[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows kino?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 232
Thread images: 55
File: deathly hallows.jpg (45 KB, 660x393) Image search: [Google]
deathly hallows.jpg
45 KB, 660x393
Is Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows kino?
>>
>inb4 somebody says muh epic battle scenes

Prisoner of azkaban was supreme kino, then deathly hallows.

every frame of that movie is beautiful.
>>
>>71867114
woah dude are you okay?
>>
of course it was

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DFe0OR-Vaww
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGH9OlTVoQA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfuArv7A8Dc

>>71867103
poa dh1 and hbp are pure kino
>>
>>71867162
the dance scene is too much for my heart tbqh
>>
>>71867211
It'll be okay senpai. I actually was gonna watch the vid but I need a moment
>>
The whole atmosphere of this movie is really interesting, I can't quite describe it but it's really something
>>
>>71867282
>>
>>71867114
this isn't even bait, this is just fucking pathetic
>>
File: dh1cine.jpg (470 KB, 1200x504) Image search: [Google]
dh1cine.jpg
470 KB, 1200x504
bumping because there arent many good thread up
>>
>>71867114
DUDE EPIC ANGRY RANT LMAO
>>
Worst book but not the worst movie.
>>
>>71867162
So they fucked in the movie universe right?
>>
>>71868390
Actually no. The point was they could have done something then or even that night, but Hermione has feelings for Ron and backs away that moment. So they didnt but could have, the moment works the best because of its position in the series and story with all they have gone through, Harry is pretty wrecked after hermione slacks away because he knows he can only cheer her up for a minute and reality is back and shes willing to die for him.


but who are we kidding, he cheered her up all goddamn night. i would
>>
File: qLy7NDf.png (1 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
qLy7NDf.png
1 MB, 1920x1080
>>71868390
>>71868442
To add, my head canon is they fucked in half blood prince, because why not they are upset about ron and ginny
>>
>>71867066
p1 is best HP movie
p2 is worst HP movie
>>
>>71868627
Idk if its worst but i like your taste because dh1 is my second favorite or favorite its hard to pick. id say goblet or philosophers stone are the worst
>>
>>71867211
>>71867255
>>71867282
>>71868627
I've always felt this way but I've never seen anyone on /tv/ share the same sentiment until now. It's got such a strange atmosphere with lots of somber moments like Harry and Hermoine walking through Godric's Hollow and >>71867211 that make the whole thing so beautiful and sad.
>>
>>71868724
movies
7.1>=6>3>1=4>2>5>7.2

books
6>4>7>>>5>3>>>>>2>1
>>
>>71868627
half blood prince better imo
>>
>>71868808
then why did you post the one scene which actually proves your statement to be wrong
>>
>>71868627
>>71868724
my favorite is still prisoner of azkaban

its kind of got a stranger tone that sets it apart from a lot of the other films in the series as well as having some pretty great shots and some great moments throughout, that werewolf near the end is still the highlight of the entire series for me
>>
chamber of secrets was the best film from the franchise
>>
>>71868820
Wrong how? Did you want me to make a webm for snape?
>>
>>71868823
wrong, look its good but not as good as most of the others, get some film appreciation
>>
>>71868849
meant for
>>71868833
oops
>>
>>71868837
because that scene made the movie worse enough to lose first place. If we had a couple more pensieve scenes instead of that and wun wun it might had been the best
>>
>>71868823
yea i love azkaban the most too but i really like dh1 and hbp

>>71868808
hbp great any more webms?
>>
>>71868870
not him, i dont like the scene but i dont hate it. its at the halfway point and they wanted to do something. it shows harrys burning hatred for bellatrix and harrys home is basically destroyed which doesnt bode well
>>
3 and pt.1 are the best in the series.
>>
File: 1461711973412.gif (2 MB, 500x281) Image search: [Google]
1461711973412.gif
2 MB, 500x281
>>71868960
someone else with great taste

you like hbp tho?
>>
File: Horcrux.webm (2 MB, 700x290) Image search: [Google]
Horcrux.webm
2 MB, 700x290
>>71868890
That was was french from the converter, and my computer is slow as fuck right now. Recommend me some scenes though
>>
>>71867103
The plot of Prisoner of Azkaban is atrocious. The time travel ending in particular is tedious as hell.
>>
>>71868990
the fuck is with those subtitles? harry never says its not my fault

