The great debate
Joseph Anderson
>>335830989
Bunnyhop likes Fallout 4
he's compromised
They are [spoilers] good [/spoilers]
both are boring autists with nothing insightful to say
Thread should have ended at the filename.
>>335832621
well i fucked that up
Matthewmatosis is great if you like in depth analysis on game design, mechanics, gameplay, level design, etc.
Super Bunnyhop is great if you like in depth analysis on business, history, background info, etc.
The correct answer is both because they compliment each other.
>>335833095
The correct answer is that they're both niggers.
>>335833095
Can't you just come up with your own in depth analysis?
>>335830989
If I had to choose I pick George.
I don't like bunnyhop, he always sound so condecending.
>someone who makes videos vs someone who doesnt
hmm i wonder
Go fuckyourselfes with your e-celeb discussions
I watch both but still fuck you.
The correct answer is that e-celeb cancer is not video games.
>>335830989
Both are great channels, their content is pretty different though but overall the quality is pretty high for a youtube gaming channel. But they're shit because cuck e-celeb something something
Mathew is pretentious crap
>>335830989
Matt, SBH is fucking retarded sometimes, while he can articulate his opinions better Matt has a knowleadge that only knowing how games work internally can give you when you talk about technical stuff, SBH sounds like an English major that talks out of his ass when he wants to discuss game mechanics.
>>335830989
pretentious autists
>>335833942
How? I am not a programmer what should I know the technicalities of how to make videogames?
>>335832583
This. I thought I was the only one who knew about the guy.
His videos are comfy as fuck.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyhnYIvIKK_--PiJXCMKxQQ here is his channel
>>335836404
Is this that "what do they eat" autist?
>>335830989
There is no debate, except that perhaps Bunnyhop has done better content on the MGS series.
Matt is in a league all his own
>>335836524
The only thing that SBH did better than Matt on MGS was releasing a fucking video about MGS V. I know that Matt takes longer to digest his ideas and to form something to say but now that he isn't working MAYBE he should focus a little more on making videos, he should remember the words that most "artist" have to face sooner or later "real artist" ship material.
>>335830989
LGR
>>335836494
nah thats mrbtngue this dude is an author who makes analysis videos most of which are Darksouls related
Mathew is my husbando
>>335832619
not really. did you even watch his review?
>>335830989
Splendid. The analysis and critique of games from non-developers.
>>335836845
Yeah it'd be nice to see some new content soon, since he went full Patreon queen months ago.
After watching George's video on the Witness, I realized he's most likely legitimately mentally retarded
>>335833095
The word is "complement" you complete fucking pleb.
Bunnyhop's voice is more annoying. Matthew's accent is goofy but acceptable.
I prefer Matt's videos
I prefer Bunnyhop's output
Seriously Matt what's going on. SBH releases a 10+ minute video every week. Next MM video better be hours long like the DaS one.
>>335836890
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""author""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
>>335830989
I've got a 100 dollars I'm gonna donate to a patreon of one or the other.
Which one should I pick or should I divide between the two and how much? Convince me. Who is the better video game scholar?
>no one knows about lorerunner
>no youtuber in history can top the insane level of analysis at 9:13 https://youtu.be/OGOhSpihpdgthis video is part 1 of 17
I like matthewmatosis' reviews more but I like bunnyhop's videos about more general things (like bots, or trends in games, or just sonic levels) more than matt's reviews
>>335830989
When the fuck is Matmo going to put out new videos?
That's his only real problem.
>>335837265
>Next MM video better be hours long like the DaS one.
Please for the love of god no
I literally fell asleep for that video
>>335837372
Don't donate it to patreon. Donating to patreon isn't a foregone conclusion, even if you imply it is.
>>335837439
>When the fuck is Matmo going to put out new videos?
In March
>>335837394
Jesus christ, has he only analyzed dogshit games?
>>335837632
Of 2017?
>>335837372
give $50 to both instead
All I know on the left is that he shills his channel here, so Super Bunnyhop wins by default.
