Does a single person exist who has actually played both of these games but still claims that TW3 is better?
>>339386760
No. Especially if they played TW3 on the PS4.
Why do you fuckers from both camps keep trying to force this shitty fanbase war?
The combat in TW3 is just the most casual tier assassin's creed knock-off shit that's ever been. It's so embarrassingly simple, yet it's so heavily lauded and praised.
Don't even give a fuck about BB.
I preffered Witcher 3 more personally. Bloodborne is good but for fuck's sake, it's the same old Souls formula. Shit is getting tiring.
TW3 was an excellent unexpected surprise, I spent much more quality time playing it.
Overall thoughWhy not both?
>>339386760
fucking retard
>>339386760
Witcher 3 is better if you want just to chill with comfy storyline. Bloodborne is better if you want mechanical challange.
>Bloodborne
>Appeal is the combat and atmosphere
>Story and and setting are incredibly interesting as well
>The Witcher 3
>Appeal is the story and setting
>Every aspect of gameplay is fucking trash
I have 'em both, Witcher 3 on PC. It didn't run that well which may have influenced my opinion, but ultimately I found it pretty boring. I can see why people like it though.
I loved Bloodborne, it was fun as fuck. Played through it a bunch of times, got platinum etc.
Hard to say which is the better game because good WRPGs are so hard to come by and these 2 games are so vastly different, but if I had to choose one to play right now I'd pick Bloodborne.
Just upgrade my PC recently though so I'll probably give Witcher 3 another chance.
>>339387181
why is simple bad again? Does every game have to have complex mechanics in order to be good?
>>339386760
But Witcher 3 IS better. Maybe if you get off Miyazaki's dick you'd see it.
Neither game is perfect, but BB's flaws are really really glaring, and TW3's flaws are minor things that you'll forget about once you get into the great looking world and do a few quests.
I have more than 100 hours on both. TW3 made me feel a wide variety of things when I played it, mostly good, while BB was mostly frustration with the occasional feeling of triumph.
I don't think the two are comparable you fucking moron.
>>339386760
Bloodborne is better if you want hack&slash repetitive mobs like F class mmorpgs and get jizzed your pants also witcher 3 is better if you want unique characters&story.
Played both, played W3 on PC on Ultra.
Overall I preferred W3.
The combat in BB was obviously better, but the storytelling and writing in W3 were just superb.
>>339386760
Theyre different games.
BB is an action adventure game, based entirely around combat.
Witcher 3 is an open world RPG, based around entirely on nudity and power fantasy dialog.
I wanted to like the witcher 3
but there are parts that just drag on and on
What exactly is wrong with TW3 combat?
It's functional, you have 2 type of dodge, parrying, guarding, quick magic, a crossbow and alchemy to spice things up. It's miles ahead of asscreed or your average AAA action game.
As for difficulty Death March can be challenging at times, requiring to make use of all your ressources.
>>339387927
funny, because bloodborne is more of an RPG than tw3 by a mile
pic related is your average witcher player
>>339387779
>Bloodborne is better if you want hack&slash repetitive mobs like F class mmorpgs and get jizzed your pants also witcher 3 is better if you want unique characters&story.
>>339388101
it's just a claim parroted by people who try it for 5 mins and don't bother learning the ins and outs of the combat.
>>339387802
>the storytelling and writing in W3 were just superb
>>339387667
Yes. Remember where you are.
>>339387181
You can't win combat in W3 by spamming one button
>>339388265
Sick counterpoints
>Chromatic Aberration : The Greyening better than W3
Depends on what you're looking for. BB does some things better than W3, and vice versa. I consider them both 10/10s.
>>339388116
Stats and equipment don't make it an RPG
Am I missing something? Why are we comparing these games? What do these two games even have to do with each other, other than being 3rd person?
Why not at least compare W3 with one of the Souls games since they have a kind-of more similar setting?
>>339387779
>repetitive
QUEST
GO SOMEWHERE
ACTIVATE SPIDEY SENSES
COLLECT ITEM/KILL MOB/TALK TO NPC
COME BACK
YOU WIN!
if any one of those games is repetitive at all, it's W3 for sure
>>339388116
Both people in this conversation are so retarded I can't even tell who is "supposed" to be in the wrong here.
>>339386760
This stupid fan war needs to end, both fanbases are some of the worst on /v/ I honestly find the Undertale fandom less irritating.
By and large if you're after gameplay you're want Bloodborne and if you're after a plot heavy game you're want Witcher, yes Witcher 3 still has better gameplay that most WRPG's but it's still not fantastic and Bloodborne has a story that the player can get into, but they can also totally avoid it.
The two go in very different directions and rather than arguing about which is better you might as well argue about which type of game as a whole is better.
>>339387730
>Bloodborne has better gameplay than W3
>get off Miyazaki's dick and hop on the dick of a game with worse gameplay
>>339388747
it's PCfats vs. Sonyggers
>>339388116
I got 3 messages in and I'm done. You're fucking retarded if you think I'm about to spend more than 10 seconds reading some literally who 3rd worlders argue about who's less poor or whatever they're talking about.
>>339388657
and what exactly makes TW3 an RPG retard?