also that cave scene is great the moment harry goes down to get water and the zombies attack and are piling up when hes underwater....the ransacking of hogwarts right after dumbledore is kill....any scenes that take place with the castle corridors engulfing the characters.....malfoy being chased and contronted by harry
>>
File: 1445701906636.jpg (1 MB, 1596x2850) Image search: [Google]
1445701906636.jpg
1 MB, 1596x2850
>>71867066
No. Harry Potter was easily one of the dullest franchise in the history of movie franchises. Each episode following the boy wizard and his pals from Hogwarts Academy as they fight assorted villains has been indistinguishable from the others. Aside from the gloomy imagery, the series’ only consistency has been its lack of excitement and ineffective use of special effects, all to make magic unmagical, to make action seem inert.

Perhaps the die was cast when Rowling vetoed the idea of Spielberg directing the series; she made sure the series would never be mistaken for a work of art that meant anything to anybody?just ridiculously profitable cross-promotion for her books. The Harry Potter series might be anti-Christian (or not), but it’s certainly the anti-James Bond series in its refusal of wonder, beauty and excitement. No one wants to face that fact. Now, thankfully, they no longer have to.

>a-at least the books were good though
"No!"
The writing is dreadful; the book was terrible. As I read, I noticed that every time a character went for a walk, the author wrote instead that the character "stretched his legs."

I began marking on the back of an envelope every time that phrase was repeated. I stopped only after I had marked the envelope several dozen times. I was incredulous. Rowling's mind is so governed by cliches and dead metaphors that she has no other style of writing. Later I read a lavish, loving review of Harry Potter by the same Stephen King. He wrote something to the effect of, "If these kids are reading Harry Potter at 11 or 12, then when they get older they will go on to read Stephen King." And he was quite right. He was not being ironic. When you read "Harry Potter" you are, in fact, trained to read Stephen King.
>>
>>71869001
you didnt get it, look up the novikov self consistency principle, theres no alternative timeline where buckbeak dies. harry always made the patronus thats why its so powerful he did it already even though from his point of view he hadnt already done it...it really goes along with the themes of harrys past his parents..his present, future, divination, prophecy etc
>>
>>71869001
Nah.
time travel part was kept simple and neat.
i liked it.
>>
File: Hagrid house.webm (3 MB, 700x290) Image search: [Google]
Hagrid house.webm
3 MB, 700x290
>>71869021
>harry never says its not my fault
No he doesn't, Dumbledore says that.
>>
File: Fire.webm (3 MB, 600x250) Image search: [Google]
Fire.webm
3 MB, 600x250
>>71869084
>>
>>71869001
>>71869047
He can understand the time travel plot and still just not like it, I liked it personally. seeing a things from a different viewpoint throughout the story was neat.

personally l like it more for the setting than the plot, everything feels a little more strange in azkaban, theres a murderer gunning for harry, a whole lot of soul sucking monsters flying about and it just gives you a glimpse into a bigger picture of weird shit going on in the adult world of hp
>>
>>71869001
>>71869047
fuck one more thing
>plot
the plot is fine and thats not what you should base a movie on, prisoners shots largely speak for themes even if theres plot
>>
>>71869024
we're talking about the films m80

nice copypasta though
>>
File: poacinegrid2.jpg (764 KB, 1200x504) Image search: [Google]
poacinegrid2.jpg
764 KB, 1200x504
>>71869192
Yea i loved it all i just didnt know if maybe it didnt click with him how the time travel fits with the themes. the last hour is fucking fantastic after the scene where lupin takes the map and the camera zooms out to him to cutting to divination class and then having harry go down the rabbit hole then back upstairs to get a prophecy from his professor (that shot of him walking out to the ominous music)
>>
File: Hogwarts.webm (2 MB, 798x332) Image search: [Google]
Hogwarts.webm
2 MB, 798x332
>>71869175
Thats about it i guess
>>
>>71869084
>>71869175
ahh nice webms more like that. so one of the cave shot before they drink the potion and when gambin take his first drink. also do one of harry getting the water
>>
>>71869300
could you make that like 5 seconds longer and keep the part right before that when harry slams into something right behind him bc he has zero spatial awareness in the tower and then goes down the stairs after them. i love that shot of them walking down the hill in the woods
>>
>>71869300
>>71869360
fuck you cut the woods shot right after the candles it my favorite make that webm 10 seconds longer
>>
File: Cave.webm (2 MB, 650x270) Image search: [Google]
Cave.webm
2 MB, 650x270
>>71869360
Okay hold on I'm also rendering other shit so it takes forever to get one done
>>
>>71869419
okay np make that one >>71869300
5 seconds longer before and 5 seconds longer after if you can
>>
>>71869419
nice nice.
>>
File: Hogwarts extended.webm (3 MB, 650x270) Image search: [Google]
Hogwarts extended.webm
3 MB, 650x270
>>71869473
>File too large (file: 3 MB, max: 3 MB)
wew
Really wish gookmoot would increase the file size limit
>>
>>71868803
what's it like to have shit taste anon?

