Which do you want more?
Mario 3D World 2.
Sunshine 2. I don't really get why people love Galaxy that much. Thought it was kinda boring.
are there enough graphics to do super mario 128
>>334410236
Sunshine
>>334410236
>>334410364
I'd honestly be happy with any of these.
As long as Luigi is playable straight from the start.
the galaxy series has more to offer, but i don't want either. i'd always like to see something new and different from nintendo.
>>334410364
This actually.
I think i enjoyed 3D world far more then I ever enjoyed galaxy or Sunshine.
Left
Sunshine.
>>334410527
holy fuck, i didn't know there were people on this board with such shit taste.
>>334410236
Sunshine 2
>>334410639
>calling other people's taste shit when you enjoyed sunshine
>>334410236
Both.
>>334410236
The sequel to the game that doesn't suck.
The obvious answer is Sunshine 2.
Galaxy 2 was already pretty much perfect, it did what it set out to do and did it expertly, there's not much to improve upon. Sunshine was great but had some kinks holding it back. It deserves a sequel to fix those few mistakes and expand on FLUDD and the tropical setting.
>>334410384
Galaxy 2 is the superior one anyway. Improved on its predescessor in every single way.
>>334410236
Super Mario 64 2
>>334411017
>Super Mario 64 2
Re-read your post and look at how stupid it looks.
I preferred Galaxy over Sunshine but we already got two Galaxy games and I can't see them adding much more without it just feeling like a glorified level pack. Sunshine has loads of room to improve and would feel much more like a breath of fresh air for the series.
>>334410747
Sunshine has the most creative world design in pretty much all of the 3d Marios. Anyone who didn't enjoy it is a contrarian. Especially those who prefer 3d World just because it has muh fun co-op.
>>334410236
Mario 65.
Sunshine 2. It's been a while since the first one.
Remember when Mario 64 DS was called Super Mario 64×4? Nintendo is weird.
>>334410364
This or Sunshine 2. Galaxy was alright.
I hated sunshine and I'm actually blown away by how many people loved it and want more of it.
Probably my least favorite of the main line mario games.Mario 2 / Lost Levelsis my favorite.
>>334410236
A new Mario game.
>>334410236
Something i can call the actual successor of Mario Galaxy in the main line games.
New super mario and 3d World do not count
>>334410236
3D World 2
>>334410236
Why not both?
>yfw using fludd to rocket through space, cleaning planets
I'd really like them to bring back the Cape Feather.
Neither
3D World did things right, and it was showing that you don't need to lock the entire game into 1 concept setting
Be more flexible
And the space mechanics has become garbage and an illusion to design
Sunshine 2 by a long shot.
>>334410364
i thought 3d world was the worst mainline mario game that i've ever played by a country mile.
I'll never get what people like about it.
I'd rather just have a completely new 3D mario game.
How about a fucking new idea?
>>334412957
>>334410364
>3D World 2
>mainline
3D World is the sequel to the handheld 3D Land, but for console.
Anyway, I'd rather see another Sunshine before another Galaxy, but I'd take a Galaxy 3 over another 3D Land/World game.
And I'm not bashing the 3D games, I like them, but I want another adventure game.
>>334412374
It had neat ideas but poor execution. A sequel that fixes the problems could be amazing.
>>334410236
Sunshine two for the movement mechanics.
Though honestly they'd probably just dumb it down, so maybe Galaxy 3. At least that way I wouldn't be let down by the focus on gimmicks.
As long as it features a season pass, a sandbox environment, preorder DLC, online PvP, and a more cinematic experience, it would be a day one purchase. My vote goes to Mario Souls.
>>334410236
neither, a Super Mario 65 would be nice thou
>>334410457
you'd need a lot more megabytes
In spite of loving SMG 1 and 2 it's been a while since we had a 3d Mario game with huge levels to explore like 64 and Sunshine
Insta-buy if they add a feather cap/red star like power-up
I would flip the fuck out if Sunshine 2 were announced. I don't know if modern Nintendo could do it justice, but I would still be excited.
Remember when sunshine came out and the general consensus was that it was SHIT?
>>334410236
Galaxy has achieved its goals in 2 games.
Sunshine still needs that second helping.
