2 > 5 > 1 > 3 > 4
1>3>5>4>2
>>338075104
>the shittiest games in the franchise are the first xD LOL
3 > 2 > 1 > 4 > 5
2 > 4 > 5 > 3 > 1
I hope your Solid Snake infiltrates my outer haven if you know what I mean
>>338075197
>the shittiest bait in the thread is the first xD LOL
As long as 4 is at the bottom I'm ok
>>338075104
3=2>1>4>5
I like metaru gear soridu
>>338075104
God damn this is impressive. How do you do that?
This is a dual sneaking missions snake
>>338075367
Honestly, how many women do you think Solid has fucked? I think it's safe to say Big Boss fucked a lot, but what of Solid?
>>338075104
3>1>2>>portable ops>5>shit>4
>>338075617
Solid Snake is canonically a repressed homosexual, confirmed by kojima.
>>338075617
Solid Snake has fucked one woman.
ey b0ss
Old fag who has been with the series for longer than the vast majority of you. My opinion is better informed than yours.
GOD TIER
MGS 3
GREAT TIER
MGS V > MGS 1 > MGR
GOOD TIER
MGA 2 > MGS: GB > MGA > MG 2 > MG 1
MEDIOCRE TIER
MGS 2 > MGS: PO > MGS: PW
COMPLETE GARBAGE TIER
MGS 4
2>1>4>3>5I've never played a Metal Gear game
>>338075617
I respectfully agree and disagree with any and all opinions and positions in the series as long as we all agree MGS 4 is the worst numbered MGS game and a good contender for worst Metal Gear game in general.
If you actually think MGS 4 is good, let alone better than 1, 2, 3 or V, you're a faggot that should get the fuck out of /v/ ASAP
>>338075104
What about Peace Walker?
>>338075104
3 > 1 > 2 > 4 > 5
5 was a complete disappointment, and I'm talking gameplay. Story was always bad. The gameplay took the surprising, weird gameplay of MGS series that was full of crazy moments, boss fights, set pieces, and turned it into an open world Far Cry like game where the only thing you could do was infilitrate somewhere, fulton out something and go away yourself.
>b-but you can experiment!!!!
Yes, I can grind for hours and then wait another real time hour to unlock something I will use once and never again because the basic tranquillizer rifle is the best thing in-game.
2>1>3>4
Haven't played V yet.
The following people are smart people with arguable but defensible positions
>>338075104
>>338075742
>>338075924
The following people are objectively wrong and most likely retarded
>>338075253
>>338075443
>>338075319
3 > 1 > V > 4 > 2
Whoever disagrees will be shot
>>338076353
Add in another retard to the list.
3 > 4 > 1 > PW > POWERGAP > GZ > TPP > MG1 > MG2 > 2
>>338075197
>MGS2 is bad
>>338075414
This
For me it's 3<5<2<1<4, aside from being unfinished I had a lot of fun with V, after the turd that was 4 I wasn't expecting much in the story department.
RISING > 2 > 4 > PW > GZ > 3 > 1
2 > 1 > PW > 3 > GZ > TPP > 4
>>338075187
>>338076438
MGS 2 was disappointing, but it's still a million times better than MGS 4 if you ask me. It has more and better gameplay (Let's not forget the VR Missions) and the story is actually pretty good.
By comparison, MGS 4's gameplay is nearly non-existent and the story is retarded beyond belief and ruined the rest of the series, not to mention it's shoved down your throat.
>>338075617
Based off of just the games no more than 2, but based on his personality id say no more than 5.
>>338076494
>4 above 1
Remove yourself from this board immediately.
wow v is awful, if people say there are worse they must be unplayable
big boss is sexy af
3>2>1>4>5
3 for fun and great story
2 for most interesting story, if a little dumb, still more relevant than ever
1 for pushing the limits of story and gameplay for its time
4 for clusterfuck story but good gameplay and multiplayer
5 for uninspired story left unfinished, even /v/s story predictions were better than the real thing, and like others have said they left the form of MGS games in the worst way
2>3=1>5>4
Objectively correct
>>338076627
You scared me there for a sec, bub, you used < instead of >
3 > 1 > RISING > 5 > 2 > 4
2 > 1 > 4 > 3 > 5
If you disagree you hate video games
>>338076925
I envy you for never having gone through the piece of shit that was 4. If you think V was a bad game, then you really have no idea how bad MGS games can get.
>>338077649
>If you disagree you hate video games
He says while rating a movie higher than two actual video games.
>>338075104
From best to worst:
3 - The best balance of everything from gameplay to story. Some annoying or unneeded mechanics like the first aid system.
2 - Improved gameplay from 1, really interesting story, but some frustrating parts and weak bosses.
1 - the most challenging sneaking, good story, good bosses, some very annoying parts near the end.
4 - Improved gameplay, but it gets buried under all the cutscenes. Still, varying scenarios, nice bosses and a decent closure to the series.