3>4>6>7>2>1>>>>>>>>>>>hot diarrhea>5
>>
>>71869505
fuck thats the perfect webm look at that shit absolutely fucking beautiful. thank you.
>>
>>71869526
He doesnt mate 3 7.1 6 are the best ones, 4 isnt even close, def not better than 6 7.1
>>
>>71869552
talking about the book you mongoloid. notice there only being a single 7?
>>
>>71867066
Do all you fags do all day is just ask /tv/ if the movie you are currently watching or just finished Kino?
>>
File: Your good health harry.webm (3 MB, 650x270) Image search: [Google]
Your good health harry.webm
3 MB, 650x270
>>71869305
Here's Albus drinking for the first time
Water coming up
>>
HOW MANY TIMES DO I HAVE TO TELL YOU PEOPLE GOBLET OF FIRE IS THE SUPREME WANDKINO JUST STOP TRYING TO DISPUTE IT AND MOVE ON
AVADA KADAVREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>71869565
sometimes people mistakenly rank both films as one, im sorry my fault i didnt think anyone was talking about the books. pretty good ranking even though i liked 5, 3 4 6 def the best
>>
>>71869586
no deathly hallows is established kino anon it is known
>>
>>71868616

STUPID DUMB WEASLEY SCUM
>>
>>71869607
Its not bad but its not top 3 worthy. The series is strong tho
>>
>>71869632
All the Harry Potter movies are terrible and if you consider any of them kino you are a reddit fag It is known
>>
>>71869024
>Each episode following the boy wizard and his pals from Hogwarts Academy as they fight assorted villains has been indistinguishable from the others

lul no

The only HP movie that is forgetable is the Phoenix Order
>>
File: Water 1.webm (2 MB, 650x270) Image search: [Google]
Water 1.webm
2 MB, 650x270
>>71869594
I have to split water into two parts because it's over a minute long and otherwise it'll end up like a pixelated webm for ants
>>
>>71869656
youre fucking cinematically illiterate. pleb.
>>
>>71869656
>he doesnt even know that reddit doesnt even appreciate the kino
They are normies like you how could they, leave the film discussion to the pros leave the thread if you must.
>>
File: Water 2.webm (3 MB, 650x270) Image search: [Google]
Water 2.webm
3 MB, 650x270
>>71869677
Make that 3 parts
>>
>>71869607
>no quidditch
>no sphinx
>only Harry gets to fight the dragon
>those fucking hairstyles
Still better than Ootp
>>
>>71869677
>>71869726
Do it. thanks anon. We needed some kino rips
>>
File: Water 3.webm (2 MB, 650x270) Image search: [Google]
Water 3.webm
2 MB, 650x270
That's the last of it i think
>>
>>71869740
they had no quidditch because the first task took its place
>>
File: 1stworlder.jpg (61 KB, 640x427) Image search: [Google]
1stworlder.jpg
61 KB, 640x427
1. The Prisoner of Azkaban
2. The Chamber of Secrets
3. The Deathly Hallows part 1
4. The Philosopher's Stone
5. The Half-Blood Prince
6. The Goblet of Fire (only last act is kino)
7. The Deathly Hallows part 2
8. The Phoenix Order
>>
>>71869753
>>71869741
I just noticed the amount of cutting at the end after rendering this one. Looks retarded lol
>>
>>71869717
You are a redditor using /tv/ memes to fit in