>>334414269
>Sunshine comes out and everyone says it's garbage
>Primary complaint is "it's different"
>Nintendo makes NSMB and it sells a million billion copies
>Everyone wonders why Nintendo doesn't experiment with Mario as much anymore
>>334414269
everyone I know liked it, the biggest complaint being that it was too hard
>>334410364
This so much. If I had to choose between OP's choices though, I'd definitely go for Galaxy 3. Sunshine was fucking garbage and Galaxy would benefit so much from HD graphics.
>>334411442
Of course, who could forget such wonderfully creative worlds such as:
>Village
>Beach
>Town
>Amusement Park
>Whatever the fuck that one place with the lava goo was
>Sea
>Volcano
Truly, they we're at their Renaissance when it came to world design.
>>334415053
Don't forget about how great the characters inhabiting that world were
>>334411442
I hate to disagree with you but other then the bonus levels and a few great ones here and there i felt that sunshine was more of a chore to play and toward the end i had little to no joy playing it.
3D world is just fun as fuck to play, easy as that.
>>334415053
You missed out harbour, hotel, cliffside, andbagatelle
Sunshine 2, because I love Galaxy but it already got 2 games and Sunshine deserves a second shot. It did some pretty neat stuff despite not being the most beloved of 3D Marios. Either way, I don't really need a Galaxy 3. Now if Nintendo wants to drop Super Mario Universe...I'm listening. Depends on what they do with it.
>>334415270
Oh, I also forgot singular poisonous river.
>>334415053
>>334415251
Seems like even with your attempt at boiling things down and trying to make them look bad you're still just punctuating how incredibly different Sunshine was from the other Marios.
>>334412830
Super Galaxy Sunshine
>>334415897
>>334415897
I'm not saying that the setting wasn't exactly bad. A resort island setting was interesting, I'd just hoped they were a little bit more creative with the settings.
>>334410236
Super Mario65
Neither
give us a full game of the FLUDD-less bonus levels
>>334415897
The character design is certainly different, but that doesn't mean its good at all. Almost every character and enemy in Sunshine looks like they came from some unlikable Canadian CG cartoon.
>>334416248
You already got that anon. It's called Super Mario 3D world :^)
>>334415685
It's a good thing that fucking river never appeared again
>>334414269
Super Mario Sunshine saved the Gamecube from being a complete failure, what are you talking about.
>>334410364
Die.
mario 64 2
go kill yourself if you want sunshine or galaxy instead
>>334416485
fuck you
>>334416737
But Sunshine is Mario 64 2
>>334416737
wouldn't that be mario 66?
>>334416737
Ow the edge
>>334410236
Sunshine 2
I love water/beach themed locations and the change from standard mario mechanics would be refreshing
>>334416150
I just don't see what makes it any less creative than, say, Mario 64.
What if we give Mario some shoes that make him real fast, and have him run through levels as fast as he can where he runs through loops and shit.
Then give Luigi some sort of flying device as he hovers behind Mario throughout the levels.
That way Luigi can pick up Mario and carry him over gaps and that.
>>334415053
>Noki bay
I could live in that place
>>334415053
Hotel resort was a level
>>334416468
Despite I loved Sunshine, wasn't Melee that did it?
3
>>334416851
its the mario 64 formula, with fludd, which changes the gameplay drastically.
and every level is the same tropical theme
i want a game that actually has different settings and no gimmicks
>platforming game
>you can hover all the obstacles pressing R
>nostalfags actually defend this
>>334417819
>platforming game
>using more than a 0.5x A presses
Casuals, I swear.
>>334417789
this right here
>>334410236
Sunshine.
It's my personal favorite due to nostalgia, it has more to be fixed/improved upon and could you image how good Isle Delfino or a similar location would look on the NX?
>>334410236
Sunshine had the best controls/physics in any 3d Mario game, I don't think they can pull off another game that's almost exclusively beach levels though. They need to do a different setting.
I just hope Nintendo's next 3D mario game game turns out better thanGalaxy 2
>>334418189
I like what are you saying.
Buuuuuuuuuuut.
Even though I like Sunshine, I would like more to see a Galaxy game, in the NX.
I would prefer any of them anyways v:
Metroid got damn it
>>334418585
Mario's movement/moveset/physics in 64 is fucking god tier and Galaxy feels like ass in comparison.
