spider webs and little Chitandas crawling all over Oreki and things like that. It's like yeah I get it. I got it from the writing because it was already beating the idea into me with the blunt end of an unnecessary soliloquy and overly dramatic music.
Panzer > mahou
Can' beat Love Live tho
>>339461134
Damn, GuP is a force to be reckoned with.
Now if OP asked about a GuP game, then he'd have some options.
>>339461068
/v/ is also the target of many devs who want to advertise their games. Which is why discussion can quickly turn sour. It's generally an awful board that should've been split long ago. I'd rather have a slow board without shitposting than /v/ in its current form. It's very obvious to tell that some posters here have an agenda. /a/ gets to enjoy the benefit of avoiding shills aswell as newfags.
>>339461102
Regardless it is still one of the very few series to actually be 1080p and not just upscale. There are a few but I can't even think of 5 series that have done that since.
>>339461051
>It was anything but generic
It wasn't even as dramatic or morally complex as the season of Precure it aired along side.
>>339457474
It isn't generic magical girl. Regards, someone who watches magical girl. Madoka has none of that cutesy filler or villain of the week faggotry that magical girls heavily rely on.
Madoka has a story to tell. It's well directed and paced and has a satisfying ending, it's an incredible package in just twelve episodes. It isn't a "magical girl" story at all, it's a fantasy-themed tragedy drama show.
>>339461068
/v/ suffers from a good portion of the board being underage as fuck and the logical step up from /b/ for many users. Even though it's a board about children's cartoons /a/ has an older user base since younger viewers tend group on MAL and various other shitty anime sites.
>>339461435
>fantasy-themed tragedy drama show
Which describes a ton of magical girl shows sans filler just as accurately. The lack of slice-of-life is more or less Madoka's defining feature.
>>339461263
Oh that's definitely true. I really wish janitors would really delete
>QUICK: HAVE YOU PREORDERED X?????
>WATCH ME SPEND MONEY AND COINCIDENTALLY GET LUCKY
and other such threads.
It's also really obvious there are viralers because threads of that form disappear late at night, presumably when the viralers get off work. Late night /v/ is pretty good in my opinion.
I don't know how you'd split /v/ to have a slow and good board with diverse topics. I don't really want to damn whatever the most popular topic is to hell, and the /vr/ split didn't work. /vr/ is a pretty awful board. Worse than /v/ for sure.
>>339461324
I have long sinced ceased being impressed by KyoAni's visuals. I take it for granted that they're going to be the best in the business and look all shiny with their K-On designs and wonderful animation. They're consistently good and they've settled on a style they like. But they've fallen into the same ennui as triple A developers in vidya where they keep pushing the envelope on graphics and diminishing returns means I care less and less. Also like triple A developers they've started putting chromatic aberration on things which I find offensive.
I'm not an artist, I don't appreciate the technical details all that well, I can only judge by how a show makes me feel.
Am I the only one that generally ignores people using "generic" as means of arguing? It means nothing. It's the equivalent of saying something is overrated. People just throw out whatever words to sound smart and critical.
>>339461590
/v/ west and /v/ Japan. Most of the shills are western devs since Japs usually don't browse 4chan when they have their own chan. Atleast it means I can stay on one board relevant to my interests without the shills.
>>339461575
Madoka's defining feature and what makes it unique is that it's a show about a girl making the decision to become a magical girl, as opposed to a show about a magical girl. Every other dark dramatic take on this genre is about magical girls dealing with their situations, this show is special because it's about the question of what makes it worth it to become a magical girl.
>>339461602
I have not really been a fan of any of their work for awhile but I can appreciate the technically aspect for its time. The only thing by them I really like is the Disappearance movie.
>>339461435
it's a pretty mediocre story, though. like the rest of the show.
it doesn't particularly excel at nothing to deserve so much praise.
>>339461590
/v/ has been split 4 times it's never going to be the answer.