Here this place is better for a 16 year old such as yourself
www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter

>>71869681
Coming from someone who is diluting the meaning of the word Kino by attaching a truly un-kino movie such as Harry Potter? You are nothing but a poor troll
>>
File: 1466531916018.jpg (56 KB, 342x342) Image search: [Google]
1466531916018.jpg
56 KB, 342x342
>>71867066
>>
>>71869824
No im not stop being a fuck, i ise this board all the time for different films. this haloens to be a potter thread. this happens to be the only place to discuss the potter films, as evident by the discussion
>>
>>71869787
it actually works well when watching the entire scene and with sound of course
>>
>>71869846
You HAVE to go back
>>
>>71868990
I never understood that part in the movie, can someone explain what was dumbledore doing there and what happened
>>
>>71869846
Back to plebbit with you

Out out out
>>
>>71869300
based Bellatrix
>>
>>71869824
>>71869874
>theres a subreddit
>go there
They dont have discussion there number 1. its reddit, im here because ive been here. dont like the thread leave. sorry something is so popular it overlaps to reddit, fucking color me shocked you spick
>>
>>71869878
They're trying to find a horcrux but in order to actually get it a (paralysing?) poison must be drunk before it becomes available. Since dumblebore is old and less valuable than Harry he drinks it
>>
>>71869899
>he comes to shit up harry potter threads
go back to your cuck thread you wolf crying fag
>>
>>71869904
>spick
If you're going to throw around random insults at least spell them properly, redditor.
>>
>>71869787
if you wanna so one more maybe the snow scene where katie gets cursed? or harry following upset and crying hermione
>>
>>71869922
Yea its not only paralyzing/weakening but likely painful and mindfucking him
>>
>>71867066
part 1 yes
part 2 sucks and the ending is top cringe
>>
I've seen some discussion but its always derailed by memes and shitposters. Glad you and others agree. The tone really is great and its shot and directed very very well.
>>
>>71870084
Fuck meant for
>>71868792
>>
File: tzu7.jpg (447 KB, 1919x2560) Image search: [Google]
tzu7.jpg
447 KB, 1919x2560
How was Harry cured of yellow fever?
>>
File: Katie 1.webm (2 MB, 800x332) Image search: [Google]
Katie 1.webm
2 MB, 800x332
>>71869966
1/2
>>
>>71870059
Did the layout of hogwarts completely change in DH2? I swear the bridge into the courtyard wasn't there and the place with all the staircases wasn't there either (not the moving staircases)
>>
>>71870059
they shot the epilogue way after they wrapped, they wrapped back to back filming with a small scene of them jumping into the fireplaces (it was simple because they knew they would be upset the whole time and after they wrapped), but them months later did the epilogue. it must have been sad for them.
>>
File: Katie 2.webm (2 MB, 800x332) Image search: [Google]
Katie 2.webm
2 MB, 800x332
>>71870122
2/2
>>
>>71870116
being cucked from the afterlife tends to do that
>>
>>71870116
whorecruxes
>>
>>71870116
He never had it.
>>
>>71869930
>Harry Potter threads
>not already shit
>>
>>71870059
not just the ending
>>
>>71870202
great post
>>
>>71869755
canceling quidditch for the triwizard was a pretty fucking retarded thing from the spectator PoV
>hey you know the exciting magic soccer sport we hold every year, well we aren't going to this year
>oh snap
>but don't worry, we'll hold a rad magic tournament
>oh cool
>... for three people
>why even fucking cancel quidditch then
>but don't worry it will be totally cool, there are three trials and in the first one you see people fighting a dragon
>fucking awesome
>the second one you see three people diving in a lake, and then you stare at lake for one hour until they come back
>what
>the third one you see three people get into a maze and then stare at some bushes until one teleports back as the winner
>fuck you
>>
>>71870216
It fits well with how shit this thread is
>>
>>71870185
>>71870122
Cool thanks i even love the parts even when they are just walling to and from the three broomsticks, so chill.