>>335837728
His "rumination" series is overviews of everything from FF games, to MGS, to Zelda, to more recent stuff like Farcry 3 or the AC series. He generally covers what people ask him to because he has so few subs.
>>335837632
Remember when he was acting like there would be a surge of content now that this is his full-time job?
>>335837394
Why does he have a mic stuck down his throat? I'd prefer it if a bald man didn't whisper into my ear for hours at a time.Unless it's eggscum.
SBH is more entertaining to watch but Matt is more thorough.
>>335837928
Nah I'd rather see gameplay than this neckbeard's face
>>335836845
>>335837112
didn't he already decide to make videos full time?
>>335832583
JHudson had a better bloodborne analysis.
>>335838047
He did.
Is Matthew even alive?
>>335837937
At work he wore Hawaiian shirts
Now that he's home we walks around naked and only speaks in grunts and howls
Beware the feral irishman
>>335838041
Then maybe go back to let's play scum, and get out of a thread about youtubers who do in depth analyses
>>335837959
I dunno, I've never been bothered by his voice at all.
>>335838201
He's taking his time, according to his Twitter.
>>335838287
>I dunno, I've never been bothered by his voice at all.
His voice is fine. It's his mic placement.
>>335832619
He shit all over it bruh
>>335838176
well shit
actually, considering how long it takes him to make videos, how much time would you guys be willing to wait in between vids from him?
Personally, I think he could go for once a month, the mario reviews were almost all once a month even, though to be fair it's all one "series" so maybe once every 2 months would be more manageable for him?
>>335838379
Even that hasn't bothered me, not sure if its the same for the rest of his videos.
>>335832818
highlight text in quick reply
CTRL + Syou're welcome
>>335838360
I wonder if he feels pressured to put out better content now that he's doing this full time.
Which is understandable but still if this is basically his new job i dont know how he's supposed to manage with just one video a year. Or in the case of when he starts a series, one every other month.
>>335833095
>in depth analysis
i hate this fucking place
when will millenials die off
>>335838461
I've never understood the whole idea of wanting a set schedule of video release.
I think Matt (or anyone else) should simply take as much time as he needs to make the best content he can.
I guess I'm not super involved in Youtube, but I'm not actively waiting for a new video. It's just that, one day it'll pop up in my subscription list and it'll be a nice surprice. I can entertain myself in the meantime.
Dark Souls 3 video when Matt?
Come on nigga
>>335838558
What's up your ass? It's fun listening to people explain things about vidya. What's bad about that?
>>335830989
Bunnyhop is a bit more pessimistic, you can tell he's lost a bit of hope in vidya as of late. Matt would be better if he had some kind of schedule but I guess he just likes to take his time
analysis of art rubs me the wrong way a lot of the time. subjectivity is never emphasised. the language used is always assuming your position: i.e. "_you_ feel this way when x happens". i hate that rhetoric. the other part that rusttles me is the way inductive logic is treated deductively, as though their conclusions are solid, undeniable and not just some decent conjecture. objective value is an oxymoron.
What about Errant Signal?
>>335838775
He said he won't play it until they release the Super Turbo HD Remix Ultra Version
>>335838775
After the Bloodborne one.
>>335838953
>>335838979
>>335838935
>Cuckant Signal
No. He's complete shit and just throws the word cognitive dissonance around as if it means something.
>>335835337
clearly turks arewhiteright guys
>>335838935
>Barbarian tribes never existed.
>ecelebshit threads aren't even being deleted anymore
good job janitors
>>335838935
Isn't he SJW™?
>>335838901
Really? It's just more strong sounding when you say it that way. I don't get why people need to acknowledge art is subjective when talking about it. It's obvious that it is just their opinion because they are talking about art which everyone knows is subjective. It seems like a waste of time to mention this everytime and would come off as condescending.