GZ & V - The best gameplay, but missions get repetitive quickly. Boring management, abysmal side content, and bosses are practically not there. Story is extremely weak, and a horrible conclusion to the series
PW - Pretty much the same as V, but on a smaller scale. Side missions are much better though
>>338075104
>all that hentai
We're gonna need a higher quality image in order to properly science it.
>>338078065
I thoroughly agree with this man
>>338077989
>4
>a decent closure to the series
t. retard
>>338077846
>he doesn't know that 5 has more hours of cutscenes than any other MGS
>he thinks fultoning the same NPC's over and over in the same locations with no boss fights or good level design is gameplay
3-1-2-5-4
>mgsv dlc
>year one complete edition
>Phantom of the First Pain
please provide for us kek. Let Konami take advantage of us. one. last. time
Big Boss >>> Solid Snake
This the only ranking that matters
>>338078694
It's not about the number of cutscene hours, it's about the number of gameplay hours. MGS 4 has like 3 when you count anything that is actually fun. And those 3 hours are obviously soured quite a bit when they're like 20 minute long scenes suffocated by tons of 30 minute shit cutscenes with a terrible story.
>>338075104
Thanks, Snek.
>>338075617
2 based on canon.
Probably 3 if he actually cucked that Steve guy from MG1.
3>5>1>4>2
objectively good opinion
Venom snake >big boss
solid snake>big boss
PW > 1 = 2 = 3 = 4 > TPP > GZ > PO
>>338075104
1 > 2 = 3 > 4I haven't played MGS5 yet, I still haven't forgiven Kojima for the wasted potential of MGS4.
2>1>GZ>5>3>4
>>338079461
How is it possible for someone to have such shit taste? You seriously manage to be the most retarded person in this thread, and that's no small task.
>>338079410
Is that doujin finally available in the panda?
I had a few chapters favorited, but they were all taken down.
>>338075187
First post best post
>>338079524
>wasted potential
You wouldn't enjoy V
3>1>2>5>4
2>1>4>PW>3
Haven't played V yet.
Snakes are NOT for sexual. They are pure.
>>338075319
> 1 last
I was about to call you underage but then I realized that by the end of the year you could literally be born after MGS1 release and still be old enough to post here.
>>338079658
That's what I've been told. Everything is half-finished from what I've heard.
MGS4 could have been great if there had been more gameplay and less shitty story. At least I could shed a nostalgia tear at Act IV.
>>338079753
2>1>PW>4>3***
2>1>3>GZ>4>PW>V
>>338078979
big boss is shit, kill yourself, Kojima.
>>338075924
>Mgr
>great
kek, it's mediocre
>>338079563
>You seriously manage to be the most retarded person in this thread, and that's no small task.
Literally the only thing people like about MGS2 is the speech the colonel gives
Raiden and Rose are shit characters
Bosses are completely forgettable
Bad swimming sections
Bad escort section
Bad hunt for bomb sections
Way too much backtracking
Half the Big shell isn't enterable
Worst level design in the series
Having to hunt for nodes in every single area to unlock the map is tedious and annoying
Cut content. Tanker Escape, Half the struts, and Arsenal in New York all not in the game
3>TTS>2>PW>4>1
3 is and will always be the best.
>>338080294
Still better than 4
3>2>5>1>4>PW
>>338075104
Is this a MGS thread or a Halo thread?
>>338080294
>Way too much backtracking
>Half the Big shell isn't enterable
>Worst level design in the series
These are the only legitimate complaints
la > li > lu > le > lo
>>338080536
God Forbid
>>338079572
It's been on tsumino/pururin since forever. Wasn't exhentai supposed to be the best source for doujins?
This comes from someone who actually likes all the games to a certain degree.
>Story:
1>3>MG2>2>PW>4>V>MG
>Gameplay:
4>V>2>3>PW>MG2>1>MG
>Level design:
3>2>MG2>PW>1>4>MG>>>>>>>V
>Setting:
1>MG2>3>PW>4>2>V>MG
>Characters (main cast)
3>PW>1>4>2>V>MG2>MG
Debate me.
Ground Zeroes is a better game overall than mgsV. It achieves better mission objecting and scenarios with less. If the complete game had been an ongoing series of GZ type games it would have been the greatest episodic game ever.
>>338081061
Yup, just checked and there are still no links unless the artist is unlisted. It's a shame.
2 = 1 > 3 >4 > Ghost Babel > GZ > PW > POOPS > TPP
>>338081115
I..... actually agree with this.
>>338081376
I completely agree
With few exceptions most of the facilities you infiltrate in MGSV are functionally the same and the open world aspect does virtually nothing to enhance the gameplay
If they just gave more detailed bases to infiltrate, preferably more indoor ones as well, then MGSV would've been so much better.
>>338075104
2>1>4>3>>>>>>>>>>>>>PW>V
/v/ has spoken on this already.
>>338081598
How weird, i've always used pururin/tsumino and thought that i was missing out on a lot of things by not using exhentai but it doesn't look like it. If it doesn't even have ShindoL then that's lame.