If you want do the part after weasley gets his kiss
>>
File: 1456529731068.png (63 KB, 210x175) Image search: [Google]
1456529731068.png
63 KB, 210x175
>>71870321
fucking epic
>>
>>71870295
I meant in the movie the quidditch world cup match was cut because they had quidditch scenes in all other films and the first task harry is on a broom anyways. the real reasok they cut it was to get to the death eaters asap

i guess they needed the quidditch pitch, the tournament was pretty hype in the books. yule ball was sweet, possibility of death is always copl
>>
File: Birds.webm (3 MB, 800x332) Image search: [Google]
Birds.webm
3 MB, 800x332
>>71870327
That's probably gonna be another 3 parter
>>
>quidditch
>interesting
>suspenseful
Yeah, nah. It's just a token suspense OH NO WE'RE LOSING before harry invariably catches the snitch and OH WOW WE WON
Fuck off.
>>
File: hp15.jpg (59 KB, 768x576) Image search: [Google]
hp15.jpg
59 KB, 768x576
WELL DONE SLYTHERIN
WELL DONE SLYTHERIN
>>
File: Birds 2.webm (2 MB, 800x332) Image search: [Google]
Birds 2.webm
2 MB, 800x332
>>71870409
Or 4, I prefer quality
>>
>>71870409
Thats a nice webm

>>71870413
the best quidditch scenes were in 3 and 6 anyways
>>
>>71870122
that's some spooky shit right there
>>
>>71870445
very nice quality. Thats beautiful and brutal
>i know
>i see the way you look at her
>youre my best friend
>>
File: Birds 3.webm (3 MB, 600x250) Image search: [Google]
Birds 3.webm
3 MB, 600x250
>>71870448
3/3
Managed it
>>
The most unrealistic thing about these movies with magic in them is how Harry never falls for Hermione.
>>
>>71870448
and 3 it was raining 6 snowing
>>
>>71870409
>>71870445
>>71870498
Thanks a lot man good shit, I love how HBP was shot
>>
File: wer.jpg (67 KB, 768x576) Image search: [Google]
wer.jpg
67 KB, 768x576
>>71870442
H O W E V E R
O
W
E
V
E
R
>>
>>71869024
>Atlas Shrugged God Tier
Shiggydiggy desu senpai
>>
>>71869084
Why did they leave Harry there instead of kidnapping him and giving him to Voldemort for free?
>>
>>71870669
because snape is actually good and he told bellatrix to back the fuck off
>>
>>71870498
ayo do right after this >>71870669
>>71869084
when harry tries to sectumsempra snape, he reveals himself as hbp and kicks harrys wand away as the hut burns and harry looks at the dark mark
>>
File: er.jpg (14 KB, 413x240) Image search: [Google]
er.jpg
14 KB, 413x240
Was it rape?
>>
File: 1466178167886.jpg (545 KB, 1305x667) Image search: [Google]
1466178167886.jpg
545 KB, 1305x667
>>71870784
>>
>>71870693
Yes but surely the other death eaters wondered why they just left Harry there for no reason?
>>
File: Snape 1.webm (3 MB, 600x250) Image search: [Google]
Snape 1.webm
3 MB, 600x250
>>71870774
1 / 2
>>
>>71870883
>1 / 2
Never mind that's the whole scene already
>>
>>71870858
they were peaceing out, dumbledore was their mission, snapes in charge, he doesnt want harry to be captured or killed so he acts like voldemort has plans himself and not to fuck with it
>>
>>71870907
can you make an extended with harry looking at dark mark right after that?
>>
File: Dark mark.webm (986 KB, 1280x532) Image search: [Google]
Dark mark.webm
986 KB, 1280x532
>>71870966
Extending it will decrease quality significantly since that's over a minute long in total
you still want it?
>>
>>71871044
No that ones perfect too thanks!
>>
File: goblin.png (327 KB, 472x346) Image search: [Google]
goblin.png
327 KB, 472x346
>>71870784
>>
File: bella.jpg (91 KB, 800x800) Image search: [Google]
bella.jpg
91 KB, 800x800
who here loves Bellatrix Lestrange?

would love to motor boat her big boobs while she puts her wand in my anus and yells CRUCIO.
>>
File: z8.jpg (194 KB, 808x1024) Image search: [Google]
z8.jpg
194 KB, 808x1024
>>71871152
Too old now
>>
>>71871152
BIG
>>
File: bella qt.gif (500 KB, 500x211) Image search: [Google]
bella qt.gif
500 KB, 500x211
>>71871196
of course we are imagining bella in her prime m8.