>>339461863
Mediocre how? Can you expand without using words that generally boils down to "I don't like it."
>>339461134
>Love Live
Who even enjoys that idol bullshit?
>>339461796
Disappearance was really good, I shouldn't overlook that. Hell, Disappearance was great.
I liked KyoAni a lot better when they were adapting stuff for the soulless LN megagiant and not trying to be a soulless LN megagiant.
>>339461863
Hot opinion you got there but many would disagree for instance the soundtrack is better than anything I've ever heard out of Precure.
>>339462010
LN shit was not smothering the industry to death with it's garbage harems at the time of Haruhi anyway.
>>339461693
Even if Mami was being a little selfish, she just didn't want to be lonely and to have friends. How is she any worse then say Sayaka who literally only became a magical girl all because she wanted a violin boy to like her?
madoka's arse
Hibike! was great. What's this talk about KyoAni falling. They seem to be doing very well.
>>339461957
I just fap to Maki 2bh
>>339457474
You seem to have not watched episode 3 if you think it's just like any other magical girl show
>>339461717
I suppose that would work for me anyway since I like mostly Jap games.I'd feel bad about Deus Ex 1 and a couple other good western games being condemned to /vw/.
In the end I can't help but feel like this is a management problem. I think the 4chan administration should step up its game.
>muh deeeeeeep deconstruction
>muh lesbians
>muh symbolic crayon backgrounds
>muh doka
>>339462313
>muh muhs
>>339462115
She pretty much pushed Madoka and Sayaka to become magical girls.
Had she not talked about how great it is and awesome she is and how she feels lonely and then even took the girls along into a witch area, Madoka and Sayaka would've never even thought about becoming magical girls.
Especially Madoka.
As a direct result of Mami being so pushy about this all the shit in the series happened.
>>339462148
Chav Homura pls
You have 10 seconds to post a more fuckable magical girl.
>>339462421
Madoka would've become a magical girl regardless. She makes the dumbest wishes possible early on because she just wants to be a magical girl and help people.
>>339461924
like you said, it's not 'cutesy' enough to be a magical girl show nor grim enough to be a deconstruction. it's not creative enough to be its own thing, either.
so what is it? yet another show about a neigh-omnipotent force threatening the world and the subsequent doomsday? because other anime did it better.
the direction and imagery are indeed pretty good but that's about it. other than the focus on morality like some anons mentioned before, there's not much substance here.
it's better than a good chunk of modern series but it's not deserving of all the praise it gets.
>>339462115
Because she actively damned 2 girls, and by proxy a third.
I imagine they likely aren't the first girls that she's damned either because so many burn out quickly.
>>339462538
>She makes the dumbest wishes possible early on because she just wants to be a magical girl and help people.
Oh gee, and I wonder why she did that. Surely not because of Mami.
>>339462493
Mami is very fuckable despite being worst girl.
>>339462493
>>339462836
It really wasn't, she's just that kind of person.
>>339462573
Of course it's grim enough to be a deconstruction. And a deconstruction doesn't even really need to be grim. You're being needlessly obsessed over genres.
>>339462154
Band girls get me off better than magical girls. Glad this came up.
>>339461957
Me u little fuckI watched their Final Live, kill me
>>339462836
in the very first timeline, she becomes a magical girl before anyone else because she wishes a random cat back to life
>People call madoka a deconstruction of the magical girl genre
>literally generic as fuck story
Without Rebellion the series is standard anime fantasy crap.
>>339463147
I'm just trying to point out that Madoka is all show and no substance.
it doesn't fit anywhere, it doesn't do anything except the same old doomsday plot with a twist.
and even the twist is meh. it falls short in comparison to anything remotely similar and, even as its own thing, there's not much to say about it.
what do you find so enjoyable about it, anyway? what's so great and deserving of all the praise? because I'm pretty sure I can point out anime that did it better.
>>339462313
>muh mi
>>339463453
>/v/ the post
>>339463416
Wait, when was that shown?