>>335838935
he's not that bad, I came to like him through Shamus Young's blog, but he often falls into >>335839049
>>335830989
MattVisual is better
>>335832583
T H I S
i thought i was the only one who knew about him
his videos are like matthewmatosis but with a more personal touch and i really like that
>>335839110
Why don't you do you part start reporting shit then?
>>335838478thank you
>>335838935
>cuckster
>>335839125
very much so. he has a disdain for """"reactionary, entitled gamers"""" and automatically loves every single walking simulator he comes across
weedman has a background in business and journalism so his channel is great for that kind of thing, but matt knows way more about video games and in my opinion is more entertaining
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AK3n-srj5E
This guy has made 3 part hour long videos analyzing sonic games
>>335832583
I like him a lot but it kind of bothers me that he thinks the people behind the Souls games didn't care about the world building. It's fine if he doesn't care about the lore, and I get that people go way overboard with analysis, but I don't see how you can play a game like Bloodborne or Demons' Souls and not find coherency in what little plot is fed to you. Coming across Upper Cathedral Ward is chilling if you pay attention to shit.
Who cares, post some good small time channels.
NitroRad and Pgunnii are really great.
I'm waiting for the day I see George walking around Atlanta so I canfanboy over him and ask him what classes he took at school
Antisocialfatman.Feels like yesterday when I was recommending him around here.
Matthew isn't a fuckboy trying too hard to be RLM, so he wins.
>>335839783
Ross's Dungeon
>>335832621Ctrl+s
>>335838160
I can't find this channel. It's kind of a common name.
>>335839783
Chiliconcomrades has this interesting SA-like quality to their LPs, though they appear to be a bunch of furfags whose power level isn't quite clear.
>>335840194
his videos are pretty comfy
would recommend/10
>>335839889
>Literally dead for 4 years
Who cares?
>>335832583
He's solid. Plus he knows Bloodborne is top shelf.
>>335830989
Bunnyhop cause he makes videos.
The problem with videogame analysis on YouTube is that it's not actual academic analysis. It's structured properly and is conducted as an argument properly, but unlike in academia, art, music, or even gastronomy, there is no dialogue. There is no colloquium. It's just a podium and an opinion is offered and the listener can just agree or disagree and move on. This isn't a problem itself, the problem lies in the people that will repeat and mold their opinion based off something that is misinformed, shortsighted, or just plain wrong.
You could also say that videogames outside of indies are unsuitable for an artistic or similarly focused critique simply because of the medium. You can analyze parts, but the whole is a lot less cohesive than say a dish from the Pavilion or a Monet or a Bach. You end up analyzing it as a mechanic does a car - well this worked and this didn't. There's very little depth in an argument about the choice of a sportscar to include a spoiler or what inch rims they have. Similar in games outside of a few exceptional ones, a design decision isn't often an artistic choice.
I don't watch too much Super Bunnyhop but I remember him taking a historical and technical approach with his analysis - and that seems to be a better choice than anything artistic or literary.
The only video of Bunnyhop was one in which he called Pillows of Eternity a "Masterpiece".
>>335837394
His videos are great, but the games he covers are mostly shit. Barely any video of his have an interesting game subject.
>>335839783
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=glsc2hbmF_U
I never thought a channel trailer would become one of my favorite videos of Nitro's
not even a question
bhop all the way
>>335830989
>both have literally no credentials
>a debate
The thread should have ended at the filename.
>matthew quit to yt full time
>still takes an assload of time to even consider announcing a new video
>>335840393
That's why I see these videos as over glorified reviews instead.
>>335837394
>the wind signifies change XD!
That's pretty basic criticism, senpai.
Best vidya YouTube channels (Not including "Let's Players)
>Super Bunnyhop
>Matthewmatosis
>LGR
>Accursed Farms
>MechaGamezilla
>Ahoy
>Noah Caldwell-Gervais
>Classic Game Room
>>335840393
The problem is that most people's idea of criticism is just nitpicking. Youtube amplifies the worst aspects of this.
>>335840393
>The problem with videogame analysis on YouTube is that it's not actual academic analysis.