I think she will crucify you more for calling her old.
>>
File: rq.jpg (178 KB, 1017x546) Image search: [Google]
rq.jpg
178 KB, 1017x546
>>71871266
I'm ok with that
>>
Everything after azkaban was crap because the cinematography was so shite
>>
>>71870498
>that scene where the werewolf is sucking her blood

I didn't feel a thing
>>
>>71871367
Shit opinion. Idziak, Delbonnel, and Serra were fantastic. goblet cinematographer was the same as chamber of secrets
>>
>>71871390
theres no scene where that happens, they cut a scene of scabior talking about raping her and then the werewolf beating the shit out of ron
>>
Who was the best dumbledore?
>>
>>71871445
they took the grimdark edge filter to new levels after goblet
>>
>>71869024
what a walking meme.
You didn' t even read any of those books
>>
>>71871445
other movies were not crap but POA's cinematography was certainly better.
>>
>>71871456
oh you mean lavender, nvm nobody liked her, also they didnt show her neck getting sucked just her ded right?
>>
>>71871456
wait are you sure? I remember during the final battle they pass that werewolf guy and he's just killed her then harry casts that stunning spell that flies him in the air

I have to redownload to movies again I suppose
>>
>>71871463
no 'they' didnt, the cinematographers did their job, they are all shot differently and fit the films tones perfectly get some respectable taste. 5 6 7 are great
>>
>>71871462
The first one without a doubt. It would be interesting to see him in a duel if he would have the strength.
>>
>>71871487
i thought you meant hermione for some reason you might be right
>>
>>71871515
Harris was humble not eclectic and he was dying, Gambon was great he was directed shitty in goblet thats all
>>
>>71871152
would love to be choked by her.
>>
>>71871476
i love poa but the cinematography for 6 and 7 is brilliant as well.
>>
>>71871462
Both were great.
>>
>>71871463
color pallets for each film after goblet are great and match the material, the skin tones were good, they look very good and are crafted very well get a better tv
>>
HBP 2 had the best moment in the entire series though

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHolRZeQNG4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqyf-kJWwIg
>>
>>71871712
>hbp2
>cuck scene
>best in series
i would rank almost every other scene besides those with cho above that. theres so much better stuff in 2 3 4 5 6 7
>>
>>71871758
> hurr durr cuck meme
>>
>>71871758
/pol/ overload m8.
>>
>>71871796
yea i was joking, i mean its good but not even the best in dh2, snapes death way better
>>
>>71871629
Nah man. When I watched philosopher's stone for the first time it was just like I imagined it. Warm, natural and earthly colors. Sure the tones in the later movies were different but I don't like the dark, almost blue filter in some cases they applied to every shot. It was quite nauseating to be honest and the half-blood prince was the worst perpetrator. Just a simple scene like when they were brewing the felix felisis had this unnecessary brown/dark filter that gave me eye cancer.

I don't agree with the need to have weird colors just because the tone is dark. It's just compensating for the lack of "x-factor" the movies have. Jurassic park isn't supposed to be light-hearted, well maybe in the beginning, but just look at the excellent natural colors and I love it for it
>>
>>71871823
desu I consider it part of the same scene

What I meant to say was that the Snape reveal was the best part of the series
>>
>>71867066

Every HP movie is better than The Godfather
Every HP movie is better than Citizen Kane

Fight me.
>>
>>71871826
this.

every fucking frame was grey or dark. i know tone is mature/dark but that was too much dark.
>>
>>71871826
also this is probably photography, not cinematography or whatever, I mistake the two quite a lot since I'm not educated in moviemaking so sorry if anyone mistook me. As a filmbuff I can only see what I see and identify colors, lightning, camerawork etc and then judge what I like or don't like
>>
>>71871826
the first two were vanilla as fuck look at the movie barcodes, earthly just means lots of orange tan and brown. and then also blue at night or dark, its not rocket science.

