Better than all of the grand theft auto games
>implying the bar is high
it literally is a grand theft auto game. rockstar doesn't know how to make anything else.
hey I've got a ps3
should I play this game?
>>330920030
Yes.
>>330919595
I've always wondered, what would a GTA game have to do and have its story be about to be on the same level as RDR, and have that same sense of adventure/journey?
>>330921746
Set it in the future perhaps?
>>330919595
San Andreas is better, but they are both good
One of my favourite games ever, hope they make another
>>330919949
Well it's a perfect format, it just depends if the setting works or not.
Law Noire and GTA4 nope
Bully, RDR and San Andreas yes yes and yes
>>330921908
I feel like a cyberpunk type future with little to no real aliens would work best, making it too futuristic can allow for more wackiness, and i appreciate saints row taking the wacky futuristic sorta spot. GTA needs to retain the kind of darker tone
>>330922262
I think LA Noire works because its doing its own thing and not really being 50s GTA. varied, interesting gameplay mechanics definitely improve their format
>RDR2 never
>my opinion matter
>>330919595
Have a 360, but I've never been fucked to buy it with the abysmal resolution and frame rate. I'm still waiting for the PC version
>>330921746
Be San Andreas.
>>330922884
It's not really a Rockstar game. You could have said Oni or something.
>>330919595
Has anyone replay it? tis been like two years since i beat but it was borrowed from a friend.
Should i buy it again? will it feel dated?
>>330923449
>be a game about a cowboy traveling through the west, hunting down the old members of his gang so he can get his family back
>be a game about some hoodrat doing a bunch of dindu gangsta shit, then going to a different city and completely changing the theme, and then going to another city and completely changing the theme, before remembering what the story was supposed to be about and going back to the first city so you can finish your dindu gangsta shit
yeah, no
>>330923494
I was playing it recently and it still holds up. It was one of the most polished games for its time, it's still beautiful and fun
PC when?
>PC port never
What I would give to play this game at a better resolution/framerate
Did they really lose the source code?
GTA Online would have been made infinitely better with the RDR Online announcer.
>>330923932
Will do. Thanks.
i never did finish the undead nightmare dlc. i need to do that sometime
>>330919595
I never liked cowboy shit. They all old dusty bones now.
>>330923964
Lose it? I don't know about that, but the code was complete spaghetti anyway. Porting it would have been a massive nightmare.
>>330923964
>Did they really lose the source code?
No. As a matter of fact, nobody knows where this fucking rumor started.
Everyone goes on about how they lost the source code, or that the code was a mess, or that there are no //comments in the code so nobody knows anything, or a bunch of console shortcuts in the code to make things work etc.
All these reasons about the messy code on why it will never come to the PC, yet there's no source. The earliest I could find was some retard spouting the same shit on the IGN forums. Other than that, who knows where this rumor came from.
It's a lot more believable to say they didn't port it just because San Diego never releases their games on PC. That much is true.
The closest we'll ever get to having RDR on the PC is if someone ported the map, weapons, models, etc. to GTA V (Couldn't be done with GTA IV because of something with terrain shaders for the map) and someone would have to do all the missions, minigames, random events etc. from scratch.
Sadly the GTA modding community is made up of children who can't work together properly, faggots that are full of themselves and think they're the best thing since sliced bread, and somewhat decent folk who realize this and work on their projects alone - but because it's just them working on it the shit takes literally forever and is stuck in development hell
>>330924151
me neither, I always lose interest when it sends you to mexico.
I use to love getting new horses and stuff
Also, it's bullshit John couldn't fuck those whores in clubs or saloon whatever you Americans call it
>>330923470
yea you right
>>330925417
Saloon is right, my friend. And you can't fuck them because John is a married man, I'm afraid.
>>330925417
John was faithful to his wife. Which is hilarious because she was the cum dump for Dutch's gang when John wad part of it.
>>330925417
He was married and loyal.
It's a wonder whyJackcouldn't.
Speaking of which, how is there not some sort of save edit tool or mod to revert back to John? You would think that people would be all over that shit.
