For the people that played Persona, without using a walkthrough or having the game spoiled, at what point did you realize Naoto was a girl?
Was it obvious from the very beginning?
>>332768789
The game draws female and male bodies and faces differently. She had a female face and a petite (female) body, not to mention a female voice. It wasn't that it was obvious (but in retrospect it was), but more that it wasn't really a big deal.
To answer the question, I definitely wasn't surprised.
>>332768789
I watched the anime first, but even then, I was more surprised and confused when they tried to tell me that Naoto was a guy. For a while, I thought that may have been the case, but when she 'came out', it just seemed obvious.
The voice tipped me off immediately.
She kept saying boku.
>>332768789
Dropped the game before I reached her desu.
>>332771181
the VA is famous for doing boy's role
In the English Version, I thought she was a dude the first time I saw her, and then the game told me she was guy so I just rolled with it.
I can picture the Japenese version being a lot harder to figure out with the whole VA and Gender words thing.
>>332768789
Figured it out before the reveal, second guessed with the dungeon, wouldn't be at all surprised even if I hadn't
I knew the second I noticed her voice giving me an erection.
Can't remember if I was spoiled on her being a girl or not
>>332768789
I had immediate suspicions she was a girl, but then I did remember I was playing a JRPG and that the game was telling me it's a guy, so I pretty much rolled with the whole thing.
>>332768789
I've only played the undub and the voice actress was so obviously female, but then Japan does that sometimes. Has an actress do a male character. So my intital expectation was that she was a girl but then the constant male pronouns made me doubt that. So I changed my mind and thought she was a guy for a short time but still 'figured it out' or went back to my initial common sense deduction before the reveal.
I have no idea what the dub voice sounds like.
I want someone to give Naoto a hard fucking in front of me.
>>332775995
lol cuck
>>332768789
I couldn't tell, but my dick knew before me
>>332771539
Yes and every time I hear it I know it's a girl.
>>332776504
I know I'm a pathetic cuck who barely deserves to clean her holes.
>>332775995
ok Kanji
>>332768789
Voice made it obvious immediately. I really don't get how you wouldn't know.
>>332771539
Isn't the VA a close guarded secret?
Mary Elizabeth McGlynn did the anime voice but the game VA has never been truly verified iirc.
>>332776887
Why Cary? Don't you want to be the one the make her happy?
>>332775970
>I have no idea what the dub voice sounds like
Dubbed Persona is actually very good, relatively speaking
And Naoto is DIAMONDS
Well, at the start I thought Naoto was the protagonist from Persona 3, since I hadn't played Persona 3 first.
Once I saw her in game though I knew it was a she though, and ruled out the fact she was the P3 protagonist.
(It was the intro to Golden)
>>332777497
Naoto is my queen, no one person can satisfy her.
>>332768789
There's a time before introduction when Naoto is talking off-screen and she is described as "Feminine Voice"
>>332768789
Obvious bait. I refuse to belive that people are really so stupid as to not realize that she's a womeinine
Even DSP realized she's a girl the moment she appeared for the first time.
>>332778158
So you want all the Naotofans to work together to please her then.
>>332777183
Who do you suspect the VA was?
I'm sad that they've quit doing it. Damn her voice was hot.
Im pretty sure it was stated in one of the promotional materials that naoto is a girl but dresses as a boy
I knew about naoto weeks before i played the game
>>332768789
During her arc? I'm not sure (before she went to the shadow world). After further interactions with her, i was dead certain he was a she. The feminineenglishvoice was my clue. But, only after multiple hearings.
>>332778581
Mainly the hung alphas that can give it to her good.
>There are people browsing /v/ right now who didn't turn off voiced dialogue as soon as Chie first showed up
>>332768789
I played P4 before P3 and I thought Naoto was P3's MC.
I feel stupid now.
>>332768789
The voice gave it away. That sultry voice can't fool anyone's dick.
>>332777183
No not at all. Her voice is the voice of Edward Elric.
>>332778841
>There are people here who played Golden first
>>332779010
He probably meant the English VA for the original PS2 game. Its a closely guarded secret.
>>332779059
>implying Golden's Chie wasn't miles better than the original's.
Aha, is this our chance!