Bloodborne is an RPG, TW3 is a linear assassins creed without the good animations or fun parkour and a mass effect powerwheel thrown in
in BB you CHOOSE YOUR ROLE both story and gameplay wise, you join different covenants, use the equipment of different factions and groups, use different weapons that completely change your playstyle etc
>>339388747
it's Sony fanboys who can't hack the fact that W3 won all the awards they thought BB should have won. The butthurt seems to be eternal.
>>339388116
>tähkäalapää
Fuck of you attention whore cunt
For those of you who don't know, this fucking fat female landwhale is a delusional attention whore who goes on /v/ and /r9k/, camwhores for sad little saps and shittalks everyone with her moronic opinions
This fucking asshat already got BTFO and doxed in one thread, but looks like the landwhale can't have enough
>>339386760
Nope.
Bloodborne was way better.
TW3 was just a buggy session of Game of Thrones.
You don't have to choose a game.
I know you faggots like to stir up competition and fight about everything, but get this: If you can't acknowledge that both of those titles are awesome then you're fucking clueless. With that said, I did enjoy BB the most in my time of playing it. That game has changed me, and I still read and watch things about it long after beating it.
>>339386760
I like both get rekt :^)
>>339388952
>3rd worlders
what country were you from again?
>>339388990
are you retarded? I always find it hilarious when people call me a landwhale with zero proof
inb4 someone posts another picture of "me" with zero proof and idiots like you get apeshit over it
also never posted on /r9k/, go hang yourself
>>339388954
you play the ROLE of the witcher
playing a ROLE = Role Playing Game = RPG
I never played a Witcher game, but every time people discuss it, they start talking about lewd shit. Every time i think am getting interested in the game, and look some up gameplay, most of it revolves around sex (How to Romance ...ect). Every time i ask people to tell something about the story, they scream go read the books as a cop out. I feel this just masquerades as a mature game for gamers, and the fantasy is just some low-tier Tolkien fan-fic.
Bloodborne is excellent. The Lore is also pretty rad.
>>339386760
Wildly different goddamn games.
>>339388954
>Witcher 3 is linear
I feel like you haven't actually played it
>>339386760
Well PCucks never ever played BB, and Sonycucks played the Witcher 3 at silky smooth 15 fps, with ps2 graphics. As someone who's played both, I can say I overall preferred the Witcher 3, but BB is definitely the one with better core gameplay and atmosphere. Still you can't really compare them too much since BB is an action jrpg with a heavy focus on combat and the witcher is more of a traditional rpg, which focuses on a lot of other things besides combat. Also mods make the Witcher 3's combat much better.
>>339387667
Yes other wise combat loses interest very quick
>>339388792
Honestly Witcher 3 threads are rarer than threads shitting on Witcher 3 just to shit on it.
>>339389191
>I feel this just masquerades as a mature game for gamers, and the fantasy is just some low-tier Tolkien fan-fic.
took the words right out of my mouth
the game has some plebbit tier humor and dialogue
How are they comparable again?
Not really no. Witcher 3 won /v/ awards simply because this board is majority PC users. I remember even the announcer calling out /v/ for it being bullshit.
I've played both and Bloodborne is a league of its own. The design philosophy behind BB is one that promotes user interaction and curiousity. The design philosophy of Witcher 3 is really no different than any other western AAA.
But one was available on /v/'s most hated console and the other was on PC, so guess who won?
>>339387269
unexpected how? it's literally just another open world game
>>339389163
Here you go, you fat fuck
Name - Nina Smith
Nickname - "nuunuu"
kik name - ninanuunuu
Known to be highly autistic on 4chan, camwhoring for anyone who says anything remotely nice about you and being a fat fuck
As I said, you already got BTFO, you fucking grilled-cheese-looking motherfucker
>>339387667
>Does every game have to have complex mechanics in order to be good?
no but having any mechanics at all would certainly help W3 combat
>>339389191
Meanwhile Bloodborne is a low tier Lovecraft fanfic.
>>339387779
>witcher
>unique character and story
I like The Witcher but come the fuck on mate
>>339386760
people who can't tell a difference between good/bad combat mechanics aka Polygon
>>339389412
I'm a PCfat and I think it's easy to see that Bloodborne is a much better game.
Not worth buying a PS4 just for that, though. I'll just wait for FF7RE and then get both.
Apples and oranges, mayne
It's really fucking stupid to compare a game that's 99% combat to a heavily story focused game
TW3 has the better story related content, and a much larger amount of it than Bloodborne
Bloodborne has better combat and is more challenging
Apples and oranges
They are wastly different games and i enjoyed bouth of them in different ways.
>>339386760
I've played both and Witcher 3 is better in every way possible.
>>339388963
Fallout 4 one GotY. Awards are meaningless.
Bloodborne is made by a legit auteur. Probably the only auteur who is making AAA games. The difference between Witcher 3 and Bloodborne is that Bloodborne is the vision of Miyazaki come true and Witcher 3 is more of a result of slightly improving on what other AAA open-world games on the market have already done.
Also Bloodborne has a criminally underrated narrative. It's pretty tragic once you read into it.