>>338083546
>Ghost Babel lost against Rising
>>338081115
>4 above anything in Story despite the fact 4 is easily the worst story in the entire series and the one that raped the series to death
>4 above any of the numbered games in gameplay when there's almost none of it
>4 above anything in level design when there are barely no levels in the damn game
Nah.
>>338084245
Are you saying that Snake's Revenge is better?
>2 >
Is how you instantly know a MGS game ranking is shit
>>338084660
This
>>338084551
Story wise? They are as retarded as each other.
3 = 1 > 2 > pw > 5 > 4
3>1>5>PW>4>2>PO
1 > 3 > 2 = V > MG2 > PW > 4 > MG > PO
>>338079026
>when you count anything that is actually fun
not an argument
>>338084120
Rising is way better, you tremendous faggot.
1>2>3>4>5
If you disagree you don't know how to count
>>338085208
Maybe in gameplay
Not sure how can you compare them, they're too different
It's a 2D stealth game vs a Hack 'n' Slash
>>338085208
Not it isnt.
The story and characters are written like a parody, the gameplay is shallow and the soundtrack is fucking awful with vocals
>>338085547
Rising isn't even a good Hack 'n' Slash so MG2 is better by default
>>338075104
>the time and effort that went into creating this
I mean, cool, I guess
>>338085669
It's pretty good
It's hard to compete with games like DMC3 and NGB
>>338075104
>5
OP confirmed for not knowing shit about MGS.
Rising is the only game i havent played
>It's a /v/ pretends it likes MGSV episode to forget their pain substory
I want to get off the wild ride, stop making me think about this bland Far Cry Clone.
>>338075104
2 > 1 > 3 > 4 > 5 > GZ > PSP games
Revengeance >>>> 4 >>>> 1 >>>> 3 >>>>>>> everything else
>>338085554
>having shit this taste
I liked MGS4. It was fun when it had gameplay. It's only downfall now is that I'll never want to actually PLAY it again since if I just want to PLAY I'll put in MGSV.
>>338086316
Shit bait
The tranq breaks every game after 2
>>338077649
1 > 3 > 4 = 5 > 2
3>2>1>4>V>PW
So long as 3 tops your list, it is correct
V > 3 > 1 > PW > 2 > 4
>>338084245
>4 above any of the numbered games in gameplay when there's almost none of it
That's why there is a category for level design, you kiddo; 4 has really good gameplay, Snake controls in a godly way, and all the gear you have at your disposal is amazing. But it has no chance of being put to use thanks to the way each chapter is structured.
And I give it a prop because the story managed to give closure to the series, while the story of V is even worse, and the one of MG is just plain bad.
>>338084551
>Snake's Revenge
>MG2
I think you have facts mixed up. MG2 stands for Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake.
>>338084070
Well, there are many other fucked up fetishes that you won't find otherwise if you're into that.
3>1>2>4>PW>5
Anyone who actually liked MGSV are just deluding themselves.
3 > 4 > 2 > 1 > 5
>>338080294
I liked that it was all small rooms and you had to figure out how to pass through them, one at a time. It felt more "arcade" than MGS3 for instance. It's got a pacman vibe, if you will.
I agree with many of your complaints however, the thing I remember the most about MGS2 was the tanker section. It was probably the best part of the game and it's the prologue.
>>338081115
I think I agree with this, although I have a very difficult time judging the gameplay of MGS4. The only thing I remember from this game are eggs in a pan and NANOMACHINES.
I think I prefer the characters of MGS1 more than 3 but that could be the nostalgia talking.
>>338086147
>It's a neo-/v/ pretends MGS 4 was not an atrocity and way worse than any other Metal Gear game episode
Fucking newfags
>>338088634
>And I give it a prop because the story managed to give closure to the series
>lol it raped the series story but at least it finished it
Literally you
>>338091379
You say it as if I had in the first place, when it is in fact the third lowest. The story of V is just even more stupid than the one in 4, and you should simply admit that you've never played MG1.
3=1>4>2>portableops>gz>pw>>>>>>>>>>>>>V
>>338091283
Fook
Of .
4 fucking delivered on everything, had great closure, great gameplay, great final boss, great music.
>>338092739
>almost a movie length worth of the most blatant exposition crammed at the end of the game
>"great closure"
lmao
>>338093308
After Kojima made that Patriots clusterfuck in MGS2, I can't really blame him. The series should have ended in MGS2 as he wanted.
The story is really flawed, especially because of NANOMACHINES, but it had its moments.
And yes, by the time Big Boss had his last cigar and the real credits began to roll, I felt some pretty good closure.
>>338077989
>decent closure to the series.
This. They should've stopped with 4 instead of finishing with 5. Everyone met their peace in the end of 4.
>>338075104
official and best rating here, cannot be argued with:
3 > 2 > V(GZ>TPP) > MGR > PW > 1 > MG2 > 4 > MPO > MG1