>>332779059
i know this is bait but... that's like saying "there are people here who played 3 before fes" or "there are people here who played the western persona 1 before persona 1 psp" like its a good thing
here's the only (you) you're going to get by the way, enjoy my man.
>>332778830
What would you and the rest do then?
>>332779298
>everything Golden Chie says
hey lets just grab this northwestern girl off the street to do the voice, it'll be fine
>>332779528
But Golden's Chie is an actual voice actress.
Original Chie sounded like a mom in her 40's.
>>332768789
First voiced line. I believe after exiting the textile shop.
I get why extreme autists would fail to pick up on it though.
>naoto is only15
>already has massivr hooters
Protag should have been slipping bovine growth formula into her coffee and massaging those things when she slept, it would be great to see how big she could get. Push that cow to her limits.
I suspected it immediately because of her voice, but my friend who watched me play it and watches a ton of anime thought she was a boy. So maybe I just don't have as big a suspension of disbelief or something and assumed female voice actors meant female character.
>>332779298
>>332779528
>>332779708
Not this again. Stop it.
>>332779906
>massaging those things
I'm not all that familiar with jap culture, but why do they always bring up that rubbing/massaging a girls tits will make them bigger?
>>332779528
The Golden voice is infinitely better than vanilla. Yes, she's shrill, loud, bombastic, and obnoxious, but so is Chie.
Vanilla dub Chie is terrible. Just dead. Worse than Naoto (who is shit in both versions, by the way)
>>332768789
A boy that cute can't possibly be a boy
>>332780203
Because that actually works. Something about increasing circulation.
>>332768789
Instant she talked, English VA wasn't subtle at all
>>332779198
She came back and did the voices for the new scenes in Golden aswell, but her name wasn't listed anywhere. I know the japanese VA is pretty famous and have voiced characters in alot of popular anime like naruto(and full metal alchemist if I remember correctly).
>play Persona 4 on Hard
>its exactly the same except the enemies have more health and can kill you instantly if they're lucky
>14 hours into the game and its too late to lower the difficulty to one that isn't Boring Grindfest without going through all the shit inbetween
I don't know what I expected from a JRPG to be honest.
>>332780203
Its an excuse to rub boobs.
Anyways for me I just think its adorable that Naoto is embarrassed by her huge melons. I bet protag just calls her Jugs instead of her name or goofy stuff like that to keep her hot and flustered.
The other characters literally had to call her a "boy" right as she was introduced, that's how obvious it was.
>>332778883
Before I played either game, I thought the exact same thing from just seeing the game covers and merchandise. I played P3 first and didn't realize they were seperate people untilthe P3 protagonist died.
>>332768789
I played the european english dubbed version so it was obvious the moment she spoke
>>332779906
She's 16-17.
>>332780771
Is there a difference in EU and US?
>>332780801
>first year in high school
>16-17
I thought she was 14-15
>>332780850
I dunno. Just meant to say I'm european which is why I have dubbed version. Sorry about that.
>>332779383
That begs the question. I've only played P3, P4 and their spinoffs, but now I'd like to go back and play P1 and P2. Are the PSP versions faithful, or should I emulate the PS1 versions?
>>332781031
Are you enjoying multi culturalism?
>>332768789
I suspected it, but when they kept referring to Naoto as a boy, I figured it was bad casting on the director's part... But then she was a girl and I wasn't surprised.
>>332781095
Several Isis-members were arrested in my town. Otherwise, no
>>332781073
>play p1 and p2
Why would you want to suffer? 1/2 and 3/4 are so different they might as well be separate series.
>>332781175
Lemme guess: Belgian?
>>332781031
It would've been cool if it was dubbed from the english into English-English, like a reverse Star Wars situation.
>>332781175
>Otherwise, no
Okay, that made no sense. Meant to say "doesn't affect me at all"
>>332780946
Japan has 3 years in Junior High and 3 in High School so most first year students are 16
>>332781225
Mostly out of curiosity for the series's roots. Besides, I still hear from several people that P2 at least is very good.
>>332768789
It was the most obvious thing I've seen in my life.
>>332780946
It's different in Japan, same with Europe(atleast where I come from), we don't start highschool until we're 16 years old and college when we're 19-20.
>>332781651
High school starts at 11 years old for us.