>>339389561
>literally high literature
>fanfic
ayyy polski get the fuck ouuuut
>>339389503
Im literally cracking up, I just image searched for that and zero results came up
what fucking "smith"? Its Mariin
you could literally search for me on FB, or simply open up that kik, or fucking fetlife Ive shared on 4chan a million times. Only thing from the uggo you posted thats even close to reality is that im naturally brunette, but even that I bleach
>>339386760
I think the Witcher 3 is a lot better. I enjoyed Bloodborne for being challenging at points, but it was lacking on a lot of fronts and is using a really old and tired formula.
Witcher 3 was just fantastic. Great story telling, great world, I enjoyed the combat on Death March, is over 80 hours long, and there was a sense of adventure and accomplishment to finding secret areas in the game world.
Bloodborne was really linear, little incentive to explore, and the highlights were the bosses, but it had little impact because I already played Demon Souls before it. It's nothing really outstanding, but it was enjoyable. I don't think its better than DS1, DS3, or Demon however, due to the lack of replay-ability and how much less content it had.
Bloodborne's better if you just want to "Turn your brain off" and enjoy the shitty assassin's creed knock off combat.
>>339389669
>to a heavily story focused game with similar amounts of combat
fixed
>>339389273
In BB:
>80 hours into a strength build and want to use a DEX weapon? Start a new file from scratch and make a DEX character cause no way to respec! :^) same with going from arcane to bloodtinge builds
>at the end of the day the weapons are the varying degrees of fast, most range weapons can be dodged easily
In Witcher 3:
>Respec whenever you want
>3 different ways to play the game that are vastly different (alchemy magic and adrenaline) each with a few subgenres within them
>every weapon type is good and satisfying to use on enemies because you don't have to worry about PVP balance
>not having a ps4 and a pc with an overclocked 5820k with a 980ti amp extreme and a 60" plasma/$2500 speakers
i remember being poor. pull yourselves up by your bootstraps before our race becomes the same as the nigros.
>>339389790
I'd be cracking up too if I were covered with 10 tonnes of lard
>>339389719
They are and I never said they weren't. But here we are looking at yet another "BB is the best game ever, recognise it as such" thread.
>>339389561
We didn't even know it used Lovecraft till mid-point of the game. That was the most hardcorest twist you could've got.
Also, it used it's environment to convey a really interesting story. No game will ever EVER do that again.
But you already knew that.
>>339386760
I'm not going to argue with you. It's clear you are a vocal minority with shit taste. The end.
>>339386760
I have.
I vastly prefer The Witcher 3.
>>339389812
hahaha
>>339386760
I do.
>>339389673
>TW3 has the better story related content
Not really. Bloodborne's story has an immense amount of work put into it. It's just that most people don't notice since they don't stop to think about it.
The combining of narrative, art design and gameplay is unique to Bloodborne. I haven't seen a game in years that combines these elements as efficiently as BB does.
Also holy shit these boss battles. Why can't western devs do good boss battles? It feels so empty playing games without proper climaxes.
Bloodborne has better combat mechanics but overall I prefer Witcher 3's scope, visual design, level design, rpg mechanics, C&C and storytelling. And I like DaS3's combat mechanics better than BB's anyway.
>>339389838
there's a good amount of missions with literally no combat, it's just talking and looking at shit
>>339389891
Are you retarded? Where are you getting the idea that the fatty you posted is me?
Do show me the source where the apparent proof is
>>339389412
>>339389737
Oh please, Bloodborne is overrated as fuck. I agree that it's better than the Witcher 3, but don't do with that "a league of its own" or "made by a legit auteur" shit. Why do you think Sony fans keep getting voted most hated fanbase over Nintendrones?
if I could choose one game I would choose TW3, but bloodborne was good
>>339386760
W3 is better
>>339389976
>he thinks GotY means anything
Funny enough that despite combat is the only single gameplay element in Bloodborne and yet they still managed to make it boring and repetitive button smashing garbage.
>>339388101
not the combat, the encouters
you fight guys or groups of drowners or group of 4 legged something or a single flying giant turkey retexture into 4 different ones. the game doenst mixed up until boss fights, who are fairly simple because loading time is too long.
heart of stone makes bosses much better but encounters are the same mmo shit. but mmos mix thing up with raids and dungoen. Witcher 3 just push some mobs in to lenghthen playtime.
>>339387070
This is inFamous vs Prototype all over again
>>339389976
congratulations, your favorite game is now on par with this masterpiece!
>>339386760
I liked TW3 more, and I absolutely loved Bloodborne.TW3 wins out, though, because it's one of the only Open World games that isn't 99% filler, and the writing is head and shoulders above just about every other video game in recent memory.
>>339386760
I prefer Witcher 3, but then again I'm a storyfag
>>339389976
>I'm not going to argue with you, here is some Dorito Pope awards to prove I'm right
Atleast the Skyrim babbies were honest about the flaws of their games. CDPR drones can't even admit how flawed Witcher 3's gameplay is.
>>339387730
What are bloodborne's flaws?
I've played both
They're both good games
Why do people feel the need to attack different games or defend something to the death?
They're just video games, play both of them.
>>339389163
Fat whore.
>>339390049
yeah but W3 is also much longer than BB
the amount of time you'll actually spend fighting are fairly similar
>>339386760
>Yfw Playing through Bloodborne right now and its amazing
>Yfw Preordered Blood and Wine on Steam and it will be amazing
Both are fucking amazing and some of the best games I've ever played.