>>339457474
FUCK off Digibro.
>>339463453
I always found it funny that it's more or less just Kamen Rider Ryuki with the movie ending.
>>339462573
>it's better than a good chunk of modern series
I'd argue that inherently elevates it above mediocre.
unless you're one of those odd people that uses mediocre to describe 6 and 7/10's rather than 4/10's
>>339463503
I'm not saying it's the greatest anime of all time that nullifies all other anime. Nobody has said that. I don't know why you even assume it does. The character interactions, the direction, music and story are all told really well. Its ability to pace itself just right.
>>339462573
>deconstruction
>grim
?
>not creative
Yet it spawned dozens upon dozens copy shows none of which has been able to capture the magic.
>other anime did it better.
What anime exactly? Also, you're forgetting that absolutely everything in fiction has been done before in some form or another, nowadays it's a matter of effective combinations, narrative and detail that make something unique and interesting.
Sure, it's horribly overrated like everything popular but it's still easily in the top 20 % of Chinese cartoons, that you cannot deny.
What is it about Mami that makes me want to have sexual intercourse with her so bad
>>339463789
It's not better than [my favorite anime].
Therefore it's mediocre.
>>339457474
>I watched it thoroughly hoping for some nefarious deconstructions
you have to read essays if you want deconstructions.
>>339463453
Rebellion was garbage and turns Homura into a blithering retard. She deserves better than this.
>>339463881
She's just incredibly sexy for a 15 year old.
>>339458757
I remember Arjuna. OST was dope as hell. I liked the twist at the end too.
I still find the whole episode with 'if I just plant shit in the ground and then do absolutely nothing else my crops are healthier' ridiculous though. Not using chemical pesticides and crap sure, just cultivate ladybugs and crap to eat your pests, but just pretending weeds are harmless seems delusional.
>>339463453
Do you also think that NGE is generic mecha shounen?
>Rebellion
That piece of filth was literally created to milk the last pennies out of desperate neckbeards. Even the author considers it shameful and non-canon, like the addition of the glasses lesbian to Eva 3.0 - they simply weren't selling enough figurines, yet some flaming retards consider her the ultimate waifu goddess who saved the series.
>>339461608
I have a wordfilter installed that swaps 'generic' to 'vaporwave'
>>339463559
design docs that were made public, but that's why there's a cat in the first OP. It got hit by a car and she wished it back to life, then kept it a secret from the others because she was embarrassed she wasted her wish on something so frivolous and impulsive
>>339464512
Got a source?
>>339458953
>Mami
>worst girl
Objectively not Homura post
>>339461370
I'm curious now.
Which precure was this.
>>339463930
>blithering retard
nah, it was entirely in-character. her desire to save Madoka was a selfish one from the beginning.
>>339463845
top 20% aint impressive anon.
80% in highschool wasnt good.
>>339464578
I double checked, it wasn't a design doc, it was Drama Cd 1
I want to fuck Madoka
>>339463453
The only thing Rebellion did was make me wish I had my own Bebe for friendly cuddling.
>>339464949
maybe in your crappy highschool.
Homura knew that all that Madoka wanted to do was protect people and save anyone in the universe. She should of respected her wish if she liked her panty smells so much. Then again Homura's wish was to protect Madoka instead of Madoka protecting her. Which she fucking did in a way, but such two powerful wishes colliding is creating a bomb. When the fuck is Movie 4 coming out.oh yeah. this is the part where I talk about video games. I never played any of the PMMM video games.
This fight was. FR*CKING. POINTLESS.
Why can't Homura and Mami be friends.
>>339464202
>Even the author considers it shameful and non-canon
That's a lie
Also rebellion was good and you're an idiot
>>339463573
This. I fucking hate that pretentious cunt.
>>339463887
My favorite anime is Sex and Violence with Machspeed, my taste is OBJECTIVELY better than yours.