>>71871907
you couldnt be more wrong, the first two were simole adaptations, the reason poa is somgood is nbecause of cuaron and sesserin made it their own, yates did the same, if you dont like it okay, but dont act like you have the correct opinion, they are better reviewed for a reason and even delbonnel got an oscar nom. they had to make the films their own they couldnt go point by point like colmbus
>>
File: 1.jpg (100 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
1.jpg
100 KB, 1280x480
>>71872068
>>71871907
>>71871826
Heres the shitty cinematography from the first one
>>
>>71871826
its like you have no basic understanding of cinema. wew why did the studio directors films look generic like 90s films and the others looked better. If you cant see get glasses, hbp looks like a portrait it looks fantastic
>>
File: 2.jpg (90 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
2.jpg
90 KB, 1280x480
>>71872170
just look at those color stretches yet you complain about the latter ones having the same look?
>>
File: 3.jpg (99 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
3.jpg
99 KB, 1280x480
>>71872225
black begins to be injected in between as the films go on
>>
>>71872170

What the fuck is this image?
>>
File: 4.jpg (92 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
4.jpg
92 KB, 1280x480
>>71872247
learn something, its a movie barcode. every single image every frame compressed. thats philosophers stone, see the color bands of orange and peach such thats just normal cinematography
>>
File: download.png (8 KB, 226x223) Image search: [Google]
download.png
8 KB, 226x223
>>71869661
>>71870640
>>71871472
Why are you replying to pasta?
>>
>>71868808
I honestly don't get it, they didn't have time for actual important plot points from the books yet they still made up new shit for literally no reason
>>
>>71872249
philosopher stone im posting all the movie barcodes, ie every single frame compressed for color
>>
>>71872318
the book had lots to be cut still, stop fucking mentioning a book when film is a different medium. literally learn about flow and such the film is perfect
>>
Half blood prince also had a goat OST
>>
>>71872318
>he watches films for plot
>he doesnt think no matter what things would be left out of 600 page book so you might as well make your own movie or something
>>
File: 5.jpg (94 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
5.jpg
94 KB, 1280x480
>>71872294
>>
>>71872442
>when you recognize the color of Umbridge's cardigan
>>
File: 6.jpg (86 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
6.jpg
86 KB, 1280x480
>>71872442
>>
File: 7.jpg (83 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
7.jpg
83 KB, 1280x480
>>71872467
>>
File: 8.jpg (85 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
8.jpg
85 KB, 1280x480
>>71872492
>>
File: completeseries.jpg (93 KB, 1280x480) Image search: [Google]
completeseries.jpg
93 KB, 1280x480
>>71872520
Here is the entire series

in all this looks great, the progression is very nice. those who think colombus' had the only good cinematography nee their head checked look at this and look at the individual ones, the first two have more limited childish color tones, theres nothing wrong with the, just like theres nothing wrong with the latter ones
>>
>>71868627
Half Blood Prince was the worst.
>>
File: 6_gandalf_smokingpipe.jpg (34 KB, 576x396) Image search: [Google]
6_gandalf_smokingpipe.jpg
34 KB, 576x396
>>71872577
dumb ass
>>
>>71872603
I'm probably biased because of how unfaithful it was to the book.
>>
>>71872623
Thats exactly what you are, are you 16 or what. for real listen if you want to appreciate film, judge it as its own, the ho films are complementary or standalone, ie dont criticize them for not being like the books when they are a different medium and thats the entire point

i love both
>>
>>71872623
Only the first and second were truly faithful to the books anyways, god I hope they remake this shit soon with someone who actually cares, like how Jackson did with the rings
>>
>>71872660
That's true, but Half Blood Prince straight up made stuff up for no reason
>>
>>71869755
Was talking about the World Cup actually
>>
>>71872660
Top kek....you cant be serious. zthe harry potter films were done with more care than lotr, only fellowship is a good film. Pleb tier shit, every single one except goblet of fire is fantastic. they arent remaking ot they cant make it better, tv would be even shittier case and point game of thrones.
>>
>>71872677
>no reason
>film is a different medium
>filmmakers were specifically given creative control by wb because 'thats how you make a better film' -producer heyman
>>
>>71872701
I do not agree
>>
>>71872660
Thats because they are short fucking books you retard. More doesnt equal better are you a child? 3 or even 4 hours wouldnt make a better film than 2 and a half. Congrats you arent a filmmaker
>>
>>71872735
>film is a different medium
Yes, but that doesn't warrant any retarded change. Lord of the rings aren't 100% faithul to the books but they only made changes where it made sense.
>>
>>71872757
well you should rewatch them all, the hp films get better every-time, the same cannot be said for all the lotr films.