>>339390140
>Dragon Age was the only ever game that won GOTY
Fucking retard
>that witcher webm of the wine bottle puzzle where the senses literally do the work for you
>>339387779
BB's story is better than the witcher's, though.
So's it's level design, open world is a meme.
So is it's combat
So are it's bosses and enemies
Witcher is a better book.
>>339389737
>It's pretty tragic once you read into it.
but it's ONLY tragedy. Miyazaki can't do anything other than le edgy dark Berserk worlds where everything sucks.
TW3 has tragedy humour romance adventure and betrayal spread out across hundreds of quests, all well told and with great lip synching so you can SEE the character's emotions and not just hear as they stand there with their mouth closed (which is a clear sign by the way. across 3 games CDProjeckt red gets better and better and over 4 games miyazaki still can't be asked to have characters with moving mouths)
>>339390262
Only true answer
>>339390276
but they're the same now
they're both game of the year!
what masterpieces......wow
The entire fanbase of Bloodborne is built around the meme that the game being "hard". But in reality even Uncharted 4 on hard mode's harder than Bloodborne.
>>339390113
that's partially true, but not nearly to the same degree as TW3 combat
though BB doesn't exactly have a compelling story to make up for downcomings in combat, which is wholly the meat of the game
>>339390030
>has an immense amount of work put into it
The actual story of Bloodborne is pretty basic, at least the stuff that's actually given to the player.
The rest of the "story" amounts to autistic fanfiction based on nothing but vague item descriptions and occasional NPC conversations.
>>339390247
sonyggers want every games to be sony exclusive. literally the sjw of platforms.
Why the fuck are you trying to pit bloodborne and witcher against eachother?
They are completely different types of games trying to do completely different things
>>339390140
Holy shit 2014 was such a shit year. Even worse then 2012.
>>339390140
Dragon Age Inquisition GOTY awards - 134
Witcher 3 GOTY Awards - 254
hmmm
>>339386760
>Comparing an exclusive to a multiplat
This is always asking for trouble.
>>339389940
>We didn't even know it used Lovecraft till mid-point of the game.
Dude come on, blood and aristocracy, dreams, those little alien niggers? Overgrown New England hamlets, crowded victorian cityscapes, underground laboratories? Have you ever even read Lovecraft?
>Also, it used it's environment to convey a really interesting story. No game will ever EVER do that again.
Oh wait, you're trolling. Never mind.
BB's the officially GOTY, no contest
I have played both but I like them for different reasons so I can't say which one is better. Bloodborne has a great feeling of exploration and combat, while Witcher 3 offers me great dialog, story and characters.
>>339390262
I like you enthusiasm anon!I don't really car for bloodborne tho
>>339390349
Witcher 3 has an awful story though. Why do CDPR drones pretend it's good? The Wild Hunt is shit and Ciri is Mary Sue.
Also CDPR keeps confusing gore and sex for maturity. They are immature as fuck in truth.
>>339390380
like making a shooting game hard is complex. just aimbot the ai and let them 2 shotting you.
>>339389790
>Mariin
Is that pronounced like marine, as in large marine animal?
>>339389182
I play the ROLE of a hero in Mario, so therefore Mario is an RPG
>>339389841
Respec is horseshit. There's no reason to replay DaS3 because you can just lol Rosarias into another build: that is, one of the three viable ones anyway.
>>339390060
By the fact that all the information uncovered about you matches up
You did post a facebook account yesterday, but I highly doubt you're a 30 year old french milf on fucking 4chan
>>339390508
So Bloodborne's on par with Dragon Age Inquesition and TLOU? Glad to know that.
>>339390508
how many different institutions give out an annual GOTY award?
>>339390380
Not really. I don't find the game hard at all.
This meme is spouted by people who have no legitimate reason to hate the game. Sure, some bosses may take a few times to beat but the game isn't Ninja Gaiden or anything.
Why do sonyggers hate TW3?
It's not excusive to PC
>>339389191
>Every time i ask people to tell something about the story, they scream go read the books as a cop out
I guess you didnt ask many people, I never ever heard someone say that
woah.......game of the year.....
>>339390427
Sonygger inferiority complex. They have to shitpost against other games and claim superiority over their exclusives. Just look at the daily Bloodborne vs DS3 threads or Uncharted 4 graphics threads.
>>339390103
>>339390140
>>339390242
I'm sorry your 'underrated' console game didn't win any significant awards anon. I know your salty, but the W3 is a superior game in every respect. Every. Respect.
>>339390680
Why do you assume everyone that hates a highly flawed open-world game is a sonygger? Maybe your game just sucks?
>>339390623
rosaria only do it 5 times per ng
The Witcher has good writing that makes me interested in the game's characters and instils a want to explore the world. After a while you care about the conflicts and feel attached to the little digital people. Sometimes you fight, other times you can utilize diplomacy or trickery. Despite being an established character, Geralt is still fun to play as and his dry manner and delivery in contrast to the other boisterous and loud characters of the game is very entertaining. The games have plenty of flaws, but they are all overshadowed by being a genuinely good time when playing.