>>339465331
Becouse Mami is a psycho bitch
>>339465331
Becausr Homura needs to be destroyed
>>339465508
the most recent episode of Space Patrol Luluco took place there
>>339456721
Mami is a sweet girl
The remade movies weren't fun to watch personally. Most of the time I was just missing the original soundtrack. I also missed the meguca faces
https://youtu.be/1Jm0GZgCPNs
https://youtu.be/HcgEHrwdSO4
https://youtu.be/btmSuNcxiIU
>>339465331
That fight was FUCKING AWESOME
>>339465331
because Homura was already transforming into a witch
![flat,800x800,075,f.u1[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/c7MgoxS.jpg "flat,800x800,075,f.u1[1].jpg")
>>339465121
>When the fuck is Movie 4 coming out
same time as Eva 4.0
>>339465528
>>339465575
nah she just needs a snicker bar.
What's your favorite megucadoujin?
>>339465812
source???
>>339466083
>Madoka trying to compete in the big titty committee
>>339466083
Gimme somevanilla harem
>>339466257
Read filename
>>339465805
Shit man I haven't seen the latest episode yet, I haven't even seen the episode where she meets Sucy.
>>339466364
I can only assume Ninja Slayer is gonna be in next episode
>>339464202
>NGE is the same as Madoka
Spoken like a true fucking retard
>tfw one of my best girl buddies got me into Madoka when we got together and watched it
I miss those times. where did 2011 go..
>>339466083
Are there any good Mami doujins?
>>339466470
>Tfw hoping for a Black Dynamite episode but then remember that they only did the Opening.
Fuck I just want more Black Dynamite.
>>339466635
With that rack, I think you answered your own question. Though personally I've never searched out for Madoka doujins, I've seen plenty out there though.
>>339466679
might get an homage at least
>>339466635
most of them are about her being a prostitute, whether that's your thing or not.
I vaguely recall one where Bebe was some cross dressing shota she treated as her sex slave
Can I have an online co op witch hunting PMMM game to play with my buddies pls.
and none of that visual novel bs
>>339457474
>it's just your generic magical girl.
How much anime have you watched again?
>>339467091
Try grief syndrome
>>339467249
man, I'd completely forgotten about that
so much fun abusing the hell out of walpurgis with a friend on NG+++
>yfw Madoka/magical girl game by Platinum
>>339467879
Those shoes are cute af
KEKI
KEEEEKI
>>339468087
does anyone have the picture of all the homuras playing it with Kyuubey? I've been looking for that for ages
>>339464768
Heartcatch and Suite, both are good, but the guy is just wrong about that.
>>339468087
MARUI KEEEKI
MAARUI KEEEKI WA DAAAARE?
>>339466083
sauce?
>>339468315
Keki wa anon?
>tfw accidentally click the english dub for Madoka Magica
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4jH0WeV67I
>>339468317
http://exhentai.org/g/397411/7b22a96d37/
It's only Homu though but the artist has other Madoka work where there's all the girls
post lewd
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-ui1DDErMA
watashi wa meron
chigau wa ringo
omae wa L desu
what's the name of the one where homura sticks her soul gem in madoka's vajayjay
>>339469746
Madoka Magica: Rebellioin Story
>tfw /v/ has better Madoka theads
Fucking tripfags and that insane dude.
Why is every Madoka doujin yuri or futa?
Oogie Madoogie is a cool magoogie but moomie tomookie is best
>>339470612
the only male characters are madoka's dad and the guy worst girl had a crush on
>>339470592
/a/'s PMMM threads especially are a fucking nightmare. if it isn't constant waifufagging, its petty arguments that go nowhere. too bad the series has barely anything to do with video games.
>>339470592
it's because they're actually madoka threads
Maximum Autismo going on in this thread, couldn't happen excepted anything else from weebs.
>Persona 2: EPP english patch never because the group with that called dibs would rather work on Madoka games even though they're 80% done
>>339470713
You're forgetting about class room "answered question about eggs" guy
>>339470948
>needed English patches from some tumblrites
You brought it to yourself.