>>332781348
None of them are. They are just a pain to go through and are incredibly boring. By all means do what you want.
>>332768789
Yes, you are absolutely retarded if you can't instantly distinguish someone's sex by the sound of their voice and will probably get buttfucked by a tranny some day because of how oblivious you are.
Out of wishful thinking, I didn't realize until the big unveal because I wanted some hot yaoi action between 'him' and Kanji.
Was the VA embarrassed of voicing Naoto? I don't see why they would want it to be a secret.
>>332768789
Until they revealed it directly
I was thinking something was up when I first heard her voice, but my friend who already had beaten the game said that she was a guy. I believed him, but I kept joking about Naoto by saying he/she and his/her everytime. I was pretty surprised when I got to her shadow.
>>332782341
So you couldn't ruin the "surprise" by looking at the actors names?
>>332782341
Who would want to be associated with a shitty weeb game anyway?
>>332781947
and it never ends sadly.
>>332782341
she probably didn't want to be known for voicing a reverse-trap in a weeb game. That would probably stick with her for a long time.
ERP?[email protected]
>playing P3
>Shinjiro's voice sounds familiar
>find out his voice actor had roles dubbed hentai
>>332782914
Why is dubbed hentai a thing? Does a market for it even exist?
>>332779383
>2
Because no one has a vita you dipshit, when I played 4, Golden was already out but I played the PS2 original, Chie's new voice is ok but annoying as shit, I preffer the other voice, I always had sex fantasies with the other voice, you can't just rewrite hours of mind fan fiction out of the window.
>>332768789
any non-child character with a female voice actor is either a forced trap or a girl
because naoto dressed like a boy, it its not a trap and so by process of elimination naoto had to have been a boy, or rather a reverse-trap.
>>332783071
The only reason I can think of is for shits and giggles in some of the lines.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6TNFFmFOwnY
You'd have to be pretty dense to not notice that.
>>332768789
Ever since I played Danganronpa, there wasn't a single anime trap I couldn't identify instantly.
>>332779906
Stop scheming to ruin best girl.
>>332785278
Tits will only improve her.
>>332779906
>>332786248
Naoto is not for lewd, only for cuddling.
>>332787738
What about lewd cuddling?
Naoto is objectivelythe best gf material
>>332788019
as long as there's no handholding involved.
>>332777183
So mysterious.
Whoever voiced her in english is really damn talented.
>>332788160
So it's okay to brush fingers over her knuckles?
>>332788330
I guess...
>>332768789
I was suspicious right when I met her first time, then at some point something she said comfirmed she was a girl in school hallway.
>>332768789
Marie is the best Persona 4 girl.
>>332789000
excuse me while I go vomit
>>332789000
shutupstupidihateyoujerk
>>332789206
I actually enjoy her talking like that.
>>332788415
I HAVE IMPORTANT INFORMATION 4 U PLZ SEE ME TOMORROW AFTER SCHOOL
>>332781947
it is more middle school+high school in one. Especially since some people start at 12 and end as 16 and go to another school
>>332789000
Go home, Poochie.
>naoto will never send you text pictures of her in different styled dresses and skirts
>>332791085
I want her to text me pictures of her sucking big cocks.
>>332789000
You forgot to say "April Fools!"
>>332791469
That would be nice too.
>>332791469
I want her to text you pictures of her sucking my cock.
>>332768789
>English VA
obvious it was a girl within the first sentence of dialogue
>Japanese VA
obvious it was a girl PRETENDING to be a boy within the first sentence of spoken dialogue
when was the last time someone got legit fooled by a reverse trap?
>>332792290
Danganronpa
>>332768789
>Automatically assume it's a girl (tomboy)
>Much of the dialogue comes off weird
>Realize all the characters think she's a girl
She's like the Superman/Batman of characters--everyone fucking knows she's a girl, complete with a feminine physique and hairdo, but instead they all pretend she's a guy for the sake of the story.
In real life, more than one person would be taking a second-glance when she identifies herself as a dude.
>>332792115
I love that.
Maybe a video of her sucking you until you blow your load on her tits.
>>332792085
>implying her christmas gift wasnt cute as fuck
you dont deserve naoto
Reminder that Naoto wanted to kill Namatame
>>332792595
Sure anon. Is penetration off the table or would that be fine?
