Well, /v/? Is it true?
>S: God Tier
>A: High Tier
>B: Above Average Tier
>C: Average Tier
>D: Below Average Tier
>E: Low Tier
>F: Shit Tier
S4 Ep2 in C
Bump up secret rings
Labyrinth in F
Dark Brotherhood in F
>secret rings that low
>dark brotherhood that high
Nah.
>>334755116
>Adventure 2 isn't at least A
I am of a differing opinion the likes of which i cannot carry unto a simple "yay" or "nay".
>>334755116
I wish you'd produced that graphic in a program that can apply anti-aliasing.
>>334755116
both adventures in D tier
Spinball up a tier
Sonic 2 in S tier, what the fuck are you doing putting it so low
3D blast in F tier
shadow in E tier
Sonic 4 in C tier
>>334755116
>Secret rings that low
>Black Knight not in A
>Chronicles that high
>Riders Zero G that low
>Episode 1 not in E
Someone didn't play past the first few missions in Black Knight (or with a controller)
Secret Rings should be in C
While the game suffered from forced motion controls, the gameplay and story were very solid.
other than that, list looks okay...
>>334755116
>Advance 1 in S rank
>All those enemy and spike placements, especially in Zone 5 and 6
Put it in B. I haven't played the other Advance games in a while, but I'm not sure about Advance 3 being that high.
Move Sonic and the Black Knight up a tier
Move Adventure in with Adventure 2
I haven't played anything other than the demo, but add Shattered Crystal somewhere
This list just reminds me that I've only played about 20 Sonic games
>Sonic Colors in S
>Higher than SA, SA2, Heroes
I don't get it
>No one complaining about S3&K and Generation's placement
>>334758351
Come on, you dont think /v/ would be THAT contrarian do you?
>>334758472
It's neo /v/. All I expect anymore are shit posts.
>Sonic Adventure that low
>below Sonic Heroes
Play the international version on the Dreamcast guys, it has less bugs than the GC.
Also, I doubt anyone here actually played some of these games (like SegaSonic) so we probably shouldn't put them on the list out of fairness.
>>334758351
I don't really care about those rankings.
We all have our ideas about these games.
In my case, I really don't understand why Colors is so high.
>>334755116
Sonic adventure 1 and 2 should be F tier
And sonic 2 should be S
I can't be bothered to make an image like that but I'd say my favorite Sonic games are CD and Adventure. A few random notes:
>Colors and Generations are both good, but probably the most overrated 3D games
>Sonic the Fighters is underrated as fuck
>Sonic Heroes is trash and I'll never understand why so many people like it
>>334755116
In a rectangular selection, Sonic Advance to Sonic 4 Ep 2 go into B Rank.
>>334758992
>>334758351
S3K is amazing but either on their own isn't really worth being that high.
Generations' modern levels are great (except Planet Wisp) and outside of the final boss the boss fights are pretty great. But the classic levels are okay at best and the various missions are either boring or in the case of that music note one utter trash. and then there's that fucking final boss.
>Sonic as a series
>anything above B tier
lol
>>334755116
>Sonic Shuffle E
FUCK YOU
Secret Rings doesn't deserve to be that low, but I have no idea why the hell they thought it was a good idea to force players to unlock the proper controls
>>334759662
proper controls weren't until like half-way into the game
>>334755116
>sonic
>not on genesis
Why?
>>334755116
>Sonic Chronicles Dark Brotherhood not in F
Bad list
>>334755116
>Rush, Rush Adventure, Unleashed, and Lost World that low
>Sonic Chronicles that high
Everything else I agree with it's just seeing those good games down a tier is weird
>>334755116
>Black knight isn't at least B rank
>secret rings ain't at least E
>boom doesn't have its own category
>shadow isn't F
you didn't play it, did you?
>>334755116
Both Adventures need to be bumped up a rank or two. 3D Blast and Chronicles both need to be bumped down.
>>334755116
>Sonic Heroes
>B tier
kek
>>334759207
What exactly is there not to like? It's just a really fun, solid platformer. I will never understand complaints about glitches, I don't recall any during my playthroughs.
>>334755116
Put SA2 in A tier, and SA2 in B tier. Knock Chronicles down a few and you got the perfect list.
>>334760771
>It's just a really fun, solid platformer.
Did we play the same game? It was tedious as fuck. The first two stages were okay, the first far moreso, but after that it loses steam entirely and never recovers.
Adventure 2 is the only good one
>>334761142
Adventure 2 is just Adventure with prettier levels and none of the "this is kinda shitty but in an endearing way" charm
>Chronicles in C
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6o47N-aYd08
Just for this shit alone it deserves a spot in E.
In terms of OST (The ones I've played)
God tier: Sonic CD (JP and US), Generations, Sonic Adventure 2, Sonic Adventure 1, S3&K
High tier: Sonic Heroes, Sonic 06, Sonic R, Sonic 2
Okay tier: Sonic 1
Low tier: Most of the game gear games
Shit tier: Chronicles
>>334760046
Just compare it to the games actually in F. It's bad, but it's not Sonic 06 bad.
>>334761142
Adventure 2 is fucking awful, what is wrong with you?
>durr make all the speed levels uninteresting and railroaded
>durr neuter the emerald hunt missions into the most boring experiences this side of Shadow the Hedgehog
>durr take an already shaky and unnecessary shooting segment, make the controls and physics less agreeable, and cram two otherwise interesting characters into it
>inb4 muh nostalgia
>inb4 muh multiplayer
>inb4 muh story
>inb4 muh not as bad as later entries
SA2 apologists are the worst, fuck right off.
>>334762201
I know full well that SA2 is shit, but I love it anyway.
>>334756538
Black Knight was fucking awesome and I'm happy to see someone else share that opinion
Bumping with a template. Now you kids can make your own and rate each other's. There's an empty icon to use for any missing games, too. Have fun.