>>339470592
The babbies are waking up now and the mod will probably delete this thread anyways.
>>339468087
>>339468315
>>339468359
Years later that scene is still 2deep4me.
>>339461608
To be fair, it depends largely on how its used and in relation to what. People do use it a lot so a lot of its meaning has been lost, though.
Something needs to be the soulless incarnation of the sum of its components to be generic in any bad way.
Madokadonk
>>339471196
It was to show how wrong everything was in that world
>>339471196
It's literally just fan service
>>339457651
>Rinne no Lagrange isn't particularly good by any measure
This. >>339456917 you should just go ahead & watch Madoka Magica without listening to what anyone tells you about it, be it hype about any aspect of it, or possible spoilers.
>>339471196
it's just there to throw off anyone who is going in blind but thinks they know what to expect
>>339471196
The only thing to get out of that scene is foreshadowing that Homura remembers when she reacts to bebe's true form.
TOO FAR
>>339471550
like most of Rebellion, it was fan service.
>>339471550
>friends can't hold hands
>>339471196
They're stuck in this illusionary world where everyone is happily fighting nightmares instead of witches. The cake song/ceremony is just the way to defeat the nightmares.
>>339471668
Are you fucking insane?
>>339471550
I just noticed that Kyouko needs to trim her fingernails. shit is nasty
>>339471635
Why does Mami react like that?
>>339471843
Most girls have fingernails approximately that long or maybe a little longer
The fuck are you talking about.
>>339471843
>not cultivating talons
>not getting your friends addicted to your headscratches
>>339462313
>symbolic crayon backgrounds
They were symbolic? I thought they were
>a shout-out to an episode of Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei where they went through a variety of animation styles, including the one used in MadoMagi
>An indicator that something is off, that they are in an otherworldly place or somesuch
Otherwise what was the symbolism?
>>339471913
Mami came out really well in Rebellion. She went from dying early for shock effect and being the weakest girl (mentally) to reminding everyone in Rebellion that she's the most experienced girl and can outwit Homura's time bullshit. Rebellion really upped it's Mami game.
So I guess she's shocked at how cool Rebellion Mami was.
>>339471196
It was supposed to make no sense, to hint that something wasn't right
Mami is lovehttp://eye.swfchan.com/flash.asp?id=189291&n=Mami-San+Yes.swf
>>339472151
http://www.productionig.com/contents/works_sp/54_/s08_/000673.html
http://production-ig.com/contents/works_sp/54_/s01_/000601.html
>>339453724
>Magical Girl Noir
I stopped reading that a long time ago. Has it gotten better?
Mami's death was a lot more hardcore in the manga. In a way I kind of wish they went for more of that design and tone.
>>339472260
Thanks for reminding me how much of a faggot ainsley is
>>339472260
anyone have other meguca edits of this pic?
>>339457942
Oh my fuck
>>339472485
goddamn if I was wathching that happen, I would either become insane until the creature eats me too or just become insane until I kill myself, it doesn't really make sense how it didn't happen to them, humans cannot live with such image in their minds
>>339472936
seeing her lifeless corpse wobble around was creepy enough. I'll make do.
>>339472936
Cthulu shit aside, the mind is much more resilient than you give it credit
>>339473198
I don't think you're giving PTSD enough credit
>>339461602
I'm probably not the person to speak, being a secondary anime only fag that watched lile 30 shows, but I think K-On looks fucking retarded
![--tomoe-mami-mahou-shoujo-madoka-magica-drawn-by-fal-maro--cfbda6651bbf4ccb1afc9e8b153353b3[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/0lRyuia.jpg "--tomoe-mami-mahou-shoujo-madoka-magica-drawn-by-fal-maro--cfbda6651bbf4ccb1afc9e8b153353b3[1].png")
I've only seen the series, but I enjoyed Madoka.
