S M A S H
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /v/ - Video Games
You are currently reading a thread in /v/ - Video Games
WHICH SMASH IS BEST SMASH?
>strawpoll.me/10207036
>strawpoll.me/10207036
>strawpoll.me/10207036
>implying
Anyway, Melee is my favorite. Wish the newer ones used Melee's physics for a base and just built it around that. It isn't as if casuals disliked Melee or anything.
That said I enjoy dicking around with the new one, my main complaint is that most throws throw way too far and there can be matches where a whole lot of nothing happens. It's a drag, but chock full of fan service and fun so I can't really complain too much.
>>337548942
This may be the first non-shitposting SMASH post I have seen. You are right. Melee had great physics and mechanics, but the newest one has a great roster and great addition. Sm4ash+Melee would make the perfect smash game.
>>337548942You fall too fast in Melee.
>>337549068
>the newest one has a great roster
bump?
I'm genuinely curious about which Smash game I should dump all my time into.
Lads?
>>337549193
I like that though. I don't wanna be floating in the air for too long
>>337549068
Thanks anon. I'm a Meleefag and won't deny it, but I still just love Smash in general. I'll play any Smash Bros with anyone if they ask.
>>337549974
How do you feel about Project M? Feels like a superior Melee imo.
>>337550046
Oh, I really enjoy it. I like customizing the music too. My main issue is that I don't like Brawl's sound effects because they lack UMPF so to speak, so where I can I replace them with Melee's.
That said, its hard to find people to play PM with because they write it off purely because its unofficial. It's hard to say that its "superior" to Melee, but I genuinely enjoy that the bulk of the cast is more than playable compared to the official Smash games where you're gonna have a sad time if you pick Zelda.
>>337550519
>no map maker in Project M or Sm4sh
>>337549262
If you told 12 year old me that Pac Man, Mario, Sonic, Mega Man, and Ryu were all in the same game I'd flip shit
>>337551119
>he forgets Cloud
Yeah the roster for Smash 4 is better great. It's just missing Snake
>>337551119
>>337551268
fw there's absolutely no chance of cloud, ryu, or mega man coming back in smash 5
>>337551463
MegaMan seems like a realistic choice, but I really can't be sure if the other two come back. Square Enix and Nintendo have had a rocky relationship for a while but it might be getting better again so who knows?
Which game is best lads?
>>337552629
64 has the best stages, best roster, and best single player mode, so 64
>>337552665
>best roster
>no Bowser
If you got rid of Nigglypuff for him, then I'd agree with you.
But aren't you forgetting the most important thing? Gameplay? I mean, I love Sm64sh, but isn't it a little dated?
>>337552750
Not really, no.
>>337552665
this has to be bait... stages were expanded on only the good ones kept from 64
Brawl was shit but if you think that single player is better than SSE you're fucking delusional
>>337552665
>best stages
lol. Literally every stage (or a nearly identical version) shows up in future games aside from the retarded Saffron City stage.
The best.
>>337553385
Replace Ness with Marth and we're golden.
>>337553435
What about Mega Man or Sonic?
>>337552910
>>337552990
More =/= better. Every other Smash has a huge amount of just pure trash clogging things up.
>>337553465
We aint that far yet. I'm just saying Bowser and Marth would fit into the first Smash a lot better than Jigglypuff or Ness.
>>337553707
It is done.
>this will never exist
Why don't faggot indie devs make a more streamlined version of Sm64sh with Marth and Bowser rather than fucking cancer like Nu-Male RPG Cucktastica?
>>337554021
The unlockables were all to the side. Notice how Luigi is before Mario even though it defies debut order. Put Bowser at the top right, and have Yoshi next to him to keep the themed side-to-side thing. Marth and Captain Falcon are good where they're at though.
>>337554184
On second thought, maybe have Bowser in the bottom left, so all four Mario universe characters fit in a 2x2.
>>337548704
>best smash
Melee. It's literally the only game that's lasted for 15 years solely off of being just that good.
The poll should've been about your favorite Smash game, as "best" is indisputably Melee.
I like the newest one's roster but the game could still use a few tweaks here and there imo.
I don't exactly approve of the cheap tricks like water and wind pushing.
>>337554259
I wish my shoop skills were stronger, but until then this will have to do.
>>337554443
Shit that does look pretty good, character and organization-wise. Wish we had gotten this instead. Marth would have made for a better literally who than Ness.