Bloodborne has no writing. It's just your standard jumbled bunch of nip nonsense as a paper-thin backdrop for fighting endless amounts of enemies in exactly the same way. No thought or consideration needed and as is also standard to Japanese games, no choices because they don't think the player can ever be trusted with free will, or a main character with a personality for that matter. The only characters from Bloodborne anyone ever mentions is the Pickle-Pee raven and that's because it's a meme in a meme game, no other characters are even remotely interesting. When you boil it down, the only thing the game has going for it is the boring, samey combat.
There's no reason why anyone would ever defend any of this, unless the game is literally the only thing they have, and they therefore cannot bear that it might not be all that good.
>>339390718
That's just your opinion mate.
And that's fine.
>>339390718psssstI haven't played BB nor W3But W3 does some really dumb fucking shit that makes a game instantly worse, which BB does much less of
>>339390571
The bloody baron's quest line is an excellent example of a proper mature story - not just shoving gore and sex into everything
>>339390496
Not the person you responded to, but the things you listed are aspects of regular ol gothic horror. When I played Bloodborne I wasn't aware that it was going to be so "Lovecraftian", either. Made for a nice surprise tee-bee-aitch
Both fantastic games but I honestly wish TW3 had something close to TW1's combat, though I might be the only person who actually enjoyed it
>>339390692
This is literally
>>339389412
Witcher 3 really is babby's first game.
>>339390030
Not even close. There method of "story telling" is just pieces that only make sense when you make a lot of assumptions.
>>339390781
That's five replays there's no reason to do. I'm a fan of making decisions.
>>339390250
maybe if you say it enough times it will come true
>>339390587
Dunno how to explain, its not like marine
>>339390632
french milf? what the fuck, im from finland
as I said, do show me the place where the image of that fatty shows up with my other info
>>339386760
Witcher 3 is far superior. Bloodborne's combat is quite possibly the most overrated thing in video games. It's simplistic in its entirety and the variety is quite pathetic.
Once you figure out boss patterns, that's all there is to the game. Witcher 3 at least has great quest systems and a fantastic, coherent story. The combat is serviceable and quite frankly, more varied than BB's. Of course the universe, characters, and graphics BTFO BB.
/thread
>>339388954
>TW3 is linear
>Somehow BB isnt
I hope you're not paid for being such a terrible drone
>>339390128
It isn't even that. Infamous and Prototype were two different games of the same basic genre. Both were Sandbox Murdercity Superpower Action games.
Bloodborne and TW3 aren't even in the same basket. The Witcher belongs in a basket with fucking Dragon Age in terms of narrative goals and gameplay style (that isn't to say the Dragon Age is even remotely in The Witcher's league, just that they're both story-driven fantasy RPGs) while Bloodborne is only really comparable to the rest of the Souls series.
The whole BB vs. TW3 war bullshit is like if the Doctor Mario and Crash Bandicoot Kart Racing fan bases decided to duke it out over which of their games is the REAL best game ever.
>>339390825
>I haven't played BB nor W3
>But W3 does some really dumb fucking shit that makes a game instantly worse
/v/ in a nutshell
>>339390941
>bashes BB combat
>W3 combat is "serviceable"
hooooly fuck the fanboys are real
>>339389412
Let's settle down buddy.
It was a gothic Souls clone
>>339390941
>Slams BB's combat
>Praises TW3's
Your bias is showing.
>>339390128
That was a thing?
>>339386760
it's comparing almost 2 different things.
TW3 is a story based game with graphics porn.
Bloodborne is an old school masochist obstacle course with great designs but with low graphical fidelity due to the PS4.
>>339390941
>/thread
>thread continues without validating your shit opinion
Checkmate atheist
>>339390941
>pretending you have just arrived into the thread when you don't have a new IP tag
>samefagging this hard to shill for a game
>/threading your own post
These polack marketers are amazing.
>>339389790
Cobgenital
>>339390970
everyone knows about Witcher senses and crowded UI, don't have to play the game to see that
>>339390103
>GotY means nothing
>sales mean nothing
>reviews mean nothing
>user scores mean nothing
>a vocal minority in an anonimous image board means EVERYTHING
>>339391050
>>339391075
What did you expect of actual Polack shills? They've been at it for years. A plague on this board.
>>339390718
Lovecraft>regular fantasy, objectively speaking.
So you are wrong.
Holy shit i really need to leave this shithole.
>>339389273
Most shooters are just click to kill. That doesn't mean they are boring. There is more to combat and more to gameplay then the complexity of the mechanics.
>>339390851
Maybe it was because I had just read through the Lovecraft anthology, but it was pretty damn obvious to me where the game was going the moment they started talking about dream shit. It sure as fuck wasn't a twist to me when more blatant cosmic horror shit started popping up.
>>339388792
I'll right out that I've yet to play Bloodborne, I don't have a PS4 so I can only guess what it's like based on other fromsoft games.
Ok first of W3 is not that much like GOT's it's a dark fantasy but it's less serious and far more colourful, it's also only has two main characters rather than dozens, it's not got a ton in common with GOT outside of being western fantasy and being an 18 rated title.
The combat is far from AC bad, it's got issues here and there but unless your playing on a low difficulty it's at least above average and good for an action based WRPG, it's not up to the Souls games but the Souls titles are gameplay first, Witcher is mostly a bunch of plot heavy short story's, many of them pulpy and sometimes houmous.