Mami a best.
>>339473350
the movie is pretty good, you should watch it
>>339473270
PTSD stands for post traumatic stress disorder. In the exact moment, you would not just fucking go crazy. Thats not how the brain does unless you look at cthulu, and that ain't cthulu.
I don't wanna sound like a queer or nothin. but Homura's voice actress for sure is one of the best out of the cast. breaks my heart, especially when she confesses to madoka that she's a time traveler.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFQRp6EP_JM&feature=youtu.be&t=133
>>339473494
well in that exact moment, you go into shell shock, then later the PTSD sets inalso looking at Cthulhu never drove the protag crazy. obsession over how humanity is gonna get wiped out as soon as the stars are right, with no idea how long until the stars will be right, meaning it could happen any minute of any day, that drove the protag crazy /autismo
>>339473436
Maybe someday, I'll probably rewatch Madoka as well.
>>339473724
obligatory
>>339473724
>>339473494
Maybe if it was a stranger, but Mami was no stranger to Madoka, she was her role model.
In a way, we could say that Madoka witnissed her superior self, being brutally murdered in the worst way in front of her, of course she should have gone fucking crazy in the instant she saw it.In my case, watching my waifu get that would at least guarantee a suicide
>>339473494
reading about PTSD...
>PTSD can increase arousal
what
>>339473724
Right here senpai.
>>339472180
>outwit Homura's time bullshit
That wasn't wit. She got rused and had to have some asspull plotarmor drag her out of it. Plus if Homura shot at the soulstone instead of the leg Mami would have been rekt. Homura's feelings are why she got caught.
>>339473724
>>339472485
>>339467095
How much have you?
>>339474330
get out
>>339474161
It was all a ribbon substitute you fucking retard.
>>339474371
nearly 400 anime
I've seen like 3 anime and jerk off to japanese drawings. I'm probably the most normie anon in this thread
>>339471279
hnnng
I'm surprised this thread has stayed up as long as it has. I hope I didn't jinx it. this has been a fun thread. I miss being able to talk about this show.
>>339474680
That's the most retarded theory I've ever heard and nothing in the movie even suggests that. There was no ribbon going offscreen when she turned into ribbons and I doubt she can fake a soulstone with ribbons. She never even had a change to switch with a fake unless her fake can fight as good as her. This isn't fucking Naruto.
>the endless amount of tears over rebellion
It's just yuri faggots, get over it
>>339475315
Are you retarded? it was pretty obvious.
What you are implying seems more of a theory than anything
>>339475364
it's not yuri, it was platonic until Rebellion.
>>339466535
It starts pretty innocent, like any other show in the genre. Timid teen being pushed into the role of a hero. Does he want to do it? Can he really do it? How does he handle the responsibility? Where do the enemies come from, and where do our powers come from? It's all a great conspiracy with space aliens. Fucked-up shit happens and everyone suffers, homo loses his head and best buddy suicides, yet the protagonist ends up figuring out the right thing to do and manages to follow it through in the end. But at what cost?
They're basically the same show.
>>339475476
At least the symbolism made sense some of the time.
Why are the openings still cutesy when we've already gotten passed the trick and bait schtick it had when it first released?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQo8o682Ny4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EPZRPig5m0
>>339458524
>is there a show that /a/ praises that is bad?
this harem garbage
>>339476275
Rebellion included all that corny magical girl stuff as pure fanservice, since it never happened in the series
I'm actually impressed that they did it in a way that doesn't cheapen the events of the original (much)
>>339476275
>Movie 1
People who didn't see the series weren't bait-and-switched yet.
>Rebellion
Did you even watch it? The intention behind that opening is pretty obvious.
>>339453501
They have nice endings. There is one where Madokasuggests both her and Homu takes a bath.
>>339460505
Yeah, I know and I am horribly sorry about that.
>>339460686
Just filter scumbag and degrading. 99.9% of his posts contain insults.
