I'd argue OFF.

>>334477242
Fez

>>334477242
a series I played once that contains a serial killer clown.

part 1 and 4 are no longer avaliable so no point mentioning it.

>>334477461
Should still tell us. Maybe someone has it on their harddrive or something?

>>334477282
Well then you'd be fucking retarded as the game isn't even remotely scary.
Very interesting game but there's nothing scary about it.

>>334479045
>Very interesting game but there's nothing scary about it.
are you fucking high, mate?
i haven't even played the thing and it looks fuckin spooky
>creepy cat companion
>some enemies are NPC characters forcefully mutilated into abominations, at least one screams for help while you kill it
>what happens when you "purify" a zone

Amnesia.

>>334477242
The Grifter

>>334479213
not him, but I played it and it's never scary. unsettling? yes. kind of fucked up? yes. but not scary

>>334479486
then what the fuck is "scary" anymore?
it shouldn't be the jack in the box type crap that's become horror film

>>334477242
Penumbra: Black Plague

Gone Home

Obscuritas.

>>334480769
This

>>334479603
It should make you feel scared.
OFF was eerie at times, but it didn't make me feel scared.

A mod rather than an indie, but Nightmare House 2/Underhell is rather spooky.

>>334477242
Amnesia the dark descent

Hipsters will argue penumbra is scarier and contrarians will argue amnesia is youtube bait but they both know they are wrong

Toy Maker