2 3 5 6 7 are legitimately great and thats leaving out the critics best rated.
>>
>>71872785
I didn't mention length once
>>
>>71872844
I've seen them very recently, I still don't agree.
>>
>>71872820
>another lotrfag
>he doesnt even realize peter butchered the material
>he likes bloated messes
honestly im not joking the 10 year hp series was way more impressive

>>71872857
you mentioned lotr you mentioned things being different from the books ie they didnt add things
>>
>>71872877
maybe you should get better taste because ive rewatched lotr recently for xxxxx amount of time and the two towers and return of the king are massively overrated to the point of sucking
>>
File: 1457567940001.jpg (8 KB, 323x241) Image search: [Google]
1457567940001.jpg
8 KB, 323x241
>>71872660
>Jackson
>>
>>71871462
I never actually noticed they changed actors, that's some good casting.
>>
>>71872976
>>71872930
>>71872895
(you)
>>
>>71872979
are you for real anon because of you are this is a great moment indeed

they are both irish, gambon went with a slight accent though to cuarons liking
>>
>>71871462
gambon was much better
the first one was way too faggy desu like a caricature
>>
>>71873007
Have you been in lotr threads? This isnt a joke anybody who is a patrician knows fellowship is the only good one and its perfect. You can pick apart peters directing afterwards it almost becomes a self parody. Even based viggo knows this
>>
>>71873066
>[Sir Michael] gambon was much better
>>
>>71869001
I'm pretty sure that sequence is often cited as an example of time travel "done right" (if it were possible of course).
>>
>>71873115
Yep
>>
>>71871885
i wont
>>
>>71870000
>>71869922
I thought the potion made a person relive his worst possible memories amplified greatly

pretty clever actually, Voldy being incapable of empathy would be virtually unaffected by it but any normal person has at least one moment he truly regrets, a moment of genuine emotional pain and suffering.
Dumbledore at that point was forcefully reliving the moment where he let his sister die and possibly even killed her himself
>>
>>71867066
Yates made the worst Potter movies
>>
>>71873512
no he didnt, that would be newell or colombus
>>
>>71873512
>I'm a contrarian
>I'm a filthy contrarian
ok
>>
>>71873548
>>71873577
Cry more. First four had a good matiné feeling with great world building. Last four are just mediocre young adult flicks
>>
>>71869084
Harry should've just avada kedavra'd Beatrix in the back while she was busy burning the house down.

Like seriously, if the Third Reich has taught me anything then it's that it's ok to kill the baddies.
>>
Actually no
Harry potter is flick tier redit trash
>>
>>71867103
If only movies were made of static frames
>>
File: helena-bonham-carter-8484.jpg (917 KB, 1920x1200) Image search: [Google]
helena-bonham-carter-8484.jpg
917 KB, 1920x1200
>>71873768
fuck off m8.

she is cute,
>>
>>71873849
That profile really brings her British teeth out.
>>
>>71873768
IIRC that spell is powered by the desire to kill, which is why using it successfully is automatically premeditated murder
its likely that harry would, especially given he's still young and not exactly an expert in that type of magic, be fully incapable of killing someone with it
>>
>>71873840
visually, poa is best.

we might differ on story though.
>>
>>71873882
He's a manlet and just had his gay mentor killed, that should make him hateful enough for that spell to work properly, no?
>>
>>71874041
after Bella murdered Sirius right infront of his eyes he still was incapable of properly using the crucio spell which is similar in that its powered by the desire to torture
pure righteous anger doesn't work for spells like this, its why they're a special kind of evil even if there's plenty of other spells that could be used to kill someone, often rather gruesomely
>>
>>71874137
Man, Hogwarts students are sissies. I bet they learn how to use those spell in that Bulgarian school.
>>
>>71874179
what would the japanese students do?

would their curses and spells be cute?
>>
>>71874447
They cast spells sideways
>>
Did anybody find the students marching like Nazi cringy?
>>
>>71875033
in dh2
>>
>>71875063
Pretty much all of DH2 was cringy.
Thread replies: 232
Thread images: 55

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.