That's why I like it. In my experience academic analysis is pretentious and often times just trying to push an agenda politically. I would much rather hear just some guy talk about his views on shit and maybe he uses knowledge he learned from school, maybe not.
>>335840939
>LGR
>Ahoy
>CGR
>Mecha
I appreciate you.
>>335830989
Matthewmatosis wins on overall quality.
Bunnyhop wins on quantity
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__q_Nx9WbgY
this faggot analyzes the drakengard series and other games like dino crisis
>>335841028
>push an agenda politically
Push a political agenda is what I meant to say.
>>335841028
>In my experience academic analysis is pretentious and often times just trying to push an agenda politically.
What field(s) did those analyses concern?
>>335830989
>Who? or Who?
VIDEO GAMEEESSSSSSS
>>335840939
>MechaGamezilla
The absolute best. His Yakuza video might be my favorite Youtube video I've ever seen.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ObLoGm2BWs
>>335841143
Video games actually. I was looking through my college database on supposed academic journals about video games and violence and most of them were clearly pushing an agenda and ignored flaws in their studies. I've seen other situations too but I can't think of exact examples.
![mqdefault[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/2E6P4P4.jpg "mqdefault[1].jpg")
DUDE
DMC
LMAOhurry up with your new video you fuck. and talk about other games
>>335841014
The problem is that most fanboys' idea of criticism of criticism is just calling it nitpicking. The internet amplifies the worst aspects of this.
>nobody mentions my boy HyperBitHero
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IK7SeYf8zxs
>>335841474
rustled
>>335841540
>shit I got called out!
>>335841519
Oh shit, I forgot about him. He's great.
>>335841189
>my factory-sealed copy of Ghost Trick had a pube inside the box
>>335836101
>How? I am not a programmer what should I know the technicalities of how to make videogames?
Neither of the two people in the OP are programmers nor qualified either.
>>335841309
>another cynical marble mouth britbong video game reviewer
how original
>>335841280
>were clearly pushing an agenda
Fundamentally, that's what an analysis is. It's an argument. It's a statement X because of reasons: A, B, C and i'll pop u in da mouf if u disagree m8.
In fact, with literary analysis, that's the entire point. You analyze using lenses like socialist, feminist, historical, etc. A writer isn't saying Mark Twain was a goddamn commie. They're saying Huckleberry represents X quality of Communism as can be seen by Y reference from the Communist Manifesto.
It's not trying to put words in the creator's mouth. It's using the art piece as a platform for a larger idea.
That's not the only way to conduct an analysis, and I'm not saying whatever analyses you were thinking of were good or anything, I just wanted to explain why it comes off as pretentious. Because that's pretty much what analysis is. You gotta go deep up your butt.
>>335841648
>called out
Reddit's over there.
Let's see
>matthew
>uploads maybe three times a year
>has a patreon where get nearly $1k per month
>bunnyhop
>uploads once a week
>doesn't have a patreon
Obvious answer is obvious
>>335841189
>>335841690
I don't get it
>>335841813
Actually the main reason I find it pretentious is because many of them are very verbose and seem like they are trying to sound smarter than they are. Also by agenda I meant politically. I am fine with someone having an argument in their video, even beyond this game is good or bad, but I don't want to hear bullshit about how it's a eco-feminist socialist blah blah blah. That's why I prefer hearing just some guy talk about his views because typically it won't be to push something political. Academics seem to be obsessed with politics as if something isn't worth talking about unless it relates to politics. Maybe not all Academics are like this but from my experience they are not very common.
>>335841957
quality over quantity kid
>>335842326
Juxtaposition is the joke
>>335839076
Baba is the savior of the white race.
>>335840393
>It's just a podium and an opinion is offered and the listener can just agree or disagree and move on
That's the same for pretty much any review based video series. They're offering their own view on a subject, which is what any review comes down to.
>>335838240
Where did he work?
