Let's play a game of "Good Idea, Bad Idea" starring the shittiest game of 2015, Witcher 3
>Good idea
Allow players to choose dialogue that they'd actually want to say whether it be good, evil or neutral aka any RPG worth its salt
>Bad idea
Force the player to play someone that at worst, can only be chaotic neutral cause the character is still a good guy that can't do anything bad aka Witcher 3
>Good idea
Having character stats that define your character and allow for non violent approaches aka Fallout and Planescape Torment
>Bad idea
Being forced to play a single set character that does nothing but sword fight aka Geralt in Witcher 3
>Good idea
Being able to roleplay a character of several races, genders, etc aka Dragon Age Origin and Morrowind
>Bad idea
Despite the lore saying otherwise, force the character to play only one character aka Geralt in Witcher 3
>Good idea
Having multiple characters that fulfill multiple roles your main PC can't aka Baldur's Gate 1/2
>Bad idea
Being a multiclassing Mary Sue aka Geralt in Witcher 3
>Good idea
Having Batman vision in a Batman game aka Arkham games
>Bad idea
Having Batman vision in a non-Batman game aka Witcher 3
You really wrote all that diarrea?
>bad idea
OP
>>330546573
>diarrea dookie poop
This is a Witcher fan, everyone
Oh boy, new pasta
>>330546508
Cool OP, I'll play along
>Good Idea
A video game board where you can make video game threads
>Bad Idea
This thread
>>330546629
Havent played them.
>>330546659
>new
I remember seeing this exact same thread with that pic a few days ago
>play assassin's creed
>forced to play as an assassin
fucking bullshit
>>330546861
Does Assy Creed ever describe itself as an RPG? No
Does Witcher and its retarded fanbase describe their bad action adventure game as an RPG? Yes.
>>330546508
Remember to sage OP, anons, don't bump the bait
here is a far shittier game that came out in 2015
The "the witcher 3 is not an rpg" asshole appears every saturday, one more to the underage theory
>>330546967
Everyone knows, at this point we all just respond to see how far the OP will continue playing along or if he slips up.
>>330547026
i'm pretty sure he's australian
>>330546967
>A far worse game exists (Fallout 4), so thusly, this bad game is good (Witcher 3)
It doesn't werk that way.
>>330546753
Very well done. I laughed and lost
>>330546508
>people are still mad because Witcher 3 won GOTY
HA
>>330547375
He said "the shittiest game of 2015"
Work on your reading comprehension, anon.
>>330548479
>Here you go
What did the game mean by this?
>>330546508
yeah its weird how all those bad ideas sound like witcher 3 but its actually a great game lol
>>330547092
its 1am here m8
>>330546508
I don't get how anyone can say that it's a bad game. I know i'm being memed here but if you had actually played it you would realise it's the best game to come out in years
>>330548591
Here (You) go.
>good idea
Playing a game
>bad idea
Playing a witcher game
the R part of RPG in regard to withcer 3 is that you are role playing as a witcher
>>330546573
Nope, this is a pasta. We've has the same thread literally dozens of times now.
>>330549474
>witcherfags are this dumb
Role-playing means picking a role
by your arbitrary retarded rules Super Mario Bros is an RPG
>>330546508
>>330546629
>>330546912
>>330547375
>>330549298
>>330549786
Good idea: Reporting this thread
Bad idea: Be an autistic sperg with anger issues who makes this thread every day
>>330550596
At what point does that make OP wrong?
>>330550680
>I'M NOT OP !!!!!!!
Kill yourself autist
>>330550732
OPs can't bump their own threads but kek at your niggerness
>>330546508
>a game about the witcher book series is making play as the main character of the book which inspired the game to be made in the first place.
kill ur a're self
>>330551049
Then it's not really a roleplaying game, is it?
>>330546629
better a witcher fan than being someone who defends a shitty meme.
>bloodbabbys are STILL mad
>>330546508
It's supposed to be be about Geralt, you freaking moron. Hey, think to yourself for a moment. Why is Geralt even the main character?
>>330552364
It's not DND or some generic shit like that, it's the Witcher. If you wanted to play DND or something similar, why the hell are you playing something literally based off of a book character specifically? This game even has 2 earlier game series entries about the same guy.
Just off yourself OP, the world will become a better place afterwards
>>330553923
Witcherfag defense force lmao
>>330546508
a deal is a deal >>>/mods/
now you have to suck this thread
>>330550596
This.
>>330548345
>Witcher 3 couldn't surpass a Sony exclusive in GoTY count
Embarrassing
>>330550596
> Stating broken rules in a thread is against the rules and wil result in a kick/warning/ban
You're a fucking idiot.