The sex stuff is exaggerated, maybe not in 1 which felt almost like an HRPG with how much it popped up but in two onwards it's not been that big a part, yes there's waifu and daughterfui bait but so what, it's not Bioshock Infinite, the cast is likable..
While I've not played it let me just bat for bloodborne based on my Souls Knowledge, first of all saying it's same old doesn't mean much, remove witchers plot and the games nowhere close to Souls in terms of gameplay, Souls titles carefully place each foe and stage hazard, W3 is a massive open world game were much of the time high levels and good items will win out over skill, like I said it's still better than most in it's genre but unlike a souls title, trying to fight high-level bad guys is not a fun challenge as a dude in his underpants will still take 60 axe hits if his level is far ahead of your's and you can always, item abuse is also easy to do as there's no risk to using a healing item, unlike how in Souls you slow down to use it.
I feel like I'm going on at this point but can most of you guy's shut up if you're just gonna shout easily disproven meme's like Witcher 3's combat is as bad as AC and its story is like GOT or BB is repetitive and has broken difficulty.
>>339388305
Yes, you can, there's a lot of videos about that.
>>339391173
I'm actually debating whether to go out and buy a PS4 with bloodborne right now just out of spite
would've bought one eventually anyway but the Bitcherbabbies ITT are fucking dumb
>>339390941
>witcher 3's combat
>more varied than bloodborne
>literally one weapon vs 26 main-hand weapons which transform in another weapon, two character transformations and fuckton of offhand weapons and spells
>more varied than bloodborne
>>339391087
That was very much a thing. It was still a thing when both games had sequels
>>339391247
Don't worry. With the way things are going now with endless Witcher shilling, the boards will be split and Witcher drones can bath in their circlejerk alongside Skyrim babbies.
>>339391168
I didn't say the vocal minority means everything. This shithole means nothing too.
Strawman harder, pleb
>>339386760
tw3 is better than bb and deserved its goty.
bb > ds3 also
The amount of asshurt coming from Sonyggers seems to be suspiciously close to Blood and Wines release. Hmmm,just look at the ratcheting up of daily SoulsBorne shill threads this past week.
Sonyggers pain seems to be eternal knowing Bloodborne WILL NEVER EVER be GOAT. You know who that title belongs too
Bloodborne is really just a tired regurgitation of previous souls titles. There's just nothing at all there if you don't like the same games forty times. It's the Final Fantasy of dodge-based combat.
But unlike FF it doesn't even try to have a story anyone can give an autistic shit about.
I bought TW3 a couple days ago
Played 7 hours in a row and it was enjoyable
Then I remembered that gameplay wise I only had done random chit chat, ran around with my horse and killed some random bandits in a shallow as fuck combat system for those 7 hours
I don't know
I'll play it through eventually but by god is it boring
>>339391173
Real talk now. What is it with this board and all this polish shilling? Anything that comes out of that shithole is praised as the second coming of christ here and it's always been this way. I just don't get it. What's up with this obnoxious slavshit marketing here precisely?
>>339391348
You could have 2000 weapons but if the combat 's still the same R1 smashing then it's meaningless
>>339391219
Lovecraft is the most overrated shit ever.
>oh no it's a le spooky tentacle monster OH SHIT EVERYONE MINDBROKED BECAUSE SPOOKY
>>339391168
GoTY actually literally means nothing. Dragon Age Inquisition won it, and that's not a good game.
>>339390812
>Bloodborne
>pickle pee raven
Please, play the game.
>>339391285
doom is the greatest shooter and has many mechanic going for it, you dunce. the reason why none of them are apparent because everything die so fucking quick, including you.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJcf0aOwmiA
and that didnt touch the multiplayer
shooter mechanic is the go-to, normie version of "low floor, high ceiling"
>BB fans will still not shut the fuck up about their game
>They will still pretend their community isn't just as fucking annoying as the Souls oneand that their game is actually different
>>339391247
Your leave shall be granted, young traveller.Be back by 5, okay?
>>339389412
>t-the majority can't be right my memegame is better REEEEEEEE
Welcome to reality, kiddo.
Played both, both were pretty good games.
But Witcher 3 is the best Open world game to date something you cant say about BB, because BB is just another Souls game.
Its hard to decide really because Witcher 3 had everything i wanted from the game, great story, graphics, engaging and interesting quests, authentic cities with a shitload to discover, characters i really cared about and pretty decent gameplay for an open world game ( in comparison to turds like Skyrim or F4 )
Bloodborne was great too, it was challanging and had a huge ammount of shit to explore.
I guess i chooseGeralt in the end because it was the last game for him and the trilogy ended with near perfection
>>339391347
Wait for the neo, that's what I'm doing.
>>339391465
Mods are incompetent and have no idea how to deal with Slav marketers. I've suggested a range ban on them before but they don't seem to be willing to do it considering how Slav marketers always come back like roaches.
If we split the boards, atleast we get one board that isn't infested with Polacks.
>>339391358
Shit, that must've been a couple of years back then
>>339391501
>I've only read about Lovecraft, the post
Fucking hell anon.
>>339391521
It had no competition.
In 2015 MGSV, Fallout 4, Bloodborne came out
Even Dragon Age Inquisition of all games got GOAT.