>>335842621
explain like I'm five please
>>335842450
No, a balance of the two is always the best when it comes to things like entertainment on youtube
>>335840194
I don't think I've heard of a single game he's reviewed
>>335830989
Bunnyhop keep saying Lovecraftian a lot, which bothers me.
>>335841701
matthewmatosis is a software dev if i remember correctly
>>335837394
Pretty good analysis but his taste is too basic for me.
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
GET OUT GET OUT GET OUT
THIS IS NOT VIDEO GAMES
STOP MAKING FUCKING THREADS ABOUT E-CELEBS, WHO CARES ABOUT HUMAN BEINGS THIS IS A BOARD WHERE YOU TALK ABOUT FUCKING VIDEO GAMES.
WHY WONT THEY BAN E-CELEB THREADS ALREADY
>>335830989
matthewmatosis or death
>>335841701
Matt was a programmer before quitting to do videos full time
>>335842326
I unironically don't get it either. Is it just him being random?
>>335838935
>LUDONARRATIVE DISSONANCE
Nah, I've had enough english majors screaming bullshit into my ear.
Potato nigger's videos are always the same
>state the obvious
>complain about personal opinion shit "FEELS bad/good"
>drone on for ridiculous amounts of time repeating the same points
>rinse and repeat releasing one video every 9 months, like a shit baby
I wish /v/ would stop bitching about muh e-celeb boogeyman
These threads are more civilized and productive than the countless console war threads
>>335843258
>productive
nah nigga, nah
>>335843239
I'm sure if you repeat your opinion enough /v/ will come around to it. /v/ is contrarian like that.
see: undertale, halo, dark souls
>>335842764
Not sure where but he was a programmer (apparently his work used a lot of Python programming)
>>335830989
SBH solely because he releases videos. Quality-wise Mathew's better though.
>>335838935
Hit-or-miss
>>335843239
Who is potatonigger? I've never heard of him.
>>335842941
>aha! instead of reporting the thread, i'll get myself reported, that'll show them!
wow great work
>>335843258
>civilized and productive
Wrong, also if it were true does that even matter? When porn is discussed on /v/ its more "civilized and productive", it doesn't mean it fucking belongs on /v/
>>335842810
>Expect a review of Yakuza
>Get a depressing story that gets more and more absurd and depressing
>Yakuza gameplay footage reflects this going from rainy scenes and drinking to combat and crane games
>Non sequitur to basic Yakuza information
>>335841309
Only talks about DMC but his non-DMC shit is bretty gud actually.
>>335843363
Yah nigga, yah
>>335843239
>complain about personal opinion shit "FEELS bad/good"
What's with this meme? He almost never says that, most of it is him talking about what certain design decisions do for the game, why they are there and how they could be improved.
>>335843501
Matt is an irish redhead.
>>335837632
Is MM the Nintendo of content creators?
>>335843541
How do video game reviews not belong?
It's because it has to do with talking about video games? I guess that is pretty odd for this place.
>>335843787
is he cute
>>335843787
does he have freckles and a cute butt too
I wish there were more videos like the Devs Play with John Romero. That shit's great and none of the other Devs Play videos lived up to it, which is a shame because as cool as the John Romero one was, he's already talked about Doom so much that it lost its novelty. It's always nice to hear designers talk indepth about how they made their games and why certain choices were made, though.
>>335839783
clemps has some g
>>335840194
Excellent taste, his videos are comfy and informative. That and he covers games I mostly haven't heard of.
>>335844327
For (you)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VgtAXCaSlpk
>>335844726
>fill out captcha beforehand
>press space and it posts the post before i finish
anyway hes got some good shit on drakengard if you wanna get into the series
>>335830989
Which one is more autistic? Matthew of course.