>>330924029
true opinion
>>330924653
>It's a lot more believable to say they didn't port it just because San Diego never releases their games on PC. That much is true.
That's wrong though, Midnight Club 2 is on PC
>>330924029
tfw never played red dead online back in its prime
>Have Undead Nightmare on 360 version
Does anyone else's zombies heads disappear randomly after 10mins of playing. You have to die and trigger a loading screen for it to fix itself until it decides to crap itself again. Want it to 100% it, but it was too much of a pain in the ass.
does rockstar hate money?
why dont they remaster this shit already?no pc version please :^)
>>330919595
100% factual statement.
>>330919595
Bully is the best Rockstar game
>>330926290
you really cant beat that high school feel to it
really brings me back
>>330924151
>beat the game
>trade it in ASAP so it's still worth something
>the DLC comes out
i fucked up
>>330926290
Bully is pretty great, but RDR slightly edges it out.
>>330919595
Literally the most overrated game of all time.
>>330926473
I replay Undead Nightmare every October. Needless to say, I've gotten pretty good at it.
>>330925953
I dont know whats worse, the fact that you dont want it on pc or that you want a remaster of a semi-modern game in the first place.
>>330925832
>just one game
Shut the fuck up.
>>330926290
Any good mods for the PC version?
>>330926682
Leave that child alone
>>330921746
Have a different theme than modern day because that shit is boring, Think something like Moonbeam city
Have 1 protagonist and not make him a whiny annoying cunt or someone who looks to the camera and rolls their eyes whenever someone does something wacky
Also don't make his motivation for crime "it's what I do" Jesus fuck R*
>>330919595
I just want R* to make a game that isn't packed to the gills with hamfisted political commentary. Like I kmow that's their hat these days but in this day and age you can't go an hour without someone ramming politics down your throat and it's really starting to get old.
>get some bros together in multiplayer
>go find a bear or some cougars
>melee only
>mfw
Of all the shit games they HD re-release, they cant give us RDR?
>>330927743
I don't know, I feel like modern day is fine.
I think the protagonist/motivation is really it. They pretty much have become "I break the law and do these things because I'm a criminal." And that's it. At least IV Niko had some real motivation and goal, but there wasn't much of a journey or sense of adventure.
We just need more original and interesting protagonists. I'm still hoping one day for a crooked cop type thing from Rockstar.
>>330927743
Tommy Vercetti needed to get Sonnys money. By the time he told Sonny to go fuck himself he was in a position to just build an empire and take him on. Best writing in any GTA game right there
>>330928398
Vice City was good, and I liked how they handled the story/missions with it being based around you buying properties and essentially building your empire.
Sadly, it's obvious how much of a homage it is to Scarface and that kind of detracts from it.
>>330928369
I'd like to see Rockstar take a page from the LSPD mod for V, myself. I had more fun playing as a cop than I ever did with the main storyline.
>>330922262
what about broody middle aged alcoholic white male protagonist #1223 's sao paolo adventure?
>>330919595
>Better than all of the games
fixed
this game is the Bloodborne of GTA series
>>330923494
Still looks really nice and the atmosphere is unmatched.
The Clint Eastwood of vidya.
name some western reads for me so i don't look like a social invalid at the city mingle
>>330929509
Reading won't change how you look.
>>330925690
I always wondered how he lives with that thought of having a whore wife?
>>330928873
What about spoiled middle-class feminist who thinks she's oppressed #1234556245761256
>>330929654
tons of ugly people go to city affairs
>>330929731
I always wondered hoe she lives with that thought of having a murdering husband?
They were both shitty people back then who wanted to change who they were.
>>330925945
yes the last patch R* did to fix the hacker issue completely fucked the game and they never fixed it. If you have the GOTY version you are fucked. If not just remove the patch and you should be fine
>>330928123
I don't know anon, sometimes their satire is just too good.
>>330929509
smugglers run isnt a better GTA, its pretty much a GTA 3 beta test, a fun but frustrating one.
>>330926608
You're the anon that posted in my thread, too. I remember you!