Sunshine feels good too although FLUDD unfortunately is used most of the time.
>>334419117
>Mario's movement/moveset/physics in 64 is fucking god tier
damn straight.
>>334418748
there's federation force, you can either enjoy it or stay mad for more years
Neither. Give me a good 2D Mario
>Rehashing the same level half a dozen times for missions because MUH EXPLORATION.
vs.
>Tiny-ass planetoids with gimmick suits and most of the time spent flying through sling stars i.e. doing fuck-all platforming.
3D World 2.
>>334419117
Sunshine was a step up from 64 imo. Mario felt much more responsive and in-control.
>>334410236
neither will come out you retard, this console was dead on arrival..at least post it with a nx coverart
>>334410364
This tbqh famboni.
>>334410482
samehere
>>334415053
I think Galaxy had better levels, my top 5 favorites were:
>Space
>Space
>Space
>Space
>Space
>>334419790
instead all the other marios have
>planet earth
>planet earth
>planet earth
>planet earth
>planet earth
>>334419949
>Mario 64
>planet earth
>not paintings
>>334410364
Yes please.
>>334419994
>enter painting
>still on planet earth
>>334415053
The sad thing is, it actually was a renaissance in world design for the Mario series. What did they have in every game before that?
>plains level
>underground level
>desert level
>lava level
>a few air fleet levels
>Bowser castle level
I don't even think they did snow levels until 64, unless if you want to count the pallette swap levels in SMB1
>>334420087
The paintings transfer you into a separate dimension and reality.
It's no longer planet earth.
>>334410948
This
>>334419459
>no dustless dives
>no speedkicks
>no frame/angle dependent wallkicks
>no longjump
>no feeling of momentum or weight
>sliding doesn't feel good or natural
>who the fuck thought fludd was a good idea
sunshine wasn't bad though. it's definitely the 2nd best 3d mario in terms of movement tech.
>>334410236
I honestly wouldn't mind either but would probably prefer Sunshine 2 followed by Galaxy 3.
>>334410236
Both games were fucking shit. Especially Sunshine and its boring ass level themes. Just give me Mario 64 2 with no added gimmicks.
>>334415685
Which area is this? I don't remember an area with this description.
How about a Sunshine game set in Galaxy with the FLUDD?
Throw in plenty of 3D World bonus levels.
There, everyone wins.
I just saved Nintendo.
>>334417376
Same. Beautiful place with soothing music.
>>334420251
sure anon, and Sans is Ness
>>334420493
the bonus stage you can get to if you ride the gondolas with yoshi.
>>334420540
No
>>334419117
This so much. I don't understand how people prefer Banjo Kazooie as a collectathon when Mario's movement is so fun to play around with.
>>334420657
Fine, make FLUDD optional, and an option for levels like Yoshi.
There, everyone wins again.
>>334410236
3D Mario is worse than AIDS.
>>334420103
There were snow levels in SMB3, Super Mario Wrold, and Yoshi's Island.
>>334411014
Except for story and atmosphere. Which the first did way better.
>>334420657
Oh right. I'm glad I had forgotten about it.
>>334416737
>comet within
oh fuck i just got reminded of this
>>334420794
>>334420794
It will still have the linear stars, rather than levels you can fully explore at once like SM64, which is why I always preferred BK to the 3-D Marios
>>334410236
Sunshine 2
Never liked mario galaxy
>>334421043
Fine, make the Galaxy levels more open world, like some of the Sunshine levels, so it's more like 64.
Less relying on linear levels, and open to exploration.
We keep FLUDD and Yoshi for levels, and let it play a mix of Sunshine/Galaxy.
Better?
>>334410236
Sunshine.
I want 3D full levels to roam around, not chunks of levels with hamfisted puzzles.
>>334412065
>64x4
>it isn't 64x4 resolution
Into the trash it goes.
>>334410236
A 3D Mario maker.
Gimme Galaxy 3.
>>334421664
Literally impossible. 3D platformers are not able to suit level editor-type games yet.
>>334414269
It's unfortunate that back then reviewers had the loudest voice
The fuckers killed Kirby Air Ride.
>do you want a rehash or a rehash?
>>334414269
They weren't wrong.