On the subject of comfy fun videos where people talk about vidya, does anybody else watch Easy Allies? I'm really worried because their videos only get a couple thousands views each. I really hope they don't stop.
https://youtu.be/dCNnzEWy-1w?t=24m13s
I love their podcasts and stuff, but my favorite video series of theirs so far is Brandon Plays Pokemon. The dude has literally never touched a Pokemon game before. His only knowledge is random stuff he's learned through osmosis like what a Pikachu or Charizard is. But everything else- like, he literally didn't even know what a Gym Leader was called. He's trying to catch all the pokemon because it's fun to him. He's nicknaming all of his Pokemon (E.G. his Jigglypuff is called 'gonyny", like a parent telling their child to go to sleep). He thinks the fossil he got was for Onyx. He naturally taught himself about switching pokemon out to level them both up. He's reading all the pokedex entries because he genuinely wants to know what's going on in this world.
The video timecode above is him losing his shit about each Pokemon having their own sound effect- something incidental to you or me, but he loves it. The second episode also has him freaking out about how cool Paras being the fungus is, which is another good highlight.
>>335837347
The only real criteria to be an author is to write, and then sell your writing.
He does that.
I do not know if its any good, but he is an author.
>>335837394
I've been looking for new long ass video essay channels, thanks man.
I stooped low enough to listen to a multi-hour three part series on the Sonic games.
I don't even fucking like Sonic.
>>335845107
Look up that
"""""""""""""""""""book"""""""""""""""""""
he's written and say that again.
>>335845249
Looks like your time is valueless
>>335837347
>>335845274
>>>/reddit/
>>335845367
Or maybe he listens to stuff while drawing/sleeping/etc, retard.
>>335844979
They literally just started a month ago and they already have 30k subs and get 3k per month on patreon. Give them time to grow. I like their tabletop show and their reviews, but I haven't really given much attention to anything else since those videos don't interest me
>>335845458
>Not liking bargain bin fantasy schlock makes you reddit
>>335845489
>sleeping
Jesus christ, it's like brainwashing yourself with hipster opinions
Bunnyhop is better. Matt is a little to... eh. foreign.
Both should be watched though. No real debate.
>>335845367
>go for a walk
>turn on the video in the background and listen
Yeah, wow.
>>335845565
spamming quotation marks makes you reddit, fucking newfag
Bunnyhop actually uploads semi-often.
>>335845694
>>335845489
You missed the fact that he already went through so many of these types of videos that he's desperate for more, despite the poor quality.
>>335839630
I watched that, don't really like the Sonic games, but I watched it.
It's pretty interesting stuff, and its funny to watch it after Weedmans 40min video on Sonic.
>>335841701
Matt IS a programmer, that is why I don't give a shit about SBH but I actually care about Matt's opinion, his opinion comes from a point of knowleadge, he understand what is he talking about when he talks about game design and the like.
>>335845790
So? I have the same problem where I'm constantly looking for new decent podcasts to listen to even though I only listen to that shit when taking walks or programming.
>>335845876
He botched an explanation about RAM and one other thing in the DaS commentary
>>335840521
>that copy of LSD
>>335830989
Bunnyhop is much more professional and knows how to present himself and his arguments, if not in an objective way, then in a non-confrontational one.
Like, there are a lot of his opinions I disagree with, but his professionalism is such that I don't hold it against him at all. This is the guy who likes gone homo, and yet generally has a positive image on /v/.
Whereas Matthew can't resist making petty shots and thinks that being verbose is being articulate.
Fromsoftware has been making "open-world" games since King's Field, god damn it's not that impressive.
>>335838752
Oh absolutely. I'm happy any time he creates a new video, and although I wish I could see more, I'm completely fine because I know that he takes his time so that he can create the videos he wants to create.
That said, I do think there is power in consistency, and not just for the audience. I don't know what Matt's process is, so I can't really say anything about it, but I think having deadlines could potentially push him to really get a handle of what his own process is. This way, he can make the videos he wants to make more effectively. I want him to take his time, but I want him to push his own process so he can more effectively make videos.
All that said, I think schedules can be tough to get into, and if anything I would never want him to rush any of his works.
>>335845876
>his opinion comes from a point of knowleadge
This better be bait, he has such a limited knowledge of the technical aspects of games it's laughable.