>>337554790
Yeah, he fills the nip niche too since the only other anime character is Link, and be barely even fits.
I'm not sure about best. If I had to try to see it objectively, I'd say Melee since it has lasted for a very long time and would still be played even when the next Smash game replaces 4. That and the movement physics, mechanics, and options help it out.
I will say Project M is my favorite Smash since I like what it did with the characters and the changes they made to the items, the stages, and the new game modes they added. I know some people mention "jank" as a negative against it, but I really do like how it plays.
>>337554790
What other character other than Marth could reasonably fit into Original Smash?
>>337555076
jank?
>>337555112
Dark Pit
>>337555112
Maybe Pit as an obligatory retro rep. Dedede might edge in barely, but probably not enough to beat out the other options.
>>337555334
Probably would have Ganon over Dedede. But Pit? I don't think so.
Castlevania guy?
>>337555174
In some discussions about Project M, it's a reason I usually see people use or bring up as a flaw. To be more specific, they simply say the game mechanics and characters are jank or feel jank. Even when I ask them to be more specific, they just repeat what they said previously. I assume they just mean that the game plays awkwardly for them, but they don't really give any examples of it in action.
>>337555729
Like, rough around the edges?
>>337555479
Castlevania's third party, which should really not be a factor when figuring out who deserves most to be "the main twelve". Ganon would be a maybe though. It might have been too soon after OoT to have gotten Ganondorf just yet.
>>337556052
What about Diddy or something?
>>337555880
For the most part, yeah, and I can see where they are coming from with the argument, but to me, it just plays like how you would expect any Smash game to play. It could just be a matter of not being familiar with the character since they do play differently from Brawl and such, but I'm not holding that against them.
The only character at the time I could fully agree with being jank was Ice Climbers and that was because they were non-functional and bugged at the time. At random times, Popo and Nana would glitch into each other and would stay like that for the rest of the game, even after death.
>>337556280
Possibly. Though judging from past interviews, it seems the characters who were most viable for getting into Smash 64 but didn't were Bowser, Marth, Pit, and Mewtwo. I'd say that's about as good as it might get for other options.
>>337556287
Gotcha.
I only just got it. I think V.6 or something, but I like it a lot. I just wish there was stage builder. I fucking loved my stages on Brawl, but with the memory SD shit and how you have to play PM, you obviously can't use stages.
>>337556378
What about Meowth, he was one too IIRC?
>>337556385
Yeah, latest build is 3.6.
Also, not saying you have to, but if you have a softmodded Wii or softmodded Wii U in Wii mode, you can get around the SD card method by using the Project M homebrew files to launch it or use a CD or .iso file to launch it as well. Using either method, you will still be able to get into Project M and use your own custom stages too.
>>337556447
Maybe, but I think Mewtwo would out-prioritize him. This is all considering the thought that the unlockables aren't mishmash clones with some half work done to make them look more unique, as this is the only reason Jigglypuff got picked in the first place.
>>337556703
Oh wow, thanks mate.
>>337556731
>this is the only reason Jigglypuff got picked in the first place
>>337556849
Want another funny thing?Goldeen has the same Japanese VA as Pikachu, so that's probably why Magikarp wasn't the useless Splash user.
>>337557089
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>337557216Captain Falcon shares animations with Samus.
>>337553385
>>337554021
>>337554443
>removing Clefairy and Ninten
Nah, niggas, nah
>>337557304
>Clefairy
>>337557304
You're still missing Marth. Like it or not, he deserves to be in there.
>>337557262
haha alright you got me
>>337557467
Not really. He fits better in Melee.
>>337548704
>smash thread
>Posts overwatch character
>>337557621
How do Ness and Jigglypuff outprioritize Marth for a Nintendo All Stars game?
>>337557850
They're from vastly better games.
>>337557905
You can make an argument about Pokemon, but don't try to tell me Earthbound was really anything stellar.
>>337557905
>>337558082
The very first Pokemon games were innovative, but every game after them has just been a graphical update and bad gimmicks that barely affect the actual battles at all.
tl;dr Pokemon sucks
Earthbound wasn't anything great either.
That being said, remove Shitpuff and Ness and add Bowser and I guess Marth.
>>337557663
>here's some T H I C C now give me some (You)s
I didn't even know what it was from, but my dick told me to save it.
Overwatch is for fucking faggots though.
>>337558082
It is.
>>337558878
It's not. I fell for this meme back in the day and heartily regret it.