Sunshine 2 definitely, galaxy is too shallow
>>334410236
Galaxy 3 if Rosalina is the main character
Sunshine 2 otherwise
Galaxy 3 because that soundtrack
>>334410236
Galaxy 3. Sunshine was a disappointing experience after reading all the praise it gets around here.
>>334422691
>Listening to Cubebabbies
I love the Gamecube but the people who actually grew up on it are some of the most loathsome retards around
>>334410236
Between Galaxy 1 and 2 I had enough of the "space" aesthetic. Also the fucking black holes of death got annoying. At least with sunshine you only had to worry about instant death in a handful of stages.
>>334413378
3D World is mainline, though. It was in development before 3D Land.
>>334422637
This post made me wonder, how much does Galaxy remix its main theme compared to other Mario games? For example, compare SMW's main, underground and underwater themes, they're all basically the same song. Same with a bunch of SM64's songs, but I can't think of a single remix of Galaxy's original songs, other than the sound that plays when you get a Star
>>334423274
The Gusty garden is mixed into the purple coin theme and the main theme of Galaxy 2
A 2D Mario that isn't half-assed shit.
>>334410236
A good Paper Mario. Fuck you Miyamoto.
>>334423741
That's an oxy-moron
>>334424415
No it isn't, Nintendo just doesn't care about 2D Mario the way they should anymore.
>>334424558
Aside from World and Land 2, 2D Mario has never been remarkable and mainly benefited from standing over a still growing medium. 3D greatly helped the franchise which has since become much more fresh and varied since it came around
>>334424746
>Aside from World and Land 2, 2D Mario has never been remarkable
Stopped reading there.
>>334424834
Care to prove me wrong without overrating 3 more than Bob Chipman?
>>334424279
>Implying Miyamoto makes games
>>334421664
I want this.
>>334410236
Sunshine
It was just a fun weird game
I want a new Paper Mario game, we haven't had a new one sense Thousand Year Door.
>>334424882
If you don't understand how and why Super Mario Bros. was miles ahead of any video game released prior to it, you don't know shit about video games and have no business trying to state that World and Land 2 are the only Mario games to ever be remarkable. World is in fact the weakest link of the retro 2D Mario games.
Mario games were huge technological leaps with superb craftsmanship. Mario is no longer about that. 2D Mario gets farmed out to a team that doesn't give a single fuck about presentation or craftsmanship.
>>334425536
That's just it. The 2D Marios were simply miles ahead of a young and developing industry.
Compared to what's been accomplished since the N64 launched they've been surpassed several times both inside and outside of the series and don't impress much. Sorry you can't accept that.
>>334425493
>here's your paper mario bro
Galaxy 3 easily. And people seriously saying Mario 3D World 2 need to kill themselves.
That game was easy as fuck and the least like the other 3D mario games like Sunshine, Galaxy, and Mario 64 with all that fixed camera bullshit and terrible setting.
>>334425713
>The 2D Marios were simply miles ahead of a young and developing industry.
Which is what makes them so remarkable, you colossal retard. Saying they aren't remarkable because "LOL THE INDUSTRY WAS SHIT THEN" is fucking stupidity.
>>334426075
But when you make comments implying that we still need 2D Marios it forces me to bring up how they don't hold up by today's standards.
They were fun in the early 90s but that's where they need to stay. From the moment it launched 64 was the best Mario game in existence.
>>334410236
64 2 or Sunshine 2. I prefer the more open world levels and being able to grab whatever star I like in 64 but I like how Sunshine was actually has a story progression between Shine Sprites. Each Shine Sprite shows peace returning to the level, it might have been a small thing but that was pretty cool shit. Either way, just let Mario control the way he did in 64, like fuck, the new games aren't bad but I hate how he controls now, it's not as free and fast.
Super Mario Sunshine 2, if just only for the chance to right the wrong that was the original Super Mario Sunshine's sub-par adventure.
Also an actual full ocean/deep sea level would be nice.
>>334426025
>people seriously saying Mario 3D World 2 need to kill themselves
This
That game is such uninspired trash I can't even put it into words
Sunshine 2 with no fludd gimmick.
Or water stages.
Either one honestly. I fucking love 3D Mario games, I 100% them every time and it's a blast every time.
>>334421890
How so?