You could become more informed than him by simply reading a few wiki pages.
>>335840521
>>335839783
Thanks for bringing up NitroRad, I watched his Silent Hill videos awhile ago, liked them, but never subscribed.
I then promptly forgot about him.
But now I can fix that.
>>335845682
Matthew's voice is one of the best things about the videos though. Being foreign isnt a bad thing.
>>335846213
King's Field's openness wasn't nearly as impressive though. The amount of sequence breaking you can do in the beginning of Dark Souls 1 is genuinely impressive and not something you'll see in any other games of that type.
>liking retarded e-celebs
the best answer is to fuck off
>>335841102
Clemps is super gay, but pretty good. I think he is starting Nier soon, which should be fun.
It's not a debate
Matthew has a better accent, puts out longer, more thoughtful videos with more focused things to say
SBH is a fuckwit who puts out whatever is likely to get him traffic
>>335846109
I could do the same if you ask me to explain you how the weight distribution of an structure works, I know how and why it works the way it does but I study to understand it not to explain it.
I am more interested in the opinions he is able to form thanks to his knowleadge.
>>335846420
Sequence breaking that came back to bite them in the arse with twinks turning the undead burg into a meat blender.
>>335830989
Joseph Anderson, except that his Dragon's Dogma vid was wrong in places. The series strengths and sequel changes video for Bloodborne was great though, really interesting analysis of how the healing system works and effects each game in the soulsborne series. Game Maker's Toolkit and Turbo Button are also good
>>335846545
More than worth it since you can just avoid all of that shit by staying hollow. The online functions felt poorly thought out in general but the world design of the early areas really IS quite impressive.
>>335846521
I meant that he literally did not understand how those things work
>>335846248
He demonstrated quite a bit of in depth knowledge in his DS1 video when he hit Blighttown.
Not even sure if it was all right it was such techno babble to me.
>>335846919
>"I think colour-correction is cheating"
Shut uuuuup
>>335846710
Ohh then maybe I judge him wrongly, how badly did he fuck it up?
>>335847020
>I'm going to be glib
No youuuuuu
>>335830989
the obvious answer
>>335837394
Is it good or is it diarrhea of the month?
>>335847090
Loving
Ever
Laugh
>>335847090
remove audio filter
>>335847090
Christ, man, don't post pictures, you'll use up what internet we have left.
anybody watch Saint?
>>335845367
I will not argue this, but as >>335845489
>>335845694 say I mostly listen to long-form videos while doing something else.
Most of the time its while playing a game, sometimes for homework.
It would be hard to sit and watch some 4 hours long without anything else to do.
this guy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPqwDGXxLhU
ClementJ64's series on Sonic 06 is the greatest game review on Youtube.
>>335832583
I don't play Dark Souls.
>>335830989
I really like Matt, he seems the type of person who could probably make his own game if he tried enough.
Super Bunnyhop is good, but he can come off as a bit pretentious on some occasions and over analyzing things that are just blatantly obvious.
>>335832583
I like his style of videos but I tend to not like the games he likes at all, besides Souls and Bloodborne. Fucking Tomb Raider remakes, really?
>>335847090
Don't even joke about that.
I want matthew's videos to have time stamps, sometimes its a little annoying to have to skip around a whole video to try to find some specific points.
>>335847090design club is actually kinda good. Too bad there's only 6.
>>335847481
>but he can come off as a bit pretentious on some occasions and over analyzing things that are just blatantly obvious.
His Sonic video was spot-on though. Not that it's hard to critique Sonic as a series anymore, but still, gotta praise something done well.
>>335847809
He was much more lenient than I think anyone expected him to be.
>>335846601
When his DS2 series came out I ignored it, but after watching it he did a good job improving my thoughts on the game.
I still think its the worst souls game, but the series is such high quality that isn't really a bad thing.
Matt's videos are nicely put together and relaxing to watch.
People get hung up on the semantics of what a "review" should and shouldn't contain.
It would be better if he labeled his videos "thoughts on..."