>>332792414
This, that legit surprised me, playing through the game again I've noticed several subtle hints throughout chapter 1 and 2.
>>332793669
I'd love for you to penetrate her holes, it's about what she or you will let me see.
>>332792718
Didn't want to begin with! HA!
>>332793978
Anon you're a very sick man.
>>332793978
Wouldn't you like to be there in person?
>>332793978
Yo white boi, I'ma git a slice o'dat pie
>>332794559
Nigger please.
>>332794347
That too, having a front row seat to you fucking Naoto would be so hot.
>>332775995
I'd be right happy to. As long as you're not in the room, the house, the street, the city, maybe even in the country itself. You'd agree to it too you beta cuck. I'm sure a cracker like yourself would be happy with the thought of another man of superior genes being with Naoto than yourself.
I knew because I had played Persona Dancing All Night first.
>>332778627
>>332788171
Her voice is straight up SEX. Probably the hottest voice i've heard in a game.
>>332794701
Why not have her for yourself?
>>332795260
Don't try to understand a cuckold anon.
>>332771539
So?
Females voice small kids all the time but that doesn't mean it's not immediately obvious it's just a woman pretending to be a kid.
A woman pretending to be a teenage boy is even worse in that regard.
>>332794636
Sheeit, she gun' be searchin' muh pants for an illegal weapon
>>332795563
Anon stop, it really wasn't funny the first time you did it.
>>332795653
I dindu nuffin'
>>332789000
>>332795840
for you
>>332775995
I would love to give a good fuck to Naoto.
The thing here is that I don't like being watch and I hate cucks like you
>You will never get to fuck Naoto.
>You will never get to paint her face in cum.
Life sucks.
VIDEOGAMES
>>332796891
Yes anon, Persona is a video game.
>>332795260
She needs a bigger, better cock to pleasure her, she deserves it.
>>332796891
This is video games, yes
>>332791469
>>332792595
>>332793978
>>332794701
Get the fuck outta here Kanji!
BEST GIRL
>>332797031
I guess you like her enough to ensure she is satisfied regardless of the cost.
>>332795017
It makes me insta hard as well senpai
>>332768789
from the beginning. there was almost no way they could have made it more obvious, short of straight up dressing her up in a girl uniform.
>>332797179
I'm not seeing Margret in there with her anon. They are the best P4 girls after all.
>>332797626
Margaret isn't a girl, she's a woman.
>>332797812
The point still stands.
>>332797321
I just want to see her fully satisfied.
>>332798183
Understandable but you should at least think about how you could help her with that too.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SI7xil_jV8Q
>that change of pitch when she gets picked up
>>332798183
You are one strange man anon. You're telling me that you want Naoto to constantly send you pictures of her sucking and fucking a man with a big, hard dick? My god man, what in your fucked up mind thinks something like this is okay?
I can never understand cuckolds.
>>332798552
>help
you really don't get it, do you anon?
>>332798703
It's pretty good.
>>332798552
I'll use my mouth to clean her cum filled holes.
>>332798552
He's a god damn cuck anon.
>>332798183
What the fuck is wrong with you?
>>332798962
That's not very Christian of you
>>332798962
Nice name
>>332798703
Arem was a solid replacement for Naoto in the latter games. Not Mercer level good, but still
>>332798962
Based donut merchant?
>>332798962
That is something. Would you at least sleep in the same bed with her?
>>332799158
Anon likes watching his waifu fuck another man. He's a fucked up person.
>>332799490
YU STOP
>>332799490
You know what he's going to say anon.
are you shitting me? I guessed the plot twist to Case 2 in Danganronpa by the time I first met the tech girl. No traps make it past my eagle eye.
>>332799490
>jew yu
>>332802323
G-Gomenasai
Being legit though, how would you react to a reverse trap making you question your sexuality and just when you think you're about to fuck a boy, you get a vagina to stick your dick in
>>332803496
I would be even more aroused.
>>332803496
I'd be pleasantly surprised and brush the whole thing from before off as my brain subconsciously believing the reverse trap was a girl all along.
>>332803496
>about to do the deed
>"Wait, you're a girl?"
>"You thought I was a boy the whole time? Wait...you were about to fuck me thinking I was a boy?"
>awkwardness