Sorry Sonyggers,Bloodborne wasn't good enough
>>339391050
>>339391075
>>339391173
>>339391115
>>339391131
>>339391348
>le no armor but faster and BIGGAR weapons: the game
>le dodge hits and spam dex stat: the game
fuck that garbage
>>339390246
as mentioned already the lack of respec, which a big fucking deal when put together with the Chalice dungeon content which is basically required if you want good gems which are required if you want to get into PVP or NG+++. So that's a major flaw. Could be easily fixed with shared stash accessible to all characters or again just a respec item. Plus all the bullshit within the chalice dungeons like the defiled chalice (literal artificial difficulty) and the inability to buy dungeon materials until NG+
No MP bar so you constantly have to farm bullets for everything specially if you want to do arcane or bloodtinge (so 2/3rds of all possible builds). I won't bring up blood vial farming cause thanks to health rally it's not that big a deal.
the narrative has a lot of holes that are never really filled and it's up to autists to argue about what exactly "Paleblood" ACTUALLY means and shit like that when really the lore shouldn't be that open ended. pretty big deal for a game where the lore is such a big part of the appeal. also the player has less power over the world as the major players already fucked the world beyond saving so you're just a janitor (doing it for free) cleaning up after them in a world beyond saving.
fairly linear world is a slight flaw, not that big a deal, not pushing for the open world meme here.
again, both games have flaws, BB's flaws just REALLY piss me off to no end cause the game is close to being a masterpiece.
>>339391423
>Bloodborne is really just a tired regurgitation of previous souls titles. There's just nothing at all there if you don't like the same games forty times.
>And Witcher THREE isn't
>>339391485
>bloodborne combat
>R1 mashing
I love this meme
Somebody post that webm of the final boss in W3 getting stunlocked by igni spam.
>>339391545
BB is tweaked souls for faster combat and less demanding resource management-
>>339391501
I'm going to mind break you, fuccboi
>>339391485
>bloodborne
>R1 non-transformed, R1 transformed, R1->L1 and L1->R1 interactions mid-combo which are all different depending on when you start them, R2, charged R2, L2 for offhand weapon, weapons with way more complex moveset that witcher wouldn't dream off
>meanwhile in witcher every sword has the exact same moveset and you only have square and triangle that you press once and watch geralt perform a gigantic telegraphed attack on top of an EBIN deathcam animation
You aren't even trying.
>>339391465
>What is it with this board and all this polish shilling?
They're a new market making good games, that's it
When someone is assblasted at a game (See : the sonyggers here) that appen to be from poland, they pretend it's polack shills and bam, a meme is born
>>339391637
It doesn't matter. There were plenty of games that were more deserving of titles and awards but didn't get them because GoTY awards are literally paid shill events and nothing more.
>>339391686
>And Witcher THREE isn't
Well it's not
>>339391526
I gave it an hour of my time. There was nothing interesting about it, so that was more than enough. Maybe next time they'll make a better game.
Why do the Bloodborne shills rush out everytime a new Witcher DLC's released?
>>339390961
yeah, i really don't understand these threads explicitly trying to compare BB and TW3. witcher games have never made any sort of pretense at being as heavily skewed toward the "action" side of "action-RPG" as BB/souls titles are; it's firmly in the middle of the spectrum, with shit like baldur's gate over towards the RPG side, and monhan/BB towards action.
it's apples and oranges, and anyone that says otherwise is a fool
they're both phenomenal games
>>339391521
> Dragon Age Inquisition won it, and that's not a good game
So what that tell you about Bloodborne? The masses has rejected your Souls rehash trash. Shit Dark Souls 2 and 3 is better than Bloodborne Sonygger.
I don't get it. If we go by reviewers, MGSV wins, not Witcher 3. Why are Polack shills so much of cocksuckers? They weren't as keen about GOTY awards when Cisquisition was winning.
Witcher 3 is objectively better.
Not only is it harder, but better in every aspect that makes a video game a video game.
My casual tier girlfriend who plays animal crossing and stardew valley beat Dark Souls 3 twice over but tried playing witcher and was conviced the game is harder because you have to plan your encounters and time your parrys more often than that of BB or DS.
/v/ is filled with filthy casuals and will defend BloodSouls games without hesitation before questioning wether or not this hivemind is wrong.
>>339391582
yeah I'll wait for the price cut and get a regular one
doubt neo will do anything worth the while
They're both excellent games
>>339391285
What are you talking about most shooters have a ton of complex mechanics like bhopping,air straifing, surfing, rocket jumping, and a ton more.
>>339390571
>Also CDPR keeps confusing gore and sex for maturity. They are immature as fuck in truth.
It's like you've read literally zero literature in your life. Sex and violence are near constant themes. I'm so sorry the digital titties triggered you this much.
>>339391686
>And Witcher THREE isn't
It definitely isnt, W2 and W3 are two very different games
>>339391835
>My casual tier girlfriend who plays animal crossing and stardew valley beat Dark Souls 3 twice over
bet my ass she summon Tyrone to do it for her
>>339391887
Only someone who has never read a book would praise CDPR's shitty writing.
>>339391612
Eat shit you fucking memelord. 90% of his stories are just laboring to describe a mildly fantastical scenario and pretending it's a mindblowing experience that a spooky new england basement is spooky or that a meteorite that crashed into a small time and killed everything with radiation sickness is spooky.