I like SBH's videos and style.
And I give the guy big respect that he doesn't seem to care about making mouthbreathers analpained by talking about games like gone home.
It's refreshing to see someone who's up to speed with the current goings on in the industry, but hasn't been sucked in by the kneejerk gg/sjw bullshit that is the biggest cancer in the community.
>>335845546
>3k per month
kreeek
>>335847941
It's like he's an actual journalist.
>>335847961
I wonder if he wants to provide and care for a slut
SBH has a higher proportions of videos that are good to MM. Chances are this is probably because SBH releases A LOT more videos period, but at the current moment there are definitely more moments proportionally of MM talking out of his ass than SBH does. Numerically though SBH definitely has more moments of talking out of his ass, but again, it may just be related to how much content he releases.
Not only that, MM loses extra points because people are patreoning this guy money and he hasn't done jack shit in a long time to show for it. If we can shit on bad Kickstarter people for doing similar stuff, or Anita, MM should be held to similar judgement for doing what at the moment seems to be just that.
So yeah. SBH I guess is better because of those reasons and also being a better communicator.
>>335842393
>>335841028
I do somewhat agree to this. Academic Analysis does have it's shitty moments, but I think that's kinda new. It's like how now that there are people in STEM that care more about money and fame/le epic discovery we are having an increasing number of bullshit submitted to even the more prestigious journals. The more different agendas start to come into play rather than just actual discussion of the subject, the more this will happen. That's why I feel that it's easier to find good analyses that are older because there was less shit to sift through. It's why for example one would also find great analyses of classical music but often find ignorant analyses of modern popular music, too.
>>335847941
>mouthbreathers analpained by talking about games like gone home
That's a lot of buzzwords you got there.
>>335841519
>>335841685
Glad you guys like my stuff. Hoping to get some sweet videos out more often.
Matt is good, I like his videos.
I like Bunnyhop's videos, too, and think they're an example of quality that EVERY games journalist should reach in their things. Though, bunnyhop has some downright shit opinions sometimes ("gone home is a good game", for example)
SBH is a balding faggot.
>>335848171
How hard is it to make a new bit and brit?
>>335847961
>38K per month
What the fuck does he make? Porn videos on request or what?I wonder if he is bi or whatever I would whore myself to be a trophy wife or maintained slut
>>335848196
It will happen to you.
>>335845876
if you're a non-games programmer it barely qualifies you to talk about even games programming, let alone game design
>>335848064
The only times I'd have to say Matt talks out of his ass in my opinion is during his Demon's Souls and Dark Souls commentaries, when he mostly tries to be on the game's side for being fair and tries to explain why the things are fair, but it clearly isn't fair in anyway.
But I do like how most of the time with that stuff he usually will just state that it's his opinion and it's debatable whether the thing was fair or not.
>>335848171
Would you fuck Charlie? Be honest.
>>335843239
>DaS2 fanbois STILL mad
>>335847961
They don't even have that high of a viewcount per video. How are they making this much?
>>335847257
nice vid saint
Is there anything worse than the faggots who come into these threads and fucking belch out "MUH E-CELEBS NOT VIDYA", bump the thread, and leave? How stupid are you faggots?
>>335848623
Most likely petty money some wealthy fan is giving them or some of their friends in the industry are backing them in the early months of their venture. Or maybe someone just trolling that will retire his pledge before he gets charged.
>>335848595
Dustforce had some of this, too where he was trying to dodge around his nitpicking nature cuz he just marked out hard for the game. Then there's the Bioshock Infinite "time travel plothole" which is explained away minutes before the scene with Elizabeth saying "constants and variables" 1000000 times to establish that the universe has these rules. A last minute asspull for sure, but still exists so that the plothole Matt brought up doesn't exist.
>>335848171
I slowly discovered the entire group of youtubers you associate with.
You should tell Vash to make some more long form videos. I don't really care for Ori, but his video on it was pretty great.
I find myself agreeing with George more than Matt.