>>339391642
spin to win.......woah....
>>339391829
>what does that tell you
That goty isn't relevant
>>339391776
Nope, that's not the case at all. The board has always had a MASSIVE slavshit bias ever since the first witcher and games like stalker and metro, which are all hyped way beyond their mark here and it has always been this way. You don't see this kind of shit literally nowhere else.
>>339391586
>Guys everybody who is talking about this game MUST BE A FUCKING SHILL
>No evidence ever delivered
Pic related i have an entire folder for topics i made because i wanted to talk aboutVIDEOGAMES
>Does a single person exist who has actually tasted apples and oranges but still claims oranges are better?
>>339391686
>this is the intelligence of a fromdrone
pretty sad desu
I'm tired of Dark Souls.
Play one you've played them all. No story, no surprises. Just the same combat every time.
>>339391818
Then why do you expect people to care about the shit you spew
>>339391972
>I tried but didn't really read lol, the second post
>>339391835
>the slavshit is still samefagging and pretending he's a new IP
Holy samefagging batman.
>>339391686
>Emphasis on THREE
>3 different engines, 3 different combat system, 3 different types of game
Three stand probably for you IQ
>>339392024
They are.
Why do you think orange juice sell better than apple ones?
>>339391990
>posting a webm of Geralt fighting trash mobs he overlevels
>implying you can't 1-shot trash mobs that you over level in souls as well
>comparing Bloodborne's "strongest" aspect to Witcher's 3rd or 4th strongest aspect
How do I know you're a retard?
>Soulsfags have to make franchise war with other games again because no one's playing Dark Souls 3 anymore let alone Bloodborne
>>339391686
All three Witcher games are completely different, and are the continuation of one long story which changes according to your choices.
Bloodborne is nothing.
>>339392001
>That goty isn't relevant
Sure,thats why asshurt Bloodborne fags shill the game daily and try to convince themselves thats its better than TW3 by always comparing the two right?
>>339392154
Apple juice >>>> orange juice >>> grape juice you pleb
>>339392201
that webm is 90% of witcher 3 encounters though
I feel bad for anyone who is missing out on playing Bloodborne due to not having access to a PS4 and I feel bad for anyone that didn't get to experience TW3 on a good PC.
>>339392026
good job proving you havent played bloodborne
So we can all agree that Witchershills and Soulsfags are the most cancerous fanbases on /v/, yes?
>There are people who will read this thread and still think we shouldn't split the boards
WHO KEEPS MAKING THESE THREADS?
THESE GAMES ARE SO DIFFERENT FROM ONE ANOTHER AND BOTH ARE SO FUCKING GOOD
>>339391835
See this is what bug's me about Witcher fan's, witcher has a great collection of story's, the simple pleasures of looting and collecting, 1 really fun card minigame, and some great visuals but you guy's gotta claim that the core combat is better than BB, give it up, it's not, anyone who's played a single souls title can tell it's not, it's not bad but it's a part of a massive collection of elements instead of being the centerpiece, stop trying to win a losing fight.
>>339391990
>Mah WEBM
>Lowest difficulty possible
That shit doesnt work on every other difficulty because people block and counter that attack easily
>>339392105
No seriously, Lovecraft wrote like two stories I actually enjoyed. Dream Quest of Unknown Kadath and The Music of Erich Zann, He mostly wrote trite garbage.
>>339392236
That's quite funny, wasn't it precisely the witcher fanbase that just an year before were all up in arms saying how goty does not matter because Inquisition got it?
Hmm, that kinda shatters your narrative there, doesn't it?
>>339392236
No.
Did you need another (You)
>>339391972
>I was born into poverty: the post
>>339391916
>>339392025
>>339392149
>>339392230
well what's different about them? :^)
>>339391538
I can't tell if this is sarcasm
>>339391868
First, no. Most shooters do not have all of those mechanics. Second, things like bunny hopping and other avoidance tactics are no different from dodges and rolls in The Witcher.
>>339391887
Sex and gore for the sake of sex and gore isn't mature, it's childish.
It needs to be properly used, if you have people exploding in blood and guts every 5 seconds while there's two people fucking every other scene it doesn't come off as a mature title.
>>339391835
This
>>339392251
you're a virgin though
>>339392024
Both are shit
No joke
Orange is really fucking bad all around, it's just cheap and it mix well with other stuff
Apple is pretty much just water with lot of sugar
>>339392315
I like you
>mfw I enjoyed both because I'm not a jaded shit that compares every single game with swords
>>339392251
He's not fighting floaters and nekkers though
>>339392315
The same kind of people who make console war threads.
>>339392332
FastQuen breaks the game on Death March, get real
>>339392263
I...I feel you anon,no one should miss Bloodborne ad it's awesomeness on the powerful majestic PS4
>abundant generic high fantasy vs. rare lovecraftian lore
>200+ replies
fucking really?
Both games are god awful, and the fact that people enjoy them to the point that they argue which is better is evident of stagnation of industry.
>>339392247
>plebby plebians of plebbing plebs
nice argument. applecuck
Imagine wasting your life shilling a big company without getting paid on an anonymous image-board.
